Complete original P28-01 acceptance and preserve performance shortfalls

docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_ACCEPTANCE_AE9AE47.md

@@ -0,0 +1,37 @@
+# P28-01 正式受入記録
+
+P28-01原work/acceptance/横断6を全9条件（原7枠＋補助2）の独立fresh Desktop Opus5.5レビューPASS、高/中0・low4、通常validation/review/integration/final全PASSと実DB/traceability結合で正式完了。Sddde6f8→Qae9ae47。実測db9d613全9/r02各scope/S954528a別PID再開の版を区別し、製品1407等の実一致を確認。正式23/88・4/30、部分点なし。性能予算6件、200客OpsON、Windows/長期/全ゲーム受入は別未達を維持。
+
+提出 S: `ddde6f8ab50db6baa03f25453a02814b78bbf365`  
+統合・最終検証 Q: `ae9ae47646434dd57fc21f3e8566d0d35b242ab1`  
+基準 M: `0aee05e1d987e126ee9c00536aed5d9c75115d00`
+
+正式証拠: `P28_01_FORMAL_COMPLETION_AE9AE47.json` SHA256 `f778ac8df366110dd7c9ff0b6daa7bde824913e3d813ad090ebd8c20053915a5`
+
+独立レビューは別fresh Claude Desktop Opus5.5。原work/acceptanceと横断6を7枠、補助U1/U2を2枠として判定した。原88成果の分母は増やさない。25合成試験は構造確認であり完了数の代用ではない。全条件の証拠結合、独立レビュー、同一候補の通常integration/finalと台帳を確認して原成果1件を加算した。
+
+G3適用判断: Persisted Runtime state and paused reproduce; wall-clock backlog/sub-minute accumulator deliberately discarded by restore_clock, outside persisted-state contract. Actual writers nonzero accumulator/readers0 and all30 complete typed states/newPID match. Not inferred from non-occurrence.
+
+保存再開は実際の別4PID・各30分の全typed状態と390分の全16イベントに基づく。過負荷停止→保存→復帰の通し試験は未実施で、非0backlog保存の証拠とはしない。
+
+性能予算の失敗は次の6件を維持する。R0は10分参照、P1/P2は各本測定。
+
+| Phase | Metric | Aggregation | Actual (us) | Limit (us) |
+|---|---|---|---:|---:|
+| R0 | main_thread_stall | maximum | 468148 | 50000 |
+| R0 | simulation_x1 | average | 383229 | 4000 |
+| P1 | main_thread_stall | maximum | 4809099 | 50000 |
+| P1 | simulation_x1 | average | 479210 | 4000 |
+| P2 | main_thread_stall | maximum | 5891466 | 50000 |
+| P2 | simulation_x3 | p95 | 5062697 | 12000 |
+
+実測はdb9d613、r02はheadless/OpsOFF/x1、保存再開はS954528a。ゲートQで測定したと書き換えない。全1407製品ソース等の一致で適用範囲を検証した。登録150施設と稼働100施設、tiny OperationsON、GPU null理由、r02のseed欄なし/同一入力SHAによる根拠を保持する。
+
+独立レビューlow4（原結果の全文は `P28_01_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_DDDE6F8.json`）:
+
+- U1 budget disclosure is incomplete. GATE_CONDITIONS.unmet and SPEC §5 list four budget falses (P1 x2, P2 x2). The full9 raw R0 report also has two false verdicts: simulation_x1 average 383.229 ms > 4 and main_thread_stall max 468.148 ms > 50. They are not counted as pass, since the verifier rejects false-as-pass in every phase, and the raw is SHA-bound. The disclosure should still list all six, or say that R0 is a 10-minute reference phase, when final/ledger records are written.
+- The verifier's output 'commit' is the hardcoded registered BASE 0aee05e, not the verified S ddde6f8, so the JSON alone mislabels the version that was checked. Version binding still holds: the Runner receipt records ddde6f8, and the MANIFEST/CONDITIONS seals exist only in S's gate files. This is a labeling defect, not missing evidence. A future revision should name the field base_commit and emit the verified HEAD and the verifier's own SHA.
+- G3 residual: the overload-triggered pause→save→load path was not run end to end (overloads 0, backlog_at_save 0). Only manual-pause saves were exercised. It is judged out of the persisted-state contract: paused is persisted, while backlog and the sub-minute accumulator are discarded by design in restore_clock. Keep RESTART low #1 in the ledger, and do not cite this run as proof that a non-zero backlog survives.
+- Verifier strength: verify_conditions(conditions, load_json(craw)) compares the file with itself, so only the CONDITIONS_SHA256 seal gives protection. r02 Operations OFF is not asserted against the raw (only --headless and the absent seed are checked); it rests on report.scope and the sealed scopes. Neither weakens this run.
