diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md index 25b9186..a641734 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ ## 現在の対象(2026-10-13・現版監査更新) -2026-10-15 P08-03を正式完了。原30パッケージ/88成果単位、部分点なし。台帳は正式12/着手25/予定51。実行版d369d1c・main統合版027861b。Root局所153・Godot構文313・native196+96・全176回帰20,488厳密チェック、連続通常OS writer21643(58要求)/別PID reader32505(4要求)の全5条件、独立Opus 5.5レビュー、Runner統合・最終確認が全PASS。1,330ソース・必須入力・engine・markerの一致を非改変の適用性記録で確認し、原証跡の記録先訂正も開示済み。軽微2指摘は別記。閉鎖証拠はexecution/p08-03/ACCEPTANCE_CLOSED_D369_027861B.json。終了済み試験プロファイル2,817ファイルのSHA・パス・mtime保持圧縮で実空き約1.79GB回収。Windows同一配布版実機受入と延期済みP23保持ジェスチャーは全体残件として維持。次の1件は実Opus5.5判断71ce1c9eでP23-03「生活の観察」を選定し、現版の表示・実状態対応/同需要動線比較/依存の監査に着手。原spec8568457/base860136fでRunner登録、実Opus5.5開始判断7886b19cによりAstra1担当の初回実装を開始。Phase0の11ソースSHAと実spawn/build経路をRoot確認。部分提出03100be(A/Bfixture・意味検査12局所試験)を保持し、未完成collector/--verify-only未対応を登録検査で記録。実Opus判断で同task/worktreeの修正2回目を6.1-sol担当に切替え、実収集・正常保存再開の接続を優先。外部/仕様ブロッカーなし、上限null・timeout900維持、重複実装なし。P23-03正式加点0。 ユーザー指示で旧Windows7件/P05旧診断4件(34,103files/3.32GB)をDriveへ退避、全分割/再結合SHA照合後のみ原実体を除去、Drive同期実体0byte・一時ファイル0を確認。P23のSol追加成果は未完成のまま同worktree保持、現行受入証拠は不変。 +2026-10-15 P08-03を正式完了。原30パッケージ/88成果単位、部分点なし。台帳は正式12/着手25/予定51。実行版d369d1c・main統合版027861b。Root局所153・Godot構文313・native196+96・全176回帰20,488厳密チェック、連続通常OS writer21643(58要求)/別PID reader32505(4要求)の全5条件、独立Opus 5.5レビュー、Runner統合・最終確認が全PASS。1,330ソース・必須入力・engine・markerの一致を非改変の適用性記録で確認し、原証跡の記録先訂正も開示済み。軽微2指摘は別記。閉鎖証拠はexecution/p08-03/ACCEPTANCE_CLOSED_D369_027861B.json。終了済み試験プロファイル2,817ファイルのSHA・パス・mtime保持圧縮で実空き約1.79GB回収。Windows同一配布版実機受入と延期済みP23保持ジェスチャーは全体残件として維持。次の1件は実Opus5.5判断71ce1c9eでP23-03「生活の観察」を選定し、現版の表示・実状態対応/同需要動線比較/依存の監査に着手。原spec8568457/base860136fでRunner登録、実Opus5.5開始判断7886b19cによりAstra1担当の初回実装を開始。Phase0の11ソースSHAと実spawn/build経路をRoot確認。部分提出03100be(A/Bfixture・意味検査12局所試験)を保持し、未完成collector/--verify-only未対応を登録検査で記録。実Opus判断で同task/worktreeの修正2回目を6.1-sol担当に切替え、実収集・正常保存再開の接続を優先。外部/仕様ブロッカーなし、上限null・timeout900維持、重複実装なし。P23-03正式加点0。 ユーザー指示で旧Windows7件/P05旧診断4件(34,103files/3.32GB)をDriveへ退避、全分割/再結合SHA照合後のみ原実体を除去、Drive同期実体0byte・一時ファイル0を確認。P23のSol追加成果は未完成のまま同worktree保持、現行受入証拠は不変。 保持した03100be/R03差分から修正3回目を実Opus指示のAstra1担当で再開。画像/座標/再開/条件matrixの完成に限定し、延期済みdrag必須依存を除去、通常wheelpanは維持。Root画像復号方法診断成功、原P23受入加点0。 原30パッケージ/88成果、部分点なし。現在は正式10/着手24/予定54。P24-03は正式完了、MP-01-r02承認用資料は正式統合済みだが原88へ加点しない。P13-03既存最終修正は全7施設/84スロット/6分類が保全済み。P13/RP13の限定追加修正と正式host自己試験は直接許可待ちで、重複実装や無断上限変更をしない。 diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p23-03/OPUS_CONTINUATION_R04.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p23-03/OPUS_CONTINUATION_R04.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0c07d8b --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p23-03/OPUS_CONTINUATION_R04.json @@ -0,0 +1,54 @@ +{ + "task": "P23-03", + "project": "the-tree-p23-03-code", + "submitted_preserved": "03100beabeb55caac03f53db3d1f399b424df517", + "repair_number": 3, + "repair_cap": null, + "timeout_seconds": 900, + "repair_decision": { + "action": "request-repair", + "task_id": "P23-03", + "reason": "Only P23-03 is blocked, and the blocker is unfinished in-scope implementation. Nothing outside the task blocks it. I read the current source to confirm two defects. First, tests/fixtures/p23-03/passive_observation.gd:154-156 still requires a left-button move-mode drag and asserts that pan changed. Second, check() at tools/check_p23_life_observation_evidence.py:568 appends a BLOCKER for every condition whatever the evidence shows. Smallest finish direction, starting from 03100be with the dirty R03 files kept, harness (about 1.6k lines) kept, existing renderer kept, and source/API not re-derived:\n\n(0) passive_observation.gd ordinary_camera: delete the mandatory drag request and its expect at lines 154-156. Keep the reachable PanModeButton press, the non-Ctrl wheel pan in move mode, and the ordinary wheel zoom. Keep the input-provenance rows (ctrl=false, the event source). Write no held-gesture or Ctrl-wheel claim. In the checker, require the step names `ordinary-wheel-zoom`, `pan-mode-button` and `move-mode-wheel-pan`, and never `drag`.