P26-01-LEDGER: 原P26-01 全必要内容の台帳

2026-10-18 09:26:09 +09:00
parent da80360a60
commit f10907d8db
5 changed files with 139294 additions and 2510 deletions
@@ -12,13 +12,25 @@ build/owner-handoff/p26-repair3/ の ACTUAL_WHOLE_REVIEW.json、ACTUAL_OPUS_REPA

 現在の実承認は a13f7c0b791dd385ff8113c3d321c0e3fe7d7c94 の docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p04-01-owner-approval-20261018/D05_ACTUAL_HUMAN_APPROVAL.json、SHA256 cd365ded1b777a0327d090709f0a4161f5005562819183455d9f2e106fba3e96。チェッカーはこのgit objectのhashを照合し、4回答の原レコードを台帳に保存する。質問IDは call_5fa8987f83284eb58b685002499cb9df。破壊/完了、日付境界、停止理由、退出順序の承認であり、P04への製品採用・内容完成・P26受入ではない。D08/D09は未解決。

-## whole-unit対応と4修復
+## 修復5: 証拠のAR別帰属
+
+今回の変更前に build/owner-handoff/p26-support-attribution-repair/ACTUAL_OPUS_ASTRA_ATTRIBUTION_DIRECTION.json と ACTUAL_WHOLE_REVIEW_DA80360A.json を全文読了し、D05の上記4資料も再確認した。修復5は証拠帰属に限定する。
+
+結合した引用文のキーワードからpartialを付ける処理を削除した。SUPPORT_POLICYは証拠種別→許容ARの閉じた対応表である。関係状態は21ルートと感情3軸/盾最大値の明示状態・保存だけ、覗きは記録係/観察/証拠収集に関する列挙ARの停止中コンテナだけ、夜間は2 ARの欲求入力だけ、赤字は終端計算ARだけを支援する。人物のidentity/技能や任意のrelationship/route_action全域へは拡張しない。視点・角度・介入そのものを支援する証拠とはしない。
+
+各行のscoped_supportは対象AR・証拠種別・限定範囲・content_status=missingを明記する。unsupported_atomic_requirement_idsはその行で基盤支援がない残りのARを列挙する（用途行の既存placeholder/code-drawingは従来どおり別記）。L9は21ルートのコンテナだけpartialで、全エンド/図鑑/所要時間は未支援。L257とclause.productionは観察工程のコンテナだけpartialで、ボイス収録/実装を含む他ARは未支援。voice.all、endings全3行、encyclopedia.allはmissing、証拠なし。声に関するどのARも対応表に入れない。行数・AR対応・引用・制作数量は増減させない。
+
+verify_authorityはexpectedやcanonicalを呼ばず、提出された各claimのARと行の種類、固定出典・抜粋全文、支援/未支援ARの分割、状態と範囲文を検査する。有効なSHAでも無関係な証拠、無根拠なpartial、声への同一引用行の観察証拠の流用は拒否する。負例はmissingの音声/立ち絵/エンド/図鑑への証拠注入、混合行内の支援AR拡張、正しい夜間支援への無関係な証拠追加を含む。route、L65、L53の実際のpartialを正例にする。既存負例は維持し、AR削除負例だけ新しい分割フィールドも整合して削除する。
+
+矛盾した「no dedicated support established; …only」の連結を廃止した。任意LOWのL226はAR.ui.cut_duel/cut_defenseの対象外理由にP24 UIカットインを明記した。owner決定用content ARの追加分類は、既存の原典リンクと所有先を狭める別の判断が必要なため今回はdeferred。ownerは引き続き引用ARのprimary_packageに基づく追跡先で、専任制作担当の確定ではない。
+
+## whole-unit対応と残存不足

