From 2d506a5ce883e2bb930f9af81eef4b9a0cff5e28 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Takeshi Date: Sun, 18 Oct 2026 09:17:08 +0900 Subject: [PATCH] docs: bind repaired P26 validation and live whole-unit review --- .../ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json | 50 ++++++++------- .../ROOT_EXACT_DA80360A_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json | 31 ++++++++++ .../ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_DA80360A.json | 26 ++++++++ .../progress_snapshot.json | 61 +++++++++++-------- .../work_packages.json | 10 ++- 5 files changed, 125 insertions(+), 53 deletions(-) create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_EXACT_DA80360A_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_DA80360A.json diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json index c7ba767..06295e6 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json @@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ "original_plan_id": "P26-01", "registered_project": "the-tree-p26-01-ledger", "registered_task": "P26-01-LEDGER", - "state": "implementing", + "state": "review_pending", "actual_selection": "6b9bb7f7a8474689b4094efbfcde2eef", "base_commit": "379a1ba8fd25b5ad24226178a2492f91761dc31d", "original_denominator": { @@ -16,10 +16,8 @@ "full_acceptance": "原本で要求された未制作内容を欠損として記録し、架空の完成数を置かない。", "dependencies": "Audit observes P19/P20/P22 actual state; does not accept their production. Pending D08/D09 explicit. P04 existing D05 questions retained.", "missing": [ - "Repair original content clause omissions and independent atomic/source coverage", - "Correct requirement-level owner/status/partial support and strengthen corresponding negatives", - "Repeat only necessary modified registered checks on newS, independent whole-unit review", - "normal candidate integration/final and qualified native reuse then ledger" + "Actual whole-original Opus re-review of exact da80360 against all original/atomic clauses and all old findings", + "Normal exact candidate integration/final and source applicability qualification before ledger credit" ], "reuse": [ "P19-03 accepted table S903a2c566e73cebc874a6499410a1243bc190a63/C8e4f1d92fc2a2e8f1dd187e661cf52b13e4e51d4", @@ -31,11 +29,11 @@ "actual_commander_run_direction": "98e5c58164f24b6593e8c64273cae679", "actual_jobs": [ { - "id": "97dcf196e1c546d5a0c61c745f822151", - "role": "implementer", + "id": "dc734a96100a4c0bb1593f6dc124fa06", + "role": "reviewer", "status": "running", - "pid": 14734, - "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/97dcf196e1c546d5a0c61c745f822151" + "pid": 22314, + "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/dc734a96100a4c0bb1593f6dc124fa06" } ], "repairs": 4, @@ -51,34 +49,35 @@ "committed_accepted_material_anchor": "137639773c9017f9ee7733d78e37179b687f965c", "manifest": "accepted-p22-01-inputs/ROOT_MATERIAL_PRESERVATION_MANIFEST.json" }, - "resume_rule": "First inspect actual task and samejob97dcf196/PID14734 status and real liveness. Follow existing handle while live; no duplicate run. After new submission registered checks once, qualify exact newS inputs, whole independentreview thennormalgates. P26 historical sourcefacts explicitlyasofanchor; currentD05approval separately pinned. P04 next with actualcurrentM not old5f version.", + "resume_rule": "Inspect actual task/submission and current review dc734a96100a4c0bb1593f6dc124fa06/PID22314 real status/liveness first. Follow same handle; no duplicate review. If pass prepare-integration normal, exact C/M qualification, existing owner main permission, integration/final then ledger. If changesrequested use actual findings same task. P04 approved4D05rules next aftercurrentclosure; currentformal15/88 no partialcredit.", "second_setup_attempt": { "run": "81b128df2b3741ec9ab480f3d05d96c1", "writes": 0, "result": "Prior commander direction incorrectly assumed existing P26 outputs. Actual Opus818862 withdrew assumption and actual3e55ca authorized creating all5newfiles; immutable spec unchanged. Three precreation invocations exited2 missing script, not actual tests or acceptance." }, "original_unit_credit_added": 0, - "S": "35b3de0d59d41633fe89678e742f35f4df620618", - "submitted_source": "35b3de0d59d41633fe89678e742f35f4df620618", + "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "submitted_source": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", "formal_validation": { "passed": true, "all_registered_checks": 3, - "meaningful_self_tests": 