\n\n(1) Checker images, in new functions within check_p23. `png_pixels(data)`: stdlib zlib/struct, IHDR/IDAT/IEND with CRC, 8-bit RGB/RGBA, filters 0-4, returns (w, h, rows). `image_kind(data)` reuses the P08 jpeg_dimensions via module(). Add `inspect_conversion(rec)` with schema {raw_path, raw_sha256, raw_kind:'jpeg', tool_call_id, converter:'/usr/bin/sips', converter_sha256, argv, exit_code:0, stdout/stderr sha, png_path, png_sha256, width, height}. It requires raw bytes to be unchanged against the CUA receipt hash, matching dimensions, and an actual PNG decode. Collector `convert_screenshot()` runs sips on Root into an extra file and writes that receipt. Never rename or rewrite the raw file. No PIL dependency and no JPEG decoder.\n\n(2) Binding rows to rectangles. The endpoint's report records `view_rows[{category, id, rect_viewport[x,y,w,h]}]` plus `viewport_to_screen{scale, offset}` for every draw-consumed row of the 6 categories. `bind_rows(report, png, calibration)` maps each rect to screen pixels. Each rect must lie inside the image and show non-background pixel variance, and the rect set must differ between FRONT and BACK.\n\n(3) Visual history. The diagnostic stream records `prior_visual{id:[x,y]}`, `visual{id:[x,y]}`, `frame_delta` and `destination{id, eligible}`. `check_motion()` requires each visual position to lie between prior and target with a step no larger than the speed times the delta. A rest destination must equal the typed stored destination and eligibility, and AI is not re-simulated.\n\n(4) Save/resume. `check_resume(writer, reader)`: writer.pid != reader.pid, both actual OS PIDs. The save ACK {path, sha256, formal_members[]} must equal the reader's load ACK {sha256, members}. The reader's first typed state equals the writer's formal-model snapshot, the reader's report passes inspect_stream, and both pass inspect_os_receipt (profile, stage, source, owned process/audio gates).\n\n(5) Dynamic matrix. condition_matrix(results) marks a condition `static-verified` only when its named gate functions ran on present evidence. Otherwise the status is `pending-root` (evidence absent) or `fail` with the exception text. Delete the unconditional extend. Overall integrity passes only when all 7 named conditions and all 6 display categories pass. A/B gets real public commands with the same seed/demand, and B strictly improves on the predeclared metric.\n\n(6) Negatives in test_p23_life_observation_evidence.py, one per class, each asserting a specific deficit: forged or mismatched source/spec/formal SHA, same PID across writer/reader, missing or mismatched ACK members, profile or stage drift, JPEG labelled .png without a conversion record, converter SHA/argv mismatch, a rect outside the image or on a blank region, a mismatched state/report field, a drag required in a camera step, and an all-true self-asserted matrix.\n\nNo Godot, collector run or full regression in the worker. Root native/OS evidence stays explicitly pending. Report only the local Python results that actually ran. No acceptance claim, no partial credit (denominator 30/88 unchanged). Afterwards Root runs parse and local impact before OS collection.", + "codex_model": "gpt-6-astra", + "codex_model_reason": "Astra is justified for concrete reasons. Two earlier repairs both stopped short on the same hard gates and left check() deliberately fail-closed. What remains is dense verification logic split across three languages and modules: a stdlib PNG filter decoder, a pinned sips conversion chain, mapping viewport rects through an affine transform to pixels, interpolation-bounds checks, distinct-PID ACK and formal-member equality, a dynamic 7-condition by 6-category matrix, and about 10 specific negatives. All of it has to tie into the existing P08 helpers without re-deriving the source API. One subtle mistake would cost another Root native/OS cycle, which costs more in time