From a65af90168e4b4448d7e5556556bae78f67ca22c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Takeshi Date: Sun, 18 Oct 2026 09:41:08 +0900 Subject: [PATCH] docs: record direct Opus source judgment and exact P26 attribution repair --- ...AL_OPUS_DIRECT_SOURCE_ATTRIBUTION_MAP.json | 7 +++ .../ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json | 49 ++++++++------- ...D_DA_F109_VALIDATION_STORAGE_RECOVERY.json | 24 ++++++++ .../ROOT_EXACT_F10907D8_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json | 31 ++++++++++ ..._FACT_COMPARISON_DA80360A_TO_F10907D8.json | 13 ++++ .../ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_F10907D8.json | 26 ++++++++ .../p26-01/ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_F10907D8.json | 27 +++++++++ .../progress_snapshot.json | 59 +++++++++---------- .../work_packages.json | 10 ++-- 9 files changed, 184 insertions(+), 62 deletions(-) create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ACTUAL_OPUS_DIRECT_SOURCE_ATTRIBUTION_MAP.json create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_ENDED_DA_F109_VALIDATION_STORAGE_RECOVERY.json create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_EXACT_F10907D8_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_FACT_COMPARISON_DA80360A_TO_F10907D8.json create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_F10907D8.json create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_F10907D8.json diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ACTUAL_OPUS_DIRECT_SOURCE_ATTRIBUTION_MAP.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ACTUAL_OPUS_DIRECT_SOURCE_ATTRIBUTION_MAP.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1176a05 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ACTUAL_OPUS_DIRECT_SOURCE_ATTRIBUTION_MAP.json @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +{ + "action": "request-repair", + "task_id": "P26-01-LEDGER", + "reason": "This is a same-task repair of SUPPORT_POLICY attribution, based on my own direct reading at f10907d8. I read SUPPORT_POLICY at check_content_ledger.py:40-64. I read every listed AR condition in atomic_requirements.json. I read each pinned span: peeping_room_service.gd:124-164, simulation_runtime.gd:10860-10880, guest_service.gd:355-360 and operations_coordinator.gd:1183-1195. Because the relationship sources are pinned as whole files, I also read original_relationship_state.gd:1-39 and relationship_service.gd:33-58 and 315-355. Finally I read ledger row original.line.221.\n\nALLOWED, kept with exact code proof. Narrow each scope string to the cited fragment.\n(1) relationship-container\n- AR.relationship.three_emotions: FIELDS affection/lust/netorare, original_relationship_state.gd:6 and 21-25.\n- AR.relationship.affection_shield_max: the invariant shield_max==affection plus the 0<=shield_current<=shield_max bound, at :26.\n- 21 AR.heroine.

.route.: the per-heroine original record is keyed by subject_id and stored by register_original_relationship (relationship_service.gd:38-58). Separately there is a generic route_lock/route_id record (:315-355). It holds no original route IDs, has no natural reach, and has no content.\n- Replace the whole-file pins with these exact excerpt spans. Keep the route rows partial with content_status=missing.\n(2) peeping-container\n- AR.underground.observation: covers only the state half. Room state is stopped/link_state/target, and the precondition precedence is at peeping_room_service.gd:127-138. The 通常入口 is absent because place returns BUILD_DEFINITION_PENDING_D04 at simulation_runtime.gd:10863-10864.\n- AR.observation.recorder: covers only the evidence ledger record fields evidence_id/room_id/target_instance_id/source_event_key/minute at :155-164. Writes are fixture-only, production record_evidence returns RECORDER_ELIGIBILITY_PENDING_D04_D08_P16 (:140-142), and recorder placement is absent.\n(3) night-input\n- AR.guest.need_sexual_night_peak: covers only the adult intimacy need choosing the intimacy_night or intimacy_day input key from is_night (guest_service.gd:355-359). There are no peak values and no event production.\n(4) bankruptcy-bookkeeping\n- AR.progression.three_deficits_gameover: consecutive negative-net-profit counter → TERMINAL_BANKRUPT once it reaches the config bankruptcy_close_count (operations_coordinator.gd:1190-1194). Do not claim the configured value is 3. There is no authored game-over ending.\n\nEXCLUDED: remove from SUPPORT_POLICY. In every row, these go to unsupported_atomic_requirement_ids.