From 243a3593bb49f0a829cda47d75fe79e84c0e10a8 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Takeshi Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2026 01:11:19 +0900 Subject: [PATCH] docs: preserve P24 native failure and diagnostic evidence --- .../mac-lock-readonly-r01.json | 26 ++++ .../p24-03-code-start-r02.json | 133 ++++++++++++++++++ .../p24-03-local-native-failure-r01.json | 57 ++++++++ .../p24-json-metadata-diagnostic-r01.json | 36 +++++ .../plan_validation.json | 2 +- .../work_packages.json | 20 ++- 6 files changed, 267 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-) create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/mac-lock-readonly-r01.json create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-03-code-start-r02.json create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-03-local-native-failure-r01.json create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-json-metadata-diagnostic-r01.json diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/mac-lock-readonly-r01.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/mac-lock-readonly-r01.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..8ae9a64 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/mac-lock-readonly-r01.json @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +{ + "observed_at_jst": "2026-10-13T00:50:08.864306+09:00", + "host": "TakeshinoMac-mini.local", + "read_only": true, + "settings_changed": false, + "observed_settings": { + "system_sleep_minutes": 0, + "display_sleep_minutes": 180, + "screensaver_idleTime": 0, + "askForPassword_default_domain": "not present, not interpreted as disabled" + }, + "relevant_events": [ + "2026-10-12 21:24:44: startUnlock kLWUnlockFromUserActive; previous kLWLockFromDisplayDim", + "2026-10-12 21:47:18.329: _handleAppleEvent Received a kAELockScreenEvent", + "2026-10-12 21:47:18.332: startScreenLock entered kLWLockFromDirectLock (8)" + ], + "inference": "21:47 event was a direct screen-lock request, not an idle timeout; earlier display-dim path also observed. Sender and explanation of repeated historical locks unproven.", + "sender_query": "appleeventsd/SystemUIServer 21:47:15-20 lock/lcks query returned no matching events", + "ui_inventory_current": "CUA returned native inventory without connection error; actual candidate OS input not yet executed", + "raw_log_hashes": { + "the-tree-lock-diagnostic.log": "cca22e0f7e6e8e28097e5b7ee68a0f36afa599d87619a803581c08254b9e4b3d", + "the-tree-lock-caller.log": "2c6f0e422c91f5ef39433dce9498e8408645def69968e5a45733b301d3cdb588", + "the-tree-lock-sender.log": "9f56fca152030dba9e8ee76dee4fc8967ab667507b5878f0f9ab819d55b6b9a6" + }, + "original_game_acceptance_inferred": false +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-03-code-start-r02.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-03-code-start-r02.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..fafbe3b --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-03-code-start-r02.json @@ -0,0 +1,133 @@ +{ + "observed_at_jst": "2026-10-13T00:50:08.864306+09:00", + "original_delivery": "P24-03", + "same_original_conditions": true, + "old_ui_job": { + "job_id": "3eefb441761546d6ae2f59000d912e9a", + "state": "cancelled", + "project": "the-tree-p24-03", + "task_id": "P24-03", + "operation": "dispatch", + "created": 1791819430.489873, + "pid": 92328, + "started": 1791819430.5233622, + "error": "Stopped