Record formal P28-02 equivalence harness acceptance without original-unit credit

P28-02-EQ (support task) completed through the normal Runner flow: S 9adbbee -> Q 4e34e52 on main 54e07ca. Exact-S native 7 phases, formal unit 179 and native-verify, fresh independent Opus review of all 6 conditions (pass, low 2), normal integration and final, joined with the actual Runner DB and traceability. The earlier changes_requested (a46418d, EQ5) and the b2dbda8/6f75c9a failures stay preserved. Original P28-02 remains in progress; 23/88 and 4/30 unchanged. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-22 10:15:10 +09:00
parent 4e34e52097
commit 44bce9177c
5 changed files with 911 additions and 322 deletions
@@ -18073,7 +18073,7 @@
    },
    "legacy_state": "planned",
    "state_scope": "package-level; completed means whole package accepted; partial implementation is not completion",
-    "current_summary": "原P28-02未完、補助EQも未受入。旧S6f75c9aは146局所試験後に通常提出済みだが正確S nativeのmkdir失敗を保全。実Runner repair_ready10、旧Codex run92b50は終了済み。ユーザー委任をevent84へ記録し、Desktop Opus5.5超高が同WのS5を指揮・実装中。R/O双方E1〜E5・39行を維持、信号のコマンド/通常公開をsource因果で完全照合。旧156局所試験211.416秒の後にも修正があり、新版合格に流用しない。scratch R3はGodot942秒/exit0、Pythonのcheck_report/自己比較True・実exit0だが全体1270.3秒、lifecycle300.6秒で正式verify300秒未達。NA/既存不具合をPASS補完せず全raw保持。Opusが保持R3 rawでcProfileと結果同値のreader高速化を進行、Rootは重複実装/engine/試験を起動しない。最終Sのnative7・両正式validation・fresh独立Opus全6・通常Q資格/委任承認/統合final、続くOPT T1/同条件3反復/RESTART/正確最終全192/原work・ACと横断6のwhole-unit受入は未達。原30/88・正式23/88、4/30・部分点なし、補助EQの原加算0。最大場面性能、完成資産、同一Windows実機、長期通し、全ゲームの未達を維持。",
+    "current_summary": "P28-02-EQ補助はS 9adbbee→Q 4e34e52で正式完了（Runner completed・補助6/6）。正確S native7（PID7・profile14・cleanup0・source1407・seal v2）、正式unit179/native-verify、fresh独立Opus全6 PASS（high/medium0・low2）、通常integration/final、実DB/traceability照合。前S a46418dのEQ5 changes_requested、b2dbda8のvalidation失敗、6f75c9aのnative失敗は保全。実装はユーザー委任のDesktop Opus5.5（contract workerはcodexのまま）。原成果加算0。次はOPT_CONTRACT_T1 §6の順で、EQ前の値（S_eq nativeをQ_eqで資格確認済み）と(b)前版2回、OPT登録・実装（許可6ファイル、範囲内の既存Eの不具合の修正を含む）、S上のEQ after・(a)(b)(c)(d)、OPT validation、whole-unit独立レビュー、統合final、台帳23→24。原P28-02は未完。正式23/88・4/30、部分点なし。性能予算false6・200客OpsON/同一Windows/長期/全ゲームは別未達。",
    "remaining_deliverables": [
      {
        "id": "P28-01",
@@ -18314,20 +18314,27 @@
            "sha256": "021b76676bc68a9e008cfd27c7f1438f2d483f0f44e85e75cb83e2d49f700d71",
            "scope": "Actual EQ registration and repair1 implementing checkpoint only; no auxiliary or original acceptance credit",
            "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-21T07:31:50.231974+09:00"
+          },
+          {
+            "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_FORMAL_COMPLETION_4E34E52.json",
+            "bytes": 23096,
+            "sha256": "833f29fd97f54a2150a3e674ba45353f938207f57b59687cfa97f1c65caeea7a",
+            "scope": "EQ support six conditions formally completed; original P28-02 remains incomplete; original credit zero",
+            "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-22T10:14:42.989122+09:00"
          }
        ],
-        "progress_summary": "原P28-02未完、補助EQも未受入。旧S6f75c9aは146局所試験後に通常提出済みだが正確S nativeのmkdir失敗を保全。実Runner repair_ready10、旧Codex run92b50は終了済み。ユーザー委任をevent84へ記録し、Desktop Opus5.5超高が同WのS5を指揮・実装中。R/O双方E1〜E5・39行を維持、信号のコマンド/通常公開をsource因果で完全照合。旧156局所試験211.416秒の後にも修正があり、新版合格に流用しない。scratch R3はGodot942秒/exit0、Pythonのcheck_report/自己比較True・実exit0だが全体1270.3秒、lifecycle300.6秒で正式verify300秒未達。NA/既存不具合をPASS補完せず全raw保持。Opusが保持R3 rawでcProfileと結果同値のreader高速化を進行、Rootは重複実装/engine/試験を起動しない。最終Sのnative7・両正式validation・fresh独立Opus全6・通常Q資格/委任承認/統合final、続くOPT T1/同条件3反復/RESTART/正確最終全192/原work・ACと横断6のwhole-unit受入は未達。原30/88・正式23/88、4/30・部分点なし、補助EQの原加算0。最大場面性能、完成資産、同一Windows実機、長期通し、全ゲームの未達を維持。",
-        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-22T01:45:37.125591+09:00",