\n- AR.ui.observation_camera_entry: 裏層のカメラアイコンから専用観察画面へ. No icon, view or screen transition exists in any cited span.\n- AR.ui.observation_capture: スクリーンショット根拠収集. There is no screenshot or capture. The fixture evidence key is not a screenshot.\n- AR.underground.blackmail: 脅迫取引の状態と収支. There is no transaction state and no income. The evidence ledger is only a precursor.\n- AR.route_action.observation_progress: 観察部屋からルート進行確認. No peeping span reads relationship or route state.\n- AR.schedule.B-14.3.observation: 専用観察モード達成. The dedicated mode is absent.\n- AR.events.ntr_night_peak: NTRイベント夜ピーク. guest_service only selects a guest-need input key and contains no NTR events.\n\nROW EFFECTS: --write must derive these.\n- Any row whose scoped_support becomes empty is status=missing with evidence=[]. Check at least original.line.221, 222 and 156, the row(s) for L21 and L257, and any clause.* row that contained only excluded ARs.\n- Rows that keep an allowed AR stay partial and list the excluded ARs as unsupported. Examples: L34 keeps underground.observation, L53 keeps recorder, L65 keeps guest_need, L72 keeps the bankruptcy AR.\n- Do not delete real code. Describe the excluded-AR related code only as 'uncredited precursor, not required behaviour' in the row reason text and in IMPLEMENTATION_REPORT. Do not attach evidence pins to it and do not claim the code is nonexistent.\n\nINDEPENDENT CHECK:\n- Add a hard-coded EXCLUDED_ATTRIBUTIONS table in check_content_ledger.py that is separate from SUPPORT_POLICY. Map each of the 6 ARs to the feature its scope disclaims.\n- verify must fail if any SUPPORT_POLICY kind contains an excluded AR, or if any row claims an excluded AR in scoped_support.\n- Add one negative test per excluded AR (6 total). Each must inject an old-kind claim into that AR's row and must also monkeypatch SUPPORT_POLICY to re-add the AR. Both must be rejected.\n- Include valid controls for the allowed ARs.\n\nLOW:\n- For chapters.all and dialogue.all, keep status=undefined. Change the reason text to say that produced content is 欠損 and that only scope and quantity are undefined.\n- Owner precision stays deferred.\n\nINVARIANTS:\n- Change only the 5 outputs.\n- Coverage stays at 762/1309/675, accounting stays at 15/88 with credit 0, and every count stays null.\n- Add no content, values or native runs. Keep the immutable pins/spec and all 4 approved D05 history entries.\n- Make no gate, API or permission changes. Repairs continue in this task with no cap change.", + "codex_model": "gpt-6.1-sol", + "codex_model_reason": "I'm changing from Astra to Sol. Astra was chosen because the worker had to judge AR attribution semantically, and this repair removes that need. I have already read every AR condition and source span myself and fixed the exact allowed and excluded lists, the narrowed spans, and the rules for which rows flip. What remains is mechanical: edit a closed table, add an independent exclusion table, add 6 negative tests with controls, run --write to regenerate, and edit report text. Sol's quality is enough for a closed, implementation-ready map. It also costs less time and usage, which matters after 5 repairs at about 1-1.5M input tokens each, and it lets the P04 D05 work proceed sooner. The checker and tests catch any deviation from the map, so a repeat repair costs less than paying Astra's premium again." +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json index d017bee..59e20aa 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json @@ -16,9 +16,9 @@ "full_acceptance": "原本で要求された未制作内容を欠損として記録し、架空の完成数を置かない。", "dependencies": "Audit observes P19/P20/P22 actual state; does not accept their production. Pending D08/D09 explicit. P04 existing D05 questions retained.", "missing": [ - "Fix requirement-specific semantic support attribution and independent compatibility detection; voice/ending/encyclopedia must not gain unrelated backend partial support", - "Validate new exactS once, requalify full input evidence and independent whole-unit review", - "Normal candidate integration/final and all evidence before ledger credit" + "Apply actual direct-source Opus map: keep justified fragments, exclude6 precursor-only ARs, narrow exact pins and independent policy/row rejection tests", + "New exactS registered validation and input requalification, whole-original independentreview", + "Normal candidate integration/final and complete evidence before16/88" ], "reuse": [ "P19-03 accepted table S903a2c566e73cebc874a6499410a1243bc190a63/C8e4f1d92fc2a2e8f1dd187e661cf52b13e4e51d4", @@ -27,17 +27,17 @@ ], "model": "actual Opus selects; proposed gpt-6.1-sol", "storage_estimate_scope": "Opus under5MB is output-material estimate, excludes required Runner checkout copies (~240MB each); stage copies, recover only ended fully restorable duplicates", - "actual_commander_run_direction": "b5edaa31d9b84c8ab04427fb550f5d76", + "actual_commander_run_direction": "1f3936da8f174bbd983f55f4b749c764", "actual_jobs": [ { - "id": "49fd5959853d47f7b3b9085d9a05582e", + "id": "91576d3eca304b9eb36fe59a5b8118d0", "role": "implementer", "status": "running", - "pid": 24906, - "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/49fd5959853d47f7b3b9085d9a05582e" + "pid": 34638, + "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/91576d3eca304b9eb36fe59a5b8118d0" } ], - "repairs": 5, + "repairs": 6, "repair_limit": null, "setup_attempt": { "run": "860ffd16cb38404ab434d65688eb0f68", @@ -50,42 +50,39 @@ "committed_accepted_material_anchor": "137639773c9017f9ee7733d78e37179b687f965c", "manifest": "accepted-p22-01-inputs/ROOT_MATERIAL_PRESERVATION_MANIFEST.json" }, - "resume_rule": "Inspect actual same task/new submission and current Astra job 49fd5959853d47f7b3b9085d9a05582e/PID24906 real liveness. Follow samehandle, no duplicate implementation. After newS normal registeredvalidate, exact native-reuse qualification, actual wholeOpusreview, normalcandidate/final/ledger; original15/88 untilallgates. P04 approvednext.", + "resume_rule": "Inspect actual task/newS and same current Sol job 91576d3eca304b9eb36fe59a5b8118d0/PID34638 live status first. No duplicate run. All exact map/review/source snapshot supplied under p26-direct-support-r06 and actual4D05 approvals remain present. AfternewS registeredvalidate, exactqualification, next-review-context with previous1d87, actualwholeOpusreview thennormalcandidate/final. P04 approvednext; original15/88 untilallgates.", "second_setup_attempt": { "run": "81b128df2b3741ec9ab480f3d05d96c1", "writes": 0, "result": "Prior commander direction incorrectly assumed existing P26 outputs. Actual Opus818862 withdrew assumption and actual3e55ca authorized creating all5newfiles; immutable spec unchanged. Three precreation invocations exited2 missing script, not actual tests or acceptance." }, "original_unit_credit_added": 0, - "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", - "submitted_source": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "S": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", + "submitted_source": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", "formal_validation": { "passed": true, + "S": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", "all_registered_checks": 3, - "meaningful_self_tests": 17, - "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", - "artifact": "ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_DA80360A.json", - "scope": "sameS doc/source checks only, not whole acceptance" + "meaningful_self_tests": 18, + "artifact": "ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_F10907D8.json" }, "whole_original_review": { - "actual_run": "dc734a96100a4c0bb1593f6dc124fa06", - "model": "claude-opus-5-5", + "S": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", + "actual_run": "1d87b50d0be3488f80eda4cee7fea06d", "status": "changes_requested", - "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", - "previous_all_findings_required_to_reassess": true, - "high": 1, + "high": 0, "medium": 1, "low": 3, - "artifact": "ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_DA80360A.json" + "artifact": "ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_F10907D8.json" }, "D05_current_human_answers": "All4remaining rules approved clientdate2026-10-18; separateP04adoptionnext. Frozenf4/379audit must explicitlylabel historicalsource.", "native_reuse": { - "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "S": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", "exact1368inputs_settings_policy_marker_engine_roster_defaultplayer_equal": true, - "actual_proof": "ROOT_EXACT_DA80360A_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json", + "actual_proof": "ROOT_EXACT_F10907D8_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json", "new_native_runs": 0 }, - "actual_repair_direction": "a8dc6b9fa0144a10abba1eddb87c5f22", + "actual_repair_direction": "5c77fcb3394e4c34a2558cde5e1ff3e8", "repair3_result": { "run": "3094806e368d4ed18952ff238508fe23", "result": "blocked on exact D05 approval source