docs: retain scoped OS evidence and re-audit P04 current acceptance

2026-10-17 16:30:58 +09:00
parent 565fd80507
commit 2f3884be11
15 changed files with 6587 additions and 29 deletions
@@ -3598,7 +3598,7 @@
    },
    "legacy_state": "in_progress",
    "state_scope": "package-level; completed means whole package accepted; partial implementation is not completion",
-    "current_summary": "現行1338sourceでS1/S2a/S2b/S3実測と正式復元を収集済み。実Opus/Astra18が動的raw収集/各series検証を実装し、Rootも実data・新規拒否fixture・既存Cをfile-onlyで各exit0再確認、既存Cブロック全bytes不変。担当が全体未達を理由にblocked応答したため未commitコードを全保持し通常repair19へ継続、goal停止なし。残3条件は停電/18:00の既存raw参照と保存getter型説明・厳密適用性を補正し、A実HEAD/tree/FS結合・旧fixture整合を実装する。getter追加APIの配列型差分を旧説明が網羅していなかった点はnoticeで訂正、正式全Runtime型付き復元一致の実測は保持。全原15+EV/7領域/安全性3結果/30-88/部分点0、必須whole・独立wholereview・通常integration/final未達、原成果加点0。",
+    "current_summary": "次に閉じる優先候補。実Runnerは提出2dde7596・修正29・repair_pending・未稼働、worktree差分0。実Opus ea12167cが最新29を再監査し、旧台帳のraw結合/getter/HEAD fixture等は既修正と確認、重複repairを起動しない。登録validationはpassでも正式レビュー275d1fd6はD05規則未確定等で不合格。破壊順序・00:00売上帰属と理由表示/退出の明文化を具体案で確認中。既承認2規則維持。全15+EV/7領域/安全性3結果/全条件・必須最終全回帰・独立wholeレビュー・通常integration/finalは維持。正式14/88、今回加算0。",
    "remaining_deliverables": [
      {
        "id": "P04-01",
@@ -3851,38 +3851,41 @@
            "sha256_at_integration": "dfd9665ec1a8922201ce325c70505e7bf2d880a044daa49dddd92241007a438f",
            "scope": "S3 bounded raw proof only; six actual native cases/formal22 slots/176phase pairs/16clock replay pairs; no whole original credit",
            "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-16T04:54:54.811581+09:00"
+          },
+          {
+            "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261017/CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json",
+            "sha256": "908111f64a3d6c206504e26e76c721a0a97864238f6f6bb6604ac7b8e31ce7bf",
+            "scope": "Actual latest29 state and Opus re-audit supersede stale repair19 remaining work; zero formal credit"
          }
        ],
-        "current_summary": "現行1338sourceでS1/S2a/S2b/S3実測と正式復元を収集済み。実Opus/Astra18が動的raw収集/各series検証を実装し、Rootも実data・新規拒否fixture・既存Cをfile-onlyで各exit0再確認、既存Cブロック全bytes不変。担当が全体未達を理由にblocked応答したため未commitコードを全保持し通常repair19へ継続、goal停止なし。残3条件は停電/18:00の既存raw参照と保存getter型説明・厳密適用性を補正し、A実HEAD/tree/FS結合・旧fixture整合を実装する。getter追加APIの配列型差分を旧説明が網羅していなかった点はnoticeで訂正、正式全Runtime型付き復元一致の実測は保持。全原15+EV/7領域/安全性3結果/30-88/部分点0、必須whole・独立wholereview・通常integration/final未達、原成果加点0。",
+        "current_summary": "次に閉じる優先候補。実Runnerは提出2dde7596・修正29・repair_pending・未稼働、worktree差分0。実Opus ea12167cが最新29を再監査し、旧台帳のraw結合/getter/HEAD fixture等は既修正と確認、重複repairを起動しない。登録validationはpassでも正式レビュー275d1fd6はD05規則未確定等で不合格。破壊順序・00:00売上帰属と理由表示/退出の明文化を具体案で確認中。既承認2規則維持。全15+EV/7領域/安全性3結果/全条件・必須最終全回帰・独立wholeレビュー・通常integration/finalは維持。正式14/88、今回加算0。",
        "remaining_conditions": [
-          "原7種更新順序・証拠対応の原本/承認済み仕様への全条件適合性と規約凍結を最終独立受入する",
-          "承認D05の依存先休業pause/resume日跨ぎと正式SaveService/別PID復元はmain5f6bc11で実測済み。既存証拠と残の原7領域全条件への適合性・独立whole受入を残す。直接休業D-034と区別する。",
-          "承認18:00完了後交代/同分再送/実00:00決算、夜番不在/残業に加え、停電+直接休業/退出/元忍耐自然枯渇/破壊の原残境界と正式22slot再生をS3 accdで収集済み。全原条件raw結合・適用性・独立whole受入は未達。",
-          "既存39証拠等の適用版・入力・設定・環境を照合して不足境界だけ検証。全条件独立受入と通常統合/final/台帳反映。D05他領域は具体的根拠を確認し一括解決/一括停止にしない"
+          "owner choices for destruction order and midnight-sale day, plus explicit disposition of reason label and command/AI exit",