+        "progress_summary": "P28-02-EQ補助はS 9adbbee→Q 4e34e52で正式完了（Runner completed・補助6/6）。正確S native7（PID7・profile14・cleanup0・source1407・seal v2）、正式unit179/native-verify、fresh独立Opus全6 PASS（high/medium0・low2）、通常integration/final、実DB/traceability照合。前S a46418dのEQ5 changes_requested、b2dbda8のvalidation失敗、6f75c9aのnative失敗は保全。実装はユーザー委任のDesktop Opus5.5（contract workerはcodexのまま）。原成果加算0。次はOPT_CONTRACT_T1 §6の順で、EQ前の値（S_eq nativeをQ_eqで資格確認済み）と(b)前版2回、OPT登録・実装（許可6ファイル、範囲内の既存Eの不具合の修正を含む）、S上のEQ after・(a)(b)(c)(d)、OPT validation、whole-unit独立レビュー、統合final、台帳23→24。原P28-02は未完。正式23/88・4/30、部分点なし。性能予算false6・200客OpsON/同一Windows/長期/全ゲームは別未達。",
+        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-22T10:14:42.989122+09:00",
        "historical_summary_before_integrated_full9_20261021": "既採用e561 Pathを保持。source1273最大規模・Operations OFFの30分/保存再開を診断し25918+293parse/0。no-route候補の全15byte対照は一致したがmacro因果改善不足で不採用。Operations ON/新1277性能/Windows描画/長期プレイは未受入。",
        "historical_before_P28_01_formal_completion": {
          "progress_summary": "旧1273時点の限定軽量化・不採用記録を保持。現在の製品source1407（83b170aと同一）の実main db9d613全9測定で、代表R x1平均479.210ms/P95745.365ms/最大4809.099ms、x3P955062.697ms/最大5891.466msの予算未達を確定。O小入力の合格を最大負荷へ拡張しない。原P28-01の別PID再開・wholeunit受入を先に閉じ、同等性と失敗拒否を固定してから実測上位の改善へ進む。本単位の新規最適化/受入は未実施。",
          "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T01:04:05.061475+09:00"
        },
        "remaining_gaps": [
-          "S5 reader optimization preserving every typed state/event/check: completed R3 diagnostic took 1270.3s; whole registered verify cap remains 300s; new exact-source local tests required after changes",
-          "Normal owner submission of actual Opus retained implementation; exact final-S native7 with full raw/owned/guard/PID/source/player/cleanup bundle, both registered validations",
-          "Fresh independent Opus all6 review, normal prepare-integration, exact candidate qualification, honest delegated owner approval, integration/final; EQ support adds zero original units",
-          "Original P28-02 T1 product optimization, same-condition three-run comparisons, RESTART, exact final full192 roster, whole-unit original work/acceptance plus cross-cutting6 review/final"
+          "Before record: S_eq native 9adbbee (version before) qualified on Q_eq 4e34e52; Root runs (b) frame-before r02/r03 (OPT_CONTRACT_T1 §4)",
+          "Fix the OPT acceptance rule for cross-version differences (review low 1): only before-version existing-defect scenarios and their cause fields",
+          "P28-02-OPT registration and implementation (existing allowed 6 product files; in-scope existing E failures fixed), then on its S: EQ after (run_eq --opt-changed), (a) DIAG phase after, (b) frame after x3, (c) RESTART, (d) full192 roster",
+          "OPT validation (unit and every bundle verify incl. verify_eq --compare-versions), fresh independent Opus whole-unit review (original work/acceptance, cross-cutting 6, U1/U2), integration, Q reuse qualification §5, final, ledger 23->24"
        ],
        "baseline_original_unit_completion": {
          "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/P28_01_FORMAL_COMPLETION_AE9AE47.json",
@@ -18359,9 +18366,9 @@
          "sha256": "9cbe071dcae33e5577fabc00bff915ab112d6acd7ae55a6bef693a6062176255"
        },
        "current_EQ_execution": {
-          "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_OPUS_READER_CONTINUATION_AC1A115.json",
-          "bytes": 14049,
-          "sha256": "abdef6f3e17a46c5061d43ad2953f6d6f0fedfbbb04002be1c2aa2456b5fefff"
+          "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_FORMAL_COMPLETION_4E34E52.json",
+          "bytes": 23096,
+          "sha256": "833f29fd97f54a2150a3e674ba45353f938207f57b59687cfa97f1c65caeea7a"
        },
        "historical_before_EQ_S3a": {
