Preserve EQ ownership evidence and final submission-stage contract

2026-10-21 09:40:14 +09:00
parent f3840c9637
commit e758d6873a
11 changed files with 858 additions and 81 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"action":"request-repair","task_id":"P28-02-EQ","reason":"Stage S3b r02 run c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4 (worker PID 34943 exit 0 after 710.903 s, Root exec 18378 exit 2) ended at the planned checkpoint: formal status blocked with the low finding 'stage S3b complete, next S4'. This is a staged checkpoint, not a failure; all 6 conditions remain pending. State: blocked, repairs 7, no S, no active run. Root preserved 58 files and 6 raw files at retained-s3b-c056b92-r01/RETURN.json SHA 251752724519d048db99c84824e38d5d738e38b64f116dd7a6f52242377eb467 and joined the 9 unit attempts at ROOT_S3B_LOCAL_JOIN_C056B92.json SHA 5e3e67d306d4d0ef067754855df7664bfeb0e804f23f1224435e16665ff46a61, with counts [91,null,114,114,114,118,1,119,119] and exits [0,1,1,0,0,0,1,1,0]. The syntax, digest, dictionary-order and fixture failures of attempts 02, 03, 07 and 08 are kept. The final run passed 119 tests in 32.034 s, output SHA 8360a2065b303099d5c546b3e4aecc0cc0ab0c2c1e5120b8034b6a1a64317030. All 91 earlier test bodies are unchanged by AST and 28 were added. Frozen materials, earlier raw and supplements are unchanged, tracked product source is unchanged, and every change is inside eq/. A limited independent read-only check found no concrete high or medium false PASS and no immediate native API mismatch. The compare_versions digest exception is bound only to the enumerated E5 outside-in operation point with the full proof, aliasing is kept as an existing defect, and E4 uses the real registry with full preview records. That check is not the formal fresh Opus review. Root also fixed the frozen dependency API notes at S4_FROZEN_DEPENDENCY_API_NOTES_R01.json SHA 682a0d9a04978411691e9a8291b46a9ddc6eeb621d38c0f699a756e47be0084b. Request the normal repair (blocked, repairs 7, to repair_ready, repairs 8) so the same W continues with the final stage S4 under EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN.txt. SPEC, TASK, the 6 conditions, eq/references, eq/registration, clarifications r01, r02 and r03, and the staged, S3 and S3b plans are unchanged; the earlier 7da027a plan error stays recorded. Decided by Claude Opus 5.5 in the Desktop control session (message 340); not a CLI commander result."}
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"action":"run","task_id":"P28-02-EQ","reason":"Use only after Root verifies through the normal gates: repair_ready, repairs 8, no S submitted, no active run, and all 58 current S1 to S3b files still present unchanged in the W. Run repair 8 of P28-02-EQ once on the same W from base 2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988 with the single worker codex gpt-6-astra, doing only the final stage S4 as defined in EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN.txt. Deliver EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN.txt in full as part of the one supplementary key, together with both S3b plans, both S3 plans, both staged plans, S4_FROZEN_DEPENDENCY_API_NOTES_R01.json and this decision; clarifications r01, r02 and r03 stay read-only in build/eq-staged-readonly-r04. Start by reading eq/PROGRESS.md and eq/IMPLEMENTATION.md, list every existing 'S4 must' requirement and the closing S4 binding requirements, and reuse the existing code and schemas (join_report, check_report, check_observation, check_lifecycle, strict_json, compare_reports) without redesign. S4 scope: (1) eq/run_eq.py with an engine-free --check and a --run over the 7 phases import, parse-base, parse-wrapper, R-A, R-B, O-A and O-B, using the read-only collector API as frozen. run_private_engine takes the original project.godot bytes as public, the startup profile name as name and a not-yet-created folder. guard_gate takes the runtime profile name. Gates return None or raise and are never treated as bool. inputs(readonly) checks the original manifest and its 9 original destinations, never a copied root. An empty profile_files result is never proof. (2) After each owned process ends, copy and hash every private evidence file (report, lifecycle with measurement, e3, e3_b1 and e45, audio-close, events, observation, e3-00 to e3-17, e45-00 to e45-20 and package evidence), using strict_json. Call check_observation, check_lifecycle and check_report with lifecycle.e45, require 39 scenarios (18 E3 plus 21 E4/E5), call join_report before compare_reports, and keep raw, joined, join_facts sidecars, proofs and checker outcomes separate with SHAs. Compare R-A against R-B and O-A against O-B separately, requiring zero difference. Keep existing defects, including aliasing, as defects. (3) Bind raw3, owned5, actual PID start and end, strict diagnostics, guard, role to phase to PID, the full 1407-file source map and all pins (fixture, engine, source map, machine, EQ files, project, settings, marker, policy). Keep the finally cleanup with 0 remaining. Write the manifest and the seal last, only on full success, and label the result S_eq native, not Q measurement. On failure, keep raw, build no bundle and exit nonzero. (4) eq/verify_eq.py reads $BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR/p28-02-eq-evidence, fails when it is absent, recomputes every check from raw and binds the pins to the actual files. (5) Add bundle normal and rejection unit tests as listed in the plan, keeping all 119 test bodies and the full failure history except fixes a failing test requires. Run the engine-free python3 -B test_eq.py until every test passes, save every raw output with SHAs, update PROGRESS.md and IMPLEMENTATION.md with the requirement-to-code table, and submit formally as local unit evidence only, not native, accepted S, Q measurement or product PASS. Do not trial-run either formal validation or run_eq.py --run to make them fail; the bundle is joined once after the real native. No engine, no git write or commit, no product change, no full regression; the Runner commits and gates normally. SPEC, TASK, eq/references and eq/registration stay unchanged. Ordinary implementation choices are recorded without stopping; block only for undecided matters affecting original product spec, values, permissions, billing or original acceptance. The remaining order after submission: Root native on the exact S in 7 phases, the bundle placed at $BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR/p28-02-eq-evidence, both validations (p28-02-eq-unit, p28-02-eq-native-verify), a fresh independent Opus review of all 6 conditions, then the normal prepare, candidate qualification, approval, integration and final, then the OPT and whole-unit gates. No original credit (23/88, 4/30); the 900-second timeout is unchanged. Quota fallback only on structured provider quota, once, same role, Antigravity claude-opus-5-5-high; any other failure is blocked. Decided by Claude Opus 5.5 in the Desktop control session (message 340); not a CLI commander result."}
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"action":"run","task_id":"P28-02-EQ","reason":"Supersedes DESKTOP_EQ_S4_RUN_DECISION.json, which was never dispatched and is kept unchanged as history. DESKTOP_EQ_S4_REPAIR_DECISION.json stays valid and usable as written: its facts (the S3b r02 checkpoint, the retained evidence and the S4 continuation) are unchanged by this correction. Use only after Root verifies through the normal gates: repair_ready, repairs 8, no S submitted, no active run, and all 58 current S1 to S3b files still present unchanged in the W. Run repair 8 of P28-02-EQ once on the same W from base 2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988 with the single worker codex gpt-6-astra, doing the whole final stage S4 as defined in EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN.txt and corrected by EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN_R02.txt: run_eq.py, verify_eq.py, bundle normal and rejection unit tests, full local PASS and the formal submission, in this one run, with no reduction to a smaller deliverable. Deliver both S4 plans in full as part of the one supplementary key, together with both S3b plans, both S3 plans, both staged plans, S4_FROZEN_DEPENDENCY_API_NOTES_R01.json and this decision; clarifications r01, r02 and r03 stay read-only in build/eq-staged-readonly-r04. The r02 corrections are as follows. Import the collector read-only inside the frozen SPEC §1 closure only; restart_pair.py belongs to the RESTART task, is not imported, and copy_states is read as reference only. EQ implements its own evidence copy and inventory in eq/ and rejects out-of-closure imports. raw3 is the collector's actual stdout.log, stderr.log and engine-native.log (collect_p28_01.py:217,225). The exit code is read from the owned receipts (for example process.json), never from raw3, and engine-native.log is required. Call check_report(raw, measurement, e3_evidence, b1_record, e45_evidence) with lifecycle.measurement, e3, e3_b1 and e45, and call check_lifecycle(raw, lifecycle, guard). The exact evidence names are checkpoint-00..30, observation-00..30, e3-00..17, e45-00..20, events, report, lifecycle and audio-close, all .json, plus the existing package evidence. The final worker JSON status must be exactly 'submitted' (core.py:1015), not pass or blocked, with commit set to the base. The worker writes no git, and Runner.submit commits normally. Formal validation runs with a read-only checkout (core.py:1064 writable=()) and BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR assigned to the runtime build area (core.py:827), so bundle-synthesis unit tests write only under that BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR or tempfile.gettempdir(), and verify_eq.py only reads. Nothing writes into the source tree, and environment and permissions are unchanged. Everything else in S4 r01 is unchanged: all S4 bindings, raw recomputation in verify, the 7 phases, pins and the 1407-file source map, seal only on success, the S_eq-native-not-Q label, all 119 test bodies and the full failure history, raw outputs with SHAs, and PROGRESS and IMPLEMENTATION updates. No engine, no run_eq.py --run, no trial formal validation, no git write, no product change, no full regression; SPEC, TASK, eq/references and eq/registration stay unchanged. Ordinary implementation choices are recorded without stopping; block only for undecided matters affecting original product spec, values, permissions, billing or original acceptance. After submission: Root native on the exact S in 7 phases, the bundle placed at $BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR/p28-02-eq-evidence, both validations, a fresh independent Opus review of all 6 conditions, then the normal prepare, candidate qualification, approval, integration and final, then the OPT and whole-unit gates. No original credit (23/88, 4/30); the 900-second timeout is unchanged. Quota fallback only on structured provider quota, once, same role, Antigravity claude-opus-5-5-high; any other failure is blocked. Decided by Claude Opus 5.5 in the Desktop control session (message 342); not a CLI commander result."}