 | 対象 | 実際の記録・修復 | 残存不足 |
 | --- | --- | --- |
 | 全章 | chapters.all、原本内容行、対応AR | 章名・章数・順序・シーン列は未定義。仕様書章番号を物語章数に転用しない |
 | 7名×3ルート | 原名の21 route行、人物別AR、P19セルの版固定と関係状態ソース | 共通状態・保存のみpartial。固有イベント列・自然到達・台詞・素材・終点はmissing、D08未決 |
-| 全エンド | endings.all / bad / game_overとAR | 全集合/本数は未定義。赤字終端の処理はpartialで物語エンド制作とは別 |
+| 全エンド | endings.all / bad / game_overとAR | 全3行missing、全集合/本数は未定義。赤字終端の処理はoriginal.line.72の該当ARだけpartial |
 | 台詞/立ち絵/音声/図鑑 | 各総括行、原文個別行、人物/用途AR、P22全614枠 | 完成本文・画像・ボイス・項目集合の完成証拠なし。汎用BGM/UI音は声の代用にしない |
 | 原本欠落の修復 | original.line.13 / 53 / 65 / 196 / 221 / 222、各原文全文・行・SHAとAR | イベント/台詞/CG/音声/専用操作内容はmissing。個別場面数はundefined |
 | 独立網羅 | 原本テキストの内容語彙・節見出しとARドメイン/condition/source_anchorsから選択 | 機械的な保守的選択方針を明記し、独立レビューが原単位網羅を判定 |
@@ -34,7 +46,7 @@ build/owner-handoff/p26-repair3/ の ACTUAL_WHOLE_REVIEW.json、ACTUAL_OPUS_REPA

 scripts/relationship/original_relationship_state.gd の明示値検証と relationship_service.gd の保存コンテナを直接参照する。route行と対応する原文行はpartialであり、content_status=missingを別記する。更新・攻撃・閾値・固有物語を実装済みとはしない。

-scripts/special/peeping_room_service.gd:127–162 と autoload/simulation_runtime.gd:10860–10880 を直接引用する。停止・対象参照・証拠キー/保存の基盤はあるが、製品配置はBUILD_DEFINITION_PENDING_D04、記録はRECORDER_ELIGIBILITY_PENDING_D04_D08_P16で止まる。覗き/記録/脅迫/カメラを引用する行のpartialはこの基盤だけを指し、視界、専用画面、スクリーンショット、介入や制作イベントを証明しない。
+scripts/special/peeping_room_service.gd:127–162 と autoload/simulation_runtime.gd:10860–10880 を直接引用する。停止・対象参照・証拠キーの基盤はあるが、製品配置はBUILD_DEFINITION_PENDING_D04、記録はRECORDER_ELIGIBILITY_PENDING_D04_D08_P16で止まる。閉じた対応表にあるARのscoped_supportだけがこの基盤を指し、視界、専用画面、スクリーンショット、介入や制作イベントを証明しない。L13の自律観察/介入、L53の専用視点、L222の角度/介入にはこの証拠を帰属させない。

 scripts/guest/guest_service.gd:355–360 は夜間の欲求入力の切替のみ。L65のNTRイベント内容の制作証拠ではない。scripts/operations/operations_coordinator.gd:1183–1195 の赤字連続による終端計算は存在するが、完成シナリオ/画像/声ではない。L196の専用代物弁済イベントは現物制作証拠なしとしてmissing。数量/シーン列はundefinedのまま。

@@ -52,6 +64,8 @@ authorities()は提出行や旧監査の合否を使わず、BASELINE本文の

 このworkerはJSON/Markdownの生成処理と読取による実装確認だけを行った。p26-ledger / p26-negative / p26-source-binding、--check、--source-binding-only、unittestは実行していない。PASSは主張しない。正式試験はRunnerが契約の3コマンドを実行する。

+修復5の生成後の読取比較では762行、1309 AR処置、675関連ARを保持し、全行のID・引用・ARリンクは開始時と同一。全required_count/completed_countはnull。JSONの変更した最上位領域はrowsとatomic_dispositionsのみで、D05の4回答を含む他の領域は同一。JSONとMDはexpected/markdownによる決定的生成であり、試験実行結果ではない。生成後に変更したcheckerの独立検証と負例はRunnerでの実行待ち。
+
 ## 新Sと受入の残ゲート