+
+次成果P28-02は実測上位の改善。P28-03、同一Windows配布版実機、長期通常プレイ、全施設・人物・ルート・エンド・図鑑・完成素材・全ゲーム受入は未完。

docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_DDDE6F8.json

@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
+{
+  "task_id": "P28-01-GATE",
+  "commit": "ddde6f8ab50db6baa03f25453a02814b78bbf365",
+  "status": "pass",
+  "summary": "Fresh independent Desktop whole-unit review (claude-opus-5-5), read-only; nothing executed, edited or committed. Integrity: actual-review-packet SHA 791cf223… (normal packet 8eb2fc73… differs only by the material-pointer line), schema 4334b9c4…, manifest 35495218…, and all 3200 material files re-hash to their manifest SHA. Scope: S ddde6f8 vs base 0aee05e changes only the 4 files under gate/** (new; no test removed). Validation raw: p28-01-gate-unit ran 25 synthetic tests, OK. p28-01-gate-verify against the real bundle exited 0 with passed=true, verified_files 3175 and source_files 1407. Its stdout equals build/p28-01-gate-verify.json. The MANIFEST/CONDITIONS seals that exist only in S matched, so S's verifier was what ran. G0 met: Tick and render CPU (P1–P4: 150/50/2398/745) come from full9, actually measured at db9d613, not at Q. Path, snapshot (count 5), save/autosave and load come from r02 (headless, Operations OFF per report.scope, x1 count 300, path cold 245). Every report carries machine Mac16,10, build/engine c7cccbf8…, seed, speed, interval and mean/P95/max with counts. r02 has no seed field and none is invented: its input_sha256 eb4f7700… equals the R0 input, the fixture and readiness, and R0's seed is 28012026. Registered 20000/200/50/150 with 100 active; the P2 warm-up is 31. G1: collector C1/C9 UI speed path and RESTART RS1 UI save/load; Mac only, Windows not verified. G2: default autoload world; O is a real Operations ON run on a tiny input (guests 0–2, facilities 0, 50 cells). G3 met (independent judgment): the original wording 「途中保存・再起動で再現」 requires the persisted Runtime state to reproduce after a mid-run save in a new process. The product's save contract persists paused in clock_snapshot, so an overload stop survives as paused. restore_clock (simulation_kernel.gd:217-231) deliberately sets _accumulator=0 and _skip_next_process: backlog and the sub-minute phase are wall-clock catch-up debt, not game state, and create_snapshot (simulation_runtime.gd:521-583) does not carry them. Requiring them to survive would contradict the product contract and is not implied by the original text. This is not inferred from 'did not occur'. Raw shows the writers saved with a non-zero sub-minute accumulator (R 0.0539 s, O 0.1 s) while the readers restored 0. All 30 per-minute complete typed SHAs still matched across 4 distinct PIDs. Tamper was rejected with CHECKSUM_MISMATCH, and O IDs 9–24 / counter 24 at 390 are equal across the restart. G4: collector stop contract and phase failures, RESTART tamper, paused-idle and boundary. G5: formal 192/192, 22198 checks; source map equals the current 1407-file product map and the full9/r02/RESTART maps; marker and engine match. G6: every receipt is SHA-bound through the sealed manifest. U1/U2 are recorded as auxiliary, not original. U2: each evidence is applied only to its own commit, input and scope. C1 is confirmed independently: SPEC.md at 0aee05e and ddde6f8 has raw SHA e2bff09a… and text.strip() SHA 641ce9ea…, the same blob with no criteria change. The first b78c718 block was a correct contract question with 0 edits. This is the gate judgment only; RESTART completed is not original completion. P28-01 stays 22/88 until prepare, approval, integration, final and the ledger.",
+  "acceptance_ids": [
+    "P28-01-G0",
+    "P28-01-G1",
+    "P28-01-G2",
+    "P28-01-G3",
+    "P28-01-G4",
+    "P28-01-G5",
+    "P28-01-G6",
+    "P28-01-U1",
+    "P28-01-U2"
+  ],
+  "findings": [
+    {
+      "severity": "low",
+      "message": "U1 budget disclosure is incomplete. GATE_CONDITIONS.unmet and SPEC §5 list four budget falses (P1 x2, P2 x2). The full9 raw R0 report also has two false verdicts: simulation_x1 average 383.229 ms > 4 and main_thread_stall max 468.148 ms > 50. They are not counted as pass, since the verifier rejects false-as-pass in every phase, and the raw is SHA-bound. The disclosure should still list all six, or say that R0 is a 10-minute reference phase, when final/ledger records are written."
+    },
+    {
+      "severity": "low",
+      "message": "The verifier's output 'commit' is the hardcoded registered BASE 0aee05e, not the verified S ddde6f8, so the JSON alone mislabels the version that was checked. Version binding still holds: the Runner receipt records ddde6f8, and the MANIFEST/CONDITIONS seals exist only in S's gate files. This is a labeling defect, not missing evidence. A future revision should name the field base_commit and emit the verified HEAD and the verifier's own SHA."
+    },
+    {
+      "severity": "low",
+      "message": "G3 residual: the overload-triggered pause→save→load path was not run end to end (overloads 0, backlog_at_save 0). Only manual-pause saves were exercised. It is judged out of the persisted-state contract: paused is persisted, while backlog and the sub-minute accumulator are discarded by design in restore_clock. Keep RESTART low #1 in the ledger, and do not cite this run as proof that a non-zero backlog survives."
+    },
+    {
+      "severity": "low",
+      "message": "Verifier strength: verify_conditions(conditions, load_json(craw)) compares the file with itself, so only the CONDITIONS_SHA256 seal gives protection. r02 Operations OFF is not asserted against the raw (only --headless and the absent seed are checked); it rests on report.scope and the sealed scopes. Neither weakens this run."