delivery; report-only edits, actual review fixes not done", @@ -101,6 +98,6 @@ "low": 1, "artifact": "ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_35B3DE0D.json" }, - "implementation_model": "gpt-6-astra", - "model_selection": "Actual Opus a8dc6b9f and b5edaa31 chose Astra for semantic mapping and avoiding repeat cycles; actual provider argv independently verified. No API switch." + "implementation_model": "gpt-6.1-sol", + "model_selection": "Actual Opus5c77 directly read every policy AR condition and each cited code span and fixed exact allowed/excluded memberships. Actual1f3936 switches to Sol6.1 for mechanical implementation; provider argv verified. Prior Astra output remains currentS." } diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_ENDED_DA_F109_VALIDATION_STORAGE_RECOVERY.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_ENDED_DA_F109_VALIDATION_STORAGE_RECOVERY.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..dba2ade --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_ENDED_DA_F109_VALIDATION_STORAGE_RECOVERY.json @@ -0,0 +1,24 @@ +{ + "at_unix_ns": 1792283537701105000, + "removed": [ + { + "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p26-01-ledger/P26-01-LEDGER-validation-1b73eeae", + "head": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", + "files": 4963, + "logical_bytes": 297061841 + }, + { + "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p26-01-ledger/P26-01-LEDGER-validation-4fd47d16", + "head": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "files": 4963, + "logical_bytes": 282396293 + } + ], + "free_before_bytes": 718565376, + "free_after_bytes": 1371758592, + "observed_gain_bytes": 653193216, + "all_source_blobs_verified": true, + "all_unique_runtime_evidence_preserved": true, + "restore_manifest": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p26-01-ledger/.runtime/coordinator-start-20261017/ENDED_DA_F109_VALIDATION_CHECKOUT_FULL_GIT_RESTORE_PROOF.json", + "restore_manifest_sha256": "5dc84346ab742a2d9ea0e7659777b246cda42c68ad7654e55dee419f79e65f5a" +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_EXACT_F10907D8_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_EXACT_F10907D8_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4ae8728 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_EXACT_F10907D8_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json @@ -0,0 +1,31 @@ +{ + "artifact_commit": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", + "kind": "submitted", + "existing_product_C": "65f07bf5eaa759a8e2e17c7bdbbbdbceb24ee373", + "old_actual_native_S": "a7e3069b167511b3194242b3403fbcc35244a526", + "all1368_selected_source_settings_assets_tests_tools_byte_equal": true, + "marker_policy_engine_roster_parse_default_player_equal": true, + "scope": "Unmodified existing source_refs algorithm exact key set; doc audit files excluded by preexisting algorithm, no narrowed source set. All source file bytes hashed independently by Root.", + "native_full_evidence_reuse_qualified": true, + "new_native_runs": 0, + "existing_full": { + "actual_suites": 184, + "missing_marker_paths": [], + "remaining_unexecuted_tests": [], + "available_marker_checks": 21903, + "actual_all_roster_checks": 21903, + "strict_accepted_checks": 21903, + "verified": true, + "composed": true, + "original_full_attempt_passed": false, + "whole_original_acceptance": false, + "parse_checks": 329, + "setup_phases": 2, + "owned_ended": 186, + "tested_source": "a7e3069b167511b3194242b3403fbcc35244a526", + "engines_started": 0, + "verifier_sha256": "d00bf46bfcc0e0bb197edd284a3ae14610ca710507831e18e071a79461946e8a" + }, + "whole_original_P26_01_accepted": false, + "time_ns": 1792283275576147000 +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_FACT_COMPARISON_DA80360A_TO_F10907D8.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_FACT_COMPARISON_DA80360A_TO_F10907D8.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c558e5f --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_FACT_COMPARISON_DA80360A_TO_F10907D8.json @@ -0,0 +1,13 @@ +{ + "old_S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "new_S": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", + "row_count": 762, + "all_same_ids_original_citations_AR_links": true, + "top_level_changed_only": [ + "rows", + "atomic_dispositions" + ], + "all_required_and_completed_counts_null": true, + "voice_all_missing_no_unrelated_evidence": true, + "scope": "Independent Root JSON facts comparison; not semantic whole-unit acceptance. Existing requirement coverage preserved; changed statuses/support still need actual independent Opus review." +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_F10907D8.