+          "after actual answers, normal batched checker destruction-authority pin / registry / approval record / stale current metadata correction",
+          "final gates as listed; previous full178 f5 receipt is not full final checker a61 evidence; no relabeling"
        ],
-        "progress_summary": "現行1338sourceでS1/S2a/S2b/S3実測と正式復元を収集済み。実Opus/Astra18が動的raw収集/各series検証を実装し、Rootも実data・新規拒否fixture・既存Cをfile-onlyで各exit0再確認、既存Cブロック全bytes不変。担当が全体未達を理由にblocked応答したため未commitコードを全保持し通常repair19へ継続、goal停止なし。残3条件は停電/18:00の既存raw参照と保存getter型説明・厳密適用性を補正し、A実HEAD/tree/FS結合・旧fixture整合を実装する。getter追加APIの配列型差分を旧説明が網羅していなかった点はnoticeで訂正、正式全Runtime型付き復元一致の実測は保持。全原15+EV/7領域/安全性3結果/30-88/部分点0、必須whole・独立wholereview・通常integration/final未達、原成果加点0。",
+        "progress_summary": "次に閉じる優先候補。実Runnerは提出2dde7596・修正29・repair_pending・未稼働、worktree差分0。実Opus ea12167cが最新29を再監査し、旧台帳のraw結合/getter/HEAD fixture等は既修正と確認、重複repairを起動しない。登録validationはpassでも正式レビュー275d1fd6はD05規則未確定等で不合格。破壊順序・00:00売上帰属と理由表示/退出の明文化を具体案で確認中。既承認2規則維持。全15+EV/7領域/安全性3結果/全条件・必須最終全回帰・独立wholeレビュー・通常integration/finalは維持。正式14/88、今回加算0。",
        "remaining_gaps": [
-          "既存CとS1/S2a/S2b/S3のraw収集/各series検証は実装済み、Root実data/新fixture/C各exit0。停電はS3実power flagと復旧前後、18:00はnative-first-current actual-nativeの正しい生証拠へ結合する。全原15+EV適用性を揃える。",
-          "save_restoreの正式全Runtime var_to_bytes一致は保持。追加API rawgetterに既存source _to_snapshot_variantが配列型制約も変換する点を旧説明が見落としたため、原frozen条件とsource定義のcanonical契約へ厳密に照合し訂正する。JSON-only/盲目的正規化/原基準緩和は禁止。",
-          "Aの実候補HEAD/tree/FS照合、旧MAIN/metadata数固定とcandidate_tree自己申告の穴、旧negative/applicability fixture失敗を直す。C全bodyと改ざん拒否は保持。",
-          "原7領域/安全性3結果/全条件と必須whole検証・別セッション独立wholeレビュー・通常integration/final・台帳反映を完結する。原成果加点0。"
+          "owner choices for destruction order and midnight-sale day, plus explicit disposition of reason label and command/AI exit",
+          "after actual answers, normal batched checker destruction-authority pin / registry / approval record / stale current metadata correction",
+          "final gates as listed; previous full178 f5 receipt is not full final checker a61 evidence; no relabeling"
        ],
-        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-16T05:25:51.943207+09:00",
-        "current_recheck": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json",
-        "policy_candidate": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/D05_POLICY_CANDIDATE.md",
+        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-17T16:30:38.746525+09:00",
+        "current_recheck": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261017/CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json",
+        "policy_candidate": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261017/D05_REMAINING_ORDER_CANDIDATE.md",
        "owner_policy_update": {
          "approved": true,
          "reference": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/D05_OWNER_APPROVAL.json",
          "scope": "two owner policy selections only; no acceptance credit",
          "remaining": "condition-specific evidence applicability, missing boundaries, independent review, ordinary integration/final",
-          "actual_commander": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/OPUS_REPAIR18_FULL_INPUT_CONTINUATION_DECISION.json",
-          "runner_state": "repair_ready",
-          "repairs": 19,