+    }
+  ]
+}

docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/plan_validation.json

@@ -243,7 +243,7 @@
     "facility_value_contracts_validation.json": "bf490a9ca585c48fc318e76c4a069ef244827d828d46e6415399f7710590dd16",
     "performance_audit.json": "0b630b15a392c3e0366f1362bfe4ddacb968f915f54549f82e4d6fa315384762",
     "progress_contract.json": "ccbdfce8c8365d5c13f59531955708834cce45acd0e136561c95295dfdb5df77",
-    "progress_snapshot.json": "3c9175a894f639fd8fc6795c421a9f38742bab1f18d45c58fec3d65296d80613",
+    "progress_snapshot.json": "ded46f69cf3179bc94b0614b61da4d6ee10a0ec4eaad9a8b212e46f40063378d",
     "progress_validator_guard_checks.json": "72ee513fcf1cad85c24bfd0a4b472f425f6acf117928ece0f6b41e29018da627",
     "progress_validator_guard_checks.r01.json": "14c26adffa5a1938241db4912e50ea54b660641ee6fee2e412d467dce14d0519",
     "requirement_coverage.json": "03b10e4da367579db502d0671a6e0dda36fd385111c6f1c0084acaff7605f593",
@@ -253,6 +253,6 @@
     "validate_facility_value_contracts.py": "91640e2a76cd6cc9186f7b85c0bf379b24b6cac0d48962815235ee628e7ae43e",
     "validate_plan.py": "4973d3c2797289d266f5c6e7c36f3d2c31931b23a1022eab3d94328267bcc1b4",
     "validator_update_checks.json": "f997d0f3de2cea29550840b1d5cb23647d64f81329de46758551e2b6c8fecc27",
-    "work_packages.json": "26ae4834d412f88743cd3bcff1d891edc597b1e357244139b3fd8ba9d90fd9f1"
+    "work_packages.json": "2e680092a2d1f9bd1055b648fc6872f353d1ed305b69a2a852707dd38f36aa16"
   }
 }

docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/progress_snapshot.json

@@ -1,9 +1,9 @@
 {
   "schema_version": 1,
-  "integrated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T04:37:36.598744+09:00",
+  "integrated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T05:32:26.404125+09:00",
-  "scope": "原30パッケージ/88成果、正式完了22成果・4パッケージ。部分点なし。現在P28-01は未完、collectorの補助成果は原加算0。全ゲーム/同一Windows版の最終受入は未完。",
+  "scope": "原30パッケージ/88成果、正式完了23成果・4パッケージ。部分点なし。P28-01全条件を独立レビュー/通常final/実DB結合で正式完了。次P28-02未完。全ゲーム/同一Windows最終受入は未完。",
-  "source_head": "3ac2cedc8dc977778fd5a3ba152197cc6cf00fa2",
+  "source_head": "ae9ae47646434dd57fc21f3e8566d0d35b242ab1",
-  "source_authority_note": "台帳更新直前mainQ3ac2ced。RESTART S954528a→Q3ac2ced正式8/8全4通常ゲートPASS。実native7/全raw243/PID/sidecar結合、独立freshDesktop Opus5.5全8PASS/highmedium0/low3を実証。受信900秒失敗は保持し、同じ実結果だけ正確凍結入力で通常reviewへ1回再接続。CLI認証回復とは扱わない。原22/88・4/30、P28-01 whole-unit未完。",
+  "source_authority_note": "台帳更新直前main Qae9ae47。P28-01原成果はSddde6f8で別fresh Desktop Opus全9PASS、高/中0・low4、Qで通常integration/finalと実DB/traceability照合。実測db9d613/r02/S954528aを自身の版/scopeで保持し、候補source1421一致。正式23/88、P28 package未完。新SHA別の人間発言は作らず既存のRoot判断委任を正直に適用。",
   "immutable_history": {
     "baseline.json": {
       "sha256": "750bb3d313cc5e2ce0d4c79e563a995abd7a78f991dee1dd75c627877b02cd7b",
@@ -160,8 +160,8 @@
     "in_progress": 26
   },
   "current_delivery_state_counts": {
-    "completed": 22,
+    "completed": 23,
-    "in_progress": 19,
+    "in_progress": 18,
     "planned": 47
   },
   "completed_current_deliveries": [
@@ -186,7 +186,8 @@
     "P23-01",
     "P23-03",
     "P24-03",
-    "P26-01"
+    "P26-01",
+    "P28-01"
   ],
   "whole_packages_newly_completed": [
     "P04",
@@ -197,7 +198,7 @@
     "原子条件の8観点と適用外/独立判定者",
     "最終内容catalog/全施設適用範囲",
     "全機能の途中保存・旧版移行・fresh process再開",
-    "20,000/200/50/150の実Runtime性能と描画",
+    "20,000/200/50/150測定記録はP28-01正式完了。性能予算6件の改善・200客OpsON最大場面・Windows描画・長期操作感は未達。",
     "同一Windows配布版の実機通常操作/保存再開",
     "全施設/人物/ルート/エンド/図鑑/完成素材/実プレイ時間"
   ],
@@ -5252,30 +5253,56 @@
     "sha256": "45845238d8a73b84fd346f2d834ee4aaa12d32b45367ea0952b523db9b2523d9"
   },
   "next_single_delivery_unit": {
-    "id": "P28-01",
+    "id": "P28-02",
-    "title": "現HEADの性能基準",
+    "title": "意味を保つ軽量化",
     "state": "in_progress",
     "completed": false,
+    "work_verbatim": "失敗時拒否を含む同等性を先に固定し、snapshot変換・検証・コピー・経路接続の実測上位から改善する。",
+    "acceptance_verbatim": "同条件の反復比較と全状態・全イベント一致を確認し、キャッシュの古さ・所有権・不正入力を検証する。",
+    "cross_cutting_acceptance_verbatim": [
+      "原本条件とUI操作が一致",
+      "Runtimeの実利用・会計・行動へ接続",
+      "途中保存・再起動で再現",
+      "異常/境界/中断を検証",
+      "関連回帰PASS",
+      "要件別ログとソースハッシュを保存"
+    ],
+    "dependency": {
+      "package_depends_on": [
+        "P27"
+      ],
+      "does_not_claim_P27_complete": true,
+      "P28_01_baseline_formally_completed": {
+        "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_FORMAL_COMPLETION_AE9AE47.json",
+        "bytes": 65719,
+        "sha256": "f778ac8df366110dd7c9ff0b6daa7bde824913e3d813ad090ebd8c20053915a5"
+      }
+    },
     "reusable_evidence": [
+      {
+        "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_FORMAL_COMPLETION_AE9AE47.json",
+        "bytes": 65719,
+        "sha256": "f778ac8df366110dd7c9ff0b6daa7bde824913e3d813ad090ebd8c20053915a5"
+      },
+      {
+        "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/INTEGRATED_FULL9_MEASUREMENT_DB9D613.json",
+        "bytes": 180441,
+        "sha256": "a76082f767e0a0d52cb70e2f66fa371b62a88754e9be319da3c08d4b48e78ba0"
+      },
       {