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_F10907D8.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a7a5642 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_F10907D8.json @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +{ + "task_id": "P26-01-LEDGER", + "commit": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", + "kind": "validation", + "checks": [ + { + "id": "p26-ledger", + "exit_code": 0, + "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/47f3444c78da46809fcde2de6b57b1a2", + "passed": true + }, + { + "id": "p26-negative", + "exit_code": 0, + "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/8c8c6b23af954aba837b770d3bf78271", + "passed": true + }, + { + "id": "p26-source-binding", + "exit_code": 0, + "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/94f2e37d61f043ed966195985e20dbd0", + "passed": true + } + ], + "passed": true +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_F10907D8.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_F10907D8.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3d4aa39 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_F10907D8.json @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +{ + "task_id": "P26-01-LEDGER", + "commit": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", + "status": "changes_requested", + "summary": "Independent whole-unit review of P26-01 (AC-P26-01) at f10907d. Evidence read: BASELINE.txt in full (L1-258); check_content_ledger.py and test_content_ledger.py in full; IMPLEMENTATION_REPORT.md; the CONTENT_LEDGER.json rows for chapters, endings, encyclopedia, dialogue, portraits, voice, clause.*, 21 routes and original.line.9/53/65/72/221/222/257; the atomic_requirements records for every AR in SUPPORT_POLICY; the cited game source excerpts (peeping_room_service.gd:127-162, simulation_runtime.gd:10860-10880, guest_service.gd:355-360, operations_coordinator.gd:1183-1195); the prior da80360 review; the Root f10907d8 supplement, fact comparison and game-input reuse proof; the D05 binding; Runner receipts and logs. The diff file list was checked: changes touch only the 5 allowed outputs.\n\nReassessment of the da80360 findings:\n(1) Fixed. The merged-text keyword partial assignment is gone. It is replaced by a closed SUPPORT_POLICY that maps each support kind to its allowed ARs, plus a support_family limit. Claims are per AR in scoped_support, with an exact unsupported_atomic_requirement_ids partition.\n(2) Fixed. voice.all, endings.all/bad/game_over and encyclopedia.all are status=missing with evidence=[]. verify_authority line 508 rejects any evidence or partial status on voice/ending/encyclopedia rows. Mixed rows L9, L257 and clause.production keep the voice, ending and encyclopedia ARs as unsupported.\n(3) Fixed structurally. Partial support is scoped to the listed ARs. The self-contradictory concatenated 'no dedicated support; ...only' text is gone.\n(4) Fixed. Negative tests cover: injecting valid peeping pins into missing voice/portrait/ending/encyclopedia rows; copying a same-line observation claim into voice.all; giving a peeping claim to the L196 debt-settlement AR; expanding a claim to voice/ending/encyclopedia ARs; adding an unrelated pin to L65. Each has a valid control.\n(5) Preserved. Per the Root fact comparison and the checker: 762 rows, the same IDs, citations and AR links, 1309 AR dispositions, 675 relevant ARs linked, and required ⊆ seen_lines enforced from the BASELINE text.\nThe optional L226 low item is now explicit (P24 cut-ins). Owner precision is honestly deferred.\n\nStill holding:\n- All required_count and completed_count values are null. No row is produced.\n- Accounting stays at 15/88, credit 0, no partial credit.\n- D05 is historical at f4f85bc/379a1ba, and the current approval is pinned separately at a13f7c0 (cd365ded). D08 and D09 are unresolved.\n- P22-03 is a reference only.\n- Route rows keep exact original names and are partial (relationship container) with content_status missing.\n- Definition projection rejects changes to work, acceptance, depends_on and requirement_ids.\n- All 3 Runner validations exited 0 (18 tests OK, 1368 selected files, 329 parse files).