 FROZEN_GAME_INPUT_PINS.json SHA256 6c778226a4cc6d0b0d682500759e7d4229c926a27bd2e247b00b9c3e5f1a2fb0 と、全1368 selected game inputs・settings・assets・tests・tools・marker・policy・engine・roster・329parse・default player identityの照合処理は保持する。docs helpersは対象ゲーム集合外。TASK_SPEC raw SHAは8026040345de6b7d06cfce40beac9150bfe9ad303d6b26c11bd94e66b1080b29、strip表現は1fedc9ade42a04722846daa9ac8ec26f821fb4efbce8dbbb53e3e76e31f38d02。
@@ -35,6 +35,45 @@ APPROVAL_COMMIT = 'a13f7c0b791dd385ff8113c3d321c0e3fe7d7c94'
 APPROVAL_PATH = PLAN + 'execution/p04-01-owner-approval-20261018/D05_ACTUAL_HUMAN_APPROVAL.json'
 APPROVAL_HASH = 'cd365ded1b777a0327d090709f0a4161f5005562819183455d9f2e106fba3e96'

+# Closed attribution policy: membership means only the named backend fragment,
+# never the whole AR, its content, or other ARs sharing its source line.
+SUPPORT_POLICY = {
+    'relationship-container': {
+        'ars': frozenset({'AR.relationship.three_emotions',
+                         'AR.relationship.affection_shield_max'} |
+                        {'AR.heroine.' + p + '.route.' + r for p, _ in PEOPLE for r in ROUTES}),
+        'sources': [('scripts/relationship/original_relationship_state.gd', None),
+                    ('scripts/relationship/relationship_service.gd', None)],
+        'scope': 'shared explicit relationship state/validation/save container only; no updates, attacks, thresholds, authored content or natural route completion'},
+    'peeping-container': {
+        'ars': frozenset({'AR.observation.recorder', 'AR.underground.observation',
+                         'AR.underground.blackmail', 'AR.route_action.observation_progress',
+                         'AR.ui.observation_camera_entry', 'AR.ui.observation_capture',
+                         'AR.schedule.B-14.3.observation'}),
+        'sources': [('scripts/special/peeping_room_service.gd', (127, 162)),
+                    ('autoload/simulation_runtime.gd', (10860, 10880))],
+        'scope': 'stopped room/target reference and fixture evidence-key container only; production placement/recorder eligibility pending; no view, camera UI, screenshot, intervention, transaction or authored content'},
+    'night-input': {
+        'ars': frozenset({'AR.events.ntr_night_peak', 'AR.guest.need_sexual_night_peak'}),
+        'sources': [('scripts/guest/guest_service.gd', (355, 360))],
+        'scope': 'night-dependent guest need input only; no event production or peak-frequency implementation'},
+    'bankruptcy-bookkeeping': {
+        'ars': frozenset({'AR.progression.three_deficits_gameover'}),
+        'sources': [('scripts/operations/operations_coordinator.gd', (1183, 1195))],
+        'scope': 'bankruptcy terminal bookkeeping only; no authored ending'},
+}
+
+
+def support_family(row):
+    # Content summaries cannot inherit support from neighbouring schedule ARs.
+    return (row['kind'] == 'route' or row['id'].startswith('original.line.') or
+            row['id'] in {'clause.route_rules', 'clause.production', 'clause.scope'})
+
+
+def support_pins(root, kind):
+    return [excerpt(root, path, *span) if span else source(root, path)
+            for path, span in SUPPORT_POLICY[kind]['sources']]
+