13, - "scope": "sameS35b3de0 docs/source only, not whole acceptance" + "meaningful_self_tests": 17, + "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "artifact": "ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_DA80360A.json", + "scope": "sameS doc/source checks only, not whole acceptance" }, "whole_original_review": { - "actual_run": "8a8f40a333de4f0f993bc757c665c696", + "actual_run": "dc734a96100a4c0bb1593f6dc124fa06", "model": "claude-opus-5-5", - "status": "changes_requested", - "high": 2, - "medium": 2, - "low": 1, - "artifact": "ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_35B3DE0D.json" + "status": "running", + "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "previous_all_findings_required_to_reassess": true }, "D05_current_human_answers": "All4remaining rules approved clientdate2026-10-18; separateP04adoptionnext. Frozenf4/379audit must explicitlylabel historicalsource.", "native_reuse": { + "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", "exact1368inputs_settings_policy_marker_engine_roster_defaultplayer_equal": true, - "actual_proof": "ROOT_EXACT_SUBMITTED_35b3de0d_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json", + "actual_proof": "ROOT_EXACT_DA80360A_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json", "new_native_runs": 0 }, "actual_repair_direction": "b0dbf18d6cd148b79cd96830704f8ae7", @@ -87,5 +86,14 @@ "result": "blocked on exact D05 approval source delivery; report-only edits, actual review fixes not done", "resolved": "Actual4humananswers/policytexts/questionID and published a13f7c0 approval bytes/SHA supplied in same implementer handoff; actual Opus b0db/98e5 verified all4handoffdocs before same-task resume", "approval_file_sha256": "cd365ded1b777a0327d090709f0a4161f5005562819183455d9f2e106fba3e96" + }, + "previous_whole_original_review": { + "actual_run": "8a8f40a333de4f0f993bc757c665c696", + "model": "claude-opus-5-5", + "status": "changes_requested", + "high": 2, + "medium": 2, + "low": 1, + "artifact": "ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_35B3DE0D.json" } } diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_EXACT_DA80360A_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_EXACT_DA80360A_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..5c51e28 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_EXACT_DA80360A_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json @@ -0,0 +1,31 @@ +{ + "artifact_commit": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "kind": "submitted", + "existing_product_C": "65f07bf5eaa759a8e2e17c7bdbbbdbceb24ee373", + "old_actual_native_S": "a7e3069b167511b3194242b3403fbcc35244a526", + "all1368_selected_source_settings_assets_tests_tools_byte_equal": true, + "marker_policy_engine_roster_parse_default_player_equal": true, + "scope": "Unmodified existing source_refs algorithm exact key set; doc audit files excluded by preexisting algorithm, no narrowed source set. All source file bytes hashed independently by Root.", + "native_full_evidence_reuse_qualified": true, + "new_native_runs": 0, + "existing_full": { + "actual_suites": 184, + "missing_marker_paths": [], + "remaining_unexecuted_tests": [], + "available_marker_checks": 21903, + "actual_all_roster_checks": 21903, + "strict_accepted_checks": 21903, + "verified": true, + "composed": true, + "original_full_attempt_passed": false, + "whole_original_acceptance": false, + "parse_checks": 329, + "setup_phases": 2, + "owned_ended": 186, + "tested_source": "a7e3069b167511b3194242b3403fbcc35244a526", + "engines_started": 0, + "verifier_sha256": "d00bf46bfcc0e0bb197edd284a3ae14610ca710507831e18e071a79461946e8a" + }, + "whole_original_P26_01_accepted": false, + "time_ns": 1792282413524270000 +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_DA80360A.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_DA80360A.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..87453e7 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_DA80360A.json @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +{ + "task_id": "P26-01-LEDGER", + "commit": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "kind": "validation", + "checks": [ + { + "id": "p26-ledger", + "exit_code": 0, + "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/efd869f3b9024afd82659924fcbf4d4d", + "passed": true + }, + { + "id": "p26-negative", + "exit_code": 0, + "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/744733ca201d41869d1eb8422f428f7b", + "passed": true + }, + { + "id": "p26-source-binding", + "exit_code": 0, + "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/a5bbe5d88a344ebd8eee59bd62315893", + "passed": true + } + ], + "passed": true +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/progress_snapshot.