and usage than the difference between Astra and Sol. The spec's recorded commander direction also named Astra. Sol is adequate for routine work, but its record here is incomplete delivery on exactly these gates." + }, + "run_decision": { + "action": "run", + "task_id": "P23-03", + "reason": "This records the actual RUN for P23-03 in the same task and worktree. The task is repair_ready, repairs stay at 3, and the cap stays null. Start from submitted 03100be and keep every existing dirty R03 source file (the 7 modified files and the 3 untracked p23-03 fixtures). Do not repeat the Phase0 API audit or redesign anything. Keep the harness of about 1.6k lines and the existing renderer.\n\nThese stay unchanged: the original 7 conditions, the 6 display categories, the 30/88 denominator with no partial credit, timeout 900, no billing, and no new rights. Root native/OS evidence still pending after the source is complete is not a reason to block. Implement the missing gates fully, then submit genuinely. Do not use unconditional fail stubs or self-asserted PASS.\n\nEXACT FINISH RECIPE:\n\n(0) Camera step in tests/fixtures/p23-03/passive_observation.gd (ordinary_camera):\n- Delete the mandatory left-button move-mode drag request and its expect that pan changed (about lines 154-156).\n- Keep the reachable PanModeButton press, the non-Ctrl wheel pan in move mode, and the ordinary wheel zoom.\n- Keep the input-provenance rows (ctrl=false, the event source).\n- Make no held-gesture or Ctrl-wheel claim.\n- The checker requires the step names ordinary-wheel-zoom, pan-mode-button and move-mode-wheel-pan, and rejects any step named drag.\n\n(1) Checker image functions in tools/check_p23_life_observation_evidence.py:\n- png_pixels(data): stdlib zlib/struct only. Check IHDR/IDAT/IEND with CRC, 8-bit RGB/RGBA, filters 0-4. Return (w, h, rows).\n- image_kind(data): reuse the P08 jpeg_dimensions via module().\n- inspect_conversion(rec) with schema {raw_path, raw_sha256, raw_kind:'jpeg', tool_call_id, converter:'/usr/bin/sips', converter_sha256, argv, exit_code:0, stdout_sha256, stderr_sha256, png_path, png_sha256, width, height}. It requires raw bytes unchanged against the CUA receipt hash, magic-derived dimensions equal to the PNG IHDR, and an actual PNG decode.\n- Collector convert_screenshot() in tools/run_p23_life_observation.py runs sips on Root into a separate file and writes that receipt. Never rename or rewrite the raw file. No PIL and no JPEG decoder.\n- Feasibility is confirmed only by Root's probe. The raw P08 R19 CUA JPEG at the .png path (sha fc86fcc0…d5e5, unchanged) went through /usr/bin/sips (sha 854fe5bb…5cf6) to a valid 1280x752 8-bit RGB PNG (sha 7be5b498…2fb32) with all CRCs and zlib valid. This is not P23 acceptance.\n\n(2) Binding rows to rectangles:\n- The endpoint report records view_rows[{category, id, rect_viewport[x,y,w,h]}] plus viewport_to_screen{scale, offset} for every draw-consumed row of the 6 categories.\n- bind_rows(report, png, calibration) maps each rect to screen pixels. Each rect must lie inside the image and show non-background pixel variance, and the rect set must differ between FRONT and BACK.\n\n(3) Visual history:\n- The diagnostic stream records prior_visual{id:[x,y]}, visual{id:[x,y]}, frame_delta and destination{id, eligible}.\n- check_motion() requires each visual position to lie between prior and target, with a step no larger than speed times delta.\n- A rest destination must equal the typed stored destination and its eligibility. Do not re-simulate AI.\n\n(4) Save/resume, check_resume(writer, reader):\n- writer.pid != reader.pid, and both are actual OS PIDs.\n- The save ACK {path, sha256, formal_members[]} must equal the reader's load ACK {sha256, members}.\n- The reader's first typed state equals the writer's formal-model snapshot.\n- The reader's report passes inspect_stream.\n- Both pass inspect_os_receipt (profile, stage, source, and the owned process/audio teardown gates).