 def authorities(root):
    """Selection reads authority text, never generated rows or old audit statuses.
@@ -225,15 +264,15 @@ def expected(root):
    add('chapters.all', 'chapter', [(8,), (26,), (27,30), (256,)],
        'メインストーリー全章。原本の仕様書章番号をシナリオ章と混同しない。章名・章数・順序・場面一覧は未定義。', 'D08')
    add('endings.all', 'ending', [(9,), (135,)],
-        '全エンドを要求。個別エンドID・本数・到達条件は未定義。', 'D08')
+        '全エンドを要求。個別エンドID・本数・到達条件は未定義。', 'D08', 'missing')
    add('endings.bad', 'ending', [(135,)],
-        '特定バッドエンド確定時の敵/背景オブジェクト化。カテゴリのみ原本定義、対象人物/場面/数は未定義。', 'P26-02')
+        '特定バッドエンド確定時の敵/背景オブジェクト化。カテゴリのみ原本定義、対象人物/場面/数は未定義。', 'P26-02', 'missing')
    add('endings.game_over', 'ending', [(72,)],
        '赤字決算3回連続のゲームオーバー。物語エンド数への換算不可。', 'P26-02', 'missing',
-        [source(root, 'scripts/economy/economy_service.gd')],
+        [],
        '欠損: 経済処理の既存コードは存在するが終点のシナリオ・画像・音声・全受入を証明しない。')
    add('encyclopedia.all', 'encyclopedia', [(9,)],
-        '図鑑コンプ。対象集合・項目ID・解放条件・必要項目数は未定義。', 'D08')
+        '図鑑コンプ。対象集合・項目ID・解放条件・必要項目数は未定義。', 'D08', 'missing')
    add('dialogue.all', 'dialogue', [(155,), (230,), (256,)],
        '会話/イベント用台詞とシナリオ。本文・話者・行数・場面単位は未定義。UI通知文を完成脚本に数えない。', 'P26-02')
    add('portraits.all', 'portrait', [(160,161), (230,), (235,), (242,)],
@@ -312,7 +351,6 @@ def expected(root):
            'undefined', 'missing', reason='原本条件を保存。専用制作内容は欠損、場面ID・数量は未定義。下記AR所有先で残作業を追跡。')
    relationship_paths = ['scripts/relationship/original_relationship_state.gd',
                          'scripts/relationship/relationship_service.gd']
-    relation_pins = [source(root, p) for p in relationship_paths]
    # Direct source inspection is limited to explicit state/container support.
    # These excerpts never assert authored scenes, usable observation controls,
    # or a naturally reachable character route.
@@ -322,8 +360,6 @@ def expected(root):
    peep_runtime_pin = excerpt(root, 'autoload/simulation_runtime.gd', 10860, 10880)
    require('RECORDER_ELIGIBILITY_PENDING_D04_D08_P16' in peep_pin['text'] and
            'BUILD_DEFINITION_PENDING_D04' in peep_runtime_pin['text'], 'peeping backend boundary')
-    night_pin = excerpt(root, 'scripts/guest/guest_service.gd', 355, 360)
-    terminal_pin = excerpt(root, 'scripts/operations/operations_coordinator.gd', 1183, 1195)
    dispositions = {}
    for row in rows:
        cited = {n for c in row['citations'] for n in range(c['lines'][0], c['lines'][1] + 1)}
@@ -337,34 +373,21 @@ def expected(root):
        row['owner_assignment'] = 'original package deliverables; specific production assignee undefined'
        row['content_status'] = row['status']
        row['support_scope'] = 'no dedicated support established'
-        # Shared relationship model is genuine partial support, while content
-        # and unknown catalogs remain missing/undefined separately.
-        if row['kind'] == 'route' or row['id'] == 'clause.route_rules' or (
-                row['id'].startswith('original.line.') and any(
-                    a.startswith(('AR.relationship.', 'AR.route_action.', 'AR.heroine.')) for a in matches)):
-            row['evidence'] += relation_pins
+        row['scoped_support'] = []
+        for kind, policy in SUPPORT_POLICY.items():
+            supported = sorted(set(matches) & policy['ars']) if support_family(row) else []
+            if supported:
+                row['scoped_support'].append({'kind': kind, 'atomic_requirement_ids': supported,
+                    'scope': policy['scope'], 'content_status': 'missing'})
+                row['evidence'] += support_pins(root, kind)
+        supported_ids = {a for claim in row['scoped_support'] for a in claim['atomic_requirement_ids']}
+        row['unsupported_atomic_requirement_ids'] = sorted(set(matches) - supported_ids)
+        if row['scoped_support']:
            row['status'] = 'partial'
-            row['support_scope'] = 'shared relationship state/container only; no character-specific production or natural completion'
-            row['reason'] += ' 共通関係状態・保存の部分支援のみ。専用イベント/台詞/CG/ボイスは欠損。'
+            row['support_scope'] = '; '.join(c['scope'] for c in row['scoped_support'])
+            row['reason'] += ' scoped_supportに列挙したARの基盤断片のみpartial。他のARは未支援、全制作内容は欠損。'