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/progress_snapshot.json index 63073e6..a981b6a 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/progress_snapshot.json +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/progress_snapshot.json @@ -5246,13 +5246,14 @@ "current_acceptance_and_missing": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json", "supersedes_next_selection_only": "P24-02 sourcefe44f55 and all8unaccepted conditions retained; no duplicate worker", "actual_worker": { - "id": "97dcf196e1c546d5a0c61c745f822151", - "role": "implementer", + "id": "dc734a96100a4c0bb1593f6dc124fa06", + "role": "reviewer", "status": "running", - "pid": 14734, - "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/97dcf196e1c546d5a0c61c745f822151" + "pid": 22314, + "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/dc734a96100a4c0bb1593f6dc124fa06" }, - "actual_runner_state": "implementing" + "actual_runner_state": "review_pending", + "source": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7" }, "current_P14_01_contract_audit": { "audit": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p14-01-current-contract-audit-r01/audit.json", @@ -10533,7 +10534,7 @@ "original_plan_id": "P26-01", "registered_project": "the-tree-p26-01-ledger", "registered_task": "P26-01-LEDGER", - "state": "implementing", + "state": "review_pending", "actual_selection": "6b9bb7f7a8474689b4094efbfcde2eef", "base_commit": "379a1ba8fd25b5ad24226178a2492f91761dc31d", "original_denominator": { @@ -10546,10 +10547,8 @@ "full_acceptance": "原本で要求された未制作内容を欠損として記録し、架空の完成数を置かない。", "dependencies": "Audit observes P19/P20/P22 actual state; does not accept their production. Pending D08/D09 explicit. P04 existing D05 questions retained.", "missing": [ - "Repair original content clause omissions and independent atomic/source coverage", - "Correct requirement-level owner/status/partial support and strengthen corresponding negatives", - "Repeat only necessary modified registered checks on newS, independent whole-unit review", - "normal candidate integration/final and qualified native reuse then ledger" + "Actual whole-original Opus re-review of exact da80360 against all original/atomic clauses and all old findings", + "Normal exact candidate integration/final and source applicability qualification before ledger credit" ], "reuse": [ "P19-03 accepted table S903a2c566e73cebc874a6499410a1243bc190a63/C8e4f1d92fc2a2e8f1dd187e661cf52b13e4e51d4", @@ -10561,11 +10560,11 @@ "actual_commander_run_direction": "98e5c58164f24b6593e8c64273cae679", "actual_jobs": [ { - "id": "97dcf196e1c546d5a0c61c745f822151", - "role": "implementer", + "id": "dc734a96100a4c0bb1593f6dc124fa06", + "role": "reviewer", "status": "running", - "pid": 14734, - "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/97dcf196e1c546d5a0c61c745f822151" + "pid": 22314, + "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/dc734a96100a4c0bb1593f6dc124fa06" } ], "repairs": 4, @@ -10581,34 +10580,35 @@ "committed_accepted_material_anchor": "137639773c9017f9ee7733d78e37179b687f965c", "manifest": "accepted-p22-01-inputs/ROOT_MATERIAL_PRESERVATION_MANIFEST.json" }, - "resume_rule": "First inspect actual task and samejob97dcf196/PID14734 status and real liveness. Follow existing handle while live; no duplicate run. After new submission registered checks once, qualify exact newS inputs, whole independentreview thennormalgates. P26 historical sourcefacts explicitlyasofanchor; currentD05approval separately pinned. P04 next with actualcurrentM not old5f version.", + "resume_rule": "Inspect actual task/submission and current review dc734a96100a4c0bb1593f6dc124fa06/PID22314 real status/liveness first. Follow same handle; no duplicate review. If pass prepare-integration normal, exact C/M qualification, existing owner main permission, integration/final then ledger. If changesrequested use actual findings same task. P04 approved4D05rules next aftercurrentclosure; currentformal15/88 no partialcredit.", "second_setup_attempt": { "run": "81b128df2b3741ec9ab480f3d05d96c1", "writes": 0, "result": "Prior commander direction incorrectly assumed existing P26 outputs. Actual Opus818862 withdrew assumption and actual3e55ca authorized