Correct facility enumeration and retain EQ continuation evidence

docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/DESKTOP_EQ_S3B_REPAIR_DECISION_R02.json

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"action":"request-repair","task_id":"P28-02-EQ","reason":"Stage S3b run 7da027a85548460bb008b562a79a52ae (worker PID 32210 exit 0, Root exec 63195 exit 2) returned a formal blocked status that is not the planned checkpoint: EQ_S3B_STAGE_PLAN.txt E4-1 named mvp_content_catalog as the facility enumeration source, but scripts/data/mvp_content_catalog.gd:26-31 DEFAULT_PATHS lists only 4 person kinds, so a scan would yield an empty list and a false not-placeable NA. Root confirmed in source that facilities are registered into runtime.definition_registry at autoload/simulation_runtime.gd:446-447 from the FacilityCatalog paths, that scripts/core/definition_registry.gd get_facility_ids() -> Array[StringName] and get_all_facilities() are the real API, and that preview_build_facility uses the same registry. The worker correctly refused to prove NA from an empty list. This is a reference error in the Desktop plan, not a product or spec change and not a worker failure. Nothing was implemented and no tests were added; the only change is a PROGRESS addition, and all code, the 91 tests and earlier raw are unchanged. Root preserved 39 files and 6 raw files at retained-s3b-7da027a-r01/RETURN.json SHA 4961d36957bf14b9ad05d3fcbc162ad30e971e7dde2bae18fce6bc5eb18b3e1e; earlier successes are not counted as this run's tests. State: blocked, repairs 6, no S, no active run. Request the normal repair (blocked, repairs 6, to repair_ready, repairs 7) so the same W continues S3b under EQ_S3B_STAGE_PLAN.txt as corrected in E4-1 only by EQ_S3B_STAGE_PLAN_R02.txt. SPEC, TASK, the 6 conditions, eq/references, eq/registration, clarifications r01, r02 and r03, the staged plans, the S3 plans and the rest of S3b are unchanged; the old plan, decisions and run are kept as history. Decided by Claude Opus 5.5 in the Desktop control session (message 336); not a CLI commander result."}

docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/DESKTOP_EQ_S3B_RUN_DECISION_R02.json

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"action":"run","task_id":"P28-02-EQ","reason":"Supersedes DESKTOP_EQ_S3B_RUN_DECISION.json, which is kept unchanged as history. Use only after Root verifies through the normal gates: repair_ready, repairs 7, no S submitted, no active run, and the S1, S2 and S3a files still present unchanged in the W. Run repair 7 of P28-02-EQ once on the same W from base 2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988 with the single worker codex gpt-6-astra, doing only stage S3b as defined in EQ_S3B_STAGE_PLAN.txt and corrected in E4-1 only by EQ_S3B_STAGE_PLAN_R02.txt. Deliver both S3b plans in full as part of the one supplementary key, together with both S3 plans, both staged plans and this decision; clarifications r01, r02 and r03 stay read-only in build/eq-staged-readonly-r04. Start by reading eq/PROGRESS.md, including the run 7da027a entry, and eq/IMPLEMENTATION.md, including the S4 binding requirements, and reuse the S1/S2/S3a types, paths, schema, API and code without redesign. E4-1 correction: in both R and O, take candidates from that PID's runtime.definition_registry.get_facility_ids(), sorted by text ID, scan cells in (x, y, z) lexical order with rotation 0, judge each pair only with the public preview_build_facility, and submit the first placeable pair through submit_command(&\"build_facility\", {definition_id, origin, rotation}). Save the raw enumerated list and count, the sorted list and rule, the cell range rule, every tried candidate with its full preview result, the chosen candidate with its submit and command result, and any non-application reason. NA is allowed only when the real list is non-empty and every pair is not placeable; an empty list is a failure, and a false NA from an empty or wrong source is forbidden. NA is never PASS, no facility values are invented, and nothing is built outside this path. Everything else in S3b is unchanged: E4 paths 2 to 5, E5 over all 4 targets by 2 locations by 2 directions, full typed state and event records, the latest_snapshot aliasing (:12617-12621) recorded as an existing defect and never as PASS, the listed check_eq.py rules and negative tests plus the r02 E4-1 rejections, and keeping E3, the 91 existing test bodies and the failure history except for fixes a failing test requires. Run the engine-free python3 test_eq.py until every test passes, save the raw output, update PROGRESS.md, and end S3b with formal status blocked and the finding 'stage S3b complete (not a failure; next is S4)'. Do not submit. No engine, no git write or commit, no product change, no full regression; SPEC, TASK, eq/references and eq/registration stay unchanged. Ordinary implementation choices are recorded without stopping; block only for undecided matters affecting original product spec, values, permissions, billing or original acceptance. The remaining order is S4 (driver and verify) and submission, then Root native on the exact S in 7 phases, then both validations, then a fresh independent Opus review of all 6 conditions, then the normal prepare, candidate qualification, approval, integration and final; the OPT whole-unit gate follows later. No original credit (23/88, 4/30); the 900-second timeout is unchanged. Quota fallback only on structured provider quota, once, same role, Antigravity claude-opus-5-5-high; any other failure is blocked. Decided by Claude Opus 5.5 in the Desktop control session (message 336); not a CLI commander result."}

docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3B_R02_STARTED_2549CF7.json

