Preserve retained EQ completion and static-check repair evidence

docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/DESKTOP_EQ_S4_REPAIR_DECISION_R03.json

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"action":"request-repair","task_id":"P28-02-EQ","reason":"S4 run 20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe reached the unchanged 900-second limit and ended with exit 124. Provider PID 43572 and its child unit processes ended, and Root exec 51860 ended. Runner state: blocked, repairs 8, S null, no active run. Root preserved all 70 files with matching SHAs at retained-s4-20dc413-r01, RETURN SHA a2c0d5ffd42b67ef340d5624dd299e294b867168bd1270933aec458a9cde1dc5, joined at ROOT_S4_TIMEOUT_JOIN_20DC413.json SHA 945fec6bcfa431d794ac74513219cce8eab8dccade517c6a6faeb391f86e05d7. All 119 earlier test AST bodies and the earlier unit history are kept, and tracked product source is unchanged. run_eq.py and verify_eq.py are implemented. Unit attempt 05 passed 132 tests in 194.460 s with embedded exit 0, a fact for that version only. Two tests were added afterwards, so there are now 134. Attempt 06 started but produced no output before the limit, so a 134 PASS is not claimed. The failure raws of attempts 01 (syntax), 02 (added unit) and 04 (recompute mismatch) and the failed S4_SUPPLEMENTARY literal-reconstruction assert are all kept. The docs still describe S3b. A limited separate read-only check, confirmed by Root in source, found one medium false PASS: run_eq.py:257 and verify_eq.py:144 ignore the return value of check_probe, which returns {ok, errors} rather than raising (check_eq.py:384). No other collector API mismatch was found within that scope; this is not the formal all-6 review. Root placed the r09 ACTUAL_OPUS_TASK_CONTEXT.json as original-bytes read-only JSON in the same W runtime. Request the normal repair (blocked, repairs 8, to repair_ready, repairs 9) so the same W finishes S4 on the retained implementation under EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN_R03.txt, without reimplementation and without reducing the S4 deliverable. SPEC, TASK, the 6 conditions, eq/references, eq/registration, clarifications r01, r02 and r03 and all earlier plans are unchanged. Decided by Claude Opus 5.5 in the Desktop control session (message 346); not a CLI commander result."}

docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/DESKTOP_EQ_S4_RUN_DECISION_R03.json

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"action":"run","task_id":"P28-02-EQ","reason":"Use only after Root verifies through the normal gates: repair_ready, repairs 9, no S submitted, no active run, all 70 retained files present unchanged in the W (RETURN SHA a2c0d5ffd42b67ef340d5624dd299e294b867168bd1270933aec458a9cde1dc5), and the r09 ACTUAL_OPUS_TASK_CONTEXT.json placed read-only with its original bytes. Run repair 9 of P28-02-EQ once on the same W from base 2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988 with the single worker codex gpt-6-astra, finishing stage S4 on the retained implementation as defined in EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN_R03.txt, with EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN.txt and EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN_R02.txt still in force. Do not reimplement, re-audit or reduce S4 to a smaller deliverable. Remaining work, all in this one run: (1) fix the medium false PASS at run_eq.py:257 and verify_eq.py:144 to static = check.check_probe(...) and require(static['ok'], message with all errors), fix any other ignored check return in those two files the same way, and add rejection tests proving that both the driver and the verifier reject ok:false and accept ok:true; (2) add any remaining S4 tests; (3) update PROGRESS.md and IMPLEMENTATION.md to S4, with the requirement-to-code table covering every 'S4 must' item, the S4 binding requirements and the r02 corrections; (4) write S4_SUPPLEMENTARY.json by loading Root's read-only r09 ACTUAL_OPUS_TASK_CONTEXT.json, plus this r03 plan and decision as Root places them, without hand reconstruction, recording and checking the source and per-plan SHAs, and keep the earlier assert failure; (5) check fixes with targeted class runs, saving their raw, then run the full python3 -B test_eq.py once at the end over all 134 tests plus every test added in r03, starting with at least 300 seconds left. Attempt 05's 132 PASS covers that version only, so the final full PASS must include every later test. A further fix with related rechecks and one more full run is allowed if recorded. If time runs short, return a normal blocked status with all raw kept, and never claim an unproven PASS. (6) Submit the formal JSON with status exactly 'submitted' and commit 2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988, as local unit evidence only, not native, accepted S, Q measurement or product PASS. Keep the 119 earlier test bodies, all raw outputs and failures, every S4 r01 and r02 binding and raw recomputation, the 6 conditions and both validations. No engine, no run_eq.py --run, no trial formal validation, no git write, no product change, no full regression, and no API fallback. SPEC, TASK, eq/references and eq/registration stay unchanged. Ordinary implementation choices are recorded without stopping; block only for undecided matters affecting original product spec, values, permissions, billing or original acceptance. After submission: Root native on the exact S in 7 phases, the bundle at $BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR/p28-02-eq-evidence, both validations, a fresh independent Opus review of all 6 conditions, then the normal qualification, approval, integration and final, then the OPT and whole-unit gates. No original credit (23/88, 4/30); the 900-second timeout and permissions are unchanged. Quota fallback only on structured provider quota, once, same role, Antigravity claude-opus-5-5-high; any other failure is blocked. Decided by Claude Opus 5.5 in the Desktop control session (message 346); not a CLI commander result."}

docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S4_RETAINED_CONTINUATION_2549CF7.json

