From e10005b1edc3d3eac9cc26c01135d9f8bfedf80f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Takeshi Date: Wed, 14 Oct 2026 04:09:29 +0900 Subject: [PATCH] Record passing P08 writer and strict full-state save/load effect repair --- .../ACTUAL_OPUS_R02_OPERATION_REPAIR.json | 7 ++ .../p08-03/ACTUAL_OPUS_R02_OPERATION_RUN.json | 7 ++ .../execution/p08-03/CURRENT_EXECUTION.json | 26 +++-- .../NATIVE_R02_READER_OPERATION_DELTA.json | 102 ++++++++++++++++++ 4 files changed, 134 insertions(+), 8 deletions(-) create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/ACTUAL_OPUS_R02_OPERATION_REPAIR.json create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/ACTUAL_OPUS_R02_OPERATION_RUN.json create mode 100644 docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/NATIVE_R02_READER_OPERATION_DELTA.json diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/ACTUAL_OPUS_R02_OPERATION_REPAIR.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/ACTUAL_OPUS_R02_OPERATION_REPAIR.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7ce9b55 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/ACTUAL_OPUS_R02_OPERATION_REPAIR.json @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +{ + "action": "request-repair", + "task_id": "P08-03", + "reason": "判断: request-repair。不具合はoracle側で、製品側ではない。tests/fixtures/p08-03/placement.gd:249 は writer-checkpoint.var(保存直後のsnapshot)と reader の create_snapshot()(読込直後)を全バイト一致で比較している。しかし既存 Runtime の仕様では、保存成功時に SAVE_CHECKPOINT_SUCCEEDED を発行し(simulation_runtime.gd:4621→4680)、メニュー読込は recovery 経路で成功時に SAVE_RECOVERY_LOADED を発行する(4386)。payload は _save_event_payload(4691) が実際の戻りdictから作る。このため、両側に1件ずつ種類の違う通知が source-defined に必ず追加され、全バイト一致は原理的に成立しない。NATIVE_R02_READER_OPERATION_DELTA.json の結果も、差分は recent_events[161] の event_type/payload だけで、formal→post の差分も id_generator.counters.domain_event / published_ids / recent_events の3箇所だけだった。原 spec separate_pid_resume が求めるのは、保存時の対象セル/施設ID/占有/判定の保全であり、別種の完了通知を同一バイトにすることではない。したがって検証修正は原 spec に忠実で、基準緩和にはあたらない。\n\n厳密な修正指示(変更してよいのは fixture/checker/meaningful tests/docs のみ。UI/collector/Runtime/SaveService/Schema/原30/88/5条件/過去raw/過去PASSは変更しない):\n(1) Writer: 実際の ManualSaveButton 操作の直前に、正式保存対象の snapshot(161 events)を全文rawで保存する。続けて、実保存後の post-save snapshot(162)と、save_operation_completed で受け取った実戻りdictを全文rawで保存する。既存の writer-checkpoint.var は変更も削除もしない。\n(2) Reader: 実際の load menu 後の post-load snapshot(162)と、実戻りdictを全文rawで保存する。戻りdictの recovery_report.selected_candidate_id と restore_committed から、formal primary(writer が保存した正式 world.bin)が選ばれたことを確認する。fallback や旧候補が選ばれた場合は拒否する。\n(3) 保存モデルの照合: 正式 world.bin を、実 SaveService の通常読込経路で fixture 内から読み取り専用でデコードする。得たモデルを writer の pre-save formal snapshot と、時刻/財布/Actor/占有/施設ID/判定/IDカウンタを含めて全state完全一致で照合する。MEMBERS の SHA 照合も維持する。\n(4) 操作差分の照合: formal→post-save と formal→post-load のそれぞれについて、許す差分は次の3点の正確な1回増分だけとし、それ以外のすべてのパスの差分を拒否する。\n - counters.domain_event がちょうど +1\n - published_ids が末尾に新ID1件だけ追加\n - recent_events が元の161件をバイト一致で保ったまま末尾に1件だけ追加\n 追加イベントについては次を検証する。\n - event_id が新ID と一致\n - event_type は実際に通った経路の source 定義値に一致すること(実戻りdictの operation から導出する。save なら SAVE_CHECKPOINT_SUCCEEDED、recovery なら SAVE_RECOVERY_LOADED)\n - source=save_service、entity_ids=[]\n - causation と minute が Runtime の発行規則どおり\n - payload の全fieldを、実戻りdictから _save_event_payload と同じ射影で再計算して一致すること\n 通知の削除・マスク・読み飛ばし・snapshotの捏造は禁止。\n(5) Checker と tools/test_p08_normal_placement_evidence.py: Python 側でも raw から上記の全判定を再計算する。全boolean自己申告は不可。正例1件に加え、少なくとも次の負例をそれぞれ拒否することを確認する。\n - 追加の欠落、重複、余分な通知\n - event_type の取違え\n - payload の改ざん、または payload field の欠落\n - counter drift(0/+2)\n - published_ids の不一致\n - 元161件中の改ざん\n - 時刻/財布/Actor/占有/施設IDの変更\n - formal 以外の recovery 候補の選択\n - stale source/input SHA\n(6) docs: CONDITION_MATRIX.md と implementation.json に、最終実行時の全実源/input SHA、実行した純Python局所テストだけを honest に記録する。旧r01/r02 の履歴は保持する。\nworker は Godot/native/OS/全回帰を実行せず、genuine submitted で返す。