\n\nRemaining blocker: the closed policy table itself contains at least one false AR attribution, so status is still not truthful for one original clause row. The checker's 'independent' compatibility check uses the same table, and the tests treat these attributions as valid. Neither can catch the error.\n\nNot verified or out of scope: prepare-integration, exact C/M, final, the Root ledger and main push remain mandatory. No native runs were required or reviewed. Native-reuse qualification rests on Root's supplied proof.", + "acceptance_ids": [ + "AC-P26-01" + ], + "findings": [ + { + "severity": "medium", + "message": "False partial attribution in the closed policy. In check_content_ledger.py:48-55, SUPPORT_POLICY['peeping-container'] lists AR.ui.observation_camera_entry (condition: 裏層のカメラアイコンから専用観察画面へ移る) as supported. The same policy's scope says 'no view, camera UI, screenshot, intervention, transaction or authored content'. IMPLEMENTATION_REPORT.md:49 also says the container does not prove 視界 or 専用画面. The cited code (peeping_room_service.gd:127-162 precondition/evidence-key fixture; simulation_runtime.gd:10860-10880 with placement returning BUILD_DEFINITION_PENDING_D04) has no camera icon, view transition or observation screen. Yet original.line.221 (CONTENT_LEDGER.json:336727-336794) has status=partial, evidence = the peeping pins, scoped_support=[AR.ui.observation_camera_entry], and unsupported_atomic_requirement_ids=[]. So a clause with zero relevant implementation is presented as fully partially supported. This is the same class of defect as the prior voice finding: unrelated backend support confers partial status. Because verify_authority reuses the same table and the tests use it as a valid control, the 'independent' compatibility check cannot detect it. Fix: remove AR.ui.observation_camera_entry from the policy, so L221 becomes missing with no evidence. Also re-justify each remaining policy AR against direct source proof, and add a negative test that rejects support for an AR whose required feature the support scope disclaims." + }, + { + "severity": "low", + "message": "Several other policy memberships rest on precursor relevance only and should be re-justified or narrowed during the same fix:\n- AR.ui.observation_capture (screenshot evidence collection; the scope disclaims screenshots).\n- AR.underground.blackmail (blackmail transaction state and income; the scope disclaims transactions).\n- AR.route_action.observation_progress (route progress shown from the observation room).\n- AR.events.ntr_night_peak (NTR events peak at night). Its support is guest_service.gd:355-360, which only selects intimacy_night vs intimacy_day for guest need; report line 51 itself says this is not NTR event evidence.\nEach row's content_status stays missing, and the parent rows have other legitimately supported ARs, so this is low. The per-AR attribution should still not credit ARs whose only required behaviour is absent." + }, + { + "severity": "low", + "message": "chapters.all and dialogue.all use status=undefined rather than missing, although the reason text begins with 欠損 and the missing field is set. This is acceptable because the original defines no chapter or dialogue set. Consider stating explicitly that the produced content is missing and only the scope/quantity is undefined, so the AC wording (未制作内容を欠損として記録) is unambiguous for these two named categories." + }, + { + "severity": "low", + "message": "Owner precision (owners derived from every AR sharing a cited line, e.g. dialogue.all → P00/P19/P25 through BGM/tile/parameter schedule ARs) remains explicitly deferred, as permitted. It does not block original acceptance." + } + ] +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/progress_snapshot.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/progress_snapshot.json index 899d115..4279968 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/progress_snapshot.json +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/progress_snapshot.json @@ -5241,19 +5241,19 @@ "completed": false, "existing_project": "the-tree-p26-01-ledger", "actual_opus_selection": "6b9bb7f7a8474689b4094efbfcde2eef", - "actual_opus_run_direction": "b5edaa31d9b84c8ab04427fb550f5d76", + "actual_opus_run_direction": "1f3936da8f174bbd983f55f4b749c764", "base_commit": "379a1ba8fd25b5ad24226178a2492f91761dc31d", "current_acceptance_and_missing": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json", "supersedes_next_selection_only": "P24-02 sourcefe44f55 and all8unaccepted conditions retained; no duplicate worker", "actual_worker": { - "id": "49fd5959853d47f7b3b9085d9a05582e", + "id": "91576d3eca304b9eb36fe59a5b8118d0", "role": "implementer", "status": "running", - "pid": 