{
  "review_date_jst": "2026-10-02",
  "reviewer": "atomic_requirements independent task",
  "review_mode": "read-only code and retained evidence audit",
  "production_edits": 0,
  "new_godot_runs": 0,
  "source_head": "285528b7a3b1b46a2a67af5aa90d9085539b42f4",
  "reviewed_source_sha256": {
    "scripts/core/save_service.gd": "7c107a509b3afccb478ba89d051fbaa9a8c93165326fac8e4cef2249c05879d0",
    "scripts/core/simulation_snapshot.gd": "fc528a3d1db1f439c10f70d6cba2f72bd65abc0d3866eb8b582df60918af0adf",
    "autoload/simulation_runtime.gd": "d3ad4aab6ded19eb137c5494481cc7333e846746a25b18dbad3c8b663e9f6b72",
    "tests/s6/test_save_preflight.gd": "49e24247649839b6f50d19b2284368efb7f8f8b189c5010491ad428e97c1c8b9"
  },
  "focused_evidence": {
    "checks": 485,
    "suites": 7,
    "all_passed_verified": true,
    "logs": [
      {
        "test": "tests/s6/test_save_preflight.gd",
        "exit_code": 0,
        "passed": true,
        "checks": 128,
        "seconds": 3.15,
        "log": "tests__s6__test_save_preflight.gd-r02.log",
        "log_sha256": "171e2af4cdd6c9d00928110642f20de6d678f300947d16b53e4485f4988206c9",
        "completion_check_counts": [
          128
        ],
        "completion_matches": true,
        "passed_verified": true
      },
      {
        "test": "tests/s6/test_save_operations.gd",
        "exit_code": 0,
        "passed": true,
        "checks": 127,
        "seconds": 2.79,
        "log": "tests__s6__test_save_operations.gd-r02.log",
        "log_sha256": "c353636c82f54e49a88ab56ca000c14a78687921e5cc5ceeea8982a2275ed2c9",
        "completion_check_counts": [
          127
        ],
        "completion_matches": true,
        "passed_verified": true
      },
      {
        "test": "tests/s6/test_runtime_save_lifecycle.gd",
        "exit_code": 0,
        "passed": true,
        "checks": 96,
        "seconds": 6.68,
        "log": "tests__s6__test_runtime_save_lifecycle.gd-r02.log",
        "log_sha256": "6ab68137561c286f85cfb1b7f970023207659cb061f8ba1db41e3ed1f1a33157",
        "completion_check_counts": [
          96
        ],
        "completion_matches": true,
        "passed_verified": true
      },
      {
        "test": "tests/run_tests.gd",
        "exit_code": 0,
        "passed": true,
        "checks": 73,
        "seconds": 1.13,
        "log": "tests__run_tests.gd-r02.log",
        "log_sha256": "91ecdbe39f081ef6124499b9cec042600e7154d72c89f029298966aa560606ab",
        "completion_check_counts": [
          73
        ],
        "completion_matches": true,
        "passed_verified": true
      },
      {
        "test": "tests/transport/test_transport_save.gd",
        "exit_code": 0,
        "passed": true,
        "checks": 29,
        "seconds": 1.7,
        "log": "tests__transport__test_transport_save.gd-r02.log",
        "log_sha256": "f0d51dfd583cd9b08d19790a39fedc9169c8802cab72f7817d9ecfa40fe93306",
        "completion_check_counts": [
          29
        ],
        "completion_matches": true,
        "passed_verified": true
      },
      {
        "test": "tests/ui/test_dimension_migration_ui.gd",
        "exit_code": 0,
        "passed": true,
        "checks": 12,
        "seconds": 2.33,
        "log": "tests__ui__test_dimension_migration_ui.gd-r02.log",
        "log_sha256": "db9f3e78c7670558b9871c1c78abbad8be27bb45fd8d3c79e7535df4d3adfe4d",
        "completion_check_counts": [
          12
        ],
        "completion_matches": true,
        "passed_verified": true
      },
      {
        "test": "tests/supply/test_supply_save_migration.gd",
        "exit_code": 0,
        "passed": true,
        "checks": 20,
        "seconds": 1.18,
        "log": "tests__supply__test_supply_save_migration.gd-r02.log",
        "log_sha256": "b26de7e09b864e70fc36822dec40851ef08a056404e25373a9c1d6e26d45211d",
        "completion_check_counts": [
          20
        ],
        "completion_matches": true,
        "passed_verified": true
      }
    ],
    "source_map_count": 318,
    "source_map_drift_paths": [
      "tests/performance/test_digest_performance.gd"
    ],
    "changed_files_pins_match": true
  },
  "new_difference_induced_major_findings": 0,
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "SFR-01",
      "priority": 1,
      "state": "candidate_only_static_reproduction_path",
      "preexisting": true,
      "file": "scripts/core/save_service.gd",
      "line": 932,
      "symbol": "_reconcile_interrupted_formal_save",
      "condition": "identifiable unsupported formal version + valid transaction marker + current tmp/bak",
      "effect": "formal package deleted/replaced by old backup before unsupported-version rejection",
      "affected_entries": [
        "load_snapshot",
        "load_with_recovery",
        "inspect_recovery_candidates",
        "migrate_save",
        "load_recovery_candidate"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SFR-02",
      "priority": 2,
      "state": "candidate_only_static_reproduction_path",
      "preexisting": true,
      "file": "scripts/core/save_service.gd",
      "line": 334,
      "symbol": "_load_recovery_candidate_impl",
      "condition": "explicit backup selection + stale marker/tmp, formal either present or missing",
      "effect": "reconcile may delete tmp/marker or promote tmp before nominal read_only result"
    }
  ],
  "candidate_artifact": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p03-recovery-readonly-candidate/candidate_receipt.json",
  "adoption_recommendation": "Reproduce and verify both preservation defects in an isolated candidate stage before claiming P03 acceptance; no main edits during ongoing full regression.",
  "all_p03_accepted": false,
  "full157_regression_result_included": false,
  "limitations": [
    "128 preflight does not combine unknown formal with valid marker/current backup",
    "256 MiB is a serialized world limit, not total peak memory",
    "inclusive upper-size test stops at manifest mismatch, not successful full-size decompression",
    "20000-cell measurement is world-only, not full Runtime acceptance",
    "new candidate has not been executed"
  ],
  "report_sha256": "57de52db51a6b0b3dcbcf20f6df3a825b83ba2d9a9a7707e9bab7026cb3fc6c6",
  "existing_contract_static_review": {
    "save_operations_lines": [
      349,
      450
    ],
    "runtime_save_lifecycle_lines": [
      170,
      200,
      230,
      380
    ],
    "preserved": [
      "registry continuity and purity",
      "current schema rejection",
      "registered legacy migration and exact original backup",
      "failed migration original preservation",
      "current-format interrupted migration backup/promotion/rollback",
      "current-format normal recovery"
    ],
    "strengthened": [
      "unsupported recognizable formal never replaced before rejection",
      "explicit candidate read does not reconcile",
      "registered legacy failed source keeps normal stale artifacts"
    ],
    "candidate_execution_verified": false,
    "candidate_driver_operations": 8,
    "candidate_foreign_shapes": 5
  }
}