\n\n(5) Dynamic matrix:\n- condition_matrix(results) marks a condition static-verified only when its named gate functions ran on present evidence. Otherwise the status is pending-root (evidence absent) or fail with the exception text.\n- Delete the unconditional BLOCKER extend in check() (about line 568).\n- Overall integrity passes only when all 7 named conditions and all 6 categories pass.\n- A/B runs real public commands with the same seed, demand, budget and clock, and B strictly improves on the predeclared metric with no new arbitrary threshold.\n\n(6) Negatives in tools/test_p23_life_observation_evidence.py, one per class, each asserting a specific deficit:\n- forged or mismatched source/spec/formal SHA\n- same PID across writer and reader\n- missing or mismatched ACK members\n- profile or stage drift\n- JPEG labelled .png without a conversion record\n- converter SHA or argv mismatch\n- a rect outside the image or on a blank region\n- a mismatched state or report field\n- a drag required in a camera step\n- an all-true self-asserted matrix\n\nConstraints:\n- Stay within allowed_paths only. completion_marker_contracts gets a single strict source-authority entry, append only. Preserve all old suite policies.\n- No Godot, collector run or full regression in the worker. Run only local py_compile and the checker unit tests, and report only results that actually ran.\n- State explicitly that Root native/OS evidence is pending. Make no acceptance claim.\n- After genuine submission, Root runs parse and local impact, then OS collection on both layouts (FRONT/BACK, ordinary pan/zoom, formal save and distinct-PID load), then one full regression and an independent Opus all-condition review.", + "codex_model": "gpt-6-astra", + "codex_model_reason": "I chose Astra for concrete reasons. Two earlier repairs both stopped short on the same hard gates and left check() deliberately fail-closed. What remains is dense verification logic that has to stay consistent across GDScript fixtures, the Python collector and the checker. It covers:\n- a stdlib PNG filter 0-4 decoder with CRC checks\n- a pinned sips conversion receipt chain against the CUA hashes\n- an affine mapping from viewport rects to pixels, with variance checks\n- interpolation-bound motion checks\n- distinct-PID ACK and formal-member equality\n- a dynamic 7-condition by 6-category matrix\n- about 10 specific negatives\n\nAll of it has to reuse the P08 helpers without re-deriving the API. One subtle mistake costs another full Root native/OS cycle, which is worth more in time and usage than the price gap between Astra and Sol. The spec's recorded commander direction also names Astra. Sol suits routine work, but its record here is incomplete delivery on exactly these gates." + }, + "root_decoder_probe": { + "scope": "Root analytic decoder probe only, not new P23 acceptance or image editing", + "raw_path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p08-03-native-os-d369d1c-r19-calibrated/os-pair/writer-request-0002/screen-before.png", + "raw_sha256": "fc86fcc0f62c725e55fee8648cc4a1cce681d0de81d30aa53bf5585d6928d5e5", + "raw_unchanged": true, + "raw_magic": "JPEG", + "decoded_path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p23-03-code/.runtime/P23-03/tmp/root-cua-jpeg-decoding-probe.png", + "decoded_sha256": "7be5b498ad224df2b971af49bf379771816176ec26b70a7370c1bf374cc2fb32", + "converter": "/usr/bin/sips", + "converter_sha256": "854fe5bb83f6176615b3f2ac599c66e808b9bb5d708ad66f743e480cc8045cf6", + "argv": [ + "/usr/bin/sips", + "-s", + "format", + "png", + "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p08-03-native-os-d369d1c-r19-calibrated/os-pair/writer-request-0002/screen-before.png", + "--out", + "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p23-03-code/.runtime/P23-03/tmp/root-cua-jpeg-decoding-probe.png" + ], + "actual_exit_code": 0, + "width": 1280, + "height": 752, + "bit_depth": 8, + "color_type": 2, + "crc_all_valid": true, + "inflated_bytes": 2888432, + "source_provenance": "Existing accepted P08 R19 actual CUA screenshot, immutable raw retained", + "required_interpreter_PIL_available": false + }, + "scope": "Single same-task worker continuation, no source redesign or unit credit; mandatory deferred drag dependency removed, ordinary wheel pan still required", + "unit_credit": 0, + "new_Godot_runs": 0 +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/plan_validation.