creating all5newfiles; immutable spec unchanged. Three precreation invocations exited2 missing script, not actual tests or acceptance." }, "original_unit_credit_added": 0, - "S": "35b3de0d59d41633fe89678e742f35f4df620618", - "submitted_source": "35b3de0d59d41633fe89678e742f35f4df620618", + "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "submitted_source": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", "formal_validation": { "passed": true, "all_registered_checks": 3, - "meaningful_self_tests": 13, - "scope": "sameS35b3de0 docs/source only, not whole acceptance" + "meaningful_self_tests": 17, + "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "artifact": "ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_DA80360A.json", + "scope": "sameS doc/source checks only, not whole acceptance" }, "whole_original_review": { - "actual_run": "8a8f40a333de4f0f993bc757c665c696", + "actual_run": "dc734a96100a4c0bb1593f6dc124fa06", "model": "claude-opus-5-5", - "status": "changes_requested", - "high": 2, - "medium": 2, - "low": 1, - "artifact": "ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_35B3DE0D.json" + "status": "running", + "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "previous_all_findings_required_to_reassess": true }, "D05_current_human_answers": "All4remaining rules approved clientdate2026-10-18; separateP04adoptionnext. Frozenf4/379audit must explicitlylabel historicalsource.", "native_reuse": { + "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", "exact1368inputs_settings_policy_marker_engine_roster_defaultplayer_equal": true, - "actual_proof": "ROOT_EXACT_SUBMITTED_35b3de0d_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json", + "actual_proof": "ROOT_EXACT_DA80360A_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json", "new_native_runs": 0 }, "actual_repair_direction": "b0dbf18d6cd148b79cd96830704f8ae7", @@ -10617,6 +10617,15 @@ "result": "blocked on exact D05 approval source delivery; report-only edits, actual review fixes not done", "resolved": "Actual4humananswers/policytexts/questionID and published a13f7c0 approval bytes/SHA supplied in same implementer handoff; actual Opus b0db/98e5 verified all4handoffdocs before same-task resume", "approval_file_sha256": "cd365ded1b777a0327d090709f0a4161f5005562819183455d9f2e106fba3e96" + }, + "previous_whole_original_review": { + "actual_run": "8a8f40a333de4f0f993bc757c665c696", + "model": "claude-opus-5-5", + "status": "changes_requested", + "high": 2, + "medium": 2, + "low": 1, + "artifact": "ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_35B3DE0D.json" } }, "p04_remaining_D05_actual_approval": { diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json index 36fb876..37dd6ac 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json @@ -17158,16 +17158,14 @@ { "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json", "scope": "Registered audit start only, no original-unit acceptance", - "sha256_at_integration": "c214c2233edf10cbe8a91e77b777661d96b2c4a7494a5d36db5e6a89b8576846", + "sha256_at_integration": "37e233dec6afc8bd3afde485114eef098214e2bb823e6431b0836efc4d76e908", "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-17T20:36:24.754292+09:00" } ], - "progress_summary": "Actual Opus98e5c581 verified all4complete handoff documents including exact D05 approval history and pins. Same managed worker97dcf196/Codex6.1-sol repairing required coverage/AR/owner-status/tests. Repairs4/null; formal15/88 unchanged.", + "progress_summary": "Repaired source da80360: all3registered validations PASS including17meaningful tests; Root independently qualified1368gameinputs/engine/policy/roster/defaultplayer exact reuse. Actual separate Opusdc734a re-review of entireoriginal unit and priorfindings running. Formal15/88 unchanged, no credit.", "remaining_gaps": [ - "Repair original content clause omissions and independent atomic/source coverage", - "Correct requirement-level owner/status/partial support and strengthen corresponding negatives", - "Repeat only necessary modified registered checks on newS, independent whole-unit review", - "normal candidate integration/final and qualified native reuse then ledger" + "Actual whole-original Opus re-review of exact da80360 against all original/atomic clauses and all old findings", + "Normal exact candidate integration/final and source applicability qualification before ledger credit" ], "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-17T20:36:24.754292+09:00" },