         "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/RESTART_FORMAL_COMPLETION_3AC2CED.json",
         "bytes": 6366,
         "sha256": "5c9b82a70f6bdb972d720aaa64f5d27aa54130f27f9d1f7cea1c7b02524f84be"
-      },
-      {
-        "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-01-runner-preflight-r01/native-restart-954528a-r01/ROOT_RAW_ACCEPTANCE_JOIN.json",
-        "bytes": 70643,
-        "sha256": "6dbb3cbb4ac1838b66034323cab22a9c5a968c1da0efe8d34676073b3f980cfb"
-      },
-      {
-        "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-01-runner-preflight-r01/ROOT_CANDIDATE_3AC2CED_QUALIFICATION.json",
-        "bytes": 235149,
-        "sha256": "5bd8030acddc385eb728441286f6a740ec1ee966125474b60ef4b1efe2a2c343"
       }
     ],
-    "remaining": "collector/full9/RESTART正式完了。残りは原whole-unit証拠ゲート・独立レビュー・通常integration/final・台帳のみ。原加算0。",
+    "remaining": [
-    "original_completed": 22,
+      "原work/acceptance/横断6の全条件を保つ具体契約を実Opusが策定し、同条件反復・全状態/全イベント一致・拒否・古さ/所有権/不正入力を固定。",
-    "original_total": 88
+      "実測上位の原因を分離し、関連変更をまとめて局所/影響試験後、正確最終版で必要全回帰・性能比較・独立whole-unitレビュー・通常統合final・台帳。",
+      "性能予算false6件（R0参照2/P1測定2/P2測定2）を合格へ補完しない。P28-03/Windows/長期条件は別未達。"
+    ],
+    "original_completed": 23,
+    "original_total": 88,
+    "new_optimization_accepted": false
   },
   "current_P14_01_contract_audit": {
     "audit": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p14-01-current-contract-audit-r01/audit.json",
@@ -9742,17 +9769,17 @@
     "execution": "the-tree-p06-01 Runner; recorded Claude decision, one Codex implementer",
     "current_gate_status": "not implemented or executed; formal completion not accepted"
   },
-  "next_closure_plan_id": "P28-01",
+  "next_closure_plan_id": "P28-02",
   "p24_03_formal_closure": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p24-03-formal-closure-r01/closure.json",
   "new_engine_run_scope": "Supplemental positive metadata diagnostic r01 failed cleanup preparation/log isolation; r02 passed17checks unchanged source and entire default profile. No duplicated full game regression.",
   "current_closure_targets": {
-    "formally_closed": "P14-03",
+    "formally_closed": "P28-01",
-    "next_candidate": "P28-01",
+    "next_candidate": "P28-02",
-    "formal_count": 22,
+    "formal_count": 23,
     "original_delivery_units": 88,
     "partial_credit": false,
-    "selection_status": "P28-01-COLLECTOR正式9/9、実db9d613全9測定、RESTART Q3ac2ced正式8/8完了。現在は原P28-01 whole-unit証拠ゲートを1件閉じる。",
+    "selection_status": "P28-01全条件の独立whole-unitレビュー/通常final/台帳まで完了。次はP28-02を1成果として閉じる。",
-    "pending_decisions": "実Opus266のwhole-unit草案を原条件・証拠と照合し通常登録。G3適用判断は別Opusレビュー。未回答ゲーム仕様は確定しない。"
+    "pending_decisions": "実OpusがP28-02具体契約/実測上位/担当を判断。新規改善は未着手。P28-01 low4・予算6件/Windows/長期等を明記し基準変更しない。"
   },
   "historical_regression_before_P08_02_formal_closure": {
     "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p23-02-final-candidate-r32-combined-root-acceptance-r01.json",
@@ -10334,8 +10361,8 @@
     "unresolved_original_content": "Five definitions absent in bounded current search, all required asset counts/content quantities remain unknown; D08/D09 pending. P13-01/P13-02 remain planned.",
     "new_engine_runs": 0
   },
-  "active_implementation_plan_id": "P28-01",
+  "active_implementation_plan_id": "P28-02",
-  "active_backend_task": "P28-01-RESTART",
+  "active_backend_task": null,
   "p18_current_execution": {
     "original_plan_id": "P18-01",
     "existing_task": "the-tree-p18-01-model/P18-01-CODE",
@@ -10550,7 +10577,7 @@
     },
     "whole_game_acceptance": false
   },
-  "next_closure_note": "P28-01を次に閉じる。S954528aのnative7→Root完全結合→独立Opus全8→通常integration/final→原wholeunit証拠ゲート/独立review/final/台帳まで原加算0。P28-02の予算未達を保持。",
+  "next_closure_note": "P28-01正式完了。次P28-02は実Opusの具体契約/実測上位選定から。予算6未達を残し、新規最適化/受入は未実施。",
   "current_p26_01_content_ledger": {
     "at": "2026-10-17T20:44:25.180745+09:00",
     "original_plan_id": "P26-01",
@@ -10742,20 +10769,23 @@
     "controller_local_session": "local_a7f85421-3eed-4482-8030-c0dca669573a",
     "actual_model": "Opus5.5 medium",
     "desktop_read_write_roundtrip_verified": true,
-    "project": "the-tree-p28-01-restart",
+    "project": "the-tree-p28-01-gate",
-    "task": "P28-01-RESTART",
+    "task": "P28-01-GATE",
     "state": "completed",
-    "submission": "954528a7c5a0e27e2e50b642373168fa0a550aba",
+    "submission": "ddde6f8ab50db6baa03f25453a02814b78bbf365",
-    "candidate": "3ac2cedc8dc977778fd5a3ba152197cc6cf00fa2",
+    "candidate": "ae9ae47646434dd57fc21f3e8566d0d35b242ab1",
     "evidence": {
-      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/RESTART_FORMAL_COMPLETION_3AC2CED.json",
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_FORMAL_COMPLETION_AE9AE47.json",
-      "bytes": 6366,
+      "bytes": 65719,
-      "sha256": "5c9b82a70f6bdb972d720aaa64f5d27aa54130f27f9d1f7cea1c7b02524f84be"
+      "sha256": "f778ac8df366110dd7c9ff0b6daa7bde824913e3d813ad090ebd8c20053915a5"
     },
-    "helper_credit": 0,
+    "independent_reviewer_session": "local_c6475c60-d77b-4441-b241-3d066d49ea07",
