P23-03 submitted19fc3f5. Supplemental independent readiness actually returned changes_required. FULL177 was NOT launched. Determine source-grounded minimal correction and ordinary Runner repair routing. Do not modify original7/all6/30-88/values or create newwork. Your last order explicitly said return actualfinding for scope decision, no full if defect. Native A/B17+17,45component,99local passed and preserved.
Actual independent Opus review (separate session):
{"reviewer": "independent-opus-readiness", "candidate": "19fc3f50c7ef66223a86b438d4327c5b1b308ed1", "verdict": "changes_required", "summary": "One blocking mismatch between the renderer and the checker was found. The checker requires that no actor identity core intersects any traffic band of an occupied cell. The renderer does not keep cabin passengers away from bands. The actual native layout-A frame-180 already contains such an intersection (riding guest core over the upper-landing band), and it passed only because that landing cell had density 0. Frame-030 shows the landing occupied (density 1) while the cabin was travelling. The checker runs inspect_stream on the OS writer and reader streams, so a normal OS frame with a loaded cabin in mid-travel and an occupied landing will be rejected, even though the band is drawn beneath actors. full177 does not run the Python checker, but any fix changes world_preview.gd or the checker, which are part of the source map. A full177 run on 19fc3f5 would then need to be repeated. Per the order, record this and return it for an Opus scope decision before running full. No other blocking defect was found. The six report-to-renderer paths, LifeOverlay serial and child order, the business enum labels, the A/B same-demand experiment and its recomputation, GDScript/Python packer parity, the shared hash-bound drawing_context consumers, and root_component's unchanged guarded execute_phase all check out. The missing OS, pixel, full and final gates are expected, and this verdict does not rest on them. Historical 49 / R13 12-false remains negative and is not used.", "checked": ["Six category paths are checked against the same report the renderer draws: report built in _build_life_observation (world_preview.gd:573-660), published at :534-548, returned as a deep copy by get_life_observation_report :566-567. Each per-frame category is recomputed independently in inspect_stream (check_p23_life_observation_evidence.py:1624-1634): staff via compare_actor_rows :690-709, rooms/business via compare_room_services :919-966 and compare_badges :1113-1146, queue via compare_queues :860-916, EV via compare_cabin_geometry :1149-1184, goods via compare_goods :1079-1110. The drawing rectangle list in drawing_rectangle_rows :308-339 matches the order in passive_observation.gd (aggregation badge added at diff L869-871).", "Rectangles and draw canvas: the band, cabin passengers, floor actors and aggregation badges are drawn only on the LifeOverlay child (world_preview.gd:778-790). The parent no longer draws actors or the congestion band (_draw_contents :520-561); the checker enforces this from source (:839-843). Band geometry matches in the renderer (:651-658) and both checker recomputations (:807-813, :846-850).", "Frame serial: observation_serial is set at world_preview.gd:535-537 and overlay_consumed_serial at the end of _draw_life_overlay. The checker requires them to be equal (:820-827). The Godot component run passed this assertion (test_p23_life_observation.gd:125-128; component log: 45 checks, 0 failures; receipt passed, guards all true), and all 34 A/B frames passed compare_traffic→validate_life_overlay.", "FRONT/BACK and pan/zoom: the report records layer, zoom, pan and viewport (:576-579). The checker's Transform (:769-796) rebuilds cell/room rects without reading report rects. The OS fixture captures both FRONT and BACK (observation.gd:149-155). LifeOverlay is an untransformed Node2D child, so it uses the parent's local coordinates.", "Business reasons: business_label maps FacilityInstance.State and SUSPENDED/RAIDED (room_presentation.gd:57-70; enum facility_instance.gd:8-18). compare_badges uses the same enum-name map (:1117-1139). frame_rows checks state_name against the source enum (:474-480). Not changed in this diff.", "A/B same demand: layout_comparison.gd:12-25 declares seed, cohort, window and metric. Layout B only appends the declared guest_elevator build at (4,0,0) (:46-48). compare_layouts (:1550-1583) requires identical declaration and initial state, identical arrival commands, a complete cohort and builds_B == builds_A + [improvement], and recomputes the sum of first-arrival offsets from per-minute ticks. This matches ROOT_19FC3F5_NATIVE_IMPACT.json same_demand A=7153, B=2585.", "Packer parity, fixed point and aggregation: GDScript _life_pack/_life_fitted_groups/_fit_life_actors (world_preview.gd:1570-1683) match Python fitted_actor_layout (:1249-1312) in grouping key, sort order, ceiling reduction max(1,int(c)-1) with monotone termination, the backward containment test, retained-member greedy packing at p=1, badge at=group[0].bounds.position and text. Regions match between _life_actor_region :1519-1559 and compare_actor_geometry :1403-1490 (queue precedence, carried, resting, treated, work slot, facility). validate_actor_nonoverlap independently rejects any remaining overlap (:369-393). Transit exemption comes only from actor_track_transit on raw track/time/pause (:1324-1338).", "Raw-context consumers: drawing_context (:1586-1597) binds report, state and rest objects by hash. It is used by inspect_os_requests :1788 and inspect_offline_mirror. validate_drawing_rows (:396-412) fails closed without state and requires rest authority when resting_staff is present. compare_rest now delegates geometry to compare_actor_geometry (:1073-1075).", "Negatives: the R13 row11/29 overlap fixture still fails as expected (test_p23_life_observation_evidence.py test_r13_false_row_11_overlaps_staff_row_29). There are tests for forged verdicts, off-screen labels, cabin vs floor overlap, invalid footprints, missing poses, stale serial and pass/child order. Historical 49 / R13 12-false is not relabelled.", "root_component_19fc3f5.py:44-50 calls r.execute_phase with arguments in the exact positional order of run_all_tests.py:143-144. Before the run it checks the exact commit, a clean tree, an identical source map against the prior native import, one engine and a fresh output, with an exact cloned stage inventory (:19-32). After the run it re-checks the source, default player and stage guards (:55-58). runner-ended reports passed=true, error=null and no cleanup errors."], "findings": ["BLOCKING (renderer/checker mismatch; would waste the normal OS run, and a repair would invalidate a prior full177): validate_life_overlay (check_p23_life_observation_evidence.py:844-857) rejects any actor core, including cabin passengers (:844), that intersects the band rect of a traffic row with current_density>0 or temporary_block. It runs from compare_traffic (:815) inside inspect_stream, which is applied to the OS writer and reader streams (:1895). The renderer has no band constraint: cabin passengers are seated from the cabin baseline (world_preview.gd:1234-1237), fitted only inside the cabin rect (_fit_life_actors :1631ff, passenger_bounds), and drawn after the band (:785-790). The intersection can therefore occur, and it is not visually occluded.", "Evidence that the BLOCKING case occurs in actual data: in layout-A frame-180 (report eeabe1205307…), the cabin rect is (708,541,72,57), i.e. floor 0.694 in TRAVEL. Riding passenger at=(718,575), scale 1, gives core [724,576,6,12]. The upper-landing traffic row rect (698,515,44,68) has band [703.28,576.5,33.44,5], so they intersect. That frame passed only because that row's density was 0. In frame-030 (80ccf1a8…), landing cell (746,515,44,68) has density 1 while the cabin is travelling (y=526). For p=3, row-0 passengers intersect the upper band at floor fraction 0.618–0.854, and row-1 passengers at 0.243–0.479. The OS fixture spawns all 48 cohort guests plus 48 service guests at once (observation.gd:139-147) and captures active-motion and per-minute frames, so this combination is likely in OS captures. Carried patients raised by 12p (world_preview.gd:1332 and :1540) have the same core-over-upper-cell-band geometry, though the OS fixture contains no rescue.", "Non-blocking: compare_actor_geometry looks up a carried patient's carrier with staff[...] (KeyError, i.e. fail closed) at check_p23_life_observation_evidence.py ~:1421, while the renderer tolerates a missing carrier (world_preview.gd:1330-1332 and :1536-1541). This can only produce a false rejection, never a false acceptance. No such state appears in the current evidence.", "Not a source defect: normal-OS, image/pixel, full177 and final-review evidence are missing for 19fc3f5, as expected. Local 99 tests, parse 319, A/B 17+17 semantics and component 45/0 were inspected as evidence only and do not substitute for those gates."]}
Root independently confirmed frame180 actual core-band intersections for guests018/019 at density0. In-memory density1 substitution alone triggers validator, not an actual occupied engine frame; raw originals unchanged. Repro:
[{"actor": "guest/p23-018", "core": [724.0, 576.0, 6.0, 12.0], "band": [703.28, 576.5, 33.44, 5.0], "original_density": 0, "cell": [0, 1, 0], "counterfactual_density_1_error": "traffic band covers actor core: guest/p23-018"}, {"actor": "guest/p23-019", "core": [748.0, 576.0, 6.0, 12.0], "band": [751.28, 576.5, 33.44, 5.0], "original_density": 0, "cell": [1, 1, 0], "counterfactual_density_1_error": "traffic band covers actor core: guest/p23-019"}]
Questions for real judgement: original requires readable actual6category observation; it does not explicitly require zero traffic-band intersection in all cross-floor projections. Existing bands draw before actors on same LifeOverlay; formal real independent pixel review remainsmandatory. Decide whether current validator's zerointersection is a mistakenlyadded overconstraint, or renderer mustbeadjusted tokeep both legible. Need concrete minimal source-derived correction and meaningful positive/negative tests, preserving actualserial/passorder/sourcecanvas and independentpixellegibility; do not simply delete assertions to getPASS. Scope may remain checker/tests only if originalreadability is faithfullyverified, or necessaryrendereronly with rationale. Defer harmless missingcarrierKeyErrorfinding unless acceptance-critical. No gameplay/Runtime/save/valuechanges.
Runner actualstate is submitted; commander validactionsvalidate/wait. Registered validate is --verify-only and canonical build currently contains historical49 R13 evidence with absoluteconverterpaths. DO NOT validateold49 ascurrent19. Provide normal routing torepair_pending without stateoverride: can preserveoldcanonical byrename and publish exact19 nativepartial with provenance, or intentionallyleavecanonicalabsent tohonestly record missingcurrentproof, runnormalregisteredvalidation ONLY fornegative repairrouting (never acceptance), then normalrepair. Must distinguish registeredmissingproof/pathdeficit from actualindependentstaticdefect. No need rerun native solely to change state. No blockallprogress, artificialcaps or newpermissionask; userauthorizesnecessaryfixes and individualcapsremoved. Choose Sol forminimalcheckerfix unlessdeepreasonAstra. Need recordedrun direction afterordinaryrepair_ready; currentaction waitmay carryconcretecorrection androuting. Do not claim supplemental review is final acceptancereview.