by workflow_cancel", + "finished": 1791819864.843694, + "stdout_tail": "", + "stderr_tail": "" + }, + "old_task_after_recover": { + "id": "P24-03", + "contract": { + "id": "P24-03", + "title": "選択と保存の受入", + "requirement_ids": [ + "P24-03" + ], + "acceptance_ids": [ + "P24-03" + ], + "spec_ref": "docs/spec/acceptance/P24-03.json", + "base_commit": "9b2ee480a88054eb863eb5cdff855b379201a7c1", + "worker": "agy", + "allowed_paths": [ + "scenes/main/main.gd", + "scripts/ui/guest_observation_panel.gd", + "scripts/ui/staff_management_panel.gd", + "tests/ui/test_selection_departure.gd", + "tests/ui/test_selection_departure.gd.uid", + "tests/ui/fixtures/selection_cross_process.gd", + "tests/ui/fixtures/selection_cross_process.gd.uid", + "tools/check_p24_selection_evidence.py", + "tools/run_all_tests.py", + "tools/regression/suite-policy.json", + "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/completion_marker_contracts.json", + "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p24-03/**" + ], + "depends_on": [], + "resource_locks": [ + "main-selection-lifecycle", + "selection-acceptance-profile", + "regression-roster-policy" + ], + "validation_ids": [ + "p24-acceptance" + ], + "max_repair_attempts": 2, + "spec_sha256": "4d353ff816d8edbb39671159e4f9fd87c20224cf0c44ea7b8fadc03bf25ae244" + }, + "state": "blocked", + "worktree": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p24-03/P24-03-implement", + "submitted": null, + "candidate": null, + "main_base": null, + "reason": "runner_interrupted: dead process", + "repairs": 0, + "evidence": [], + "owner_approval": null + }, + "role_diagnosis": { + "action": "wait", + "task_id": "P24-03", + "reason": "【判断】wait。agyの現runは停止のまま再開せず、UI調査を終端として扱う。P24-03は未達(0/1)で、受入分母・条件・上限・権限は変更しない。同じ原unitのコード実装をCodexへ渡す案は妥当と判断する。ただしspecの実装指示は「UI寿命/保存選択の担当はagy」と書かれている。worker差替えはその文言と食い違うため、窓口/オーナーの了承を待ってから割り当てる。それまで待機。\n\n【原因】agyのCLI ui promptはshell git statusだけを許し、view_fileはAbsolutePathのみで、行範囲指定や末尾までの確実な読取り手段がない。そのため同一引数で読み直す反復になった(main.gd 17回、staff_service.gd 13回、guest_service 6回、6分超)。編集は0。これは仕様不足でも環境blockでもなく、役割とツール能力の不一致。作業内容は画面設計でも素材差替えでもなく、GDScriptの選択保存/復元/不存在処理というデータ整合と寿命制御が主体。既存変更が0なので、Codexへ渡しても重複実装にならない。\n\n【最小対策】(1) agyの該当runは停止のまま維持し、同一引数の反復読取りを再試行しない。(2) agyの成果は「UI調査の終端」として記録する。範囲は、開始前の全回帰構成(1299 source/172 suite/303 parse)確認がpassだったこと、実行は0であること、読取りが停止要因だったこと。これは新しい全体blockにしない。(3) 同じP24-03・同じtask契約(allowed_paths、resource_locks、max_repair_attempts=2、validation p24-acceptance)のまま、実装担当をCodexへ割り当てる。base_commit 9b2ee48は維持する。(4) 未実行の証拠はpendingのままにする。\n\n【担当分界】\n- Codex:\n - main.gd、guest_observation_panel.gd、staff_management_panel.gd のうち、必要な不足だけを修正する。対象は、選択ID/表示値/レイヤー/地図強調の保存・復元、不存在・不正型・過大ID・旧metadataの安全処理、失敗読込時の現在選択とゲーム状態の保持。\n - 実離脱/除去後に選択しない扱い。履歴の存在と現在の選択可能性は区別する。Unique人物の解雇/消去禁止は維持する。\n - tests/ui/test_selection_departure.gd と tests/ui/fixtures/selection_cross_process.gd の追加。\n - tools/check_p24_selection_evidence.py の作成。--verify-onlyはBUILD_OUTPUT_DIR/p24-evidence/index.jsonを読み、証拠なし/古いsource/未実行/条件不足なら非0にする。自己申告trueだけを受入にしない。\n - tools/run_all_tests.py の--suite複数指定(任意)と、新suite分のpolicy追加。\n - docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p24-03/ の条件matrixと変更/不足/実行計画。\n- agy: 画面確認が必要になった場合に限り、通常OSの選択・保存・別process再開の観察を担当する。これはコード提出後の証拠収集であり、実装ではない。\n- Runner/root: 正式試験、全回帰、別Claude独立レビュー、承認、統合。commanderと作成者はgit書込みや他worker起動をしない。