@@ -0,0 +1,228 @@
+{
+  "at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:38:56.381555+09:00",
+  "plan_id": "P28-02",
+  "project": "the-tree-p28-02-eq",
+  "task": "P28-02-EQ",
+  "base": "2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988",
+  "stage": "S3b local evidence only",
+  "retained_return": {
+    "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/retained-s3b-c056b92-r01/RETURN.json",
+    "bytes": 51751,
+    "sha256": "251752724519d048db99c84824e38d5d738e38b64f116dd7a6f52242377eb467"
+  },
+  "root_raw_unit_join": {
+    "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/ROOT_S3B_LOCAL_JOIN_C056B92.json",
+    "bytes": 7250,
+    "sha256": "5e3e67d306d4d0ef067754855df7664bfeb0e804f23f1224435e16665ff46a61"
+  },
+  "local_unit": {
+    "at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:28:08.888885+09:00",
+    "stage": "S3b",
+    "actual_run": "c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4",
+    "retained_return_sha256": "251752724519d048db99c84824e38d5d738e38b64f116dd7a6f52242377eb467",
+    "unit_output_sha256": "8360a2065b303099d5c546b3e4aecc0cc0ab0c2c1e5120b8034b6a1a64317030",
+    "final_unit_checks": 119,
+    "actual_unit_counts": [
+      91,
+      null,
+      114,
+      114,
+      114,
+      118,
+      1,
+      119,
+      119
+    ],
+    "embedded_test_exit_codes": [
+      0,
+      1,
+      1,
+      0,
+      0,
+      0,
+      1,
+      1,
+      0
+    ],
+    "failed_attempts_preserved": [
+      2,
+      3,
+      7,
+      8
+    ],
+    "unit_output_provenance": [
+      {
+        "attempt": 1,
+        "full_output_sha256": "c89f4f1ca1ea9b985079cd236ffff4193fa5c76d9bfa28fa65ac08cfc93b569c",
+        "full_output_bytes": 5810,
+        "tests_ran": 91,
+        "embedded_subprocess_exit": 0,
+        "printed_projection": "full",
+        "projection_exact": true,
+        "full_subprocess_stdout_captured_and_SHA_preserved": true
+      },
+      {
+        "attempt": 2,
+        "full_output_sha256": "7bd19a6a3c84385f754261d51779f05b6e39c116459086d5aad3a83afa7225c0",
+        "full_output_bytes": 375,
+        "tests_ran": null,
+        "embedded_subprocess_exit": 1,
+        "printed_projection": "full",
+        "projection_exact": true,
+        "full_subprocess_stdout_captured_and_SHA_preserved": true
+      },
+      {
+        "attempt": 3,
+        "full_output_sha256": "0872061bbc2c1403d2cd04877b8456f3fead35236be008b1a07f02ae5d85b11a",
+        "full_output_bytes": 30717,
+        "tests_ran": 114,
+        "embedded_subprocess_exit": 1,
+        "printed_projection": "last 11000 characters",
+        "projection_exact": true,
+        "full_subprocess_stdout_captured_and_SHA_preserved": true
+      },
+      {
+        "attempt": 4,
+        "full_output_sha256": "63204c3415c9b1719fa6aa596b714077a57f530896f979d12b89a15eb2d827e9",
+        "full_output_bytes": 6983,
+        "tests_ran": 114,
+        "embedded_subprocess_exit": 0,
+        "printed_projection": "last 3500 characters",
+        "projection_exact": true,
+        "full_subprocess_stdout_captured_and_SHA_preserved": true
+      },
+      {
+        "attempt": 5,
+        "full_output_sha256": "bfcb263bf6d7f284fb2b20ee229d96b7c4a9bd7cd5e7b513df1d3ea32580ed6e",
+        "full_output_bytes": 6983,
+        "tests_ran": 114,
+        "embedded_subprocess_exit": 0,
+        "printed_projection": "last 2000 characters",
+        "projection_exact": true,
+        "full_subprocess_stdout_captured_and_SHA_preserved": true
+      },
+      {
+        "attempt": 6,
+        "full_output_sha256": "7d9bf9c602a93aca06d03eb06025beeea35603d453e293c07e7a6f81ca9ca000",
+        "full_output_bytes": 7223,
+        "tests_ran": 118,
+        "embedded_subprocess_exit": 0,
+        "printed_projection": "last 3000 characters",
+        "projection_exact": true,
+        "full_subprocess_stdout_captured_and_SHA_preserved": true
+      },
+      {
+        "attempt": 7,
+        "full_output_sha256": "f7c7c045ea98a366810b7c309fc1a87a77ccc5d8e823750eebaa742c9529e2ca",
+        "full_output_bytes": 963,
+        "tests_ran": 1,
+        "embedded_subprocess_exit": 1,
+        "printed_projection": "full",
+        "projection_exact": true,
+        "full_subprocess_stdout_captured_and_SHA_preserved": true
+      },
+      {
+        "attempt": 8,
+        "full_output_sha256": "19c3f115d6a73bf91413877878f5d5f9d78a3e253dae3ddba7dfec9b5d46eaba",
+        "full_output_bytes": 7879,
+        "tests_ran": 119,
+        "embedded_subprocess_exit": 1,
+        "printed_projection": "last 2000 characters",
+        "projection_exact": true,
+        "full_subprocess_stdout_captured_and_SHA_preserved": true
+      },
+      {
+        "attempt": 9,
+        "full_output_sha256": "8360a2065b303099d5c546b3e4aecc0cc0ab0c2c1e5120b8034b6a1a64317030",
+        "full_output_bytes": 7291,
+        "tests_ran": 119,
+        "embedded_subprocess_exit": 0,
+        "printed_projection": "last 2000 characters",
+        "projection_exact": true,
+        "full_subprocess_stdout_captured_and_SHA_preserved": true
+      }
+    ],
+    "all91_prior_test_AST_bodies_preserved": true,
+    "additional_test_methods": [
+      "test_E5_cached_digest_defect_is_comparable",
+      "test_NA_not_PASS",
+      "test_aliasing_cannot_be_PASS",
+      "test_aliasing_missing_record",
+      "test_all_paths_and_ownership_R_O",
+      "test_digest_defect_other_checkpoint_still_rejected",
+      "test_digest_materialization_required",
+      "test_empty_registry_not_NA",
+      "test_event_count_mismatch",
+      "test_facts_normalization_is_reversible",
+      "test_first_placeable_choice",
+      "test_interval_gap",
+      "test_joined_s3b_self_comparison",
+      "test_load_X_not_digest_only",
+      "test_load_extra_event",
+      "test_missing_path_and_combination",
+      "test_missing_preview_observation",
+      "test_missing_trial",
+      "test_nested_mutation_required",
+      "test_no_staleness_assertion_for_non_tick",
+      "test_ownership_fact_dictionary_order_fallback",
+      "test_path_order",
+      "test_restore_extra_event",
+      "test_signal_facts_cannot_be_dropped",
+      "test_sort_rule_rejected",
+      "test_static_handler_and_outside_mutations",
+      "test_unpreviewed_choice",
+      "test_wrong_registry_in_either_role"
+    ],
+    "prior_S3a_output_preserved": true,
+    "frozen_and_historical_files_unchanged": [
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S3A_ATTEMPT_02.sha256",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_ATTEMPT_01.sha256",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S3A_ATTEMPT_04.txt",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S2_ATTEMPT_03.sha256",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S3A_ATTEMPT_01.txt",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S2_ATTEMPT_01.sha256",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S3A_ATTEMPT_02.txt",
+      "S2_SUPPLEMENTARY.json",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S3A_ATTEMPT_03.txt",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S3A_ATTEMPT_04.sha256",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S2_ATTEMPT_02.sha256",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S3A_ATTEMPT_03.sha256",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_ATTEMPT_02.sha256",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S3A_ATTEMPT_01.sha256",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S1_FINAL.sha256",
+      "S3A_SUPPLEMENTARY.json",
+      "SPEC.md",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S2_ATTEMPT_03.txt",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S2_ATTEMPT_02.txt",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S2_ATTEMPT_01.txt",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_ATTEMPT_02.txt",
+      "TASK_INSTRUCTIONS.md",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_ATTEMPT_01.txt",
+      "UNIT_OUTPUT_S1_FINAL.txt",
+      "registration/CONFIG_PROPOSAL.json",
+      "registration/ACCEPTANCE_BASELINE.json",
+      "registration/ROOT_PROPOSAL_BYTE_TRANSFER.json",
+      "registration/REGISTRATION_PROPOSAL.json",
+      "references/OPUS_D2_SCOPE_CLARIFICATION.txt",
+      "references/OPUS_STARTUP_LIFECYCLE_CLARIFICATION.txt",
+      "references/OPT_CONTRACT_T1.md"
+    ],
+    "all_tracked_source_unchanged": true,
+    "all_changes_in_allowed_scope": true,
+    "actual_required_full_plans_and_RUN_preserved": true,
+    "actual_readonly_clarification_paths_and_SHAs_preserved": true,
+    "narrow_readonly_source_check": "No concrete high/medium false PASS or immediate native API blocker found. E5 digest exception is only named outside_in interval checkpoint2 with full ownership evidence; usual checkpoints/E3/E4/inside_out keep self-consistency. E4 all5 and E5 all4x2x2 complete in source. No tests, checker or engine run by helper; not formal independent Opus all6 review.",
+    "formal_EQ_accepted": false,
+    "all6_acceptance_pending": true,
+    "original_credit": 0,
+    "next": "Actual Desktop Opus S4 driver/verify and formal S submission judgment; then exact native7/both validations/fresh independent Opus all6/normal final. Original P28-02 OPT and whole-unit gates remain."
+  },
+  "formal_EQ_accepted": false,
+  "all6_registered_acceptance_pending": true,
+  "original_credit": 0,
+  "remaining": [
+    "S4 driver/verifier, synthetic bundle tests and normal formal S submission",
+    "Exact S native7, both validations, fresh independent Opus all6, normal candidate qualification/integration/final",
+    "Original P28-02 T1 optimization, same-condition repeated comparison, RESTART, exact final roster and whole-unit cross-cutting6/final"
+  ]
+}
@@ -0,0 +1,85 @@
+EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN（P28-02-EQ 段階 S4。最後の段階。EQ_STAGED_IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN r01/r02 の S4 を、実際の API と S1〜S3b の結合の要件に合わせて具体化する。SPEC、TASK、6条件、eq/references、eq/registration、補足 r01/r02/r03、段階の計画 r01/r02、S3 の計画 r01/r02、S3b の計画 r01/r02 は変更しない）
+
+0. 共通
+- 最初に eq/PROGRESS.md と eq/IMPLEMENTATION.md を読む。特に、S2 と S3a の「S4 must ...」の全ての箇条と、末尾の「S4 binding requirements」を、S4 の要件の一覧として最初に書き出し、各要件をどのコードと試験で満たしたかを IMPLEMENTATION.md に対応表で記録する。
+- S1〜S3b の型・path・record schema・API・コード（check_eq.join_report、check_report、check_observation、check_lifecycle、strict_json、compare_versions.compare_reports など）を、そのまま使う。再設計しない。S4 が新しく作るのは eq/run_eq.py と eq/verify_eq.py と、その試験。
+- 既存の119件の試験の本体、全ての失敗の履歴（S3b の attempt 02/03/07/08 を含む）、旧 run 7da027a の指示の誤りの記録は、消さない。書き直さない（失敗した試験が求める修正を除く）。
+- 凍結した依存の API は、RootB/S4_FROZEN_DEPENDENCY_API_NOTES_R01.json（SHA 682a0d9a04978411691e9a8291b46a9ddc6eeb621d38c0f699a756e47be0084b）の要約に従う。collector（execution/p28-01/collector/collect_p28_01.py、SHA a43e1f96…）と restart_pair.py（SHA 538302ee…）は、読取専用で import して使う。複製や書き換えはしない。
+
+1. eq/run_eq.py（Root が実行する driver。SPEC §2 の argv のまま）
+1.1 --check（engine を起動しない）