-          "worker_model": "gpt-6-astra",
+          "actual_commander": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261017/ACTUAL_OPUS_LATEST29_DECISION.json",
+          "runner_state": "repair_pending",
+          "repairs": 29,
+          "worker_model": null,
          "model_selected_by": "actual Claude Opus 5.5 run decision",
-          "run_decision": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/OPUS_REPAIR18_FULL_INPUT_CONTINUATION_DECISION.json",
-          "submitted": "accd07c91d4e34d9b7c7fc20e389df2424b167e1",
-          "registered_validation": "0689f0070bd54d4f8b5849bb63bb36a8",
+          "run_decision": null,
+          "submitted": "2dde7596a87c43f7bf0bf704b7479f2fa06a5b1c",
+          "registered_validation": "91d92e164b164bb091ae90e384da5636",
          "root_work_continues": true,
          "native_shift_proof": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/ROOT_APPROVED_SHIFT_CURRENT_RESULT.json",
          "incomplete_checkpoint": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/REPAIR7_PRESERVED_WORK.json",
@@ -3891,7 +3894,7 @@
          "formal_dependency_proof": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/ROOT_APPROVED_DEPENDENCY_FORMAL_RESULT.json",
          "timeout_adapter": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/OWNER_P04_LLM_TIMEOUT_ADAPTER.json",
          "actual_run": null,
-          "current_scope": "Preserved executable R; next actual Opus direction for missing raw joins/getter type correction and real candidate A/fixtures. No new registered validation of unchanged accd.",
+          "current_scope": "Latest29 audited; no worker or repair launched. Owner D05 answers pending; normal bounded authority/record correction only after actual answer. Existing two approvals unchanged.",
          "paid_shift_midnight_formal_proof": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/ROOT_PAID_SHIFT_MIDNIGHT_FORMAL_RESULT.json",
          "same_minute_formal_proof": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/ROOT_SAME_MINUTE_RESEND_FORMAL_RESULT.json",
          "corrected_c_bundle": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/ROOT_CORRECTED_C_BUNDLE_LOCAL_PASS.json",
@@ -3902,9 +3905,21 @@
            "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/ROOT_S2B_NATIVE_R02_RESULT.json",
            "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/ROOT_S2B_NATIVE_R01_RESULT.json",
            "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/ROOT_S2A_NATIVE_R03_RESULT.json"
-          ]
+          ],
+          "historical_runner_context_before_current_reaudit": {
+            "runner_state": "repair_ready",
+            "repairs": 19,
+            "submitted": "accd07c91d4e34d9b7c7fc20e389df2424b167e1",
+            "registered_validation": "0689f0070bd54d4f8b5849bb63bb36a8",
+            "worker_model": "gpt-6-astra",
+            "actual_commander": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/OPUS_REPAIR18_FULL_INPUT_CONTINUATION_DECISION.json",
+            "run_decision": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/OPUS_REPAIR18_FULL_INPUT_CONTINUATION_DECISION.json",
+            "current_scope": "Preserved executable R; next actual Opus direction for missing raw joins/getter type correction and real candidate A/fixtures. No new registered validation of unchanged accd."