@@ -0,0 +1,80 @@
+{
+  "at_jst": "2026-10-21T09:15:42.458566+09:00",
+  "plan_id": "P28-02",
+  "project": "the-tree-p28-02-eq",
+  "task": "P28-02-EQ",
+  "base": "2549cf7d6992560b850bbd11934e3c14b39a1988",
+  "stage": "S3b",
+  "revision": "facility enumeration source correction r02",
+  "state_at_observation": "implementing",
+  "repairs": 7,
+  "submitted": null,
+  "actual_run": {
+    "id": "c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4",
+    "task_id": "P28-02-EQ",
+    "role": "implementer",
+    "service": "codex",
+    "status": "running",
+    "pid": 34943,
+    "started": 1792541665.953645,
+    "finished": null,
+    "exit_code": null,
+    "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p28-02-eq/runs/c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4"
+  },
+  "actual_process_observation": "34943 34920 01:17 Ss   /Applications/ChatGPT.app/Contents/Resources/codex-cli/bin/../CodexCLI.app/Contents/MacOS/codex",
+  "root_exec_session": 18378,
+  "prior_incomplete_return": {
+    "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/retained-s3b-7da027a-r01/RETURN.json",
+    "bytes": 35937,
+    "sha256": "4961d36957bf14b9ad05d3fcbc162ad30e971e7dde2bae18fce6bc5eb18b3e1e"
+  },
+  "prior_return_source_join": {
+    "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/ROOT_S3B_RETURN_7DA027A.json",
+    "bytes": 2104,
+    "sha256": "f187c139214382b2e0a0bbdb45b1e5bb1dda4914531f79c21e5fb661d8846634"
+  },
+  "prior_run_implemented_code": false,
+  "prior_run_executed_tests": false,
+  "prior_local91_belongs_to_S3a": true,
+  "actual_Opus_materials": [
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3B_STAGE_PLAN_R02.txt",
+      "bytes": 5023,
+      "sha256": "9a26f47012e51ed23eb03e539fc5c4734e4d41c09ce37a21a18b4ac8a77a5f4c"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/DESKTOP_EQ_S3B_REPAIR_DECISION_R02.json",
+      "bytes": 1877,
+      "sha256": "bbdca07e1d9aee7df8e0d1599b230628a3412c14ed60847761666510b4129bf9"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/DESKTOP_EQ_S3B_RUN_DECISION_R02.json",
+      "bytes": 3417,
+      "sha256": "2fcf7035a1a729416fe236397fa0373b1479218e6786508c6ac38f7fcc902c29"
+    }
+  ],
+  "actual_Opus_session": "local_a7f85421-3eed-4482-8030-c0dca669573a",
+  "actual_Opus_response": 338,
+  "origin_note": "Unmodified real decisions label previous message336. Actual corrected response338 followed request337.",
+  "normal_repair_job": "555e77d1a5dd4b92abaac005a38a7a49",
+  "normal_repair_succeeded": true,
+  "normal_RUN_input": {
+    "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/actual-desktop-EQ-S3B-RUN-input-r08/RECORDED.json",
+    "bytes": 242,
+    "sha256": "f79dd224fc020db81026e57c25bdf2a973238a28a3b58230a8593556098101c6"
+  },
+  "actual_context": {
+    "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p28-02-root-control-r01/eq-staged-s3b-owner-run-input-r08/RUN_STARTED.json",
+    "bytes": 795,
+    "sha256": "5e99973809c6e2bd66025d3020bf3f144bafdd37466bed8d2c807413c016578c"
+  },
+  "all39_current_retained_files_verified_before_retry": true,
+  "formal_EQ_accepted": false,
+  "original_credit": 0,
+  "original_completed": 23,
+  "original_total": 88,
+  "packages_completed": 4,
+  "packages_total": 30,
+  "partial_credit": false,
+  "next": "Follow actual S3b-r02 run c056b928052a493db734593026d471b4/PID34943/rootexec18378, no duplicate. On terminal return preserve actual code/raw and join actual unit output, then actual Desktop Opus S4 judgment. S4/submission/native7/both validations/fresh independent Opus all6/normal final remain; no original credit."
+}

docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p28-02/EQ_S3B_STAGE_PLAN_R02.txt