+- 引数と pin を検証して、実行の計画（7つの phase の argv、環境変数、出力の path、profile の名前）を JSON で出す。process は起動しない。
+- 検証する pin: fixture の SHA（eb4f7700…）、engine の SHA（c7cccbf8…）、製品の source map の SHA（651f7036…、1407件の全ての相対 path・bytes・SHA を source_map(standard, root) で取る。件数だけにしない）、machine、EQ のファイル（6つ）の SHA、project.godot の元の bytes の SHA、設定・marker・policy の SHA。
+- inputs(readonly) で、元の manifest の SHA と、元の絶対の destination の9件を検証する。複製した manifest の root で代用しない。
+- --output の dir が既に存在すれば拒否する（上書きしない）。
+
+1.2 --run の phase（この順序で、それぞれ1回）
+- import: argv_for(engine, stage, wrapper, importing=True)。stage_gate(before, after, importing=True)。
+- parse-base、parse-wrapper: parse_argv(engine, stage, target) の --check-only。stage_gate(before, after)。
+- R-A、R-B、O-A、O-B: S1〜S3b で決まった R と O の起動の規則で、測定の wrapper を headless で起動する。
+- 各 phase は run_private_engine(standard, outer, command, folder, environment, stage, public, name) で行う。public は project.godot の元の bytes、name は startup の profile の名前、folder は未作成の新しい dir。戻り値の owned row の全体を記録する。
+- guard: parent の initialize の前に有効になること。startup と runtime の profile は、phase ごとに新しく一意の名前にする。環境変数 THE_TREE_PACK_PROFILE_NAME / EXPECTED / REPORT と、role（R/O）、fixture の path と SHA を結びつける。guard_gate(value, runtime: Path, name) の name は runtime の profile の名前。
+- stage_gate と guard_gate は、成功で None、失敗で例外。戻り値を bool として扱わない（試験で拒否する）。
+- profile_files(directory) は、存在しない dir で空の dict を返すが、それを fresh であることや、証拠の保存の成功の証明にしない。fresh であることは guard の受領で、保存の成功は下の 1.3 の複製と inventory で証明する。
+- 各 phase で、collector の raw3（stdout、stderr、exit）と owned5 の受領、実際の PID と開始・終了の時刻、strict diagnostic（collector の規則のまま）を保存する。
+- report の role（R/O）と、native の phase（R-A など）と、実際の PID を、driver が明示的に結びつけて記録する（role を phase 名から推測しない）。
+- finally: 既定の player の設定・source・project.godot・guard・PID の後始末を、collector の既存の処理のまま保持し、後始末の結果（残った process 0、残った profile の扱い）を記録する。
+
+1.3 証拠の複製と結合（owned の process の終了の後）
+- R-A〜O-B の各 phase で、private profile の全ての証拠を複製し、全件の bytes と SHA を記録する: report（stdout の P28_02_EQ_REPORT= の1行）、lifecycle.json（measurement、e3、e3_b1、e45 を含む）、audio-close.json、events.json、observation、全ての e3-NN.json（00〜17）、全ての e45-NN.json（00〜20）、package の証拠。restart.copy_states は参考とし、EQ 自身の正確な名前の inventory で結びつける。欠けた・余分な・変わったファイルは拒否する。
+- lifecycle の inventory が自分の hash と audio の受領を含まないことに従い、lifecycle.json と audio-close.json の SHA を、それぞれ独立に結びつける。lifecycle か audio が欠けている、または error を含む場合は、stdout の report があっても失敗にする。
+- raw の JSON は strict_json で読む。各 phase で:
+  - check_observation（raw の全 bytes と SHA の witness）
+  - check_lifecycle（guard の受領、準備と後始末、S3a と S3b の分）
+  - check_report(raw, measurement=lifecycle.measurement, e3_evidence=…, b1_record=…) に lifecycle.e45 を渡す
+  - report.scenarios が E3 の18件 + E4/E5 の21件（E4 の5件 + E5 の16件）= 39件で、順序と区間の連続が正しいこと
+- check_eq.join_report で raw を結合してから、compare_versions.compare_reports を呼ぶ。raw と、結合した出力と、join_facts の sidecar と proof と、checker の結果を、別々のファイルとして、それぞれの SHA とともに保持する。
+- 同じ版の決定性: R-A と R-B、O-A と O-B を、それぞれ別に比べ、SPEC §3.2 の版の間の比較の差が0であることを確かめる。R と O を互いに比べない。
+- 既存の不具合（latest_snapshot の aliasing、cached_digest_aliasing を含む）は、その結果のまま bundle に入れる。PASS に補わない。
+- 全ての複製と結合の後に、bundle の manifest（全ファイルの相対 path・bytes・SHA）を書き、最後に seal（manifest の SHA）を書く。seal の後に書き込みをしない。
+
+1.4 bundle の配置と失敗
+- 7つの phase と 1.3 の全ての検査が成功した場合だけ、bundle を --output の下に作る。Root がそれを $BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR/p28-02-eq-evidence に、bytes をそのまま置く（verify_eq.py は場所を変えない）。
+- 失敗した場合は、bundle を作らず、raw と失敗の記録（どの phase の、どの検査か）を --output に残し、0 以外の終了コードで終わる。失敗を成功に書き換えない。
+- 表記: この記録は「S_eq の native」であって、Q で測ったものではない。source・設定・入力・marker・policy・engine・環境・EQ の同一性が証明された場合だけ、Q_eq での再利用ができる（SPEC §5）。bundle にこの区別を書く。
+
+2. eq/verify_eq.py（正式の validation p28-02-eq-native-verify）
+- --project-root . で、$BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR/p28-02-eq-evidence の bundle を読む。BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR が無い、bundle が無い、seal が無い場合は失敗にする。
+- seal と manifest を検証し、欠けた・余分な・変わったファイルを拒否する。
+- 結合した出力を信用せず、raw から 1.3 の全ての検査（strict_json、check_observation、check_lifecycle、check_report、join_report、compare_reports、39件、R と O の別々の決定性、既存の不具合の保持）をやり直し、bundle の記録と一致することを確かめる。
+- pin（fixture、engine、source map 1407 の全件、machine、EQ のファイルの SHA、project・設定・marker・policy）が、--project-root の実際のファイルと一致することを確かめる。EQ のファイルの SHA は、検証の時点の W の実際のファイルと比べる。
+- 7つの phase の全てで、raw3、owned5、PID の開始と終了、strict diagnostic、guard、後始末（残り0）がそろっていることを確かめる。
+- 結果を1つの JSON で出し、成功だけ終了コード 0。
+
+3. 試験（test_eq.py に追加。engine を使わない）
+- bundle の正常（合成の bytes で作った bundle が verify の論理で通ること。これは native の証明ではないと試験の名前と出力に書く）。
+- 拒否:
+  - bundle・seal・manifest の欠落、余分なファイル、変わったファイル、seal の後の書込み
+  - lifecycle・audio・e3-NN・e45-NN の欠落、error を含む lifecycle
+  - 39件でない scenario、順序の違い、E4/E5 の21件の欠落
+  - guard_gate・stage_gate の戻り値の bool としての扱い
+  - 存在しない profile の空の dict を fresh や保存の成功とすること
+  - 複製した manifest の root での代用、destination の9件の不一致
+  - startup と runtime の profile の名前の取り違え、profile の再利用
+  - role と phase と PID の結びつきの欠落や矛盾
+  - raw3・owned5・PID の開始と終了の欠落、strict diagnostic の違反、後始末の残り
+  - R と O の交差の比較、決定性の差が0でないのに合格にすること
+  - join の前の compare、raw と結合した出力の混同、sidecar の欠落
+  - 既存の不具合を PASS にすること、aliasing の記録の欠落
+  - source map の件数だけの検査、1407件の1つの不一致、pin の不一致
+  - Q で測ったという表記
+  - --output の既存の dir への上書き、失敗の時の bundle の作成
+- 既存の119件を含めて、python3 -B test_eq.py の全件 PASS まで直し、生出力と SHA を保存する。失敗した試行の生出力も残す。
+
+4. 終わり（正式な提出）
+- PROGRESS.md と IMPLEMENTATION.md（S4 の要件の対応表を含む）を更新する。
+- 局所の全件 PASS を確かめた後、正式な JSON で提出する（status は blocked にしない）。提出は局所の unit の証拠であり、native の実行・受け入れた S・Q での測定・製品の PASS とは表記しない。6条件は、Root の native と両方の validation と fresh の独立した Opus のレビューまで保留のまま。
+- worker は、engine の起動、run_eq.py --run の実行、git への書込み、製品の変更、全回帰をしない。正式の validation（bundle の無い状態の verify_eq.py を含む）を、試しに実行して失敗させない。commit と gate は Runner が通常どおり行う。
+- 通常の実装上の判断は、記録して進める。
+
+5. 提出の後の順序（Root と Runner。worker の範囲の外）
+- Root が、凍結した S で native の7つの phase（import、parse-base、parse-wrapper、R-A、R-B、O-A、O-B）を run_eq.py --run で1回行い、成功した bundle を $BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR/p28-02-eq-evidence に置く。
+- 両方の validation（p28-02-eq-unit、p28-02-eq-native-verify）。
+- fresh の、別の Opus のセッションによる、6条件の全てのレビュー。
+- 通常の prepare、候補の資格の確認、承認、integration、final。その後に OPT と whole-unit の gate。
+- 原本の 23/88・4/30、原本の条件、課金、権限、900秒は変えない。
@@ -0,0 +1,34 @@
+EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN r02（P28-02-EQ 段階 S4。EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN（r01）は、ここで置き換える箇所を除いて、そのまま有効。この r02 は、r01 の §0 の import の範囲、§1.2 の raw3 の名前、実際の API の引数、正式な提出の status、validation の書込みの場所だけを、実際の source に合わせて訂正し、具体化する。S4 の範囲（run_eq.py、verify_eq.py、bundle の正常と拒否の unit、局所の全件 PASS、正式な提出）は小さくしない。SPEC、TASK、6条件、eq/references、eq/registration、補足 r01/r02/r03、段階の計画 r01/r02、S3 の計画 r01/r02、S3b の計画 r01/r02 は変更しない）
+
+1. import の範囲（r01 §0 の4つ目の箇条を置き換える）
+- 凍結した EQ SPEC §1 の読取の閉包（RESTART D1 の6つ + DIAG の5つ + EQ 自身）の中のものだけを使う。閉包と権限は広げない。
+- collector（execution/p28-01/collector/collect_p28_01.py、SHA a43e1f963ef8505ddd5acf8bf747d9bfac22a028cbb805c0b964ee11b9b40a14）は、閉包の中で、読取専用で import する。
+- restart_pair.py（SHA 538302ee…）は RESTART の task の所有物で、EQ の閉包に入らない。import しない。copy_states は、読んで参考にするだけとする。証拠の複製と inventory は、EQ が自分のコードとして eq/ の中に実装する（r01 §1.3 の正確な名前の一覧で）。
+- check_eq.py の静的な検査と試験に、restart_pair の import と、閉包の外の import を拒否するものを加える。
+
+2. raw3 の名前（r01 §1.2 の「raw3（stdout、stderr、exit）」を置き換える）
+- raw3 は、collector の run_engine（collect_p28_01.py:217、:225）が実際に作る3つのファイル: stdout.log、stderr.log、engine-native.log。engine-native.log（--log-file、--verbose）を落とさない。
+- 終了コードは raw3 ではない。owned の受領（process.json など、owned5 の中）にある実際の値を、そこから読んで記録し、結びつける。
+- 各 phase で、raw3 の3つのファイルの存在・bytes・SHA と、owned5 の5つの受領を、全て要求する。どれかが欠ければ失敗にする。試験で、engine-native.log の欠落と、終了コードを raw3 から読もうとすることを拒否する。
+
+3. 実際の API の引数（r01 §1.3 と §2 を具体化する）
+- check_report(raw, measurement=None, e3_evidence=None, b1_record=None, e45_evidence=None): measurement に lifecycle.measurement、e3_evidence に lifecycle.e3、b1_record に lifecycle.e3_b1、e45_evidence に lifecycle.e45 を渡す。どれかを None のまま呼ばない。
+- check_lifecycle(raw, lifecycle, guard): guard は、その phase の guard の受領。
+- 各 R/O の phase の private profile の証拠の正確な名前の一覧: checkpoint-00.json〜checkpoint-30.json（31件）、observation-00.json〜observation-30.json（31件）、e3-00.json〜e3-17.json（18件）、e45-00.json〜e45-20.json（21件）、events.json、report.json、lifecycle.json、audio-close.json。これに package の証拠を加える（S3a/S3b で決まった名前のまま）。この一覧と比べて、欠けた・余分な・変わったファイルを拒否する。
+
+4. 正式な提出の status（r01 §4 を具体化する）
+- Runner は、worker の JSON の status が "submitted" であることを要求する（core.py:1015）。schema には "pass" もあるが、実装の run では submitted でないと止まる。S4 の最後の JSON の status は、ちょうど "submitted" にする。"pass" や "blocked" にしない。
+- commit の欄は、base の 2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988 とする。worker は git に書き込まない。通常の git commit は Runner.submit が行う。
+
+5. validation の書込みの場所（r01 §2 と §3 を具体化する）
+- 正式の validation は、checkout を読取専用にして実行される（core.py:1064 の writable=()）。BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR は、Runner が runtime の build の領域に割り当てる（core.py:827）。
+- test_eq.py（p28-02-eq-unit）の bundle の合成の試験は、一時の生成物を、その割り当てられた BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR の下（無い場合は tempfile.gettempdir() の下）の新しい dir にだけ作る。source の tree（eq/ を含む）に書き込む設計にしない。
+- verify_eq.py は、bundle を読むだけで、checkout に書き込まない。結果は stdout の JSON で出す。
+- 試験で、checkout の中への書込みを検出して拒否する（たとえば、合成の bundle の dir が source の tree の中にあること）。
+- 環境・権限・writable の設定は変えない。
+
+6. 変更しないこと
+- r01 のそれ以外の全て: 既存の「S4 must」の要件の対応表、7つの phase、guard と profile の規則、gate の None/例外、profile_files の扱い、全証拠の複製と SHA、strict_json と check_observation と check_lifecycle と check_report、39件の scenario、join_report の後の compare_reports、raw と結合した出力と sidecar の分離、R-A/R-B と O-A/O-B の別々の決定性、既存の不具合の保持、source map 1407 と全ての pin、finally の後始末、成功の時だけの seal、「S_eq の native であって Q の測定ではない」の表記、失敗の時の bundle の不作成、verify_eq.py の raw からの再計算、bundle の正常と拒否の試験、119件の本体と全ての失敗の履歴の保持、局所の全件 PASS と生出力の保存。
+- worker は、engine の起動、run_eq.py --run の実行、正式の validation の試しの実行、git への書込み、製品の変更、全回帰をしない。
+- 提出の後の順序（Root の正確な S の native の7つの phase、bundle の配置、両方の validation、fresh の別の Opus による6条件の全てのレビュー、通常の prepare・資格・承認・integration・final、その後の OPT と whole-unit）と、原本の 23/88・4/30・原本の条件・課金・権限・900秒は変えない。
+- 通常の実装上の判断は、記録して進める。
@@ -0,0 +1,86 @@
+{
+  "observed_at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:38:56.381555+09:00",
+  "plan_id": "P28-02",
+  "project": "the-tree-p28-02-eq",
+  "task": "P28-02-EQ",
+  "base": "2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988",
+  "stage": "S4",
+  "state_at_observation": "implementing",
+  "repairs": 8,
+  "submitted": null,
+  "actual_run": {
+    "id": "20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe",
+    "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+    "role": "implementer",
+    "service": "codex",
+    "status": "running",
+    "pid": 43572,
+    "started": 1792543013.4890702,
+    "finished": null,
+    "exit_code": null,
+    "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe"
+  },
+  "actual_process_observation": "43572 43550 02:03 Ss   /Applications/ChatGPT.app/Contents/Resources/codex-cli/bin/../CodexCLI.app/Contents/MacOS/codex",
+  "root_exec_session": 51860,
+  "actual_Opus_materials": [
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN.txt",
+      "bytes": 12062,