          "progress_summary": "P28-01と補助DIAG（S d6ce6dd→Q fdb309f、全4正式ゲート）は完了。原P28-02は未完。EQはbase2549cf7/同W/Astraで段階実装し、S1比較器と型付き全状態・全event・可逆復元・差分再構成/source閉包の局所43試験を実exit/SHAと照合、未commit成果を保全した。初回局所失敗と旧3runの返答/撤去履歴は成功に変えず保持。S2–S4、正確S native7、両正式validation、別Opus全6review、通常候補資格/統合finalは未達。続いてT1 snapshot変換・コピー最適化、同条件反復比較・RESTART・正確最終全roster・whole-unit横断6レビュー/通常finalが必要。原加算0、正式23/88・4/30、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON/同一Windows/長期/全ゲームは別未達。 S2は実Opus326判断を通常記録し、同じW/Astraのrun558b96b3/PID12205/exec85980で起動（このcheckpoint時点で実生存確認）。全19保持S1ファイルを通常repair4の前後でSHA照合済み。",
@@ -18448,6 +18455,76 @@
            "sha256": "de4adb29bb8a2ec6f2426bdb4c23d5094bdfea764eb045ef33af4948625a45d8"
          },
          "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T10:01:18.016348+09:00"
+        },
+        "historical_before_EQ_formal_completion_20261022": {
+          "progress_summary": "原P28-02未完、補助EQも未受入。旧S6f75c9aは146局所試験後に通常提出済みだが正確S nativeのmkdir失敗を保全。実Runner repair_ready10、旧Codex run92b50は終了済み。ユーザー委任をevent84へ記録し、Desktop Opus5.5超高が同WのS5を指揮・実装中。R/O双方E1〜E5・39行を維持、信号のコマンド/通常公開をsource因果で完全照合。旧156局所試験211.416秒の後にも修正があり、新版合格に流用しない。scratch R3はGodot942秒/exit0、Pythonのcheck_report/自己比較True・実exit0だが全体1270.3秒、lifecycle300.6秒で正式verify300秒未達。NA/既存不具合をPASS補完せず全raw保持。Opusが保持R3 rawでcProfileと結果同値のreader高速化を進行、Rootは重複実装/engine/試験を起動しない。最終Sのnative7・両正式validation・fresh独立Opus全6・通常Q資格/委任承認/統合final、続くOPT T1/同条件3反復/RESTART/正確最終全192/原work・ACと横断6のwhole-unit受入は未達。原30/88・正式23/88、4/30・部分点なし、補助EQの原加算0。最大場面性能、完成資産、同一Windows実機、長期通し、全ゲームの未達を維持。",
+          "remaining_gaps": [
+            "S5 reader optimization preserving every typed state/event/check: completed R3 diagnostic took 1270.3s; whole registered verify cap remains 300s; new exact-source local tests required after changes",
+            "Normal owner submission of actual Opus retained implementation; exact final-S native7 with full raw/owned/guard/PID/source/player/cleanup bundle, both registered validations",
+            "Fresh independent Opus all6 review, normal prepare-integration, exact candidate qualification, honest delegated owner approval, integration/final; EQ support adds zero original units",
+            "Original P28-02 T1 product optimization, same-condition three-run comparisons, RESTART, exact final full192 roster, whole-unit original work/acceptance plus cross-cutting6 review/final"
+          ],
+          "current_EQ_execution": {
+            "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_OPUS_READER_CONTINUATION_AC1A115.json",
+            "bytes": 14049,
+            "sha256": "abdef6f3e17a46c5061d43ad2953f6d6f0fedfbbb04002be1c2aa2456b5fefff"
+          },
+          "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-22T01:45:37.125591+09:00",
+          "evidence": [
+            {
+              "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/canonical-full170-actual-root-review-r01/review.json",
+              "sha256_at_integration": "302a782d7d5597aa7f1ffefe8b24b2b8ca2c762f29323dc769e85ea13fd57605",
+              "scope": "Actual168 suites/13567 checks/170 native; Root1989 evidence controls/0; no whole original/nativeWindows/P28 acceptance",
+              "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-02T20:20:56.571408+09:00",
+              "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false
+            },
+            {
+              "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/audio-path-canonical72-adoption-root-r01/adoption.json",
+              "sha256_at_integration": "87dc7a1461d92f15fd0b51fc3015a0add39f8c373855de83460ca433cb4ec43c",
+              "scope": "Actual limited72: public71 plus outsidecollector1; production1273; private startup2 adopted0",
+              "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-02T20:20:56.571408+09:00",
+              "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false
+            },
+            {
+              "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/audio-path-canonical72-post-adoption-root-review-r02/review.json",
+              "sha256_at_integration": "261cb8d8f4ff3838af23f2cb852eadba411a55852436a3b0e8a8bba55c75046a",