-    "original_completed": 22,
+    "independent_result_sha256": "4fe71ca73b1396ef7a432f8b14da78b2cb70eb286f13c7011bc92371ccd51750",
+    "all4_normal_gates_passed": true,
+    "original_credit": 1,
+    "original_completed": 23,
     "original_total": 88,
-    "next": "the-tree-p28-01-gate/P28-01-GATE; actual Desktop266 draft; not registered yet"
+    "next": "P28-02 concrete measured-hotpath/equivalence contract by actual Desktop Opus; not yet registered"
   },
   "historical_workflow_before_desktop_handoff_20261019": {
     "source_thread": "01a14f6a-b6a1-7fd3-bd45-0f84bbef77be",
@@ -10929,7 +10959,7 @@
       "both_budget_passed": false,
       "full9_measurement": false
     },
-    "next": "原P28-01 whole-unitゲートを実Opus草案から照合・登録し、証拠検証→独立レビュー→通常統合final→台帳まで閉じる。",
+    "next": "P28-02: 実測上位と失敗時拒否/全状態・イベント一致を実Opusが具体契約化。",
     "same_Windows_verified": false,
     "full9_measurement": {
       "actual_commit": "db9d6132a8349928560dc4a4a99306d27a81e332",
@@ -11065,7 +11095,15 @@
       ],
       "source_proof": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/RESTART_954528A_FORMAL_AND_NATIVE_CHECKPOINT.json",
       "source_proof_sha256": "975a3c4dfb09af1c39786b1cd9a36aaa01a7c19bb399c0c5f3fc9d720b24537e"
-    }
+    },
+    "whole_unit_state": "completed",
+    "whole_unit_proof": {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_FORMAL_COMPLETION_AE9AE47.json",
+      "bytes": 65719,
+      "sha256": "f778ac8df366110dd7c9ff0b6daa7bde824913e3d813ad090ebd8c20053915a5"
+    },
+    "whole_unit_original_credit": 1,
+    "formal_original_completed": 23
   },
   "historical_latest_regression_before_full192_header_sync_20261021": {
     "source": "d2581afd26d1976cdfe4f44c89df49a772524d1e",
@@ -11318,5 +11356,199 @@
     ],
     "remaining": "P06 whole-unit gameplay acceptance, unapproved production mana policy, P14 warp dependency and all recorded cross-cutting conditions remain open",
     "next": "Persistent Claude Desktop controller decides next original P06 acceptance batch from completed audit; Root maintains approvals/ledger. No duplicate temporary commander."
+  },
+  "historical_before_P28_01_formal_ae9ae47": {
+    "scope": "原30パッケージ/88成果、正式完了22成果・4パッケージ。部分点なし。現在P28-01は未完、collectorの補助成果は原加算0。全ゲーム/同一Windows版の最終受入は未完。",
+    "source_head": "3ac2cedc8dc977778fd5a3ba152197cc6cf00fa2",
+    "source_authority_note": "台帳更新直前mainQ3ac2ced。RESTART S954528a→Q3ac2ced正式8/8全4通常ゲートPASS。実native7/全raw243/PID/sidecar結合、独立freshDesktop Opus5.5全8PASS/highmedium0/low3を実証。受信900秒失敗は保持し、同じ実結果だけ正確凍結入力で通常reviewへ1回再接続。CLI認証回復とは扱わない。原22/88・4/30、P28-01 whole-unit未完。",
+    "current_closure_targets": {
+      "formally_closed": "P14-03",
+      "next_candidate": "P28-01",
+      "formal_count": 22,
+      "original_delivery_units": 88,
+      "partial_credit": false,
+      "selection_status": "P28-01-COLLECTOR正式9/9、実db9d613全9測定、RESTART Q3ac2ced正式8/8完了。現在は原P28-01 whole-unit証拠ゲートを1件閉じる。",
+      "pending_decisions": "実Opus266のwhole-unit草案を原条件・証拠と照合し通常登録。G3適用判断は別Opusレビュー。未回答ゲーム仕様は確定しない。"
+    },
+    "next_single_delivery_unit": {
+      "id": "P28-01",
+      "title": "現HEADの性能基準",
+      "state": "in_progress",
+      "completed": false,
+      "reusable_evidence": [
+        {
+          "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/RESTART_FORMAL_COMPLETION_3AC2CED.json",
+          "bytes": 6366,
+          "sha256": "5c9b82a70f6bdb972d720aaa64f5d27aa54130f27f9d1f7cea1c7b02524f84be"
+        },
+        {
+          "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-01-runner-preflight-r01/native-restart-954528a-r01/ROOT_RAW_ACCEPTANCE_JOIN.json",
+          "bytes": 70643,
+          "sha256": "6dbb3cbb4ac1838b66034323cab22a9c5a968c1da0efe8d34676073b3f980cfb"
+        },
+        {
+          "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-01-runner-preflight-r01/ROOT_CANDIDATE_3AC2CED_QUALIFICATION.json",
+          "bytes": 235149,
+          "sha256": "5bd8030acddc385eb728441286f6a740ec1ee966125474b60ef4b1efe2a2c343"
+        }
+      ],
+      "remaining": "collector/full9/RESTART正式完了。残りは原whole-unit証拠ゲート・独立レビュー・通常integration/final・台帳のみ。原加算0。",
+      "original_completed": 22,
+      "original_total": 88
+    },
+    "current_workflow_handoff": {
+      "controller_title": "ゲーム開発作業",
+      "controller_local_session": "local_a7f85421-3eed-4482-8030-c0dca669573a",
+      "actual_model": "Opus5.5 medium",
+      "desktop_read_write_roundtrip_verified": true,
+      "project": "the-tree-p28-01-restart",
+      "task": "P28-01-RESTART",
+      "state": "completed",
+      "submission": "954528a7c5a0e27e2e50b642373168fa0a550aba",
+      "candidate": "3ac2cedc8dc977778fd5a3ba152197cc6cf00fa2",
+      "evidence": {
+        "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/RESTART_FORMAL_COMPLETION_3AC2CED.json",
+        "bytes": 6366,
+        "sha256": "5c9b82a70f6bdb972d720aaa64f5d27aa54130f27f9d1f7cea1c7b02524f84be"
+      },
+      "helper_credit": 0,
+      "original_completed": 22,
+      "original_total": 88,