+      "sha256": "4448602b1542f003282c9572765c71046800a1e2a92e1755792f0ba39caa56d5"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN_R02.txt",
+      "bytes": 6243,
+      "sha256": "f736fb819c8d0ee6e94822896aa995e448a203ba8395743838f1cbf2a6c72660"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/DESKTOP_EQ_S4_REPAIR_DECISION.json",
+      "bytes": 2180,
+      "sha256": "ea01690b72d69526f8ebf677caae1dc5283eb8bb707d06cfd0cad02513252575"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/DESKTOP_EQ_S4_RUN_DECISION.json",
+      "bytes": 4407,
+      "sha256": "8fb1174639ee16f420d85e6f12c9f822d949137f770ae5025aeace9fef757fa2"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/DESKTOP_EQ_S4_RUN_DECISION_R02.json",
+      "bytes": 3902,
+      "sha256": "3b103f0ed6f8fdd2d7f2427af49b1dd54d6715307ebc7321879cebe5ac897190"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/S4_FROZEN_DEPENDENCY_API_NOTES_R01.json",
+      "bytes": 3625,
+      "sha256": "682a0d9a04978411691e9a8291b46a9ddc6eeb621d38c0f699a756e47be0084b"
+    }
+  ],
+  "actual_Opus_session": "local_a7f85421-3eed-4482-8030-c0dca669573a",
+  "actual_Opus_response": 344,
+  "origin_note": "Actual unchanged effective RUN reason labels previous message342; corrected response344 followed request343.",
+  "normal_repair_job": "c9042f9b9a354065a462936d711c1e66",
+  "normal_repair_succeeded": true,
+  "normal_RUN_input": {
+    "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/actual-desktop-EQ-S4-RUN-input-r09/RECORDED.json",
+    "bytes": 242,
+    "sha256": "e2631d3e63c52d2919af56d7df4ac171f8123fdbe967233f54578a1e95924e47"
+  },
+  "actual_context": {
+    "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/eq-staged-s4-owner-run-input-r09/RUN_STARTED.json",
+    "bytes": 795,
+    "sha256": "4c5380dfc07f6b1012a341899188b8b048febdbee82d2084b77e0cb216353eca"
+  },
+  "all58_retained_S1_to_S3b_files_verified_before_launch": true,
+  "S3b_local_evidence": {
+    "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3B_LOCAL_READINESS_C056B92.json",
+    "bytes": 8846,
+    "sha256": "9cbe071dcae33e5577fabc00bff915ab112d6acd7ae55a6bef693a6062176255"
+  },
+  "formal_EQ_accepted": false,
+  "original_credit": 0,
+  "original_completed": 23,
+  "original_total": 88,
+  "packages_completed": 4,
+  "packages_total": 30,
+  "partial_credit": false,
+  "next": "Follow actual S4 run20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe/PID43572/rootexec51860, no duplicate. On submitted S read actual driver and final local raw/scope, preserve all code/history, then exact frozen S native7 once and full raw/guard/PID/source/player/cleanup bundle join; both registered validations, fresh independent Opus all6 and normal candidate qualification/integration/final remain. Original P28-02 OPT/whole-unit still pending."
+}
@@ -0,0 +1,40 @@
+{
+  "at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:22:58.012059+09:00",
+  "scope": "Read-only frozen dependency API preparation for actual Opus S4 plan; no live worker inspection, tests, engine, edits, or acceptance credit",
+  "sources": [
+    {
+      "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/collector/collect_p28_01.py",
+      "bytes": 23306,
+      "sha256": "a43e1f963ef8505ddd5acf8bf747d9bfac22a028cbb805c0b964ee11b9b40a14"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-01/restart/probe/restart_pair.py",
+      "bytes": 17486,
+      "sha256": "538302eea55b033157446363c0787ea2dda5fbd31d4181ea5e39824609560d31"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p28-01-perf-baseline/.runtime/P28-01-COLLECTOR/build/p28-01-readonly/run-r02/profile_guard.gd",
+      "bytes": 2276,
+      "sha256": "597696c705cc8f0e79a35265ca3ef8df55f7fc3c4e0e5a2ce9a4e20e29e29a6f"
+    }
+  ],
+  "APIs": {
+    "inputs(readonly)": "Verifies fixed manifest SHA and original absolute destinations, returns manifest_sha256/files. Do not substitute a copied manifest root.",
+    "source_map(standard,root)": "Full relative path to bytes/sha256 map, not count-only.",
+    "argv_for(engine,stage,wrapper,importing=True)": "Import argv; parse_argv(engine,stage,target) gives check-only argv. Measured EQ wrapper argv is explicitly headless.",
+    "run_private_engine(standard,outer,command,folder,environment,stage,public,name)": "Returns owned row dict. public is original project.godot bytes; name is startup profile name. Folder must not yet exist; startup evidence is written beside it. finally restores project bytes.",
+    "stage_gate(before,after,importing=False)": "Raises on failure, returns None on success; import allows only corresponding new gd.uid/import support files.",
+    "guard_gate(value,runtime,name)": "Raises on failure, returns None on success. runtime is Path, name is runtime profile name, not startup profile name; binds exact actual user dir/fresh/5 conditions.",
+    "profile_files(directory)": "Complete relative file SHA/byte inventory, rejects symlinks. Nonexistent gives empty dict but is not proof of freshness or successful evidence export.",
+    "restart.copy_states(out,row)": "Reference for copying private typed evidence after owned process end; EQ must bind its own exact evidence names/inventory."
+  },
+  "binding_requirements": [
+    "Seven phases import,parse-base,parse-wrapper,R-A,R-B,O-A,O-B; report role R/O is distinct from native phase and actual PID; bind explicitly.",
+    "Preserve raw3 and owned5 receipts, actual captured PID lifecycle, strict diagnostics, original project/source/default-player preservation and finally cleanup.",
+    "Guard activates before parent initialize. Each startup and runtime profile is fresh and unique. Bind env THE_TREE_PACK_PROFILE_NAME/EXPECTED/REPORT plus role/fixture path/SHA.",
+    "After owned end copy all profile evidence and bind checkpoint/observation/event/scenario/lifecycle/audio to raw report SHA. Seal after copy; reject missing,extra,changed evidence.",
+    "Only actual successful bundle goes to BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR/p28-02-eq-evidence before both registered unit and native-verify. Exact-S native is not Q measurement unless source/settings/input/marker/policy/engine/environment/EQ identity proves reuse.",
+    "All original conditions and fresh independent Opus all6 review and normal integration/final remain."
+  ],
+  "original_credit": 0
+}
@@ -243,7 +243,7 @@
    "facility_value_contracts_validation.json": "bf490a9ca585c48fc318e76c4a069ef244827d828d46e6415399f7710590dd16",
    "performance_audit.json": "0b630b15a392c3e0366f1362bfe4ddacb968f915f54549f82e4d6fa315384762",
    "progress_contract.json": "ccbdfce8c8365d5c13f59531955708834cce45acd0e136561c95295dfdb5df77",
-    "progress_snapshot.json": "43aa72fe20278949c5b7172ca16f830be8e49debc2ce2979794c06a6092b3b16",
+    "progress_snapshot.json": "fa8576dfa2fc0e17e5fff6cefba45a15a907bec4d1bfb53d46fef7955a3e30de",
    "progress_validator_guard_checks.json": "72ee513fcf1cad85c24bfd0a4b472f425f6acf117928ece0f6b41e29018da627",
    "progress_validator_guard_checks.r01.json": "14c26adffa5a1938241db4912e50ea54b660641ee6fee2e412d467dce14d0519",
    "requirement_coverage.json": "03b10e4da367579db502d0671a6e0dda36fd385111c6f1c0084acaff7605f593",
@@ -253,6 +253,6 @@
    "validate_facility_value_contracts.py": "91640e2a76cd6cc9186f7b85c0bf379b24b6cac0d48962815235ee628e7ae43e",
    "validate_plan.py": "4973d3c2797289d266f5c6e7c36f3d2c31931b23a1022eab3d94328267bcc1b4",
    "validator_update_checks.json": "f997d0f3de2cea29550840b1d5cb23647d64f81329de46758551e2b6c8fecc27",
-    "work_packages.json": "bb7aa3a2fc584b47092c971ad81daddc725f2c552c1f37941092b0ff925d1f07"
+    "work_packages.json": "b57761d3823add0e902c62bcd7a67adf6d91660c1de7caa02ec0acf705a5834d"
  }
 }
@@ -1,9 +1,9 @@
 {
  "schema_version": 1,
-  "integrated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:15:42.458566+09:00",
+  "integrated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:38:56.381555+09:00",
  "scope": "原30パッケージ/88成果、正式完了23成果・4パッケージ。部分点なし。P28-01全条件を独立レビュー/通常final/実DB結合で正式完了。次P28-02未完。全ゲーム/同一Windows最終受入は未完。",
-  "source_head": "51d453040f560e2f9b141c6c363e76c8a25b4165",
-  "source_authority_note": "Docs checkpoint: original product1407 unchanged. S3b first run stopped before code due erroneous enumeration reference; all39 files retained. Actual Opus corrected operational reference only; same-W repair7 S3b running. No original acceptance credit.",
+  "source_head": "f3840c96378df4fa1d39abf5d2d119d01f935216",
+  "source_authority_note": "Docs checkpoint before commit. Original product1407 unchanged; all58 retained uncommitted S1-S3b files/local119 evidence remain W. Actual final S4 started, no native or formal EQ/original acceptance credit.",
  "immutable_history": {
    "baseline.json": {
      "sha256": "750bb3d313cc5e2ce0d4c79e563a995abd7a78f991dee1dd75c627877b02cd7b",
@@ -5301,9 +5301,9 @@
      }
    ],
    "remaining": [
-      "S3b E4 all five invalidation paths and E5 all4x2x2 ownership combinations; actual current run pending",
-      "S4 native driver and full bundle verifier, all local units and formal S submission",
-      "Exact frozen S native7, both mandatory validations, fresh independent Opus all6, normal candidate qualification/integration/final",
+      "S4 run_eq.py/verify_eq.py, synthetic bundle positive/negative tests, all local units and normal formal S submission; current actual run pending",
+      "Exact frozen S native7 and full raw/guard/PID/source/player/cleanup/evidence bundle join",
+      "Both registered validations, fresh independent Opus all6, normal candidate qualification/integration/final",
      "Original P28-02 T1 optimization, same-condition repeat comparison, RESTART, exact final full roster, whole-unit cross-cutting6 review/final and ledger"
    ],
    "original_completed": 23,
@@ -5312,15 +5312,15 @@
    "current_support_stage": {
      "project": "the-tree-p28-02-eq",
      "task": "P28-02-EQ",
-      "stage": "S3b",
-      "revision": "facility registry correction r02",
+      "stage": "S4",
+      "revision": "import/raw/protocol correction r02",
      "state": "implementing",
-      "repairs": 7,
+      "repairs": 8,
      "submitted": null,
      "checkpoint": {
-        "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3B_R02_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
-        "bytes": 3675,
-        "sha256": "286aad8ef954e7bd9e289890b7c185c7214d71c46e74e458a06512980c7e91aa"
+        "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S4_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
+        "bytes": 4040,
+        "sha256": "493df47908fa2e6b96d1a01cea62bba365bf41450255a7bebe63f7c798c98317"
      },
      "original_credit": 0
    }
@@ -9799,8 +9799,8 @@
    "formal_count": 23,
    "original_delivery_units": 88,
    "partial_credit": false,
-    "selection_status": "P28-01/DIAG formal; EQ S3a local evidence only. First S3b incomplete; actual same-W corrected S3b running. Original P28-02 unfinished.",
-    "pending_decisions": "No human decision pending. Actual Desktop Opus338 corrected reference; S4 judgment follows terminal S3b evidence."
