diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md index 4884513..b5101e7 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ ## 現在の対象（2026-10-13・現版監査更新） -2026-10-14 現在の閉鎖対象はP08-03。正式11／着手25／予定52、原30パッケージ／88成果単位と部分点なしを維持する。提出fd643f55a271e63c554b94681454d357117c0678（修正18、6.1-sol担当終了）を凍結し、実Opus 5.5の判断で全176回帰を1回実施、20,488厳密チェックPASS、未実行・ソース／保存保護違反・終了処理エラー0。共有Runtime支援はdbf5cb8で完了済みだが原88への加点0。原P08-03は通常OS全5条件・独立受入・統合最終確認が残る。R13は33操作を収集したがMac操作中断、R14は事前校正準備不足で初回期限超過し、両方とも未受入の履歴。製品不具合を捏造せず、既存ソースとR10 native、適用一致の全回帰を再利用する。純JS校正は実JPEG2条件で確認済み、対応済みPython ACK記録器を準備してから次のOS収集を開始する。個別修正上限は撤廃済み。以下の古い上限・容量承認待ちは履歴であり停止理由ではない。 +2026-10-14 現在の閉鎖対象はP08-03。正式11／着手25／予定52、原30パッケージ／88成果単位と部分点なしを維持する。提出fd643f55a271e63c554b94681454d357117c0678（修正18、6.1-sol担当終了）を凍結し、実Opus 5.5の判断で全176回帰を1回実施、20,488厳密チェックPASS、未実行・ソース／保存保護違反・終了処理エラー0。共有Runtime支援はdbf5cb8で完了済みだが原88への加点0。原P08-03は通常OS全5条件・独立受入・統合最終確認が残る。R13は33操作を収集したがMac操作中断、R14は事前校正準備不足で初回期限超過し、両方とも未受入の履歴。製品不具合を捏造せず、既存ソースとR10 native、適用一致の全回帰を再利用する。純JS校正は実JPEG2条件で確認済み、対応済みPython ACK記録器を準備してR15を収集したが、受付の再表示31を画面成功確認前に受領し、次の選択32が画面外のまま期限超過した。R15も未受入・加点0、ソース／保存保護違反と終了処理エラー0。Macロックとは区別し、既存タスクの実Opusへパレット操作の局所切り分けを依頼中（execution/p08-03/R15_INCOMPLETE_OS_AUDIT.json）。新しい全回帰や重複実装は起動しない。個別修正上限は撤廃済み。以下の古い上限・容量承認待ちは履歴であり停止理由ではない。 原30パッケージ/88成果、部分点なし。現在は正式10/着手24/予定54。P24-03は正式完了、MP-01-r02承認用資料は正式統合済みだが原88へ加点しない。P13-03既存最終修正は全7施設/84スロット/6分類が保全済み。P13/RP13の限定追加修正と正式host自己試験は直接許可待ちで、重複実装や無断上限変更をしない。 diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/OPUS_R15_DIAGNOSIS.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/OPUS_R15_DIAGNOSIS.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..28fbd19 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/OPUS_R15_DIAGNOSIS.json @@ -0,0 +1,13 @@ +{ + "run": "78ae899abd684e33bb83c9f2d0d7b017", + "result_sha256": "be23f02240631dccf2aa9bca8d07da3b2b62ae3e4f60631eaf61add0dfab3f02", + "candidate": "fd643f55a271e63c554b94681454d357117c0678", + "decision": { + "action": "wait", + "task_id": "P08-03", + "reason": "Decision: WAIT. Do not start a new whole R15/R16 attempt yet. The incomplete R15 earns no acceptance credit. Keep the fd643f5 full176 regression (20488 accepted checks) and its fingerprints for reuse; do not rerun it. Only validate and wait are valid right now. The diagnosis below needs a narrow fixture repair before another whole attempt is worth running, and a repair cannot be issued from this state. The owner or Runner must open a repair transition. This decision does not authorize a repair.\n\nI read the source at HEAD fd643f5 only. I could not open the R15 artifacts from this checkout because the tools are restricted to the worktree, so the raw-evidence statements below rely on the owner's summary.\n\nDIAGNOSIS\n\n1. How the palette works (main.gd:791-811)\n- BuildPaletteScroll is a ScrollContainer that scrolls horizontally only: horizontal mode AUTO, vertical DISABLED, minimum height 62.\n- It holds one row: a single-row grid of all MVP_FACILITY_IDS buttons, then DemolitionButton at the far right end.\n- follow_focus is not set, so moving focus with the keyboard does not scroll the palette.\n- Home is handled by WorldPreview._unhandled_key_input (world_preview.gd:378-380), which calls reset_view. Home is therefore a camera control, not a palette control. Root seeing the camera change on Home is correct product behaviour, not a defect.\n- Under Godot 4.7, these scroll the palette normally:\n - (a) dragging the thumb of the horizontal scrollbar at the bottom edge of BuildPaletteScroll, or clicking its track;\n - (b) a horizontal or shift-wheel scroll with the pointer over the palette.\n- I expect a vertical trackpad scroll on macOS (a pan gesture) to do nothing here, because vertical scrolling is disabled. I did not check this against the 4.7 engine source.\n- I also expect mouse drag-to-scroll of the content to be touch-only, so it would not work with a Mac mouse. Not checked against the engine source either.\n- This explains the reported failures of scroll, drag and Home without any product defect.\n\n2. Why request32 was at x=-1105\n- passive point() (passive_placement.gd:66-70) computes the button's screen position from its current transform, which includes the palette's scroll offset.