        if row['id'].startswith('clause.'):
            row['reason'] += ' 所有先は引用ARのprimary_packageと原P単位定義。包括P26-03への割当はしない。'
-        if row['kind'] != 'route' and not row['id'].startswith('usage.'):
-            text = '\n'.join(c['text'] for c in row['citations'])
-            support, descriptions = [], []
-            if re.search(r'覗|マジックミラー|記録係|カメラ|スクリーンショット|脅迫', text):
-                support += [peep_pin, peep_runtime_pin]
-                descriptions.append('stopped room/reference/evidence container only; production placement/recorder eligibility pending; no view/camera/intervention/content')
-            if 'NTRイベント発生' in text:
-                support.append(night_pin)
-                descriptions.append('night-dependent guest need input only; no night NTR event production')
-            if 'ゲームオーバー' in text:
-                support.append(terminal_pin)
-                descriptions.append('bankruptcy terminal bookkeeping only; no authored ending')
-            if support:
-                row['status'] = 'partial'
-                row['evidence'] += support
-                row['support_scope'] += '; ' + '; '.join(descriptions)
-                row['reason'] += ' 引用ソースの部分機構のみ。内容状態と数量未定義を別記し、完成とは判定しない。'
    for identity, atom in atoms.items():
        linked = [r['id'] for r in rows if identity in r['atomic_requirement_ids']]
        dispositions[identity] = {
@@ -373,7 +396,9 @@ def expected(root):
            'rows': linked,
            'disposition': 'covered-by-row' if identity in relevant else 'out-of-scope-with-reason',
            'reason': ('原本条件・欠損は各行に記録。ARの旧監査合否は転記しない。'
-                       if identity in relevant else '原本内容行に結合しない追加施設契約/採用・財布条件、または内容語彙/対象節/内容ARドメインに該当しない独立メカニクス。製品受入は当該原P単位の責任。'),
+                       if identity in relevant else 'L226カットイン警告・決闘/防衛演出はP24 UIの所管。制作/受入済みを意味しない。'
+                       if identity in {'AR.ui.cut_duel', 'AR.ui.cut_defense'} else
+                       '原本内容行に結合しない追加施設契約/採用・財布条件、または内容語彙/対象節/内容ARドメインに該当しない独立メカニクス。製品受入は当該原P単位の責任。'),
            'owning_deliverables': owning_units(atom, packages)}
    approval_raw = blob(root, APPROVAL_COMMIT, APPROVAL_PATH)
    require(sha(approval_raw) == APPROVAL_HASH, 'published D05 approval')
@@ -416,7 +441,8 @@ def verify_authority(candidate, root):
        require(set(row) == {'id', 'kind', 'identity', 'citations', 'required_condition',
            'status', 'required_count', 'completed_count', 'evidence', 'missing', 'reason',
            'owner', 'atomic_requirement_ids', 'owner_deliverable_refs', 'owner_assignment',
-            'content_status', 'support_scope'}, 'closed row schema')
+            'content_status', 'support_scope', 'scoped_support',
+            'unsupported_atomic_requirement_ids'}, 'closed row schema')
        require(row['status'] in STATUSES, 'invalid row status')
        require(row['required_count'] is None and row['completed_count'] is None, 'invented quantity')
        require(type(row['atomic_requirement_ids']) is list, 'AR ID list')
@@ -437,8 +463,51 @@ def verify_authority(candidate, root):
        seen_atoms.update(ids)
        require(row['content_status'] in STATUSES and row['content_status'] != 'produced', 'unsupported content production')
        require(row['status'] != 'produced', 'partial support falsely produced')
-        if row['status'] == 'partial':
-            require(row['evidence'] and 'only' in row['support_scope'], 'unqualified partial support')
+        # Inspect submitted claims and pins directly, without expected() or a
+        # generated row. The policy is a normative compatibility table, not a
+        # keyword classifier. A valid hash alone cannot establish relevance.
+        claims = row['scoped_support']
+        require(type(claims) is list, 'support claims type')
+        claimed_ids, kinds, allowed_pins = set(), set(), []
+        for claim in claims:
+            require(set(claim) == {'kind', 'atomic_requirement_ids', 'scope', 'content_status'},
+                    'closed support claim')
+            kind = claim['kind']
+            require(kind in SUPPORT_POLICY and kind not in kinds, 'unknown/duplicate support kind')
+            policy = SUPPORT_POLICY[kind]