+    "selection_status": "P28-01/DIAG formal; EQ S1-S3b retained local evidence only; final S4 actual implementation running. Original P28-02 unfinished.",
+    "pending_decisions": "No human decision pending for S4. Exact submitted-S native7 follows normal submission, then both validations/fresh independent Opus all6/normal final."
  },
  "historical_regression_before_P08_02_formal_closure": {
    "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p23-02-final-candidate-r32-combined-root-acceptance-r01.json",
@@ -10793,35 +10793,35 @@
    "project": "the-tree-p28-02-eq",
    "task": "P28-02-EQ",
    "state": "implementing",
-    "stage": "S3b",
+    "stage": "S4",
    "base": "2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988",
    "submitted": null,
-    "repairs": 7,
+    "repairs": 8,
    "actual_run": {
-      "id": "c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4",
+      "id": "20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe",
      "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
      "role": "implementer",
      "service": "codex",
      "status": "running",
-      "pid": 34943,
-      "started": 1792541665.953645,
+      "pid": 43572,
+      "started": 1792543013.4890702,
      "finished": null,
      "exit_code": null,
-      "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4"
+      "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe"
    },
-    "root_exec_session": 18378,
+    "root_exec_session": 51860,
    "root_exec_closed": false,
    "worker_model": "gpt-6-astra",
    "checkpoint": {
-      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3B_R02_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
-      "bytes": 3675,
-      "sha256": "286aad8ef954e7bd9e289890b7c185c7214d71c46e74e458a06512980c7e91aa"
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S4_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
+      "bytes": 4040,
+      "sha256": "493df47908fa2e6b96d1a01cea62bba365bf41450255a7bebe63f7c798c98317"
    },
    "original_credit": 0,
    "original_completed": 23,
    "original_total": 88,
-    "next": "Follow actual S3b-r02 run c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4/PID34943/rootexec18378, no duplicate. On terminal return preserve actual code/raw and join actual unit output, then actual Desktop Opus S4 judgment. S4/submission/native7/both validations/fresh independent Opus all6/normal final remain; no original credit.",
-    "revision": "facility registry correction r02"
+    "next": "Follow actual S4 run20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe/PID43572/rootexec51860, no duplicate. On submitted S read actual driver and final local raw/scope, preserve all code/history, then exact frozen S native7 once and full raw/guard/PID/source/player/cleanup bundle join; both registered validations, fresh independent Opus all6 and normal candidate qualification/integration/final remain. Original P28-02 OPT/whole-unit still pending.",
+    "revision": "import/raw/protocol correction r02"
  },
  "historical_workflow_before_desktop_handoff_20261019": {
    "source_thread": "01a14f6a-b6a1-7fd3-bd45-0f84bbef77be",
@@ -11611,7 +11611,7 @@
    "next": "P28-02 concrete measured-hotpath/equivalence contract by actual Desktop Opus; not yet registered"
  },
  "current_P28_02_execution": {
-    "at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:15:00.233926+09:00",
+    "at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:37:44.617013+09:00",
    "project": "the-tree-p28-02-eq",
    "task": "P28-02-EQ",
    "state": "implementing",
@@ -11649,7 +11649,7 @@
    },
    "W": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p28-02-eq/P28-02-EQ-implement",
    "S": null,
-    "repairs": 7,
+    "repairs": 8,
    "real_runs": [
      {
        "id": "eed3a23a87144985a953513517ba6cce",
@@ -11740,21 +11740,33 @@
        "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
        "role": "implementer",
        "service": "codex",
-        "status": "running",
+        "status": "finished",
        "pid": 34943,
        "started": 1792541665.953645,
+        "finished": 1792542376.8565261,
+        "exit_code": 0,
+        "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4"
+      },
+      {
+        "id": "20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe",
+        "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+        "role": "implementer",
+        "service": "codex",
+        "status": "running",
+        "pid": 43572,
+        "started": 1792543013.4890702,
        "finished": null,
        "exit_code": null,
-        "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4"
+        "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe"
      }
    ],
    "actual_model": "gpt-6-astra",
-    "root_exec_session": 18378,
-    "actual_Opus_RUN": "DESKTOP_EQ_S3B_RUN_DECISION_R02.json",
-    "actual_Opus_RUN_sha256": "2fcf7035a1a729416fe236397fa0373b1479218e6786508c6ac38f7fcc902c29",
-    "actual_start_context": "eq-staged-s3b-owner-run-input-r08/RUN_STARTED.json",
+    "root_exec_session": 51860,
+    "actual_Opus_RUN": "DESKTOP_EQ_S4_RUN_DECISION_R02.json",
+    "actual_Opus_RUN_sha256": "3b103f0ed6f8fdd2d7f2427af49b1dd54d6715307ebc7321879cebe5ac897190",
+    "actual_start_context": "eq-staged-s4-owner-run-input-r09/RUN_STARTED.json",
    "registered": "REGISTERED_EQ_2549CF7.json",
-    "main": "51d453040f560e2f9b141c6c363e76c8a25b4165",
+    "main": "f3840c96378df4fa1d39abf5d2d119d01f935216",
    "original_completed": 23,
    "original_total": 88,
    "packages_completed": 4,
@@ -11762,67 +11774,72 @@
    "original_credit": 0,
    "partial_credit": false,
    "DIAG_completed_status": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/DIAG_CLOSED_CURRENT_STATUS_FDB309F.json",
-    "next": "Follow actual S3b-r02 run c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4/PID34943/rootexec18378, no duplicate. On terminal return preserve actual code/raw and join actual unit output, then actual Desktop Opus S4 judgment. S4/submission/native7/both validations/fresh independent Opus all6/normal final remain; no original credit.",
+    "next": "Follow actual S4 run20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe/PID43572/rootexec51860, no duplicate. On submitted S read actual driver and final local raw/scope, preserve all code/history, then exact frozen S native7 once and full raw/guard/PID/source/player/cleanup bundle join; both registered validations, fresh independent Opus all6 and normal candidate qualification/integration/final remain. Original P28-02 OPT/whole-unit still pending.",
    "actual_initial_return": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/EQ_INITIAL_RETURN_EED3A23.json",
    "current_run": {
-      "id": "c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4",
+      "id": "20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe",
      "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
      "role": "implementer",
      "service": "codex",
      "status": "running",
-      "pid": 34943,
-      "started": 1792541665.953645,
+      "pid": 43572,
+      "started": 1792543013.4890702,
      "finished": null,
      "exit_code": null,
-      "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4"
+      "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe"
    },
    "latest_checkpoint": {
-      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3B_R02_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
-      "bytes": 3675,
-      "sha256": "286aad8ef954e7bd9e289890b7c185c7214d71c46e74e458a06512980c7e91aa"
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S4_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
+      "bytes": 4040,
+      "sha256": "493df47908fa2e6b96d1a01cea62bba365bf41450255a7bebe63f7c798c98317"
    },
    "last_actual_process_observed": [
      {
-        "run_id": "c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4",
-        "pid": 34943,
+        "run_id": "20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe",
+        "pid": 43572,
        "ps_exit": 0,
-        "ps": "34943 34920 00:35 Ss   /Applications/ChatGPT.app/Contents/Resources/codex-cli/bin/../CodexCLI.app/Contents/MacOS/codex"
+        "ps": "43572 43550 00:51 Ss   /Applications/ChatGPT.app/Contents/Resources/codex-cli/bin/../CodexCLI.app/Contents/MacOS/codex"
      }
    ],
-    "main_checkpoint_pushed": "51d453040f560e2f9b141c6c363e76c8a25b4165",
-    "latest_worker_return": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/retained-s3b-7da027a-r01/RETURN.json",
-    "coordinator_state": "Actual Desktop338 corrected only the facility enumeration reference to runtime.definition_registry.get_facility_ids(); empty-list false NA forbidden. Normal repair7/RUN, all39 current retained bytes verified, one same-W Astra retry started. Original failure/code/history and original conditions preserved.",
+    "main_checkpoint_pushed": "f3840c96378df4fa1d39abf5d2d119d01f935216",
+    "latest_worker_return": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/retained-s3b-c056b92-r01/RETURN.json",
+    "coordinator_state": "Actual Desktop344 corrected S4 import closure/raw3 names/protocol. Normal repair8/RUN and all58 retained files verified; same-W Astra final S4 implementation started. Full8 plans and frozen API notes supplied as one added context, all normal packet fields/gates unchanged. No engine/native/formal validation started.",
    "governor_session": "local_a7f85421-3eed-4482-8030-c0dca669573a",
    "actual_environment_clarification": {
      "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/EQ_ENVIRONMENT_FIELDS_CLARIFICATION_R03.txt",
      "bytes": 7637,
      "sha256": "12b27f984ef5843d98327200ad261dccaf64968402192b08ad55b15ed5454ea2"
    },
-    "stage": "S3b",
+    "stage": "S4",
    "actual_staged_plan": {
-      "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/EQ_S3B_STAGE_PLAN_R02.txt",
-      "bytes": 5023,
-      "sha256": "9a26f47012e51ed23eb03e539fc5c4734e4d41c09ce37a21a18b4ac8a77a5f4c"
+      "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN_R02.txt",
+      "bytes": 6243,
+      "sha256": "f736fb819c8d0ee6e94822896aa995e448a203ba8395743838f1cbf2a6c72660"
    },
    "latest_stage_return": {
-      "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/retained-s3b-7da027a-r01/RETURN.json",
-      "bytes": 35937,
-      "sha256": "4961d36957bf14b9ad05d3fcbc162ad30e971e7dde2bae18fce6bc5eb18b3e1e"
+      "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/retained-s3b-c056b92-r01/RETURN.json",
+      "bytes": 51751,
+      "sha256": "251752724519d048db99c84824e38d5d738e38b64f116dd7a6f52242377eb467"
    },
    "latest_stage_local_join": {
-      "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/ROOT_S3A_LOCAL_JOIN_32288E9.json",
-      "bytes": 4803,
-      "sha256": "db712aea5390fd6fe9313954a1f77ce07df49556f21633437f8baa1c1a6f0701"
+      "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/ROOT_S3B_LOCAL_JOIN_C056B92.json",
+      "bytes": 7250,
+      "sha256": "5e3e67d306d4d0ef067754855df7664bfeb0e804f23f1224435e16665ff46a61"
    },
-    "local_stage_ready": "S3a local91 only. Old S3b stopped before code; r02 continuation in progress.",
-    "local_unit_checks": 91,
+    "local_stage_ready": "S3b local119 only. S4 implementation/formal submission and all6 formal gates pending.",
+    "local_unit_checks": 119,
    "latest_failed_worker_return": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/EQ_REPAIR2_RETURN_84CA0FF.json",
    "latest_stage_return_join": {
      "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/ROOT_S3B_RETURN_7DA027A.json",
      "bytes": 2104,
      "sha256": "f187c139214382b2e0a0bbdb45b1e5bb1dda4914531f79c21e5fb661d8846634"
    },
-    "stage_revision": "registry-source correction r02"
+    "stage_revision": "import/raw/protocol correction r02",
+    "S4_dependency_API_notes": {
+      "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/S4_FROZEN_DEPENDENCY_API_NOTES_R01.json",
+      "bytes": 3625,
+      "sha256": "682a0d9a04978411691e9a8291b46a9ddc6eeb621d38c0f699a756e47be0084b"
+    }
  },
  "historical_source_header_before_P28_02_DIAG_start": {
    "source_head": "ae9ae47646434dd57fc21f3e8566d0d35b242ab1",
@@ -12281,11 +12298,11 @@
    "bytes": 18478,
    "sha256": "7d83ec0e19e0c12ecefebc5ab0bdffb20743ed34c6144251a08b83b315b09ecf"
  },
-  "current_p28_02_summary": "P28-01/補助DIAGは正式完了、原P28-02未完。EQ S1/S2/S3aコード・局所91試験・全39ファイル/失敗履歴を保持。初回S3b run7da027aは指示書が人物catalogを施設一覧と誤記したためコード実装前に返却、新規試験0（旧91を今回の試験に流用しない）。実ソースの施設registryをRoot確認し、実Opus338がE4-1列挙元のみdefinition_registry.get_facility_idsへ訂正、空一覧falseNA拒否。通常repair7/RUNにより同W/Astra run c056b928・PID34943・exec18378を起動/実生存確認。残るE4全5/E5全4x2x2・S4提出・正確S native7・両validation・fresh別Opus全6・通常候補資格/統合final、続くT1最適化/反復比較/RESTART/最終全roster/whole-unit横断6/finalは未達。正式23/88・4/30、原加算0、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON最大場面・同一Windows実機・長期・全ゲームは別未達。",
+  "current_p28_02_summary": "P28-01/補助DIAGは正式完了、原P28-02未完。EQ S1〜S3b全58ファイル/全失敗履歴を保持。S3bでE4全5経路とE5全4x2x2・完全typed状態/event/signal/連続区間を実装し、実局所119試験の全保存出力/SHA・実印字範囲・embedded exitを照合。既存91本体不変、失敗02/03/07/08保全。限定ソース点検で具体high/medium不一致なし、digest例外は実証拠付きE5 outside_in操作直後のみ（正式review代用不可）。実Opus344がS4のimport閉包/raw3/提出token/validation書込契約を訂正し、通常repair8/RUNで同W/Astra run20dc4135・PID43572・exec51860を起動/実生存確認。残るdriver/verify/bundle unitと正式S提出、正確S native7、両validation、fresh別Opus全6、通常候補資格/統合final、続くT1最適化/反復比較/RESTART/最終全roster/whole-unit横断6/finalは未達。正式23/88・4/30、原加算0、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON最大場面・同一Windows実機・長期・全ゲームは別未達。",
  "current_p28_02_EQ_checkpoint": {
-    "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3B_R02_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
-    "bytes": 3675,
-    "sha256": "286aad8ef954e7bd9e289890b7c185c7214d71c46e74e458a06512980c7e91aa"
+    "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S4_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
+    "bytes": 4040,
+    "sha256": "493df47908fa2e6b96d1a01cea62bba365bf41450255a7bebe63f7c798c98317"
  },
  "historical_before_EQ_S1_local_readiness": {
    "current_P28_02_execution": {
@@ -13242,5 +13259,273 @@
      "selection_status": "P28-01/DIAG formal; EQ S3a local evidence only. First S3b incomplete; actual same-W corrected S3b running. Original P28-02 unfinished.",
      "pending_decisions": "No human decision pending. Actual Desktop Opus338 corrected reference; S4 judgment follows terminal S3b evidence."