+          }
        },
-        "historical_initial_recheck": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/recheck.json"
+        "historical_initial_recheck": "execution/p04-01-current-recheck-20261015/recheck.json",
+        "submitted_commit": "2dde7596a87c43f7bf0bf704b7479f2fa06a5b1c",
+        "normal_integration_candidate": null
      },
      {
        "id": "P04-02",
@@ -16235,7 +16250,7 @@
    },
    "legacy_state": "in_progress",
    "state_scope": "package-level; completed means whole package accepted; partial implementation is not completion",
-    "current_summary": "提出bd3a134（修正使用済み4・上限なし）を同一Runnerで正式提出し保持branchへpush。GUI成果を保持してOpus判断でCodex6.1-solへ非UIのみ引継ぎ、countによる必須roster欠損容認とenv偽HEADを修正。実compile/保全/diff確認合格、局所9試験は実exit0+3入力SHA一致で再利用。別Opus限定静的review95cffd7 pass、重大/高/中0・low5、全8受入の加点0。実合成Q4bf9a1b/treea0667b9（M51e8657）を実4競合のS内容で準備、source1368/必須roster180はいずれも未実行。厳密Root合成契約・条件別artifact対応・実UI/OS/警告上流・最終全回帰/全8review/通常統合/Windowsが残る。 P24-03既完了とP24全体の完成は別。",
+    "current_summary": "提出fe44f55保持。実main565/Q429/T905で通常OSメニュー→別名保存→取消→再開→通常終了を採取。824停止サンプル89.116049秒、3節目モデル一致、実Opus b416限定review pass（重大/高/中0）。既存保存・非空待機列・focus復元機構・全8は未証明。原成果加算0。上流未実装に依存する警告等を残し、次に閉じる優先候補をP04-01へ切替。",
    "remaining_deliverables": [
      {
        "id": "P24-01",
@@ -16388,10 +16403,15 @@
            "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p24-02/root-readiness-repair6-20261017/CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_AND_NEXT_GATE.json",
            "sha256": "ad38069fb28ca3218b31bc75673a308ee29b49ac1e30eefb4009d94e0d3b26c4",
            "scope": "Current source6 limited review/actual S-Q post-submit reproduction/native import326parse/3 affected suites; all8 unaccepted, no unit credit"
+          },
+          {
+            "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p24-02/normal-os-case-20261017/AUTHORITATIVE_NARROW_CASE_CLARIFICATIONS.json",
+            "sha256": "fd83e2edd4ac00bc9f8c568f6283ee47af43f91ef06336d36d775508a96682a5",
+            "scope": "One real normal-OS case / limited separate Opus review only; all8 unaccepted, no unit credit"
          }
        ],
-        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-17T15:19:09.416187+09:00",
-        "progress_summary": "提出fe44f55（同一Runner・修正6・上限なし）を保持branchへpush。Opus選定AstraがmovingHEAD基準と非OS証拠/段階循環の2中指摘を修正。実Sと実Qの各2局所試験を提出後に実行し全0、別Opus3cd2285限定レビューpass（重大/高/中0、low5）。実合成M54/Qefd/T1cでimport・326構文・影響3スイート171チェック合格、所有5PID終了、保全/cleanupエラー0。全8は未受入、正式加算0。実通常OS/型付き証拠のend-to-end・上流生産トリガ・最終全回帰/全8review/通常integration-finalが残る。",
+        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-17T16:30:38.746525+09:00",
+        "progress_summary": "提出fe44f55保持。実main565/Q429/T905で通常OSメニュー→別名保存→取消→再開→通常終了を採取。824停止サンプル89.116049秒、3節目モデル一致、実Opus b416限定review pass（重大/高/中0）。既存保存・非空待機列・focus復元機構・全8は未証明。原成果加算0。上流未実装に依存する警告等を残し、次に閉じる優先候補をP04-01へ切替。",
        "remaining_gaps": [
          "placement_and_invalid_drop: Local native coverage passed. Ordinary OS valid/invalid placement and assignment/drop, actual explanation, valid-target behind-modal attempts and click equivalence with model/ledger/selection proof remain.",
          "modal_and_pause_resume: Defense visibility callback and native operation/pause/cancel checks passed. Real valid-target positive control, all required normal modal/focus/pending/save identity and distinct-process continuity remain.",
@@ -16402,7 +16422,7 @@
          "japanese_input_and_scale: Current ordinary OS IME composition/cancel/confirm/invalid input, Japanese persisted save, distinct-process load and required scale/focus/clipping remain. Same Windows release device requirements remain explicitly separate and unaccepted.",
          "final_validation_review: Source/composition guard and twoMedium corrections passed limited review; actual newS/Q post-submit stdlib proof and native import/326parse/3 affected suites passed. Real typed OS/runtime/command/roster artifact assembly and schema end-to-end positive, exact final full180-or-current roster once, whole8 formal Opus review, normal candidate/integration/final remain. Rebind actual current M/Q before formal gates; oldQ is never relabelled."
        ],
-        "current_execution": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p24-02/root-readiness-repair6-20261017/CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_AND_NEXT_GATE.json",
+        "current_execution": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p24-02/normal-os-case-20261017/CURRENT_AND_NEXT.md",
        "submitted_commit": "fe44f550750acbf5c510346e7cacbea2ccbdd184",
        "normal_integration_candidate": null
      },