Record independent Opus P08 acceptance review pass
This commit is contained in:
Takeshi
+6
-4
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
|
||||
{
|
||||
"candidate": "bf559632ddd938085702529d9dd6b7c878f4ebc7",
|
||||
"original_unit_completed": false,
|
||||
"next": "actual independent Opus then integration/current applicable final verification",
|
||||
"next": "prepare exact integration candidate; run registered integration verifier; apply existing main approval and post-integration checks",
|
||||
"fixed_material_limit": null,
|
||||
"file_count_limit": null,
|
||||
"original_30_88_unchanged": true,
|
||||
@@ -24,10 +24,12 @@
|
||||
"registered_final_regression_files_whole_verified": 5612,
|
||||
"registered_validation": "bf559632 integrity verified, deficits0, original acceptance pending",
|
||||
"independent_review": {
|
||||
"state": "running",
|
||||
"session": 85138,
|
||||
"state": "passed",
|
||||
"model": "claude-opus-5-5",
|
||||
"earlier_review": "changes requested; retained in audit-r07"
|
||||
"candidate": "bf559632ddd938085702529d9dd6b7c878f4ebc7",
|
||||
"high_medium_critical": 0,
|
||||
"low_deferred": 3,
|
||||
"record": "../p08-02-audit-r07/ACTUAL_OPUS_GAME_REVIEW_BF559.json"
|
||||
},
|
||||
"repair": {
|
||||
"state": "submitted",
|
||||
|
||||
+29
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
|
||||
{
|
||||
"review": {
|
||||
"task_id": "P08-02",
|
||||
"commit": "bf559632ddd938085702529d9dd6b7c878f4ebc7",
|
||||
"status": "pass",
|
||||
"summary": "I checked candidate bf55963 against the P08-02 spec, the diff, the checked-out sources and the .review-material receipts. The commit fixes both blocking findings from the d1c7ce2 review.\n\n(1) ROOT_REPAIR_INPUT-r04.json is restored, and the `actual_readonly_diagnostics` key is present again (confirmed by Grep). This file is the input that tools/test_p08_migration_evidence.py reads when it loads. It is listed at the preserved raw SHA 23ef44a0…, which matches the bytes recorded in r07.\n(2) The checker tests were rerun on the final frozen files. The actual-local-checker-032c5c transcript checks the SHAs of r04 (23ef44a0), the test file (fd9ef7ec) and the checker (928353…) first, then shows \"Ran 4 tests in 55.197s OK\". implementation.json now reports that same run and marks the earlier runs as historical, not current.\n\nThe registered p08-evidence validator ran `check_p08_migration_evidence.py --verify-only` against this candidate's tree and passed: integrity \"verified\", deficits=[], exit 0. The checker recomputes `source_refs()` from the checked-out tree. It also verifies:\n- the frozen spec, input and marker-contract SHAs, and every production source pin;\n- the four ON/OFF positive/refusal pairs, each with distinct writer/reader native PIDs;\n- raw lifecycle, strict markers and guarded fresh profiles;\n- whole typed and raw-Variant equality across the two processes at all 162 labels;\n- the semantic checks for no overlap, orphan or loss in occupancy, rescue, cargo and EV;\n- that in refusal cases live state, formal members and backup members are unchanged, with no partial batch;\n- the normal-menu native-OS sequence (preview, cancel, confirm, changed-source rejection);\n- the full-roster final regression.\n\nThe evidence index was collected at d1c7ce2. Reusing it is justified because the selected source map, which excludes docs, is byte-identical: the validator recomputes it at bf55963, and EXACT_EVIDENCE_REUSE_APPLICABILITY lists no changed paths. This commit changes only docs and metadata.\n\nHow each condition is covered:\n- **mixed_construction:** a progressing paid job, a zero-progress paid job and a completed dorm are migrated in one batch.\n- **occupancy_change:** cell ownership and disjointness are checked, with only explicitly allowed geometry deltas and a support epoch justified from source.\n- **actual_actor_positions:** the checker allows no actor, credit, route or money delta.\n- **combined_rescue_logistics_ev:** a rescue in flight, carried cargo plus a reserved request, and 4 boarded EV passengers plus 1 waiting are all in the same save. The patient ends treated, the original cargo request completes, and each EV request arrives exactly once.\n- **no_overlap_orphan_loss:** ON and OFF are both run, with the reader in a separate PID.\n- **unsolvable_preservation:** a late refusal at the dorm rolls back with the original save and the pre-existing backup preserved, and the separate-PID continuation keeps the old shape.\n\nNo production files are changed, all edits are within allowed_paths, and no tests are removed or disabled. This pass covers the review gate only. Windows coverage, main integration, current final verification and ledger closure are still Root conditions and stay pending.",
|
||||
"acceptance_ids": [
|
||||
"P08-02"
|
||||
],
|
||||
"findings": [
|
||||
{
|
||||
"severity": "low",
|
||||
"message": "The checker only checks that the index commit is 40 hex characters. It never confirms that the commit equals the submitted candidate (the index and OS proof say d1c7ce2, the candidate is bf55963). Reuse is still sound, because the full source map is recomputed and must match exactly. But commit provenance is not machine-bound to the candidate; it rests on the reuse-applicability record."