    }
+  },
+  "historical_before_EQ_S4": {
+    "current_P28_02_execution": {
+      "at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:15:00.233926+09:00",
+      "project": "the-tree-p28-02-eq",
+      "task": "P28-02-EQ",
+      "state": "implementing",
+      "contract": {
+        "id": "P28-02-EQ",
+        "title": "意味を保つ軽量化：同等性の先行固定（harness）",
+        "requirement_ids": [
+          "P28-02",
+          "P28"
+        ],
+        "acceptance_ids": [
+          "P28-02-EQ1",
+          "P28-02-EQ2",
+          "P28-02-EQ3",
+          "P28-02-EQ4",
+          "P28-02-EQ5",
+          "P28-02-EQ6"
+        ],
+        "spec_ref": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/eq/SPEC.md",
+        "base_commit": "2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988",
+        "worker": "codex",
+        "allowed_paths": [
+          "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/eq/**"
+        ],
+        "depends_on": [],
+        "resource_locks": [
+          "p28-02-eq"
+        ],
+        "validation_ids": [
+          "p28-02-eq-unit",
+          "p28-02-eq-native-verify"
+        ],
+        "max_repair_attempts": null,
+        "spec_sha256": "cf75af22a803bf492e30f8a04a39f5187ece5b94cd54207aad8ece1683d4bc93"
+      },
+      "W": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p28-02-eq/P28-02-EQ-implement",
+      "S": null,
+      "repairs": 7,
+      "real_runs": [
+        {
+          "id": "eed3a23a87144985a953513517ba6cce",
+          "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+          "role": "implementer",
+          "service": "codex",
+          "status": "finished",
+          "pid": 91723,
+          "started": 1792534900.465473,
+          "finished": 1792534987.111678,
+          "exit_code": 0,
+          "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/eed3a23a87144985a953513517ba6cce"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "8d5e4a14dd1640a3bebeafa2b49e34ab",
+          "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+          "role": "implementer",
+          "service": "codex",
+          "status": "finished",
+          "pid": 95908,
+          "started": 1792535447.577267,
+          "finished": 1792535577.093471,
+          "exit_code": 0,
+          "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/8d5e4a14dd1640a3bebeafa2b49e34ab"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "84ca0ff895c64ac89ffcef945f8848fe",
+          "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+          "role": "implementer",
+          "service": "codex",
+          "status": "finished",
+          "pid": 1299,
+          "started": 1792536166.565137,
+          "finished": 1792536437.4674659,
+          "exit_code": 0,
+          "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/84ca0ff895c64ac89ffcef945f8848fe"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "3325e7da9d064d2792fd178f400bc492",
+          "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+          "role": "implementer",
+          "service": "codex",
+          "status": "finished",
+          "pid": 6380,
+          "started": 1792536976.04443,
+          "finished": 1792537645.841019,
+          "exit_code": 0,
+          "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/3325e7da9d064d2792fd178f400bc492"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "558b96b3fe5e462296e85bc591622d1c",
+          "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+          "role": "implementer",
+          "service": "codex",
+          "status": "finished",
+          "pid": 12205,
+          "started": 1792537978.637717,
+          "finished": 1792538824.796691,
+          "exit_code": 0,
+          "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/558b96b3fe5e462296e85bc591622d1c"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "32288e966a844f5baec4dc931bc281a5",
+          "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+          "role": "implementer",
+          "service": "codex",
+          "status": "finished",
+          "pid": 24130,
+          "started": 1792539888.089719,
+          "finished": 1792540614.1304991,
+          "exit_code": 0,
+          "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/32288e966a844f5baec4dc931bc281a5"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "7da027a85548460bb008b562a79a52ae",
+          "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+          "role": "implementer",
+          "service": "codex",
+          "status": "finished",
+          "pid": 32210,
+          "started": 1792541236.488162,
+          "finished": 1792541342.4558878,
+          "exit_code": 0,
+          "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/7da027a85548460bb008b562a79a52ae"
+        },
+        {
+          "id": "c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4",
+          "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+          "role": "implementer",
+          "service": "codex",
+          "status": "running",
+          "pid": 34943,
+          "started": 1792541665.953645,
+          "finished": null,
+          "exit_code": null,
+          "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4"
+        }
+      ],
+      "actual_model": "gpt-6-astra",
+      "root_exec_session": 18378,
+      "actual_Opus_RUN": "DESKTOP_EQ_S3B_RUN_DECISION_R02.json",
+      "actual_Opus_RUN_sha256": "2fcf7035a1a729416fe236397fa0373b1479218e6786508c6ac38f7fcc902c29",
+      "actual_start_context": "eq-staged-s3b-owner-run-input-r08/RUN_STARTED.json",
+      "registered": "REGISTERED_EQ_2549CF7.json",
+      "main": "51d453040f560e2f9b141c6c363e76c8a25b4165",
+      "original_completed": 23,
+      "original_total": 88,
+      "packages_completed": 4,
+      "packages_total": 30,
+      "original_credit": 0,
+      "partial_credit": false,
+      "DIAG_completed_status": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/DIAG_CLOSED_CURRENT_STATUS_FDB309F.json",
+      "next": "Follow actual S3b-r02 run c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4/PID34943/rootexec18378, no duplicate. On terminal return preserve actual code/raw and join actual unit output, then actual Desktop Opus S4 judgment. S4/submission/native7/both validations/fresh independent Opus all6/normal final remain; no original credit.",
+      "actual_initial_return": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/EQ_INITIAL_RETURN_EED3A23.json",
+      "current_run": {
+        "id": "c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4",
+        "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+        "role": "implementer",
+        "service": "codex",
+        "status": "running",
+        "pid": 34943,
+        "started": 1792541665.953645,
+        "finished": null,
+        "exit_code": null,
+        "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4"
+      },
+      "latest_checkpoint": {
+        "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3B_R02_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
+        "bytes": 3675,
+        "sha256": "286aad8ef954e7bd9e289890b7c185c7214d71c46e74e458a06512980c7e91aa"
+      },
+      "last_actual_process_observed": [
+        {
+          "run_id": "c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4",
+          "pid": 34943,
+          "ps_exit": 0,
+          "ps": "34943 34920 00:35 Ss   /Applications/ChatGPT.app/Contents/Resources/codex-cli/bin/../CodexCLI.app/Contents/MacOS/codex"
+        }
+      ],
+      "main_checkpoint_pushed": "51d453040f560e2f9b141c6c363e76c8a25b4165",
+      "latest_worker_return": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/retained-s3b-7da027a-r01/RETURN.json",
+      "coordinator_state": "Actual Desktop338 corrected only the facility enumeration reference to runtime.definition_registry.get_facility_ids(); empty-list false NA forbidden. Normal repair7/RUN, all39 current retained bytes verified, one same-W Astra retry started. Original failure/code/history and original conditions preserved.",
+      "governor_session": "local_a7f85421-3eed-4482-8030-c0dca669573a",
+      "actual_environment_clarification": {
+        "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/EQ_ENVIRONMENT_FIELDS_CLARIFICATION_R03.txt",
+        "bytes": 7637,
+        "sha256": "12b27f984ef5843d98327200ad261dccaf64968402192b08ad55b15ed5454ea2"
+      },
+      "stage": "S3b",
+      "actual_staged_plan": {
+        "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/EQ_S3B_STAGE_PLAN_R02.txt",
+        "bytes": 5023,
+        "sha256": "9a26f47012e51ed23eb03e539fc5c4734e4d41c09ce37a21a18b4ac8a77a5f4c"
+      },
+      "latest_stage_return": {
+        "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/retained-s3b-7da027a-r01/RETURN.json",
+        "bytes": 35937,
+        "sha256": "4961d36957bf14b9ad05d3fcbc162ad30e971e7dde2bae18fce6bc5eb18b3e1e"
+      },
+      "latest_stage_local_join": {
+        "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/ROOT_S3A_LOCAL_JOIN_32288E9.json",
+        "bytes": 4803,
+        "sha256": "db712aea5390fd6fe9313954a1f77ce07df49556f21633437f8baa1c1a6f0701"
+      },
+      "local_stage_ready": "S3a local91 only. Old S3b stopped before code; r02 continuation in progress.",
+      "local_unit_checks": 91,
+      "latest_failed_worker_return": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/EQ_REPAIR2_RETURN_84CA0FF.json",
+      "latest_stage_return_join": {
+        "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/ROOT_S3B_RETURN_7DA027A.json",
+        "bytes": 2104,
+        "sha256": "f187c139214382b2e0a0bbdb45b1e5bb1dda4914531f79c21e5fb661d8846634"
+      },
+      "stage_revision": "registry-source correction r02"
+    },
+    "current_p28_02_EQ_checkpoint": {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3B_R02_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
+      "bytes": 3675,
+      "sha256": "286aad8ef954e7bd9e289890b7c185c7214d71c46e74e458a06512980c7e91aa"
+    },
+    "current_workflow_handoff": {
+      "controller_title": "ゲーム開発作業",
+      "controller_local_session": "local_a7f85421-3eed-4482-8030-c0dca669573a",
+      "actual_model": "Opus5.5 medium",
+      "desktop_read_write_roundtrip_verified": true,
+      "project": "the-tree-p28-02-eq",
+      "task": "P28-02-EQ",
+      "state": "implementing",
+      "stage": "S4",
+      "base": "2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988",
+      "submitted": null,
+      "repairs": 8,
+      "actual_run": {
+        "id": "20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe",
+        "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+        "role": "implementer",
+        "service": "codex",
+        "status": "running",
+        "pid": 43572,
+        "started": 1792543013.4890702,
+        "finished": null,
+        "exit_code": null,
+        "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe"
+      },
+      "root_exec_session": 51860,
+      "root_exec_closed": false,
+      "worker_model": "gpt-6-astra",
+      "checkpoint": {
+        "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S4_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
+        "bytes": 4040,
+        "sha256": "493df47908fa2e6b96d1a01cea62bba365bf41450255a7bebe63f7c798c98317"
+      },
+      "original_credit": 0,
+      "original_completed": 23,
+      "original_total": 88,
+      "next": "Follow actual S4 run20dc4135cc3041dbb82fcc2b2a6b0cbe/PID43572/rootexec51860, no duplicate. On submitted S read actual driver and final local raw/scope, preserve all code/history, then exact frozen S native7 once and full raw/guard/PID/source/player/cleanup bundle join; both registered validations, fresh independent Opus all6 and normal candidate qualification/integration/final remain. Original P28-02 OPT/whole-unit still pending.",
+      "revision": "import/raw/protocol correction r02"
+    },
+    "current_closure_targets": {
+      "formally_closed": "P28-01",
+      "next_candidate": "P28-02",
+      "formal_count": 23,
+      "original_delivery_units": 88,
+      "partial_credit": false,
+      "selection_status": "P28-01/DIAG formal; EQ S1-S3b retained local evidence only; final S4 actual implementation running. Original P28-02 unfinished.",
+      "pending_decisions": "No human decision pending for S4. Exact submitted-S native7 follows normal submission, then both validations/fresh independent Opus all6/normal final."