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/plan_validation.json index cf5af37..8054752 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/plan_validation.json +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/plan_validation.json @@ -223,7 +223,7 @@ "ASSETS_PLATFORM_AUDIT.md": "a3a4b8ca0fb39a9abf88692285d26aa879815e092352ba304ef2758e71da50bd", "ATOMIC_REGISTER.md": "6070143b85b7c3b9b73d7c9768d88d2dae4d20407ad54a563cb6ffd74f2373ae", "ATOMIC_SEMANTIC_REVIEW.md": "c156b1fb57c2b4a900f27a19049510f3e9616e723d5edb3417f50d733de5be48", - "IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md": "d28b12a000c0d8cb2a0a1ba6c3c8d7f2f6150a7a8fcc67e0e88be0890df85dcd", + "IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md": "195c4b51a56a620daf865223445318b12f9e19a89e11d4429cfa11692b10fcd5", "IMPORT_UNICODE_AUDIT.md": "88b2382bfbb3411fece8be7e6004ba21d8bf6a47e9d1f3cf573ea6638f79c12f", "P09_VALUE_CONTRACTS.md": "c5abdc4543e54033b1fcfd0943cba266f664d8c10968965fd36ade40da488a25", "PERFORMANCE_AUDIT.md": "c75e806acf825fc4a61f773a2cce7e71be335a1e25dbb15d98091097e8dc47c1", @@ -254,6 +254,6 @@ "validate_facility_value_contracts.py": "91640e2a76cd6cc9186f7b85c0bf379b24b6cac0d48962815235ee628e7ae43e", "validate_plan.py": "23678227d9b3c556f1bd903f4b5b3147c4a82ce5085e10055481026803451b80", "validator_update_checks.json": "f997d0f3de2cea29550840b1d5cb23647d64f81329de46758551e2b6c8fecc27", - "work_packages.json": "a1021e601bedbf93899c2bce4e41700589d96f8c3230e8784033822db6c2647b" + "work_packages.json": "e26129d2e02fc9483c25359c15eaec1afcd7f57a0e378c98c15d679dc7af023a" } } diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json index 93253ed..4ed5ce5 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json @@ -15980,15 +15980,21 @@ "sha256": "28fb79069986a3e4cf9d5cf2322612111f804f84d4a9efd8c9c75ec688653d3b", "scope": "terminal partial worker source retained locally after storage offload; no acceptance credit", "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false + }, + { + "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p23-03/OPUS_CONTINUATION_R04.json", + "sha256": "381f2fc99a40f00697c7635b82b95128e500948fe665fa6b14d75e5ead44894a", + "scope": "actual Opus same-task finish direction and real decoder-method feasibility; no P23 acceptance", + "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false } ], - "progress_summary": "2026-10-15 部分提出03100beと修正2回目のSol成果を同worktreeに保持。CLI・規範pin・同需要fixture/native入口・観察fixture/collectorまで追加したが、画素provenance・補間/休息先・再開ACKの独立検証と指定負例が未完成。担当は終了、仕様/外部ブロッカー未確認。P23作業場所は退避対象外。ユーザー指示により旧Windows7件・P05旧診断4件をDriveへ全量読み戻しSHA照合後に退避し、現行P08証拠3pin不変を確認。正式加点0、原30/88・部分点なし維持。次は保持成果から未完検査を仕上げ、局所/影響→Root native/OS・正式別PID保存再開→正確な最終全回帰→独立レビュー/統合/最終確認。", + "progress_summary": "2026-10-15 Drive退避と台帳/現行証拠の保全確認後、保持した03100be+R03 Sol差分から同task/worktree修正3回目を開始。実Opus5.5が画像・観察座標/補間・正式別PID再開・条件matrix/負例の完成を具体指示し、Astraを選択。通常wheel pan成功後も要求していた延期済みleftdrag依存を除去し、原ordinarypanzoom条件を維持。Rootは実CUA JPEG→sips→1280x752 RGB8 PNGのbyte/CRC/非改変を確認(方法診断のみ、P23加点なし)。全7条件/6分類・30/88・上限null/timeout900維持。native/OS/全回帰/独立レビュー/統合/最終未実施、正式加点0。", "remaining_gaps": [ "既存差分を保持して実A/Bfixture・全7条件の独立意味検査・実Root収集器を完成する。初回readiness stubや固定blocked matrixは未達。", "完成した同一候補を局所/影響検証後、Root native・両レイアウト通常OS・別PID正式保存再開で検証する。", "正確な最終版で必須全回帰、独立Opusレビュー、統合・最終確認・台帳閉鎖。未確定原本値/全30施設/完成素材/Windows受入を代理せず全体残件に保つ。" ], - "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-15T08:57:01.400014+09:00" + "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-15T09:10:47.088062+09:00" } ], "estimate_person_days_historical_2026_09_29": [