24906, - "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/49fd5959853d47f7b3b9085d9a05582e" + "pid": 34638, + "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/91576d3eca304b9eb36fe59a5b8118d0" }, "actual_runner_state": "implementing", - "source": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7" + "source": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b" }, "current_P14_01_contract_audit": { "audit": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p14-01-current-contract-audit-r01/audit.json", @@ -10547,9 +10547,9 @@ "full_acceptance": "原本で要求された未制作内容を欠損として記録し、架空の完成数を置かない。", "dependencies": "Audit observes P19/P20/P22 actual state; does not accept their production. Pending D08/D09 explicit. P04 existing D05 questions retained.", "missing": [ - "Fix requirement-specific semantic support attribution and independent compatibility detection; voice/ending/encyclopedia must not gain unrelated backend partial support", - "Validate new exactS once, requalify full input evidence and independent whole-unit review", - "Normal candidate integration/final and all evidence before ledger credit" + "Apply actual direct-source Opus map: keep justified fragments, exclude6 precursor-only ARs, narrow exact pins and independent policy/row rejection tests", + "New exactS registered validation and input requalification, whole-original independentreview", + "Normal candidate integration/final and complete evidence before16/88" ], "reuse": [ "P19-03 accepted table S903a2c566e73cebc874a6499410a1243bc190a63/C8e4f1d92fc2a2e8f1dd187e661cf52b13e4e51d4", @@ -10558,17 +10558,17 @@ ], "model": "actual Opus selects; proposed gpt-6.1-sol", "storage_estimate_scope": "Opus under5MB is output-material estimate, excludes required Runner checkout copies (~240MB each); stage copies, recover only ended fully restorable duplicates", - "actual_commander_run_direction": "b5edaa31d9b84c8ab04427fb550f5d76", + "actual_commander_run_direction": "1f3936da8f174bbd983f55f4b749c764", "actual_jobs": [ { - "id": "49fd5959853d47f7b3b9085d9a05582e", + "id": "91576d3eca304b9eb36fe59a5b8118d0", "role": "implementer", "status": "running", - "pid": 24906, - "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/49fd5959853d47f7b3b9085d9a05582e" + "pid": 34638, + "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p26-01-ledger/runs/91576d3eca304b9eb36fe59a5b8118d0" } ], - "repairs": 5, + "repairs": 6, "repair_limit": null, "setup_attempt": { "run": "860ffd16cb38404ab434d65688eb0f68", @@ -10581,42 +10581,39 @@ "committed_accepted_material_anchor": "137639773c9017f9ee7733d78e37179b687f965c", "manifest": "accepted-p22-01-inputs/ROOT_MATERIAL_PRESERVATION_MANIFEST.json" }, - "resume_rule": "Inspect actual same task/new submission and current Astra job 49fd5959853d47f7b3b9085d9a05582e/PID24906 real liveness. Follow samehandle, no duplicate implementation. After newS normal registeredvalidate, exact native-reuse qualification, actual wholeOpusreview, normalcandidate/final/ledger; original15/88 untilallgates. P04 approvednext.", + "resume_rule": "Inspect actual task/newS and same current Sol job 91576d3eca304b9eb36fe59a5b8118d0/PID34638 live status first. No duplicate run. All exact map/review/source snapshot supplied under p26-direct-support-r06 and actual4D05 approvals remain present. AfternewS registeredvalidate, exactqualification, next-review-context with previous1d87, actualwholeOpusreview thennormalcandidate/final. P04 approvednext; original15/88 untilallgates.", "second_setup_attempt": { "run": "81b128df2b3741ec9ab480f3d05d96c1", "writes": 0, "result": "Prior commander direction incorrectly assumed existing P26 outputs. Actual Opus818862 withdrew assumption and actual3e55ca authorized creating all5newfiles; immutable spec unchanged. Three precreation invocations exited2 missing script, not actual tests or acceptance." }, "original_unit_credit_added": 0, - "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", - "submitted_source": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "S": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", + "submitted_source": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", "formal_validation": { "passed": true, + "S": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", "all_registered_checks": 3, - "meaningful_self_tests": 17, - "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", - "artifact": "ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_DA80360A.json", - "scope": "sameS