+      "next": "the-tree-p28-01-gate/P28-01-GATE; actual Desktop266 draft; not registered yet"
+    },
+    "next_closure_note": "P28-01を次に閉じる。S954528aのnative7→Root完全結合→独立Opus全8→通常integration/final→原wholeunit証拠ゲート/独立review/final/台帳まで原加算0。P28-02の予算未達を保持。",
+    "active_backend_task": "P28-01-RESTART"
+  },
+  "current_P28_01_formal_completion": {
+    "state": "completed",
+    "S": "ddde6f8ab50db6baa03f25453a02814b78bbf365",
+    "Q": "ae9ae47646434dd57fc21f3e8566d0d35b242ab1",
+    "all4_normal_gates_passed": true,
+    "proof": {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_FORMAL_COMPLETION_AE9AE47.json",
+      "bytes": 65719,
+      "sha256": "f778ac8df366110dd7c9ff0b6daa7bde824913e3d813ad090ebd8c20053915a5"
+    },
+    "independent_review": {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_DDDE6F8.json",
+      "bytes": 5545,
+      "sha256": "4fe71ca73b1396ef7a432f8b14da78b2cb70eb286f13c7011bc92371ccd51750"
+    },
+    "original_credit": 1,
+    "formal_original_completed": 23,
+    "original_total": 88,
+    "G3_independent_applicability_judgment": "Persisted Runtime state and paused reproduce; wall-clock backlog/sub-minute accumulator deliberately discarded by restore_clock, outside persisted-state contract. Actual writers nonzero accumulator/readers0 and all30 complete typed states/newPID match. Not inferred from non-occurrence.",
+    "all6_failed_budget_verdicts": [
+      {
+        "phase": "R0",
+        "metric": "main_thread_stall",
+        "aggregation": "maximum",
+        "limit_us": 50000,
+        "passed": false,
+        "reason": null,
+        "source": "clock.performance_budget._samples",
+        "statistics": {
+          "average_us": 383229,
+          "count": 10,
+          "maximum_us": 468148,
+          "p95_us": 468148
+        },
+        "value": 468148,
+        "window": "interval_exact_from_samples"
+      },
+      {
+        "phase": "R0",
+        "metric": "simulation_x1",
+        "aggregation": "average",
+        "limit_us": 4000,
+        "passed": false,
+        "reason": null,
+        "source": "clock.performance_budget._samples",
+        "statistics": {
+          "average_us": 383229,
+          "count": 10,
+          "maximum_us": 468148,
+          "p95_us": 468148
+        },
+        "value": 383229,
+        "window": "interval_exact_from_samples"
+      },
+      {
+        "phase": "P1",
+        "metric": "main_thread_stall",
+        "aggregation": "maximum",
+        "limit_us": 50000,
+        "passed": false,
+        "reason": null,
+        "source": "clock.performance_budget._samples",
+        "statistics": {
+          "average_us": 479210,
+          "count": 120,
+          "maximum_us": 4809099,
+          "p95_us": 745365
+        },
+        "value": 4809099,
+        "window": "interval_exact_from_samples"
+      },
+      {
+        "phase": "P1",
+        "metric": "simulation_x1",
+        "aggregation": "average",
+        "limit_us": 4000,
+        "passed": false,
+        "reason": null,
+        "source": "clock.performance_budget._samples",
+        "statistics": {
+          "average_us": 479210,
+          "count": 120,
+          "maximum_us": 4809099,
+          "p95_us": 745365
+        },
+        "value": 479210,
+        "window": "interval_exact_from_samples"
+      },
+      {
+        "phase": "P2",
+        "metric": "main_thread_stall",
+        "aggregation": "maximum",
+        "limit_us": 50000,
+        "passed": false,
+        "reason": null,
+        "source": "clock.performance_budget._samples",
+        "statistics": {
+          "average_us": 1142933,
+          "count": 50,
+          "maximum_us": 5891466,
+          "p95_us": 5062697
+        },
+        "value": 5891466,
+        "window": "interval_exact_from_samples"
+      },
+      {
+        "phase": "P2",
+        "metric": "simulation_x3",
+        "aggregation": "p95",
+        "limit_us": 12000,
+        "passed": false,
+        "reason": null,
+        "source": "clock.performance_budget._samples",
+        "statistics": {
+          "average_us": 1142933,
+          "count": 50,
+          "maximum_us": 5891466,
+          "p95_us": 5062697
+        },
+        "value": 5062697,
+        "window": "interval_exact_from_samples"
+      }
+    ],
+    "remaining_not_claimed": [
+      "All6 R0/P1/P2 failed performance budgets remain P28-02/03",
+      "200guest OperationsON maximum scene remains untested; actual O is tiny50cells/0..2guests/0facilities",
+      "GPU timing null with GLCompatibility reason; no fabricated value",
+      "Overload-triggered pause to save to load end-to-end not executed; no nonzero wall-clock backlog persistence claim",
+      "Same Windows distribution/native acceptance, long normal play and full game final acceptance remain",
+      "Low verifier commit labeling and seal/direct-scope assertion improvements retained for scoped follow-up, no criteria weakening"
+    ]
   }
 }

docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json

@@ -18066,14 +18066,14 @@
     },
     "legacy_state": "planned",