+              "scope": "Post117/0: all1273 path/SHA map exact; rawJSON serializationSHA differs, semantic map equality proved",
+              "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-02T20:20:56.571408+09:00",
+              "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false
+            },
+            {
+              "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/path-snapshot-sort-cache-r03-actual-root-review-r01/review.json",
+              "sha256_at_integration": "f7dbbf58322d05ce57e711b8252682a47068603edf3e27215a09a59bf5f3efe7",
+              "scope": "Micro only: 53 wholetyped pairs/120 literal same-call return bytes; macro scale P28 not accepted",
+              "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-02T20:20:56.571408+09:00",
+              "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false
+            },
+            {
+              "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/current1273-no-route-macro-actual-root-review-r01/review.json",
+              "sha256": "b692df04059a68349b935175a2ec1374b4d25e5d406dfbf4facb8649a3b3a488"
+            },
+            {
+              "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/INTEGRATED_FULL9_MEASUREMENT_DB9D613.json",
+              "sha256_at_integration": "a76082f767e0a0d52cb70e2f66fa371b62a88754e9be319da3c08d4b48e78ba0",
+              "scope": "実main db9d613の正規全9phase測定。native全9終了/Root160結合PASS。R x1/x3予算false、Oは50cells/客0..2のみ。別PID/原wholeunit/Windows未受入、原加算0。",
+              "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-21T01:04:05.061475+09:00",
+              "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false
+            },
+            {
+              "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/DIAG_FORMAL_COMPLETION_FDB309F.json",
+              "bytes": 18478,
+              "sha256": "7d83ec0e19e0c12ecefebc5ab0bdffb20743ed34c6144251a08b83b315b09ecf",
+              "scope": "DIAG support four conditions formally completed; original P28-02 remains incomplete; original credit zero",
+              "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-21T07:10:02.150187+09:00"
+            },
+            {
+              "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_TIMING_REPAIR1_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
+              "bytes": 4047,
+              "sha256": "021b76676bc68a9e008cfd27c7f1438f2d483f0f44e85e75cb83e2d49f700d71",
+              "scope": "Actual EQ registration and repair1 implementing checkpoint only; no auxiliary or original acceptance credit",
+              "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-21T07:31:50.231974+09:00"
+            }
+          ]
        }
      },
      {
@@ -18731,22 +18808,23 @@
    ],
    "cross_cutting_acceptance_scope": "Completion requirements only, not achieved results. Apply each to relevant slices; non-applicable views require a recorded reason.",
    "initial_revision_state": "in_progress",
-    "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-22T01:45:37.125591+09:00",
+    "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-22T10:14:42.989122+09:00",
    "execution_progress": {
      "original_unit": "P28-02",
-      "active_backend": "P28-02-EQ",
-      "controller": "Claude Desktop Opus5.5 ultra-high",
+      "completed_support": "P28-02-EQ",
+      "next_backend": "P28-02-OPT (to be registered)",
+      "controller": "Claude Desktop Opus5.5",
      "checkpoint": {
-        "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_OPUS_READER_CONTINUATION_AC1A115.json",
-        "bytes": 14049,
-        "sha256": "abdef6f3e17a46c5061d43ad2953f6d6f0fedfbbb04002be1c2aa2456b5fefff"
+        "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_FORMAL_COMPLETION_4E34E52.json",
+        "bytes": 23096,
+        "sha256": "833f29fd97f54a2150a3e674ba45353f938207f57b59687cfa97f1c65caeea7a"
      },
      "new_original_credit": 0,