+            require(support_family(row), 'support incompatible with requirement family')
+            targets = claim['atomic_requirement_ids']
+            require(type(targets) is list and targets and len(targets) == len(set(targets)) and
+                    set(targets) <= set(ids) & policy['ars'], 'support incompatible with AR')
+            require(claim['scope'] == policy['scope'] and claim['content_status'] == 'missing',
+                    'support scope/content mismatch')
+            kinds.add(kind)
+            claimed_ids.update(targets)
+            for path, span in policy['sources']:
+                pin = source(root, path)
+                if span:
+                    pin.update(lines=list(span), text='\n'.join(
+                        read_source(root, path).decode().splitlines()[span[0]-1:span[1]]))
+                allowed_pins.append(pin)
+        require(row['unsupported_atomic_requirement_ids'] == sorted(set(ids) - claimed_ids),
+                'unsupported AR partition')
+        require((row['status'] == 'partial') == bool(claims),
+                'route support/content distinction' if row['kind'] == 'route' else 'unqualified partial support')
+        if claims:
+            require(row['support_scope'] == '; '.join(c['scope'] for c in claims) and
+                    row['content_status'] == 'missing', 'support summary/content mismatch')
+        else:
+            require(row['support_scope'] == 'no dedicated support established', 'unsupported scope text')
+        if not row['id'].startswith('usage.'):
+            if row['kind'] == 'route':
+                allowed_pins.insert(0, dict(source(root, P19), cell=[
+                    row['identity']['character_id'], row['identity']['route_id']]))
+            require(encoded(row['evidence']) == encoded(allowed_pins), 'unrelated or unscoped support evidence')
+        else:
+            require(not claims, 'usage cannot inherit backend support')
+        if row['kind'] in {'voice', 'ending', 'encyclopedia'}:
+            require(row['status'] == row['content_status'] == 'missing' and not row['evidence'],
+                    'unsupported content family')
        for pin in row['evidence']:
            require(encoded({k: pin[k] for k in ('path', 'sha256', 'bytes', 'anchor', 'anchor_path')}) ==
                    encoded(source(root, pin['path'])), 'row evidence integrity')
@@ -497,6 +566,8 @@ def markdown(document):
            '- 状態: ' + row['status'], '- 所管: ' + row['owner'],
            '- 内容状態: ' + row['content_status'], '- 部分支援範囲: ' + row['support_scope'],
            '- AR: ' + encoded(row['atomic_requirement_ids']),
+            '- AR別部分支援（列挙ARの基盤断片のみ、制作内容はmissing）: ' + encoded(row['scoped_support']),
+            '- 基盤支援なしのAR: ' + encoded(row['unsupported_atomic_requirement_ids']),
            '- 所管単位: ' + encoded(row['owner_deliverable_refs']) + ' (固定参照の原P単位定義を参照)',
            '- 条件: ' + (row['required_condition'] if isinstance(row['required_condition'], str)
                else encoded(row['required_condition'])), '- 理由: ' + row['reason'],
@@ -145,6 +145,11 @@ class LedgerTests(unittest.TestCase):
            for row in d['rows']:
                if identity in row['atomic_requirement_ids']:
                    row['atomic_requirement_ids'].remove(identity)
+                    if identity in row['unsupported_atomic_requirement_ids']:
+                        row['unsupported_atomic_requirement_ids'].remove(identity)
+                    for claim in row['scoped_support']:
+                        if identity in claim['atomic_requirement_ids']:
+                            claim['atomic_requirement_ids'].remove(identity)
                    atoms = audit.authorities(ROOT)[2]
                    owners = sorted({atoms[a]['primary_package'] for a in row['atomic_requirement_ids']})
                    row.update(owner='/'.join(owners) if owners else 'undefined', owner_deliverable_refs=owners)
@@ -173,6 +178,62 @@ class LedgerTests(unittest.TestCase):
        self.independent_reject(lambda d: next(r for r in d['rows'] if r['id'].startswith('usage.') and r['evidence'])
            ['evidence'][0].update(sha256='0'*64), 'row evidence integrity')