+    }
  }
 }
@@ -18073,7 +18073,7 @@
    },
    "legacy_state": "planned",
    "state_scope": "package-level; completed means whole package accepted; partial implementation is not completion",
-    "current_summary": "P28-01/補助DIAGは正式完了、原P28-02未完。EQ S1/S2/S3aコード・局所91試験・全39ファイル/失敗履歴を保持。初回S3b run7da027aは指示書が人物catalogを施設一覧と誤記したためコード実装前に返却、新規試験0（旧91を今回の試験に流用しない）。実ソースの施設registryをRoot確認し、実Opus338がE4-1列挙元のみdefinition_registry.get_facility_idsへ訂正、空一覧falseNA拒否。通常repair7/RUNにより同W/Astra run c056b928・PID34943・exec18378を起動/実生存確認。残るE4全5/E5全4x2x2・S4提出・正確S native7・両validation・fresh別Opus全6・通常候補資格/統合final、続くT1最適化/反復比較/RESTART/最終全roster/whole-unit横断6/finalは未達。正式23/88・4/30、原加算0、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON最大場面・同一Windows実機・長期・全ゲームは別未達。",
+    "current_summary": "P28-01/補助DIAGは正式完了、原P28-02未完。EQ S1〜S3b全58ファイル/全失敗履歴を保持。S3bでE4全5経路とE5全4x2x2・完全typed状態/event/signal/連続区間を実装し、実局所119試験の全保存出力/SHA・実印字範囲・embedded exitを照合。既存91本体不変、失敗02/03/07/08保全。限定ソース点検で具体high/medium不一致なし、digest例外は実証拠付きE5 outside_in操作直後のみ（正式review代用不可）。実Opus344がS4のimport閉包/raw3/提出token/validation書込契約を訂正し、通常repair8/RUNで同W/Astra run20dc4135・PID43572・exec51860を起動/実生存確認。残るdriver/verify/bundle unitと正式S提出、正確S native7、両validation、fresh別Opus全6、通常候補資格/統合final、続くT1最適化/反復比較/RESTART/最終全roster/whole-unit横断6/finalは未達。正式23/88・4/30、原加算0、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON最大場面・同一Windows実機・長期・全ゲームは別未達。",
    "remaining_deliverables": [
      {
        "id": "P28-01",
@@ -18316,17 +18316,17 @@
            "linked_at_jst": "2026-10-21T07:31:50.231974+09:00"
          }
        ],
-        "progress_summary": "P28-01/補助DIAGは正式完了、原P28-02未完。EQ S1/S2/S3aコード・局所91試験・全39ファイル/失敗履歴を保持。初回S3b run7da027aは指示書が人物catalogを施設一覧と誤記したためコード実装前に返却、新規試験0（旧91を今回の試験に流用しない）。実ソースの施設registryをRoot確認し、実Opus338がE4-1列挙元のみdefinition_registry.get_facility_idsへ訂正、空一覧falseNA拒否。通常repair7/RUNにより同W/Astra run c056b928・PID34943・exec18378を起動/実生存確認。残るE4全5/E5全4x2x2・S4提出・正確S native7・両validation・fresh別Opus全6・通常候補資格/統合final、続くT1最適化/反復比較/RESTART/最終全roster/whole-unit横断6/finalは未達。正式23/88・4/30、原加算0、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON最大場面・同一Windows実機・長期・全ゲームは別未達。",
-        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:15:42.458566+09:00",
+        "progress_summary": "P28-01/補助DIAGは正式完了、原P28-02未完。EQ S1〜S3b全58ファイル/全失敗履歴を保持。S3bでE4全5経路とE5全4x2x2・完全typed状態/event/signal/連続区間を実装し、実局所119試験の全保存出力/SHA・実印字範囲・embedded exitを照合。既存91本体不変、失敗02/03/07/08保全。限定ソース点検で具体high/medium不一致なし、digest例外は実証拠付きE5 outside_in操作直後のみ（正式review代用不可）。実Opus344がS4のimport閉包/raw3/提出token/validation書込契約を訂正し、通常repair8/RUNで同W/Astra run20dc4135・PID43572・exec51860を起動/実生存確認。残るdriver/verify/bundle unitと正式S提出、正確S native7、両validation、fresh別Opus全6、通常候補資格/統合final、続くT1最適化/反復比較/RESTART/最終全roster/whole-unit横断6/finalは未達。正式23/88・4/30、原加算0、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON最大場面・同一Windows実機・長期・全ゲームは別未達。",
+        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:38:56.381555+09:00",
        "historical_summary_before_integrated_full9_20261021": "既採用e561 Pathを保持。source1273最大規模・Operations OFFの30分/保存再開を診断し25918+293parse/0。no-route候補の全15byte対照は一致したがmacro因果改善不足で不採用。Operations ON/新1277性能/Windows描画/長期プレイは未受入。",
        "historical_before_P28_01_formal_completion": {
          "progress_summary": "旧1273時点の限定軽量化・不採用記録を保持。現在の製品source1407（83b170aと同一）の実main db9d613全9測定で、代表R x1平均479.210ms/P95745.365ms/最大4809.099ms、x3P955062.697ms/最大5891.466msの予算未達を確定。O小入力の合格を最大負荷へ拡張しない。原P28-01の別PID再開・wholeunit受入を先に閉じ、同等性と失敗拒否を固定してから実測上位の改善へ進む。本単位の新規最適化/受入は未実施。",
          "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T01:04:05.061475+09:00"
        },
        "remaining_gaps": [
-          "S3b E4 all five invalidation paths and E5 all4x2x2 ownership combinations; actual current run pending",
-          "S4 native driver and full bundle verifier, all local units and formal S submission",
-          "Exact frozen S native7, both mandatory validations, fresh independent Opus all6, normal candidate qualification/integration/final",
+          "S4 run_eq.py/verify_eq.py, synthetic bundle positive/negative tests, all local units and normal formal S submission; current actual run pending",
+          "Exact frozen S native7 and full raw/guard/PID/source/player/cleanup/evidence bundle join",
+          "Both registered validations, fresh independent Opus all6, normal candidate qualification/integration/final",
          "Original P28-02 T1 optimization, same-condition repeat comparison, RESTART, exact final full roster, whole-unit cross-cutting6 review/final and ledger"
        ],
        "baseline_original_unit_completion": {
@@ -18354,14 +18354,14 @@
          "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T07:31:50.231974+09:00"
        },
        "current_EQ_local_readiness": {
-          "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3A_LOCAL_READINESS_32288E9.json",
-          "bytes": 6424,
-          "sha256": "aedbfdd791a61f9ebb9797b1278dca7405f3626df17c31d4fa28780ea7fe6f18"
+          "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3B_LOCAL_READINESS_C056B92.json",
+          "bytes": 8846,
+          "sha256": "9cbe071dcae33e5577fabc00bff915ab112d6acd7ae55a6bef693a6062176255"
        },
        "current_EQ_execution": {
-          "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3B_R02_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
-          "bytes": 3675,
-          "sha256": "286aad8ef954e7bd9e289890b7c185c7214d71c46e74e458a06512980c7e91aa"
+          "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S4_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
+          "bytes": 4040,
+          "sha256": "493df47908fa2e6b96d1a01cea62bba365bf41450255a7bebe63f7c798c98317"
        },
        "historical_before_EQ_S3a": {
          "progress_summary": "P28-01と補助DIAG（S d6ce6dd→Q fdb309f、全4正式ゲート）は完了。原P28-02は未完。EQはbase2549cf7/同W/Astraで段階実装し、S1比較器と型付き全状態・全event・可逆復元・差分再構成/source閉包の局所43試験を実exit/SHAと照合、未commit成果を保全した。初回局所失敗と旧3runの返答/撤去履歴は成功に変えず保持。S2–S4、正確S native7、両正式validation、別Opus全6review、通常候補資格/統合finalは未達。続いてT1 snapshot変換・コピー最適化、同条件反復比較・RESTART・正確最終全roster・whole-unit横断6レビュー/通常finalが必要。原加算0、正式23/88・4/30、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON/同一Windows/長期/全ゲームは別未達。 S2は実Opus326判断を通常記録し、同じW/Astraのrun558b96b3/PID12205/exec85980で起動（このcheckpoint時点で実生存確認）。全19保持S1ファイルを通常repair4の前後でSHA照合済み。",
@@ -18403,6 +18403,21 @@
            "sha256": "1d7881288287917a53c339f0f47dfa3cc642ade86ef3a6441850f64a29975c16"
          },
          "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:08:33.388425+09:00"
+        },
+        "historical_before_EQ_S4": {
+          "progress_summary": "P28-01/補助DIAGは正式完了、原P28-02未完。EQ S1/S2/S3aコード・局所91試験・全39ファイル/失敗履歴を保持。初回S3b run7da027aは指示書が人物catalogを施設一覧と誤記したためコード実装前に返却、新規試験0（旧91を今回の試験に流用しない）。実ソースの施設registryをRoot確認し、実Opus338がE4-1列挙元のみdefinition_registry.get_facility_idsへ訂正、空一覧falseNA拒否。通常repair7/RUNにより同W/Astra run c056b928・PID34943・exec18378を起動/実生存確認。残るE4全5/E5全4x2x2・S4提出・正確S native7・両validation・fresh別Opus全6・通常候補資格/統合final、続くT1最適化/反復比較/RESTART/最終全roster/whole-unit横断6/finalは未達。正式23/88・4/30、原加算0、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON最大場面・同一Windows実機・長期・全ゲームは別未達。",
+          "remaining_gaps": [
+            "S3b E4 all five invalidation paths and E5 all4x2x2 ownership combinations; actual current run pending",
+            "S4 native driver and full bundle verifier, all local units and formal S submission",
+            "Exact frozen S native7, both mandatory validations, fresh independent Opus all6, normal candidate qualification/integration/final",
+            "Original P28-02 T1 optimization, same-condition repeat comparison, RESTART, exact final full roster, whole-unit cross-cutting6 review/final and ledger"
+          ],
+          "current_EQ_execution": {
+            "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3B_R02_STARTED_2549CF7.json",
+            "bytes": 3675,
+            "sha256": "286aad8ef954e7bd9e289890b7c185c7214d71c46e74e458a06512980c7e91aa"
+          },
+          "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:15:42.458566+09:00"
        }
      },
      {
@@ -18936,7 +18951,8 @@
    "historical_summary_before_EQ_S1_local_readiness": "P28-01は正式完了。P28-02-DIAG補助はS d6ce6dd→Q fdb309f、native全6PID/3測定・全source1407/保存保全PASS、正式unit/nativeverifyとfresh独立Opus全4条件PASS（high/medium0・low5）、通常integration/final・実DB/traceability照合で正式完了。原成果加算0。次は実OpusのT1 snapshot変換・コピー選定に従い、EQで変更前E1-E5を固定し、OPT実装・同条件反復比較・RESTART・正確最終全roster・whole-unit横断6レビュー/通常統合finalまで進める。原P28-02は未完。旧parse失敗/900timeoutは保全。正式23/88・4/30、部分点なし。性能予算false6・200客OpsON/同一Windows/長期/全ゲームは別未達。 EQは実Opus304/306でE1-E5/全6補助条件を固定しbase2549cf7で通常登録。初回AstraがS内保存IOeventの実時間差を正しく指摘、未実装/未試験で返答を保全。実Opus312/314が対象9eventの2keyだけを可逆sidecarに残す規則とdirectrestore0/load1の実件数を確定し、通常repair1/条件付きRUN→同じWのAstra8d5e4a14/PID95908/exec28985で実装中。EQ native7/正式両validation/別Opus全6review/通常統合finalは未達、原加算0。",
    "historical_summary_before_EQ_S3a": "P28-01と補助DIAG（S d6ce6dd→Q fdb309f、全4正式ゲート）は完了。原P28-02は未完。EQはbase2549cf7/同W/Astraで段階実装し、S1比較器と型付き全状態・全event・可逆復元・差分再構成/source閉包の局所43試験を実exit/SHAと照合、未commit成果を保全した。初回局所失敗と旧3runの返答/撤去履歴は成功に変えず保持。S2–S4、正確S native7、両正式validation、別Opus全6review、通常候補資格/統合finalは未達。続いてT1 snapshot変換・コピー最適化、同条件反復比較・RESTART・正確最終全roster・whole-unit横断6レビュー/通常finalが必要。原加算0、正式23/88・4/30、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON/同一Windows/長期/全ゲームは別未達。 S2は実Opus326判断を通常記録し、同じW/Astraのrun558b96b3/PID12205/exec85980で起動（このcheckpoint時点で実生存確認）。全19保持S1ファイルを通常repair4の前後でSHA照合済み。",