doc/source checks only, not whole acceptance" + "meaningful_self_tests": 18, + "artifact": "ROOT_FORMAL_VALIDATION_F10907D8.json" }, "whole_original_review": { - "actual_run": "dc734a96100a4c0bb1593f6dc124fa06", - "model": "claude-opus-5-5", + "S": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", + "actual_run": "1d87b50d0be3488f80eda4cee7fea06d", "status": "changes_requested", - "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", - "previous_all_findings_required_to_reassess": true, - "high": 1, + "high": 0, "medium": 1, "low": 3, - "artifact": "ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_DA80360A.json" + "artifact": "ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_F10907D8.json" }, "D05_current_human_answers": "All4remaining rules approved clientdate2026-10-18; separateP04adoptionnext. Frozenf4/379audit must explicitlylabel historicalsource.", "native_reuse": { - "S": "da80360a60224bed5aedb487141511dc690a30f7", + "S": "f10907d8db7fe8d1de31bfe7726b2b002a4c727b", "exact1368inputs_settings_policy_marker_engine_roster_defaultplayer_equal": true, - "actual_proof": "ROOT_EXACT_DA80360A_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json", + "actual_proof": "ROOT_EXACT_F10907D8_GAME_INPUT_REUSE.json", "new_native_runs": 0 }, - "actual_repair_direction": "a8dc6b9fa0144a10abba1eddb87c5f22", + "actual_repair_direction": "5c77fcb3394e4c34a2558cde5e1ff3e8", "repair3_result": { "run": "3094806e368d4ed18952ff238508fe23", "result": "blocked on exact D05 approval source delivery; report-only edits, actual review fixes not done", @@ -10632,8 +10629,8 @@ "low": 1, "artifact": "ROOT_WHOLE_REVIEW_35B3DE0D.json" }, - "implementation_model": "gpt-6-astra", - "model_selection": "Actual Opus a8dc6b9f and b5edaa31 chose Astra for semantic mapping and avoiding repeat cycles; actual provider argv independently verified. No API switch." + "implementation_model": "gpt-6.1-sol", + "model_selection": "Actual Opus5c77 directly read every policy AR condition and each cited code span and fixed exact allowed/excluded memberships. Actual1f3936 switches to Sol6.1 for mechanical implementation; provider argv verified. Prior Astra output remains currentS." }, "p04_remaining_D05_actual_approval": { "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p04-01-owner-approval-20261018/D05_ACTUAL_HUMAN_APPROVAL.json", diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json index 29ce9ea..ff55bd2 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/work_packages.json @@ -17158,15 +17158,15 @@ { "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p26-01/ROOT_CURRENT_ACCEPTANCE_STATUS.json", "scope": "Registered audit start only, no original-unit acceptance", - "sha256_at_integration": "91c89a96373a07b8bc1120981128e2a82b8e0539799dc2b7fcfa0ca2d0fdbf97", + "sha256_at_integration": "ca792eef7806ffac05bf6483d348693c36c620439e2d0ccb20c84d9896a7d3a6", "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-17T20:36:24.754292+09:00" } ], - "progress_summary": "Actual whole Opusdc734a confirms earlier clause/AR/independent coverage fixes, but finds unrelated peeping backend marked partial for voice. Same task actualOpusb5edaa selects Astra for semantic evidence-family mapping and independentcompatibility negatives. Repairs5/null, actualworker running, formal15/88 no credit.", + "progress_summary": "Astra Sf10907d8:3registeredchecks/18tests PASS; actualOpus1d87 confirms voice/compatibility/coverage fixes, remaining1medium camera attribution. Actualcommander5c77 directly read all33policy memberships and6source views, fixed exact27allowed/6excluded map and span proofs. Actual1f3936 selectsSol for mechanical same-task repair6; formal15/88 no credit.", "remaining_gaps": [ - "Fix requirement-specific semantic support attribution and independent compatibility detection; voice/ending/encyclopedia must not gain unrelated backend partial support", - "Validate new exactS once, requalify full input evidence and independent whole-unit review", - "Normal candidate integration/final and all evidence before ledger credit" + "Apply actual direct-source Opus map: keep justified fragments, exclude6 precursor-only ARs, narrow exact pins and independent policy/row rejection tests", + "New exactS registered validation and input requalification, whole-original independentreview", + "Normal candidate integration/final and complete evidence before16/88" ], "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-17T20:36:24.754292+09:00" },