      "remaining_conditions": [
-        "S5 reader optimization preserving every typed state/event/check: completed R3 diagnostic took 1270.3s; whole registered verify cap remains 300s; new exact-source local tests required after changes",
-        "Normal owner submission of actual Opus retained implementation; exact final-S native7 with full raw/owned/guard/PID/source/player/cleanup bundle, both registered validations",
-        "Fresh independent Opus all6 review, normal prepare-integration, exact candidate qualification, honest delegated owner approval, integration/final; EQ support adds zero original units",
-        "Original P28-02 T1 product optimization, same-condition three-run comparisons, RESTART, exact final full192 roster, whole-unit original work/acceptance plus cross-cutting6 review/final"
+        "Before record: S_eq native 9adbbee (version before) qualified on Q_eq 4e34e52; Root runs (b) frame-before r02/r03 (OPT_CONTRACT_T1 §4)",
+        "Fix the OPT acceptance rule for cross-version differences (review low 1): only before-version existing-defect scenarios and their cause fields",
+        "P28-02-OPT registration and implementation (existing allowed 6 product files; in-scope existing E failures fixed), then on its S: EQ after (run_eq --opt-changed), (a) DIAG phase after, (b) frame after x3, (c) RESTART, (d) full192 roster",
+        "OPT validation (unit and every bundle verify incl. verify_eq --compare-versions), fresh independent Opus whole-unit review (original work/acceptance, cross-cutting 6, U1/U2), integration, Q reuse qualification §5, final, ledger 23->24"
      ]
    },
    "current_connector_endpoint_checkpoint": {
@@ -19004,6 +19082,27 @@
        }
      },
      "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T06:35:33.265223+09:00"
+    },
+    "historical_before_EQ_formal_completion_20261022": {
+      "current_summary": "原P28-02未完、補助EQも未受入。旧S6f75c9aは146局所試験後に通常提出済みだが正確S nativeのmkdir失敗を保全。実Runner repair_ready10、旧Codex run92b50は終了済み。ユーザー委任をevent84へ記録し、Desktop Opus5.5超高が同WのS5を指揮・実装中。R/O双方E1〜E5・39行を維持、信号のコマンド/通常公開をsource因果で完全照合。旧156局所試験211.416秒の後にも修正があり、新版合格に流用しない。scratch R3はGodot942秒/exit0、Pythonのcheck_report/自己比較True・実exit0だが全体1270.3秒、lifecycle300.6秒で正式verify300秒未達。NA/既存不具合をPASS補完せず全raw保持。Opusが保持R3 rawでcProfileと結果同値のreader高速化を進行、Rootは重複実装/engine/試験を起動しない。最終Sのnative7・両正式validation・fresh独立Opus全6・通常Q資格/委任承認/統合final、続くOPT T1/同条件3反復/RESTART/正確最終全192/原work・ACと横断6のwhole-unit受入は未達。原30/88・正式23/88、4/30・部分点なし、補助EQの原加算0。最大場面性能、完成資産、同一Windows実機、長期通し、全ゲームの未達を維持。",
+      "execution_progress": {
+        "original_unit": "P28-02",
+        "active_backend": "P28-02-EQ",
+        "controller": "Claude Desktop Opus5.5 ultra-high",
+        "checkpoint": {
+          "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_OPUS_READER_CONTINUATION_AC1A115.json",
+          "bytes": 14049,
+          "sha256": "abdef6f3e17a46c5061d43ad2953f6d6f0fedfbbb04002be1c2aa2456b5fefff"
+        },
+        "new_original_credit": 0,
+        "remaining_conditions": [
+          "S5 reader optimization preserving every typed state/event/check: completed R3 diagnostic took 1270.3s; whole registered verify cap remains 300s; new exact-source local tests required after changes",
+          "Normal owner submission of actual Opus retained implementation; exact final-S native7 with full raw/owned/guard/PID/source/player/cleanup bundle, both registered validations",
+          "Fresh independent Opus all6 review, normal prepare-integration, exact candidate qualification, honest delegated owner approval, integration/final; EQ support adds zero original units",
+          "Original P28-02 T1 product optimization, same-condition three-run comparisons, RESTART, exact final full192 roster, whole-unit original work/acceptance plus cross-cutting6 review/final"
+        ]
+      },
+      "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-22T01:45:37.125591+09:00"
    }
  },
  {