|
||||
},
|
||||
{
|
||||
"severity": "low",
|
||||
"message": "Some metadata in implementation.json is stale. `metadata_sync.review_material_context_gap` says there is no .review-material, but it is now present. `scope` still says 'Metadata-only synchronization against Git 1545bd42'. This is documentation only and changes no claims."
|
||||
},
|
||||
{
|
||||
"severity": "low",
|
||||
"message": "Still open from the previous review: in tests/s1/test_p08_combined_migration.gd, `break` only leaves the writer/reader loop, so the remaining combinations keep running after a failure. Failures are still counted, so this cannot produce a false pass."
|
||||
}
|
||||
]
|
||||
},
|
||||
"passed": true,
|
||||
"actual_record": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p08-02/runs/48d7a4379d5246278f74bc5b5839a09e/result.json",
|
||||
"sha256": "11626cc11d05b07decc2063307399e393b8820d1ab65006456000ceae538bd1b",
|
||||
"original_unit_completed": false
|
||||
}
|
||||
+19
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
|
||||
{
|
||||
"candidate": "bf559632ddd938085702529d9dd6b7c878f4ebc7",
|
||||
"findings": [
|
||||
{
|
||||
"severity": "low",
|
||||
"message": "The checker only checks that the index commit is 40 hex characters. It never confirms that the commit equals the submitted candidate (the index and OS proof say d1c7ce2, the candidate is bf55963). Reuse is still sound, because the full source map is recomputed and must match exactly. But commit provenance is not machine-bound to the candidate; it rests on the reuse-applicability record."
|
||||
},
|
||||
{
|
||||
"severity": "low",
|
||||
"message": "Some metadata in implementation.json is stale. `metadata_sync.review_material_context_gap` says there is no .review-material, but it is now present. `scope` still says 'Metadata-only synchronization against Git 1545bd42'. This is documentation only and changes no claims."
|
||||
},
|
||||
{
|
||||
"severity": "low",
|
||||
"message": "Still open from the previous review: in tests/s1/test_p08_combined_migration.gd, `break` only leaves the writer/reader loop, so the remaining combinations keep running after a failure. Failures are still counted, so this cannot produce a false pass."
|
||||
}
|
||||
],
|
||||
"disposition": "independent review classified all low; no acceptance waiver, product change or repeated regression; preserve for later relevant work",
|
||||
"original_unit_completed": false
|
||||
}
|
||||
@@ -6833,9 +6833,8 @@
|
||||
"current_game_acceptance_inferred": false
|
||||
}
|
||||
],
|
||||
"progress_summary": "候補bf559632で診断fixture欠損と古い試験記録を修正。Opusの実レビューhigh1/medium1とRoot KeyError再現を根拠に、Opus指示でSolがr04を元12KB/SHA一致で復元し4Python試験55.197秒OKを生ログで確認した。製品等の選択ソース1316件・仕様・入力・marker完全一致に基づきd1c7ce27のnative全8/通常OS/最終174回帰を元の版記録を保持して再利用。bf559632登録検証integrity verified/不足0。別Opus5.5読取専用再レビュー中。正式完了・統合・Windows受入は未認定。修正7/上限なし。",
|
||||
"progress_summary": "候補bf559632で診断fixture欠損と古い試験記録を修正。Opusの実レビューhigh1/medium1とRoot KeyError再現を根拠に、Opus指示でSolがr04を元12KB/SHA一致で復元し4Python試験55.197秒OKを生ログで確認した。製品等の選択ソース1316件・仕様・入力・marker完全一致に基づきd1c7ce27のnative全8/通常OS/最終174回帰を元の版記録を保持して再利用。bf559632登録検証integrity verified/不足0。別Opus5.5読取専用再レビュー中。正式完了・統合・Windows受入は未認定。修正7/上限なし。 別Opus5.5の再レビューは原6条件を含めPASS。critical/high/medium0、low3は受入を妨げないため記録して延期。候補統合・最終確認・台帳閉鎖は未完。",
|
||||
"remaining_gaps": [
|
||||
"独立Opusが全6条件・通常OS・対象版適用性をレビューする。",
|
||||
"統合候補を作成し、実際の統合版source map/spec/settingsと既存証拠の適用性を確認して登録統合検証を実行する。",
|
||||
"許可済みmain統合と統合後最終確認・台帳反映まで完結する。",
|
||||
"同一Windows配布版の実機条件は引き続き全体の未達。macOS証拠から認定しない。"
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user