@@ -0,0 +1,89 @@
+{
+  "observed_at_jst": "2026-10-21T10:01:18.016348+09:00",
+  "plan_id": "P28-02",
+  "project": "the-tree-p28-02-eq",
+  "task": "P28-02-EQ",
+  "base": "2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988",
+  "state_at_observation": "implementing",
+  "repairs": 9,
+  "S": null,
+  "actual_run": {
+    "id": "92b50d1b750e42a5bde6c325dfa1dfc1",
+    "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+    "role": "implementer",
+    "service": "codex",
+    "status": "running",
+    "pid": 52772,
+    "started": 1792544334.2423732,
+    "finished": null,
+    "exit_code": null,
+    "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/92b50d1b750e42a5bde6c325dfa1dfc1"
+  },
+  "actual_process": "52772 52756 02:24 Ss   /Applications/ChatGPT.app/Contents/Resources/codex-cli/bin/../CodexCLI.app/Contents/MacOS/codex",
+  "root_exec_session": 34631,
+  "prior_provider_failure": {
+    "run_id": "20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe",
+    "exit_code": 124,
+    "retained_return": {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/retained-s4-20dc413-r01/RETURN.json",
+      "bytes": 60561,
+      "sha256": "a2c0d5ffd42b67ef340d5624dd299e294b867168bd1270933aec458a9cde1dc5"
+    },
+    "raw_unit_join": {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/ROOT_S4_TIMEOUT_JOIN_20DC413.json",
+      "bytes": 9703,
+      "sha256": "945fec6bcfa431d794ac74513219cce8eab8dccade517c6a6faeb391f86e05d7"
+    },
+    "late_unit06": {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/retained-s4-20dc413-late-unit06-r01/RETENTION.json",
+      "bytes": 2337,
+      "sha256": "90d817cb1c915d80081820666ac6231077d6b394c8ccd31075abba88bd9fef45"
+    },
+    "failure_not_promoted": true
+  },
+  "concrete_medium_finding": "run_eq.py and verify_eq.py ignored check_probe {ok,errors}; actual Opus348 requires both reject ok:false plus targeted rejection tests.",
+  "actual_Opus_session": "local_a7f85421-3eed-4482-8030-c0dca669573a",
+  "actual_Opus_response": 348,
+  "origin_note": "Actual decision bytes retain historical reason label message346; actual UI348 follows request347. No CLI-auth recovery or new human approval is claimed.",
+  "actual_Opus_materials": [
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN_R03.txt",
+      "bytes": 5501,
+      "sha256": "6c1ca5dbed18ddb355b285fa85e0d80fd83d7f56e2a79aac3d07664456bd7a63"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/DESKTOP_EQ_S4_REPAIR_DECISION_R03.json",
+      "bytes": 2061,
+      "sha256": "fa7e42eeb222c84b51119ec4b8ddd8649bc6ab504ad114ac72cb83f95db06f2a"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/DESKTOP_EQ_S4_RUN_DECISION_R03.json",
+      "bytes": 3398,
+      "sha256": "c854a9b0f232ecce9985bcf1988caba886e4b6b484631e00db1bc4d51a28098c"
+    }
+  ],
+  "normal_repair_job": "3e6dc5d9c0c34c71a6216d824c4f82cb",
+  "normal_RUN_record": {
+    "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/actual-desktop-EQ-S4-RUN-input-r10/RECORDED.json",
+    "bytes": 242,
+    "sha256": "2bb161a81c462a6c707b9988084f0e885ddbc7865cab0a80b42ebd63eef5527c"
+  },
+  "actual_start": {
+    "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/eq-staged-s4-owner-run-input-r10/RUN_STARTED.json",
+    "bytes": 854,
+    "sha256": "5a17d6154c236d3bc561ad9320acdfbb0737017ea49d8e7419ee328c42d16f22"
+  },
+  "all_original70_plus_exact2_late_files_preserved_before_launch": true,
+  "prior119_test_AST_bodies_unchanged": true,
+  "final_current_local_unit_status": "pending after medium fix; late134/OK lacks provider command exit receipt and is before the fix",
+  "all8_previous_full_plans_available_readonly": true,
+  "formal_EQ_accepted": false,
+  "all6_acceptance_pending": true,
+  "original_credit": 0,
+  "original_completed": 23,
+  "original_total": 88,
+  "packages_completed": 4,
+  "packages_total": 30,
+  "partial_credit": false,
+  "next": "Follow actual retained S4 run92b50d1b750e42a5bde6c325dfa1dfc1/PID52772/rootexec34631. Preserve terminal source/raw, join final exact-source local tests, then exact submitted S native7, both registered validations, fresh independent Opus all6, normal qualification/integration/final. Do not restart old timed-out20dc run or duplicate tests. Original P28-02 OPT/whole-unit remains."
+}

docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN_R03.txt

@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
+EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN r03（P28-02-EQ 段階 S4 の完了。EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN r01 と r02 は、全てそのまま有効。この r03 は、run 20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe（900秒の期限で exit 124）で保持された実装を引き継いで、正式な submitted まで閉じるための残りの作業だけを決める。S4 の範囲は小さくしない。SPEC、TASK、6条件、eq/references、eq/registration、補足 r01/r02/r03、全ての段階の計画は変更しない）
+
+0. 引き継ぐもの（再実装しない、再監査しない）
+- W の中の現在の70件のファイル（RootB/retained-s4-20dc413-r01、RETURN の SHA a2c0d5ffd42b67ef340d5624dd299e294b867168bd1270933aec458a9cde1dc5 と一致するもの）。実装済みの run_eq.py と verify_eq.py、現在の134件の試験。
+- 既存の119件の試験の本体と、全ての unit の生出力（S4 の attempt 01 の構文、02 の追加の unit、04 の recompute の不一致の失敗、S4_SUPPLEMENTARY の作成の assert の失敗を含む）。消さない、書き直さない。
+- attempt 05 の 132件の PASS（194.460秒、embedded exit 0）は、その版だけの事実。その後に2件が加わり、attempt 06 は出力なしで期限に達した。現在の134件の PASS は、まだ証明されていない。134件が通ったとは書かない。
+
+1. medium の修正（必須）
+- eq/run_eq.py:257 と eq/verify_eq.py:144 は、check.check_probe(...) の戻り値を捨てている。check_probe は例外ではなく {ok, errors} を返す（eq/check_eq.py:384）。
+- 両方の箇所を、static = check.check_probe(...) にして、require(static['ok'], <errors の全件を含む message>) で拒否するように直す。戻り値を使わない他の check の呼出しが無いかを、run_eq.py と verify_eq.py の中だけで確かめ、同じ形のものがあれば同じく直して記録する。
+- 拒否の試験を加える: check_probe が {ok: false, errors: [...]} を返すとき、run_eq.py の driver（--check と、--run の probe の検査の段階）と verify_eq.py の両方が拒否すること。ok: true のときに通ること。
+
+2. 残りの文書と context
+- PROGRESS.md と IMPLEMENTATION.md を S4 の内容に更新する（今は S3b の記述のまま）。r01 §0 の「S4 must」の要件と、末尾の S4 binding requirements の全ての項目について、満たしたコードと試験の対応表を書く。r02 の訂正（collector だけの読取専用の import、restart_pair を import しない、raw3 の正確な名前、exit を owned の受領から読む、check_report と check_lifecycle の引数、証拠の名前の一覧、validation の書込みの場所）を、どのコードで満たしたかも書く。
+- S4_SUPPLEMENTARY.json: plan の全文を手で再構築しない。Root が同じ W の runtime に、元の bytes の読取専用の JSON として置いた r09 の ACTUAL_OPUS_TASK_CONTEXT.json（RootB/eq-staged-s4-owner-run-input-r09/ACTUAL_OPUS_TASK_CONTEXT.json と同じ bytes。W の中の path は Root の packet が示す）を読み込み、その内容を変えずに、1つの key actual_commander_context として保存する。元のファイルの SHA と、各 plan の SHA が一致することを確かめて記録する。この r03 と RUN r03 は、Root がその後に追加で配置するものを、同じ方法で保存する。
+- 以前の手での再構築の assert の失敗は、失敗の記録として残す。
+
+3. 時間の配分（900秒の期限は変えない）
+- 全件の unit は約200秒かかる（attempt 05 で 194.460秒）。修正の確認は、関係する試験の class だけを指定した部分の実行（python3 -B test_eq.py <Class> ...）で行い、その生出力も保存する。
+- 全件の実行は、全ての修正と追加の後に、最後に1回だけ行う。開始は、期限まで少なくとも300秒が残っている時点までとする。不具合の修正が必要になった場合は、記録して、関係する部分の再確認と、もう1回の全件の実行を行ってよい。
+- 時間が足りない場合は、それまでの成果と生出力を残して、通常の blocked で返す。全件の PASS を推定で書かない。
+
+4. 最終の確認と提出
+- 最後の全件の実行は、134件 + この r03 で加えた試験の全て。全件 PASS の生出力と SHA と件数と時間を、UNIT_OUTPUT.txt と、新しい attempt のファイルに保存する。
+- 正式な JSON: status はちょうど "submitted"、commit は 2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988。局所の unit の証拠であり、native の実行・受け入れた S・Q での測定・製品の PASS とは表記しない。
+- worker は、engine の起動、run_eq.py --run の実行、正式の validation の試しの実行、git への書込み、製品の変更、全回帰をしない。API の fallback は使わない（設定のまま）。
+- 通常の実装上の判断は、記録して進める。
+
+5. 提出の後（worker の範囲の外。変更しない）
+- Root の正確な S の native の7つの phase → bundle の配置 → 両方の validation → fresh の独立した Opus による6条件の全てのレビュー → 通常の資格・承認・integration・final → OPT と whole-unit。
+- 原本の 23/88・4/30 への加算は0。原本の条件・課金・権限・900秒は変えない。