@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
+EQ_S3B_STAGE_PLAN r02（P28-02-EQ 段階 S3b。EQ_S3B_STAGE_PLAN（r01）は、そのまま有効。この r02 は、r01 の E4 の経路 1 の「引数の選び方」（施設の定義の列挙元）だけを置き換える。SPEC、TASK、6条件、eq/references、eq/registration、補足 r01/r02/r03、段階の計画 r01/r02、S3 の計画 r01/r02 は変更しない）
+
+0. 訂正の理由（計画の参照の誤り。製品・仕様の変更ではない）
+- r01 は、施設の定義の一覧を mvp_content_catalog から取るとしていた。しかし scripts/data/mvp_content_catalog.gd:26-31 の DEFAULT_PATHS は人物の4種だけで、施設を含まない。そこから列挙すると一覧が空になり、「配置できる組が無い」という NA が誤って成立してしまう。
+- 施設の定義は、autoload/simulation_runtime.gd:446-447 で、FacilityCatalog の FACILITY_PATHS、INFRASTRUCTURE_FACILITY_PATHS、RESCUE_FACILITY_PATHS、ORIGINAL_FACILITY_PATHS、TRANSPORT_FACILITY_PATHS から runtime.definition_registry に登録される。preview_build_facility（:7660）も、同じ definition_registry.get_facility を使う。
+- run 7da027a85548460bb008b562a79a52ae の worker は、この誤りを指摘し、空の一覧を NA にせず blocked で返した。これは正しい判断であり、失敗ではない。
+
+1. E4 の経路 1 の引数の選び方（r01 の該当の箇条を置き換える）
+- 列挙元: R と O のそれぞれで、その PID の runtime の definition_registry.get_facility_ids()（scripts/core/definition_registry.gd:68-69。Array[StringName]）。R と O の両方とも、元の実際の施設の registry から候補を取る。別の catalog、固定の ID の一覧、R の結果での O の代用は使わない。
+- 順序: 取得した ID を、文字列としての ID の順序（String(id) の昇順。Python 側の記録は Unicode の code point の順序）に並べる。registry の登録の順序は、取得した生の一覧として別に記録する。
+- cell の走査: r01 のとおり、(x, y, z) の辞書順。走査の範囲は、その版の世界の公開の寸法から、固定の規則で決め、その規則と範囲を記録する。rotation は 0 に固定する（他の値は試さない）。
+- 判定: 製品の公開の SimulationRuntime.preview_build_facility(definition_id, origin, rotation) だけを使う。ID の順序の外側のループ、cell の順序の内側のループで、最初に配置できると返った組を選ぶ。
+- 実行: 選んだ組で submit_command(&"build_facility", {definition_id, origin, rotation})（:476、:305、:7717-7720）を submit する。記録の時点（submit の直後と、advance_minutes(1) の後）は r01 のとおり。
+
+2. 保存する記録（R と O のそれぞれ）
+- get_facility_ids() の生の一覧（登録の順序）と、その件数。
+- 並べた後の一覧と、並べ方の規則。
+- cell の走査の規則と範囲。
+- 試した各候補（definition_id、origin、rotation）と、preview_build_facility の戻り値の全体（typed tree）。試行の件数が多い場合も、全件を記録する（省略しない）。
+- 選んだ候補と、その submit の戻り値と、command の結果。
+- 適用しなかった場合の理由。
+
+3. NA の条件
+- NA にしてよいのは、get_facility_ids() の実際の一覧が空でなく、走査の範囲の全ての組で preview_build_facility が配置できないと返した場合だけ。そのときは、上の 2 の全ての記録とともに、理由つきの NA とする。
+- 一覧が空の場合は NA にせず、registry の取得の誤りとして失敗にし、その事実を記録する。間違った列挙元や空の一覧からの NA（false NA）は禁止する。
+- NA を PASS として数えない。施設の値を作らない。この経路の外で建設しない。
+- check_eq.py に、次の拒否を加える: 列挙元が definition_registry.get_facility_ids() 以外であること、空の一覧での NA、preview の記録が無い候補の選択、試行の記録の欠落、並べ方の規則の違反、R と O で列挙元が違うこと。
+
+4. 変更しないこと
+- E4 の経路 2〜5、E5 の 4×2×2、全ての状態とイベントの typed tree での記録、既存の aliasing の不具合としての記録、S1/S2/S3a の型・path・schema・API・code の再利用、E3 と既存の91件の試験の本体と失敗の履歴（失敗した試験が求める修正を除く）、engine を使わない python3 test_eq.py の全件 PASS と生出力の保存、PROGRESS.md の更新、正式な JSON の status を blocked にし findings を「段階 S3b 完了（失敗ではない。次は S4）」とすること、提出しないこと、engine・git の書込み・製品の変更・全回帰をしないこと。いずれも r01 のとおり。
+- 通常の実装上の判断は、記録して進める。