\n\n【原contractの保ち方】\n- 受入は7条件(facility/guest/staff lifecycle、layer_and_values、invalid_and_failed_load、normal_os_input、final_validation_review)すべて。部分完了や条件緩和はしない。\n- 直接state変更で通すことはしない。pressed.emitや関数呼び出しだけをOS入力証拠にしない。\n- テストの削除・無効化、assert削除、件数の水増しはしない。既存suite/cleanup/strict markersを弱めない。\n- 上限・予算・権限は拡大しない。allowed_paths外は変更せず、必要なら提案として返す。\n- 外部入力は必須化しない。旧別worktreeの外部パスを必要入力にせず、現repoのsourceと固定specだけで完結させる。\n- SHAは区別する。spec_sha256は git show の文字列をstrip()してUTF-8でハッシュした値。source_pinsはraw bytes SHA。末尾改行によるraw/normalizedの差だけでblockedにしない。\n- 現source pinsは再確認する。pinと違うfileは、既存成果を再利用するか判断してから修正する。正常な既存実装は再実装しない。\n- Package依存と数値未承認は統合前提であり、この縦スライスの全体blockにしない。Windows固有条件は別途未受入のまま。Macで足りない証拠は作業として扱い、環境blockにしない。\n- コード提出はsubmittedとして可。元成果の完了は、全必要証拠(native/cross-process/OS入力/最終候補の全回帰)と独立レビューの後だけ。\n- 仕様変更、受入分母変更、予算拡大、承認、main統合はオーナー判断。この提案には含めない。" + }, + "old_edits": 0, + "old_native_tests": 0, + "code_task": { + "id": "P24-03", + "contract": { + "id": "P24-03", + "title": "選択と保存の受入", + "requirement_ids": [ + "P24-03" + ], + "acceptance_ids": [ + "P24-03" + ], + "spec_ref": "docs/spec/acceptance/P24-03-code-r02.json", + "base_commit": "286730f88ce430a1cbe1501d40361188f832d235", + "worker": "codex", + "allowed_paths": [ + "scenes/main/main.gd", + "scripts/ui/guest_observation_panel.gd", + "scripts/ui/staff_management_panel.gd", + "tests/ui/test_selection_departure.gd", + "tests/ui/test_selection_departure.gd.uid", + "tests/ui/fixtures/selection_cross_process.gd", + "tests/ui/fixtures/selection_cross_process.gd.uid", + "tools/check_p24_selection_evidence.py", + "tools/run_all_tests.py", + "tools/regression/suite-policy.json", + "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/completion_marker_contracts.json", + "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p24-03/**" + ], + "depends_on": [], + "resource_locks": [ + "main-selection-lifecycle", + "selection-acceptance-profile", + "regression-roster-policy" + ], + "validation_ids": [ + "p24-acceptance" + ], + "max_repair_attempts": 2, + "spec_sha256": "dbb885b47a3ee4af3d4180bb97fe746e26a0e08d75af2cd3b5b727ed337bd37c" + }, + "state": "implementing", + "worktree": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p24-03-code/P24-03-implement", + "submitted": null, + "candidate": null, + "main_base": null, + "reason": null, + "repairs": 0, + "evidence": [], + "owner_approval": null + }, + "code_prepare_job": "b4bfb86eaa794fe7b8212710b25eb12d", + "code_doctor_job": "c177086f83d34426ae06ba7929bd13a1", + "code_commander_job": "99b733e329404f188d7666503e3c83d7", + "code_dispatch_job": "cc88bb8c62c9474a81d25d230f9c3150", + "runner_acceptance_completed": 0, + "global_completed": 9, + "partial_credit": false +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-03-local-native-failure-r01.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-03-local-native-failure-r01.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e4a9d18 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-03-local-native-failure-r01.json @@ -0,0 +1,57 @@ +{ + "observed_at_jst": "2026-10-13T01:10:31.583740+09:00", + "original_plan_id": "P24-03", + "candidate_commit": "9c711860a82d597a48dab595a49d4f23c5f3c370", + "original_unit_accepted": false, + "full_regression_executed": false, + "import_passed": true, + "parse_passed": true, + "parsed_scripts": 304, + "local_suites_planned": 4, + "local_suites_executed": 1, + "local_suite_passed": false, + "reported_checks": 31, + "failures": [ + "departed guest selection/dropdown