\n- The earlier steps used DemolitionButton at the right end of the row, so the palette was still scrolled to the right. The reception button sat about 1100px to the left of the visible area.\n- The palette was never scrolled back, so the coordinate correctly reported a button that was off screen.\n- Conclusion: this was a Root operation and location error (no use of the scrollbar, wrong use of Home), not a product defect. No main.gd or world_preview.gd change is justified.\n\n3. Evidence-integrity defects in the fixture (inside allowed_paths: tests/fixtures/p08-03/**)\n- (A) passive reveal() (passive_placement.gd:124-126) accepts any ACK. It never checks afterwards that the target is actually visible. That is how Root's wrong ACK31 was accepted as a successful reveal. The handler reveal (placement.gd:303-305) uses ensure_control_visible, which is not an OS action.\n- (B) When request() fails on timeout or identity (passive_placement.gd:42-50), it calls expect(false) and tree.quit(1) and then simply returns. The caller carries on in the same frame:\n - choose() (placement.gd:83-90) emitted the 'chosen production definition' failure;\n - button() wrote request33 after the run had already failed.\n - Nothing should be produced after the first terminal failure.\n\nEVIDENCE CORRECTION (Root ledger only; do not rewrite artifacts)\n- Mark writer-request-0031 ACK as invalid: it was a Root error, and reception was not visible.\n- Mark request-0032 as never completed (ACK missing after 300s). Mark the 'chosen production definition' failure and request-0033 as consequences of B, not real findings.\n- Record the material change from 42 to 44 and the reception demolition as real actual-receipt30 effects, scoped to this attempt only.\n- R15 stays FAILED or INCOMPLETE with no reveal success.\n- The Mac stayed unlocked; this was not a lock failure.\n- original30/88, the timeout and the security settings are unchanged.\n\nNEXT AUTHORIZED DIRECTION (once a repair transition is opened; scope is fixture/checker/docs only)\n- passive reveal():\n - Put in the request: the palette's screen rect, the HScrollBar's screen rect and its value/max, the current scroll_horizontal, the target button's rect, and which way to scroll (left or right).\n - The instructions should say: 'drag the horizontal scrollbar thumb or click its track; do not use Home'.\n - After the ACK, require that the target's global rect lies fully inside the palette's global rect and inside the window. Record scroll_horizontal before and after, plus the OS events. Otherwise fail with 'palette reveal not visible'.\n- request(): add a terminal failed flag. After the first failure, request(), button() and choose() return immediately and write no further request files.\n- Add a checker negative for a reveal with an unverified ACK and one for a request written after a terminal failure.\n- No change to Runtime or production UI.\n\nRoot operation plan for the next attempt:\n- Before each reveal, read the scrollbar rect and direction from request.json.\n- Drag the thumb, then screenshot.\n- ACK only when the button is visibly inside the palette.\n- Never press Home to scroll.\n\nStill pending: Root freeze, normal OS plus native recollection on the frozen source, applicability of the reused regression fingerprints, independent Opus review of all 5 conditions, integration, final verification and the ledger. Windows same-distribution/device stays open, with no Mac substitution.", + "codex_model": "gpt-6.1-sol", + "codex_model_reason": "Keeping the default, gpt-6.1-sol, for any repair that follows. I traced the root cause through the source:\n- the horizontal-only ScrollContainer layout (main.gd:791-811);\n- Home being consumed by WorldPreview (world_preview.gd:378);\n- the ACK being accepted without any check (passive_placement.gd:124-126);\n- the run continuing after a failure (passive_placement.gd:42-50, placement.gd:83-90).\n\nThe fix is limited to two fixture functions, a visibility assertion, an abort flag, two checker negatives and docs. There is no production, Runtime or engine debugging, so gpt-6-astra would cost more time and usage without a clear quality gain." + }, + "root_execution": "No whole rerun. Invoke existing registered verify-only checker once (180s, no full regression) to record missing acceptance evidence and enter Runner repair_pending through normal validation transition. Then ask commander to issue narrow fixture repair on the same task; no manual state overwrite or product UI edit." +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/R15_INCOMPLETE_OS_AUDIT.