     "state_scope": "package-level; completed means whole package accepted; partial implementation is not completion",
-    "current_summary": "P28-01 collector補助9/9とRESTART補助8/8が全4通常ゲートで正式完了。実db9d613全9測定とS954528a別PID保存再開の全rawを保持し、Q3ac2cedの製品1407/collector4/probe4への適用を実照合。原P28-01はwork/acceptance/横断6の最終証拠ゲートと独立whole-unitレビュー・通常final・台帳が残るため未完、原22/88・4/30・部分点なし。予算未達/200客OpsON/GPU null/同一Windows/長期は別未達を保持。",
+    "current_summary": "P28-01原work/acceptance/横断6を全9条件（原7枠＋補助2）の独立fresh Desktop Opus5.5レビューPASS、高/中0・low4、通常validation/review/integration/final全PASSと実DB/traceability結合で正式完了。Sddde6f8→Qae9ae47。実測db9d613全9/r02各scope/S954528a別PID再開の版を区別し、製品1407等の実一致を確認。正式23/88・4/30、部分点なし。性能予算6件、200客OpsON、Windows/長期/全ゲーム受入は別未達を維持。",
     "remaining_deliverables": [
       {
         "id": "P28-01",
         "title": "現HEADの性能基準",
         "work": "実Runtimeの20,000マス・200客・50職員・150施設を基準にTick、経路、snapshot、描画、保存を測る。",
         "acceptance": "機種、ビルド、シード、速度、測定区間、平均・P95・最大を残す。",
-        "state": "in_progress",
+        "state": "completed",
         "evidence": [
           {
             "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-maxscale-timeout-root-review-r01.json",
@@ -18186,17 +18186,67 @@
             "bytes": 235149,
             "sha256": "5bd8030acddc385eb728441286f6a740ec1ee966125474b60ef4b1efe2a2c343",
             "scope": "Q3ac2cedの製品1407/probe4/実nativeとfull9適用範囲照合"
+          },
+          {
+            "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_FORMAL_COMPLETION_AE9AE47.json",
+            "bytes": 65719,
+            "sha256": "f778ac8df366110dd7c9ff0b6daa7bde824913e3d813ad090ebd8c20053915a5",
+            "scope": "Original P28-01 whole-unit formally completed; all4 normal gates, actual separate Opus all9, original+1 after ledger",
+            "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-21T05:32:26.404125+09:00"
+          },
+          {
+            "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_DDDE6F8.json",
+            "bytes": 5545,
+            "sha256": "4fe71ca73b1396ef7a432f8b14da78b2cb70eb286f13c7011bc92371ccd51750",
+            "scope": "Actual fresh independent Opus whole-unit result; source Sddde6f8, G3 applicability and four low findings retained",
+            "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-21T05:32:26.404125+09:00"
           }
         ],
-        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T04:37:36.598744+09:00",
+        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T05:32:26.404125+09:00",
-        "progress_summary": "P28-01 collector補助9/9とRESTART補助8/8が全4通常ゲートで正式完了。実db9d613全9測定とS954528a別PID保存再開の全rawを保持し、Q3ac2cedの製品1407/collector4/probe4への適用を実照合。原P28-01はwork/acceptance/横断6の最終証拠ゲートと独立whole-unitレビュー・通常final・台帳が残るため未完、原22/88・4/30・部分点なし。予算未達/200客OpsON/GPU null/同一Windows/長期は別未達を保持。 正式24試験を保持、native R/O K30全状態typed一致・改ざん拒否・実arrival390分16件ID9〜24連番。非0backlog未実施/private accumulator非保存は非主張、独立low3保持。旧bc703c9/5E/e524失敗・受信900秒失敗は失敗のまま。",
+        "progress_summary": "P28-01原work/acceptance/横断6を全9条件（原7枠＋補助2）の独立fresh Desktop Opus5.5レビューPASS、高/中0・low4、通常validation/review/integration/final全PASSと実DB/traceability結合で正式完了。Sddde6f8→Qae9ae47。実測db9d613全9/r02各scope/S954528a別PID再開の版を区別し、製品1407等の実一致を確認。正式23/88・4/30、部分点なし。性能予算6件、200客OpsON、Windows/長期/全ゲーム受入は別未達を維持。",
         "historical_progress_summary_before_20261020": "現1273へPath micro軽量化を限定採用。53 whole typed pairs/120同一呼出return比較と全168回帰を確認。最大Runtime混合負荷/Operations enabled/Windows性能は未受入。旧900秒timeout/未測定値を維持。\n【限定採用前の証拠時点の履歴】\n実Runtime最大負荷診断は準備BUILDで900.024秒timeout（-15）。目標実数/保存/別process/計測に未到達。setup span候補を準備し原因特定を継続。 setup区間観測の別実行も900.018秒timeout。429→430分の公開tickは268.723秒、601→602分は未完。内部hotspot・最終target数・保存・性能測定は未確定。 現1237 counter r04もBUILD900.07856秒timeout(-9)、430CONSTRUCTION268.326934秒。inclusive Path累積は重複合算/差引禁止、602LOGISTICS未閉・最終測定null。",
+        "remaining_gaps": [],
+        "historical_summary_before_integrated_full9_20261021": "r02のheadless/OpsOFF/x1/300分、代表20,000マス/200客/50職員/150施設の既存証拠は対象区間を限定して再利用する（外側advance wall826.6msをKernel4ms予算へ比較しない）。新collectorはS5db97d7を独立Opus全9PASS、高/中0・low3記録、Q0f53a67で通常integration/finalまで完了した。新37合成試験は構造検証、実fresh R0は602→612分/4PID正常終了/Guard・audio・source/player保全を確認し、別31チェックで原rawを照合。実Kernel標本10件からx1平均379427us対4000us、stall最大466395us対50000usでfalseを記録した。これは事前診断で本測定ではない。全R/O・x1/x3・描画/区間/統計と別PID保存再開・原全条件の証拠/独立レビュー/受入まで原成果を完了扱いにしない。",
+        "historical_before_formal_ae9ae47": {
+          "state": "in_progress",
+          "progress_summary": "P28-01 collector補助9/9とRESTART補助8/8が全4通常ゲートで正式完了。実db9d613全9測定とS954528a別PID保存再開の全rawを保持し、Q3ac2cedの製品1407/collector4/probe4への適用を実照合。原P28-01はwork/acceptance/横断6の最終証拠ゲートと独立whole-unitレビュー・通常final・台帳が残るため未完、原22/88・4/30・部分点なし。予算未達/200客OpsON/GPU null/同一Windows/長期は別未達を保持。 正式24試験を保持、native R/O K30全状態typed一致・改ざん拒否・実arrival390分16件ID9〜24連番。非0backlog未実施/private accumulator非保存は非主張、独立low3保持。旧bc703c9/5E/e524失敗・受信900秒失敗は失敗のまま。",
           "remaining_gaps": [
             "原P28-01のwork/acceptance/横断6を保持するwhole-unit証拠ゲート（実Opus266草案を照合中）・独立Opusレビュー・通常prepare/Root委任候補承認/integration/final・台帳。engine/full9/192の重複実行なし。",