その後 Root が native → OS → 全回帰 → 独立Opusレビュー → 統合 を行う。", + "codex_model": "gpt-6.1-sol", + "codex_model_reason": "原因は特定済みで、変更範囲は fixture/checker/test/docs に限られ、製品コードには触れない。必要な判定(全state照合、3パスの正確な+1増分、_save_event_payload 射影の再計算、負例群)は手順として明示できており、新たな設計探索は要らない。これまでの修理も Sol の範囲で進んでおり、Astra の追加コストと時間に見合う難度ではない。" +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/ACTUAL_OPUS_R02_OPERATION_RUN.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/ACTUAL_OPUS_R02_OPERATION_RUN.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..633b886 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/ACTUAL_OPUS_R02_OPERATION_RUN.json @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +{ + "action": "run", + "task_id": "P08-03", + "reason": "State is repair_ready and the owner has explicitly asked for a real run of the repair already dispatched. Both evidence files from the worktree are present: NATIVE_R02_READER_OPERATION_DELTA.json and native-r02-reader-stderr.log. The repair stays inside allowed_paths and only touches fixtures, checker, tests and docs. The original spec, the 30/88 count, the 5 conditions, Runtime, SaveService, UI and the collector stay unchanged. Keep the submitted c2b59f04 work. Compare the full model at three points: what the writer saves just before the real save, what world.bin decodes to read-only through the normal API, and the snapshot the reader returns after loading. Keep all postsave and postload raw output, and leave writer-checkpoint.var unchanged. Rebuild the complete expected post-operation state from the saved state, with exactly one source_defined notification and exact idcounter/publishedids increments, and compare every field. Recompute the notification payload from the actual returned dict using the rules in source lines 4680-4720. Reject every other kind of drift. The counts 161/162 come from the observed trace and must not be hardcoded. Save the raw data for any new unknown difference and record it with specific evidence. Do not drop fields or convert Runtime side effects. Run pure Python only: the existing 35 tests plus new semantic negative tests, then sync source/input SHAs and docs and return a genuine submitted. Native/OS collection, the final full regression, independent Opus review and integration are still pending, so this is not acceptance. No cap; normal timeout 900 s, task-only 1800 s, no adapter; no searching production R.", + "codex_model": "gpt-6.1-sol", + "codex_model_reason": "The owner asked for the same Sol model, and the work is bounded: pure-Python checker, fixture and test changes driven by concrete raw evidence that is already provided. No native or Godot work and no cross-module redesign are needed, so Astra's extra quality is not worth its extra time and usage." +} diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/CURRENT_EXECUTION.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/CURRENT_EXECUTION.json index 743030e..fde9604 100644 --- a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/CURRENT_EXECUTION.json +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/CURRENT_EXECUTION.json @@ -23,7 +23,7 @@ "scope_relationship": "RP24 bounded-shell acceptance is independent; not a dependency of Codex functional implementation" }, "Claude_auth": "existing native subscription client automatically renewed; actual authenticated request success, no user login wait or API fallback", - "P08_03_next": "Same Sol fixture repair restarted only after terminal exit and actual Opus verified readable QA documents; no past return-dict fabrication", + "P08_03_next": "Same existing worktree performs actual Opus-approved complete saved-model and operation-effect oracle repair; no acceptance credit yet", "current_game_sources_changed": false, "permission_request": "still pending and not applied; independent source work does not require marker command", "UI_worker_method": "Codex functional implementation selected by actual Opus; Antigravity read-only visual review", @@ -65,18 +65,20 @@ }, "actual_native_run": { "state": "terminal_failed", - "session": 86040, + "session": 85807, "owned_children_ended": true, - "source": "7dd450c64c897fc8e9e6bbd9fa242f28f42cb1af", + "source": "c2b59f04f94dda0a61991ec3bb7f0e946196f995", "passed_phases": [ "import", - "parse" + "parse", + "writer" ], - "failed_phase": "writer", + "failed_phase": "reader", + "assert_failures": 1, "OS_started": false }, "native_fixture_repair": { - "state": "implementing", + "state": "terminal_submitted", "model": "gpt-6.1-sol", "repairs": 3, "max_repair_attempts": null, @@ -85,8 +87,16 @@ "previous_terminal_run": "21dfe2addb5847ed81060b1a302215d5", "handoff_corrected": true, "run": "94c75821a550487189054f0d0d47bbf7", - "pid": 53523, + "pid": null, "session": 93723, - "actual_fixture_diff_files": 2 + "actual_fixture_diff_files": 2, + "submitted": "c2b59f04f94dda0a61991ec3bb7f0e946196f995" + }, + "operation_oracle_repair": { + "state": "dispatch_started", + "model": "gpt-6.1-sol", + "repairs": 4, + "individual_limit": null, + "scope": "complete saved state + exact source-defined save/load effects; raw fields/events retained, no Runtime/UI/collector/spec changes" } } diff --git a/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/NATIVE_R02_READER_OPERATION_DELTA.json b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/NATIVE_R02_READER_OPERATION_DELTA.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d4e5bfb --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/NATIVE_R02_READER_OPERATION_DELTA.json @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +{ + "unit": "P08-03", + "submitted": "c2b59f04f94dda0a61991ec3bb7f0e946196f995", + "native_phases": { + "import": { + "pid": 58251, + "passed": true + }, + "parse": { + "pid": 58353, + "passed": true + }, + "writer": { + "pid": 58388, + "passed": true + }, + "reader": { + "pid": 58430, + "passed": false, + "failure": "whole formal resume model", + "failures": 1 + } + }, + "all_owned_ended": true, + "cleanup_errors": [], + "no_OS_started": true, + "no_full_regression": true, + "whole_typed_writer_reader_diff": [ + [ + "systems", + "runtime", + "domain_events", + "recent_events", + "161", + "event_type" + ], + [ + "systems", + "runtime", + "domain_events", + "recent_events", + "161", + "payload" + ] + ], + "writer_last_event": "SAVE_CHECKPOINT_SUCCEEDED", + "reader_last_event": "SAVE_RECOVERY_LOADED", + "formal_event_count": 161, + "post_operation_event_count": 162, + "formal_to_post_differences": { + "formal_to_post_operation_differences": { + "writer": [ + [ + "systems", + "runtime", + "id_generator", + "counters", + "domain_event" + ], + [ + "systems", + "runtime", + "domain_events", + "published_ids" + ], + [ + "systems", + "runtime", + "domain_events", + "recent_events" + ] + ], + "reader": [ + [ + "systems", + "runtime", + "id_generator", + "counters", + "domain_event" + ], + [ + "systems", + "runtime", + "domain_events", + "published_ids" + ], + [ + "systems", + "runtime", + "domain_events", + "recent_events" + ] + ] + } + }, + "existing_source_contract": "Runtime._complete_save_operation/_save_event_payload publishes the corresponding operation notification before save_operation_completed signal", + "diagnosis": "Whole post-save vs post-load raw-equality oracle contradicts distinct existing save/load notifications; all other typed fields match. Formal saved state must be compared fully, and exact operation effects must be verified without deleting/masking events. Not yet an acceptance or a product-defect conclusion.", + "required_fix_judgment": "Actual Opus must choose faithful saved-model + complete post-operation delta evidence; preserve all raw states/events/counters, no Runtime edits or criterion relaxation", + "registered_history": "old r01 preserved as historical-native-r01-7dd450c6; original published artifacts unchanged", + "acceptance_credit": 0, + "updated_utc": "2026-10-13T19:05:00.421862+00:00" +}