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/R15_INCOMPLETE_OS_AUDIT.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..547412a --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/R15_INCOMPLETE_OS_AUDIT.json @@ -0,0 +1,74 @@ +{ + "candidate": "fd643f55a271e63c554b94681454d357117c0678", + "attempt": "R15", + "formal_acceptance": false, + "original_unit_credit": 0, + "writer": { + "actual_pid": 67632, + "owner_pid": 67486, + "exit_code": 1, + "engine_ended": true, + "error": "AssertionError: ordinary native OS exit0", + "guard_errors": [], + "cleanup_errors": [], + "passed": false + }, + "failure": "Request31 reveal_palette was acknowledged by Root before the reception was visibly revealed; request32 target screen x=-1105 was offscreen. Normal scroll/drag/key attempts did not establish the intended selection. Missing ACK32 exceeded the 300s endpoint deadline; fixture emitted timeout and chosen production definition failure before termination. No Mac lock was observed during this sequence.", + "invalid_receipt": "os-pair/writer-request-0031/ack.json is historical actual action receipt only; it must not be treated as successful reveal evidence.", + "reuse": "Frozen full176 regression and R10 native evidence remain eligible only on exact source/input/config/environment fingerprints. R15 cannot be spliced with older OS attempts.", + "remaining": [ + "fresh contiguous normal OS all five conditions", + "checker acceptance", + "independent Opus review", + "integration and final verification", + "ledger closure" + ], + "next": "Actual Opus commander diagnosis requested on existing P08-03; no duplicate worker or whole rerun launched.", + "references": [ + { + "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p08-03-native-os-fd643f5-r15-calibrated/os-resume-ended.json", + "sha256": "f8f54429b765be11f3e3d9d428b926feb943718386bba4c62eca1ef26d2c7ca0", + "bytes": 197 + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p08-03-native-os-fd643f5-r15-calibrated/os-runs/writer/ended.json", + "sha256": "4d1e0e6acbc44b18f034254d9d3a5fcab9bef36002236e7085349ff88b581148", + "bytes": 1320522 + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p08-03-native-os-fd643f5-r15-calibrated/os-runs/writer/engine-native.log", + "sha256": "dce51d1d8ee4e66b422bbd597a7014d07d31943df8f3fec093aa03a9921f245e", + "bytes": 7784 + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p08-03-native-os-fd643f5-r15-calibrated/os-pair/writer-request-0031/request.json", + "sha256": "343eddb6e1afc8c8918c4d3b49f57022fd2a0e949b0c9f3da700a699264f30e0", + "bytes": 579 + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p08-03-native-os-fd643f5-r15-calibrated/os-pair/writer-request-0031/ack.json", + "sha256": "af87f224228f2b82b94d2a02b16b5d3cf87fb00dcbc02b5ed543fac4e78addb9", + "bytes": 335 + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p08-03-native-os-fd643f5-r15-calibrated/os-pair/writer-request-0031/screen-after.png", + "sha256": "703ab6c3b46081d5f8a9214a11ca74e6983544821b1c248392c27310907aeedd", + "bytes": 64891 + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p08-03-native-os-fd643f5-r15-calibrated/os-pair/writer-request-0032/request.json", + "sha256": "dd9de613a37304b604868cb9465911d64f5acd7fab86402f090b626b50dfa4d8", + "bytes": 722 + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p08-03-native-os-fd643f5-r15-calibrated/os-pair/writer-request-0032/cua-actions.json", + "sha256": "81392968431a2bf0c96f290742bf89e243b22d152a2232139c1645db72d374d9", + "bytes": 1618 + }, + { + "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p08-03-native-os-fd643f5-r15-calibrated/os-pair/writer-request-0032/screen-after.png", + "sha256": "8a4928a5cf98f85b6016c93b02e0d7d15f8f309fc7ba2059995cc2376bc7dd37", + "bytes": 63337 + } + ] +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json index c10ede8..94a1cfc 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json @@ -6939,16 +6939,34 @@ "sha256": "59a6e37141b16509449fbc90d40ea8932fe8e93dec800a6915ecfffed1f89d3e", "scope": "31aa complete actual OS collection, retained