    "historical_summary_before_EQ_S3b": "P28-01と補助DIAG（全4正式ゲート）は完了。原P28-02は未完。EQのS1/S2コードと全30ファイル・失敗履歴を同Wに保持し、S2局所72試験の実exit/SHAを生出力と照合した。phase全key集合とcore30分信号の検査欠落2点は未受入として残し、実Opus332のAPI別適用表でS3a（2修正とE3）を具体化、通常repair5/RUNにより同W/Astraのrun32288e96・PID24130・exec21040を起動し実生存確認。S3b E4/E5、S4提出、正確S native7、両正式validation、別Opus全6review、通常候補資格/統合finalは未達。続くT1最適化・同条件反復比較・RESTART・最終全roster・whole-unit横断6/finalまで原加算0。正式23/88・4/30、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON最大場面/同一Windows実機/長期/全ゲームは別未達。",
-    "historical_summary_before_EQ_S3b_ref_correction": "P28-01と補助DIAGは正式完了、原P28-02は未完。EQのS1/S2/S3a全39ファイルと失敗履歴を同Wに保持。S3aでphase全key集合/core30分信号の2欠落を修正し、実API別E3全18行と完全typed状態・イベント・package証拠を実装。局所91試験の全出力・SHA・実exit・印字範囲を照合し、既存72試験本体不変。限定ソース点検で具体high/medium不一致なし（正式reviewではない）。実Opus336判断を通常repair6/RUNへ記録し、同W/Astra S3b run7da027a8・PID32210・exec63195を起動/実生存確認。残るE4全5経路/E5全4x2x2、S4提出、正確S native7、両正式validation、別Opus全6review、通常候補資格/統合final、続くT1最適化・反復比較・RESTART・最終全roster・whole-unit横断6/finalは未達。原加算0、正式23/88・4/30、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON最大場面/同一Windows実機/長期/全ゲームは別未達。"
+    "historical_summary_before_EQ_S3b_ref_correction": "P28-01と補助DIAGは正式完了、原P28-02は未完。EQのS1/S2/S3a全39ファイルと失敗履歴を同Wに保持。S3aでphase全key集合/core30分信号の2欠落を修正し、実API別E3全18行と完全typed状態・イベント・package証拠を実装。局所91試験の全出力・SHA・実exit・印字範囲を照合し、既存72試験本体不変。限定ソース点検で具体high/medium不一致なし（正式reviewではない）。実Opus336判断を通常repair6/RUNへ記録し、同W/Astra S3b run7da027a8・PID32210・exec63195を起動/実生存確認。残るE4全5経路/E5全4x2x2、S4提出、正確S native7、両正式validation、別Opus全6review、通常候補資格/統合final、続くT1最適化・反復比較・RESTART・最終全roster・whole-unit横断6/finalは未達。原加算0、正式23/88・4/30、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON最大場面/同一Windows実機/長期/全ゲームは別未達。",
+    "historical_summary_before_EQ_S4": "P28-01/補助DIAGは正式完了、原P28-02未完。EQ S1/S2/S3aコード・局所91試験・全39ファイル/失敗履歴を保持。初回S3b run7da027aは指示書が人物catalogを施設一覧と誤記したためコード実装前に返却、新規試験0（旧91を今回の試験に流用しない）。実ソースの施設registryをRoot確認し、実Opus338がE4-1列挙元のみdefinition_registry.get_facility_idsへ訂正、空一覧falseNA拒否。通常repair7/RUNにより同W/Astra run c056b928・PID34943・exec18378を起動/実生存確認。残るE4全5/E5全4x2x2・S4提出・正確S native7・両validation・fresh別Opus全6・通常候補資格/統合final、続くT1最適化/反復比較/RESTART/最終全roster/whole-unit横断6/finalは未達。正式23/88・4/30、原加算0、部分点なし。予算false6・200客OpsON最大場面・同一Windows実機・長期・全ゲームは別未達。"
  },
  {
    "id": "P29",
				`@@ -0,0 +1 @@`
				{"action":"request-repair","task_id":"P28-02-EQ","reason":"Stage S3b r02 run c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4 (worker PID 34943 exit 0 after 710.903 s, Root exec 18378 exit 2) ended at the planned checkpoint: formal status blocked with the low finding 'stage S3b complete, next S4'. This is a staged checkpoint, not a failure; all 6 conditions remain pending. State: blocked, repairs 7, no S, no active run. Root preserved 58 files and 6 raw files at retained-s3b-c056b92-r01/RETURN.json SHA 251752724519d048db99c84824e38d5d738e38b64f116dd7a6f52242377eb467 and joined the 9 unit attempts at ROOT_S3B_LOCAL_JOIN_C056B92.json SHA 5e3e67d306d4d0ef067754855df7664bfeb0e804f23f1224435e16665ff46a61, with counts [91,null,114,114,114,118,1,119,119] and exits [0,1,1,0,0,0,1,1,0]. The syntax, digest, dictionary-order and fixture failures of attempts 02, 03, 07 and 08 are kept. The final run passed 119 tests in 32.034 s, output SHA 8360a2065b303099d5c546b3e4aecc0cc0ab0c2c1e5120b8034b6a1a64317030. All 91 earlier test bodies are unchanged by AST and 28 were added. Frozen materials, earlier raw and supplements are unchanged, tracked product source is unchanged, and every change is inside eq/. A limited independent read-only check found no concrete high or medium false PASS and no immediate native API mismatch. The compare_versions digest exception is bound only to the enumerated E5 outside-in operation point with the full proof, aliasing is kept as an existing defect, and E4 uses the real registry with full preview records. That check is not the formal fresh Opus review. Root also fixed the frozen dependency API notes at S4_FROZEN_DEPENDENCY_API_NOTES_R01.json SHA 682a0d9a04978411691e9a8291b46a9ddc6eeb621d38c0f699a756e47be0084b. Request the normal repair (blocked, repairs 7, to repair_ready, repairs 8) so the same W continues with the final stage S4 under EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN.txt. SPEC, TASK, the 6 conditions, eq/references, eq/registration, clarifications r01, r02 and r03, and the staged, S3 and S3b plans are unchanged; the earlier 7da027a plan error stays recorded. Decided by Claude Opus 5.5 in the Desktop control session (message 340); not a CLI commander result."}
				`@@ -0,0 +1 @@`
				{"action":"run","task_id":"P28-02-EQ","reason":"Use only after Root verifies through the normal gates: repair_ready, repairs 8, no S submitted, no active run, and all 58 current S1 to S3b files still present unchanged in the W. Run repair 8 of P28-02-EQ once on the same W from base 2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988 with the single worker codex gpt-6-astra, doing only the final stage S4 as defined in EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN.txt. Deliver EQ_S4_STAGE_PLAN.txt in full as part of the one supplementary key, together with both S3b plans, both S3 plans, both staged plans, S4_FROZEN_DEPENDENCY_API_NOTES_R01.json and this decision; clarifications r01, r02 and r03 stay read-only in build/eq-staged-readonly-r04. Start by reading eq/PROGRESS.md and eq/IMPLEMENTATION.md, list every existing 'S4 must' requirement and the closing S4 binding requirements, and reuse the existing code and schemas (join_report, check_report, check_observation, check_lifecycle, strict_json, compare_reports) without redesign. S4 scope: (1) eq/run_eq.py with an engine-free --check and a --run over the 7 phases import, parse-base, parse-wrapper, R-A, R-B, O-A and O-B, using the read-only collector API as frozen. run_private_engine takes the original project.godot bytes as public, the startup profile name as name and a not-yet-created folder. guard_gate takes the runtime profile name. Gates return None or raise and are never treated as bool. inputs(readonly) checks the original manifest and its 9 original destinations, never a copied root. An empty profile_files result is never proof. (2) After each owned process ends, copy and hash every private evidence file (report, lifecycle with measurement, e3, e3_b1 and e45, audio-close, events, observation, e3-00 to e3-17, e45-00 to e45-20 and package evidence), using strict_json. Call check_observation, check_lifecycle and check_report with lifecycle.e45, require 39 scenarios (18 E3 plus 21 E4/E5), call join_report before compare_reports, and keep raw, joined, join_facts sidecars, proofs and checker outcomes separate with SHAs. Compare R-A against R-B and O-A against O-B separately, requiring zero difference. Keep existing defects, including aliasing, as defects. (3) Bind raw3, owned5, actual PID start and end, strict diagnostics, guard, role to phase to PID, the full 1407-file source map and all pins (fixture, engine, source map, machine, EQ files, project, settings, marker, policy). Keep the finally cleanup with 0 remaining. Write the manifest and the seal last, only on full success, and label the result S_eq native, not Q measurement. On failure, keep raw, build no bundle and exit nonzero. (4) eq/verify_eq.py reads $BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR/p28-02-eq-evidence, fails when it is absent, recomputes every check from raw and binds the pins to the actual files. (5) Add bundle normal and rejection unit tests as listed in the plan, keeping all 119 test bodies and the full failure history except fixes a failing test requires. Run the engine-free python3 -B test_eq.py until every test passes, save every raw output with SHAs, update PROGRESS.md and IMPLEMENTATION.md with the requirement-to-code table, and submit formally as local unit evidence only, not native, accepted S, Q measurement or product PASS. Do not trial-run either formal validation or run_eq.py --run to make them fail; the bundle is joined once after the real native. No engine, no git write or commit, no product change, no full regression; the Runner commits and gates normally. SPEC, TASK, eq/references and eq/registration stay unchanged. Ordinary implementation choices are recorded without stopping; block only for undecided matters affecting original product spec, values, permissions, billing or original acceptance. The remaining order after submission: Root native on the exact S in 7 phases, the bundle placed at $BUILD_OUTPUT_DIR/p28-02-eq-evidence, both validations (p28-02-eq-unit, p28-02-eq-native-verify), a fresh independent Opus review of all 6 conditions, then the normal prepare, candidate qualification, approval, integration and final, then the OPT and whole-unit gates. No original credit (23/88, 4/30); the 900-second timeout is unchanged. Quota fallback only on structured provider quota, once, same role, Antigravity claude-opus-5-5-high; any other failure is blocked. Decided by Claude Opus 5.5 in the Desktop control session (message 340); not a CLI commander result."}