             "G3の非0backlog未発生とprivate accumulator非保存の適用判断を理由付きで独立レビュー。開示のみで再現証明へ補完しない。",
             "予算未達4件はP28-02/03に保持、200客OpsON未検証・GPU null理由・同一Windows・長期操作感・全ゲーム最終受入は未達。"
           ],
-        "historical_summary_before_integrated_full9_20261021": "r02のheadless/OpsOFF/x1/300分、代表20,000マス/200客/50職員/150施設の既存証拠は対象区間を限定して再利用する（外側advance wall826.6msをKernel4ms予算へ比較しない）。新collectorはS5db97d7を独立Opus全9PASS、高/中0・low3記録、Q0f53a67で通常integration/finalまで完了した。新37合成試験は構造検証、実fresh R0は602→612分/4PID正常終了/Guard・audio・source/player保全を確認し、別31チェックで原rawを照合。実Kernel標本10件からx1平均379427us対4000us、stall最大466395us対50000usでfalseを記録した。これは事前診断で本測定ではない。全R/O・x1/x3・描画/区間/統計と別PID保存再開・原全条件の証拠/独立レビュー/受入まで原成果を完了扱いにしない。"
+          "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T04:37:36.598744+09:00"
+        },
+        "completed_at_jst": "2026-10-21T05:32:26.404125+09:00",
+        "completion_acceptance": {
+          "S": "ddde6f8ab50db6baa03f25453a02814b78bbf365",
+          "Q": "ae9ae47646434dd57fc21f3e8566d0d35b242ab1",
+          "M": "0aee05e1d987e126ee9c00536aed5d9c75115d00",
+          "all4_normal_gates_passed": true,
+          "original_condition_groups": 7,
+          "auxiliary_condition_groups": 2,
+          "independent_review": {
+            "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_DDDE6F8.json",
+            "bytes": 5545,
+            "sha256": "4fe71ca73b1396ef7a432f8b14da78b2cb70eb286f13c7011bc92371ccd51750"
+          },
+          "formal_proof": {
+            "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_FORMAL_COMPLETION_AE9AE47.json",
+            "bytes": 65719,
+            "sha256": "f778ac8df366110dd7c9ff0b6daa7bde824913e3d813ad090ebd8c20053915a5"
+          },
+          "review_high_medium": 0,
+          "review_low": 4,
+          "original_credit": 1
+        },
+        "residuals_outside_unit_acceptance": [
+          "All6 R0/P1/P2 failed performance budgets remain P28-02/03",
+          "200guest OperationsON maximum scene remains untested; actual O is tiny50cells/0..2guests/0facilities",
+          "GPU timing null with GLCompatibility reason; no fabricated value",
+          "Overload-triggered pause to save to load end-to-end not executed; no nonzero wall-clock backlog persistence claim",
+          "Same Windows distribution/native acceptance, long normal play and full game final acceptance remain",
+          "Low verifier commit labeling and seal/direct-scope assertion improvements retained for scoped follow-up, no criteria weakening"
+        ]
       },
       {
         "id": "P28-02",
@@ -18245,9 +18295,23 @@
             "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false
           }
         ],
+        "progress_summary": "P28-01の正式完了Qae9ae47を基準に、現製品1407と実測db9d613/r02/別PID再開を再利用する。次は実Opusが実測上位と同等性・不正入力拒否の具体契約を選定する。R0の2件を含め予算false計6件を保持。旧1273限定micro採用は履歴で、現候補の新規改善/本単位受入は未実施。",
+        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T05:32:26.404125+09:00",
+        "historical_summary_before_integrated_full9_20261021": "既採用e561 Pathを保持。source1273最大規模・Operations OFFの30分/保存再開を診断し25918+293parse/0。no-route候補の全15byte対照は一致したがmacro因果改善不足で不採用。Operations ON/新1277性能/Windows描画/長期プレイは未受入。",
+        "historical_before_P28_01_formal_completion": {
           "progress_summary": "旧1273時点の限定軽量化・不採用記録を保持。現在の製品source1407（83b170aと同一）の実main db9d613全9測定で、代表R x1平均479.210ms/P95745.365ms/最大4809.099ms、x3P955062.697ms/最大5891.466msの予算未達を確定。O小入力の合格を最大負荷へ拡張しない。原P28-01の別PID再開・wholeunit受入を先に閉じ、同等性と失敗拒否を固定してから実測上位の改善へ進む。本単位の新規最適化/受入は未実施。",
-        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T01:04:05.061475+09:00",
+          "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T01:04:05.061475+09:00"
-        "historical_summary_before_integrated_full9_20261021": "既採用e561 Pathを保持。source1273最大規模・Operations OFFの30分/保存再開を診断し25918+293parse/0。no-route候補の全15byte対照は一致したがmacro因果改善不足で不採用。Operations ON/新1277性能/Windows描画/長期プレイは未受入。"
+        },
+        "remaining_gaps": [
+          "原work/acceptance/横断6の全条件を保つ具体契約を実Opusが策定し、同条件反復・全状態/全イベント一致・拒否・古さ/所有権/不正入力を固定。",
+          "実測上位の原因を分離し、関連変更をまとめて局所/影響試験後、正確最終版で必要全回帰・性能比較・独立whole-unitレビュー・通常統合final・台帳。",
+          "性能予算false6件（R0参照2/P1測定2/P2測定2）を合格へ補完しない。P28-03/Windows/長期条件は別未達。"
+        ],
+        "baseline_original_unit_completion": {
+          "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_FORMAL_COMPLETION_AE9AE47.json",
+          "bytes": 65719,
+          "sha256": "f778ac8df366110dd7c9ff0b6daa7bde824913e3d813ad090ebd8c20053915a5"
+        }
       },
       {
         "id": "P28-03",
@@ -18530,7 +18594,7 @@
     ],
     "cross_cutting_acceptance_scope": "Completion requirements only, not achieved results. Apply each to relevant slices; non-applicable views require a recorded reason.",
     "initial_revision_state": "in_progress",
-    "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T04:37:36.598744+09:00",
+    "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T05:32:26.404125+09:00",
     "execution_progress": {
       "current1277_checkpoint": {
         "source_files": 1273,