assumption", + "departed guest details assumption", + "actual facility construction starts", + "actual facility construction completes" + ], + "source_default_player_cleanup_guard_errors": [], + "evidence": { + "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p24-03-local-native-r01/runner-input.json": { + "bytes": 320004, + "sha256": "a270f87eb6a062c24da903c023af932095c29b0966aee9391e3952aff8a4fee7" + }, + "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p24-03-local-native-r01/local-ended.json": { + "bytes": 55320, + "sha256": "ca878fa4ef79736460bd02e6e735707522059e76d61ce898fd915a988fb80393" + }, + "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p24-03-local-native-r01/000-receipt.json": { + "bytes": 13059, + "sha256": "cf5f38ed6eb296e33304265ef62f9b57329fb5d6c8b39ec4be1e46921b64d1ce" + }, + "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p24-03-local-native-r01/000/engine-native.log": { + "bytes": 22233, + "sha256": "7ddf46d4e42e406499949ca69ccc830921de621919bf13d7d52be2c5fa413960" + } + }, + "formal_validation_job": "f9d9a0c639f14a5c80ce35dce6dffbbe", + "formal_validation_state": "failed: evidence missing", + "repair_job": "d02f0b6b551046dcb56eb6f2ff3b2cab", + "repair_state": "repair_ready", + "repairs_used": 1, + "repair_limit": 2, + "remaining_conditions": [ + "facility lifecycle actual demolition", + "guest and staff absence/current detail values", + "layer and valid selection roundtrip", + "invalid/failed loads", + "distinct-process formal save restart", + "normal OS delivered input and observed current model values", + "exact final candidate full regression, formal independent Claude review and integration" + ], + "global_completed": 9, + "global_total": 88, + "partial_credit": false +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-json-metadata-diagnostic-r01.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-json-metadata-diagnostic-r01.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bee6c52 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-json-metadata-diagnostic-r01.json @@ -0,0 +1,36 @@ +{ + "scope": "JSON numeric metadata type diagnostic only; no game acceptance", + "actual_pid": 99508, + "exit_code": 0, + "command": [ + "/Applications/Godot.app/Contents/MacOS/Godot", + "--headless", + "--path", + "/private/tmp/the-tree-p24-json-c200043b18364206b2ca6f61179c4d62", + "--script", + "/private/tmp/the-tree-p24-json-c200043b18364206b2ca6f61179c4d62/probe.gd", + "--log-file", + "/private/tmp/the-tree-p24-json-c200043b18364206b2ca6f61179c4d62/engine.log" + ], + "raw": "Godot Engine v4.7.2.stable.official.ed1daf0bf - https://godotengine.org\n\n{\"engine_version\":{\"build\":\"official\",\"hash\":\"ed1daf0bf001b61586d9930840f2f1394092c079\",\"hex\":263938,\"major\":4,\"minor\":7,\"patch\":2,\"status\":\"stable\",\"string\":\"4.7.2-stable (official)\",\"timestamp\":0},\"is_float\":true,\"is_int\":false,\"profile\":\"/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/TheTree-P24-JSON-5a698892c27c477f828a12f1841d8637\",\"version_value\":1.0}\n", + "probe_sha256": "2b6cba8ceee004d1788f69ba27cba73ebcb049dcce418baa9048400969cd5d34", + "finding": { + "severity": "high", + "file": "scenes/main/main.gd", + "functions": [ + "_restore_interface_selection", + "_restore_actor_interface_selection" + ], + "candidate_observed": "not selection.get(\"version\", 0) is int", + "impact": "SaveService._read_manifest JSON.parse_string