publication/format deficits; not formal acceptance", "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false + }, + { + "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/FULL_REGRESSION_FD643_R01.json", + "sha256": "cb8add2f3841bea564e550fccf66c61cc7738a10451895fb4760901d5b7556a6", + "scope": "fd643 actual full176 regression only; exact applicability required; no original acceptance credit", + "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false + }, + { + "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/R15_INCOMPLETE_OS_AUDIT.json", + "sha256": "eb54e29a9752821b527797206e0a7645adfb88775abe77960b4b05e9719ab1a8", + "scope": "fd643 R15 failed OS attempt and invalid reveal31; diagnostic history only", + "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false + }, + { + "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/OPUS_R15_DIAGNOSIS.json", + "sha256": "56a86e60a508d9e0c7891c7a48d87fd23ef1dce6617111c632f085018c31755b", + "scope": "actual Opus5.5 read-only diagnosis and next narrow repair; no acceptance credit", + "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false } ], - "progress_summary": "P08-03 original five facets; no partial credit. Submitted31aa7706: RefCounted endpoint fix, final88 local tests PASS, Root verified actual stdout and1328 source SHAs. R09 import/parse/handler writer/reader PASS. Real OS writer80337 completed64 requests, reader92565 completed5 (normal load and same-cell overlap refusal); both exit0, native errors0, all owned ended and source/default-player/stage/cleanup guards clean. Camera actual event cell(-8,0,0), selected and occupant IDs both rebuilt facility_00000004. Root pinned original index/receipt SHAs and retained every raw byte. Registered validation failed copied absolute teardown paths; direct original verification next rejected actual CUA JPEG bytes named .png. Opus prescribed validator-only repair and exact31aa reuse chain, strict JPEG validation, original/copy byte mapping, negative controls. Opus selected Astra for the strengthened proof requirements; same worker/worktree repair12, caps null, no duplicate69 OS replay or product/fixture/controller edits. Stair preview/domain semantics remain open for independent acceptance. Final175 regression, independent review, integration outstanding; formal credit0. Repair12 worker made no code edits and ended on dimension/reference access gaps. Root measured immutable138 originals with sips (all1280x752), bound hashes to original index, enabled read-only access to the already-authorized R09 game evidence for exactP08 runtime, tested readPASS/writeDENIED/other-task unchanged. Claude auth refreshed through ordinary CLI without manual login. Fresh Opus decision resumed same Astra/worktree as repair13; no native replay, new product changes or relaxed acceptance.", + "progress_summary": "候補fd643f55a271e63c554b94681454d357117c0678。修正18提出版で全176回帰・20,488厳密チェックPASS、終了・保護エラー0。R10 nativeと全回帰は版・入力・設定・環境一致時だけ再利用可能。R13はMacロック中断、R14はRoot準備不足、R15は受付の再表示31を画面成功確認前に受領し、選択32が画面外で300s期限超過。R15は不完全・正式加点0。撤去時の資材42→44は当該診断履歴に限定する。実Opus 5.5は製品修正の根拠なしと判断、受動fixtureの可視性確認欠落と失敗後継続を指摘。既存verify-only検証で修正待ちへ正規遷移し、同じworktreeの修正19を準備。新規実装担当・OS再試行・全回帰再実行なし。全5条件の連続通常OS受入、独立レビュー、統合最終確認、台帳閉鎖が未達。", "remaining_gaps": [ - "Submit validator-only repair with strong negative tests, immutable rawR09 proof and exact original/copy/version reuse mapping.", - "Pass registered validation of the frozen candidate; independently judge stair preview/domain semantics against original acceptance, not merely integrity checks.", - "Run required final175 regression, separate Opus review, integration/final checks and ledger closure.", - "Same Windows release physical acceptance and deferred P23 gestures remain separate global gaps." + "修正19: 受動fixtureにパレット／スクロールバー／対象の位置と可視性検証、終端失敗後の要求停止、checkerの意味ある否定試験を追加。Opusの具体的RUN判断を待ち、既存6.1-sol担当で実行。", + "正常な横スクロール操作を短い診断で確認後、正確な最終候補版で全5条件の連続通常OS writer／別PID readerとcheckerを通す。R15以前の断片を合成しない。", + "ソース変更時は旧全回帰の適用可否を厳密照合し、必要な最終版の必須全回帰を1回実施。独立Opusレビュー、統合・最終検証と正式台帳反映まで完了する。", + "同一Windows配布版の実機受入と延期済みP23保持ジェスチャーは別の全体残件。" ], - "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-14T09:23:44.141594+09:00" + "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-15T00:02:41.319212+09:00" } ], "estimate_person_days_historical_2026_09_29": [