+    def test_closed_support_attribution_independent_controls_and_injection(self):
+        rows = {r['id']: r for r in self.submitted['rows']}
+        audit.verify_authority(self.submitted, ROOT)
+        for identity, kind in [('route.anri.love', 'relationship-container'),
+                               ('original.line.65', 'night-input'),
+                               ('original.line.53', 'peeping-container')]:
+            with self.subTest(control=identity):
+                self.assertEqual(rows[identity]['status'], 'partial')
+                self.assertEqual(rows[identity]['content_status'], 'missing')
+                self.assertIn(kind, {c['kind'] for c in rows[identity]['scoped_support']})
+        for identity in ('voice.all', 'portraits.all', 'endings.all', 'encyclopedia.all'):
+            self.assertEqual(rows[identity]['status'], 'missing')
+            self.assertEqual(rows[identity]['evidence'], [])
+            # Valid pins + the old textual qualifier must not confer support.
+            def inject(d):
+                row = next(r for r in d['rows'] if r['id'] == identity)
+                row.update(status='partial', support_scope='backend only',
+                           evidence=copy.deepcopy(rows['original.line.53']['evidence']))
+            self.independent_reject(inject, 'unqualified partial support')
+        # Even a well-formed observation claim linked on the SAME source line
+        # cannot be attached to a voice summary.
+        def voice_claim(d):
+            voice = next(r for r in d['rows'] if r['id'] == 'voice.all')
+            mixed = rows['original.line.257']
+            for key in ('status', 'support_scope', 'scoped_support', 'evidence'):
+                voice[key] = copy.deepcopy(mixed[key])
+        self.independent_reject(voice_claim, 'support incompatible with requirement family')
+        # An original-clause row is an eligible family, but its debt-settlement
+        # ARs still cannot receive a peeping-container claim.
+        def content_claim(d):
+            row = next(r for r in d['rows'] if r['id'] == 'original.line.196')
+            donor = rows['original.line.53']
+            for key in ('status', 'support_scope', 'scoped_support', 'evidence'):
+                row[key] = copy.deepcopy(donor[key])
+            row['scoped_support'][0]['atomic_requirement_ids'] = row['atomic_requirement_ids'][:]
+            row['unsupported_atomic_requirement_ids'] = []
+        self.assertEqual(rows['original.line.196']['status'], 'missing')
+        self.independent_reject(content_claim, 'support incompatible with AR')
+        # Mixed rows retain missing voice/end/encyclopedia ARs; an attacker
+        # cannot expand a valid backend claim to those ARs.
+        for identity, atom in [('original.line.257', 'AR.schedule.B-14.3.voice_record'),
+                               ('clause.production', 'AR.asset.character_voice'),
+                               ('original.line.9', 'AR.progression.all_endings'),
+                               ('original.line.9', 'AR.progression.encyclopedia_complete')]:
+            with self.subTest(mixed=identity, atom=atom):
+                self.assertIn(atom, rows[identity]['unsupported_atomic_requirement_ids'])
+                def expand(d):
+                    row = next(r for r in d['rows'] if r['id'] == identity)
+                    row['scoped_support'][0]['atomic_requirement_ids'].append(atom)
+                    row['unsupported_atomic_requirement_ids'].remove(atom)
+                self.independent_reject(expand, 'support incompatible with AR')
+        # A valid claim does not license an additional, unrelated pinned file.
+        self.independent_reject(lambda d: next(r for r in d['rows'] if r['id']=='original.line.65')
+            ['evidence'].extend(copy.deepcopy(rows['original.line.53']['evidence'])),
+            'unrelated or unscoped support evidence')
+

 if __name__ == '__main__':
    parser = argparse.ArgumentParser()