produces 1.0 FLOAT, so normal version1 metadata will be silently rejected and valid selections lost.", + "required_original_behavior": "accept numeric exact1 from normal JSON while rejecting bool/string/non1 version; preserve old optional metadata fallback", + "acceptance_cases": [ + "normal saved JSON version1 decoded asfloat must restore map/staff/guest selection", + "bool true version must not count asnumeric1", + "1.5/string1/wrongtype safely ignored", + "no changes to gameplay snapshot or SaveService format needed" + ] + }, + "read_only_review_report": true, + "root_product_source_edits": 0 +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/plan_validation.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/plan_validation.json index 0c2558b..8ff1f6d 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/plan_validation.json +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/plan_validation.json @@ -254,6 +254,6 @@ "validate_facility_value_contracts.py": "91640e2a76cd6cc9186f7b85c0bf379b24b6cac0d48962815235ee628e7ae43e", "validate_plan.py": "23678227d9b3c556f1bd903f4b5b3147c4a82ce5085e10055481026803451b80", "validator_update_checks.json": "f997d0f3de2cea29550840b1d5cb23647d64f81329de46758551e2b6c8fecc27", - "work_packages.json": "8bd93b6a45d189486a07dfdfbc6c54de307404e4261ec2771dd5ca458165ca94" + "work_packages.json": "cfa530ede883ab3639a081e8b0ae4b7be26f26414b22b4ea9526995d606bc84a" } } diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json index 3474a74..12cc9e9 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json @@ -15640,16 +15640,24 @@ "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-03-runner-start-r01.json", "sha256_at_integration": "ef39b7de2d9f3eb5791529c5e18c96d3736d570adae1b987abcb112860bdccb8", "scope": "frozen original unit, managed single UI implementer start; no acceptance" + }, + { + "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/multi-agent-dev-handoff/p24-03-local-native-failure-r01.json", + "sha256_at_integration": "ee6a2e356f683af2e435d7f7270f05cbeee6ddd86931d6888a81d023bdf5261d", + "scope": "Exact9c candidate failed local native trial; import/parse passes only; not original acceptance" } ], - "progress_summary": "原P24-03の契約をmain9b2ee48で固定。Runner/Claude開始判断からagy1担当を起動。既存3選択suiteとUI復元を再利用して実撤去/離脱/別process再開の不足に限定。旧reader-r01不合格・現14source差を確認し合格証拠として再利用しない。正式試験/通常OS入力/別Claude正式レビュー/受入は未実施。", + "progress_summary": "候補9c711860をCodexから提出。全304script parse/import通過、局所departure試験31checkで4失敗、残3suite未実行。全回帰/別process/OS入力/正式独立レビュー未実施。原9/88を維持。証拠gate不足でRunner validate失敗、第1修正repair_ready。離脱後の他客への正常fallbackと試験前提、実建設条件を切分け、レビュー循環/OS collector過限定を修正する。同一タスクで継続、元成果未受入。", "remaining_gaps": [ - "施設/客/一般職員の実撤去・離脱時選択と画面値の現版証拠", - "正式保存・別processの通常Mainでレイヤー/各選択/表示値の復元", - "不正metadata・失敗読込・UI収集時Runtime不変の現版適用証拠", - "通常OS入力、局所/影響範囲/最終同版全回帰、正式独立レビュー" + "facility lifecycle actual demolition", + "guest and staff absence/current detail values", + "layer and valid selection roundtrip", + "invalid/failed loads", + "distinct-process formal save restart", + "normal OS delivered input and observed current model values", + "exact final candidate full regression, formal independent Claude review and integration" ], - "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-13T00:38:51.342403+09:00" + "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-13T01:10:31.583740+09:00" } ], "estimate_person_days_historical_2026_09_29": [