TheTree_mock/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/atomic_semantic_review.json

{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "reviewed_at_jst": "2026-10-02T01:29:36.666245+09:00",
  "reviewer": "/root/assets_platform_audit",
  "review_scope": "independent read-only semantic review: source conditions, duplicate identities, encyclopedia/endings, named facility scope, undefined content",
  "review_limits": "This is a register review, not implementation or game acceptance. Final denominator and final catalog coverage remain unresolved.",
  "reviewed_files": {
    "atomic_requirements.json": "82f4b4c0fbf32bd296a83e6c565dd2b64d2449336c9ada7be11742761d4a5cfb",
    "atomic_denominator_freeze.json": "467e960eb0fe47241edb217f5fa2044f2de304441daf9e51a7b0cb46ffa9194d",
    "source_atomic_coverage.json": "2ab7b9e6a2536ef248d4f7ccd695bf75a082b47018aca7a5a1b6b706fe1907bc",
    "atomic_requirements_validation.json": "8dc300b099cfd90fda862f138b6a528d01e9c488a2c67fe07a00a92a70f99175",
    "build_atomic_requirements.py": "6d6ea9e4216372dbd0f9fed3f885a4481b21a3f539a26f64cf98a6830af984c5"
  },
  "source_pins": {
    "docs/traceability/original/BASELINE.txt": {
      "expected": "75e4bdbdeb379c9269553f0c776bdb9cc96e01f2d6aa5ca650d132c63a8aeb1a",
      "observed": "75e4bdbdeb379c9269553f0c776bdb9cc96e01f2d6aa5ca650d132c63a8aeb1a",
      "matches": true
    },
    "docs/traceability/original/requirements.json": {
      "expected": "eb8ec13aefc3a814644280ebf4dcf8f9c8965c6e2ab24b33f69be65f58b98a57",
      "observed": "eb8ec13aefc3a814644280ebf4dcf8f9c8965c6e2ab24b33f69be65f58b98a57",
      "matches": true
    },
    "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/decisions.json": {
      "expected": "ad0673051b0fa601e525f05128e0b11e2dddd9d4bae6a3e0170bbf47da35efe9",
      "observed": "ad0673051b0fa601e525f05128e0b11e2dddd9d4bae6a3e0170bbf47da35efe9",
      "matches": true
    },
    "docs/traceability/original/audit-2026-09-29/TRACEABILITY.md": {
      "expected": "caed024fe5b35a4636975646a32bb3f0960e24eabfb5e9688d0d78f8592d5b5f",
      "observed": "caed024fe5b35a4636975646a32bb3f0960e24eabfb5e9688d0d78f8592d5b5f",
      "matches": true
    },
    "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.initial.md": {
      "expected": "f9cb3f61e4cb020e37f792c615dfbd4794763884a8ec528de14c3469cf4e5248",
      "observed": "f9cb3f61e4cb020e37f792c615dfbd4794763884a8ec528de14c3469cf4e5248",
      "matches": true
    }
  },
  "checks": {
    "feature_atom_count_1291": true,
    "historical_schedule_atom_count_18": true,
    "denominator_ids_unique_and_match_feature_rows": true,
    "freeze_matches_register": true,
    "source_pins_current": true,
    "source_condition_coverage_all_258_lines": true,
    "source_feature_groups_71_schedule_groups_4": true,
    "chapter10_facilities_30": true,
    "chapter10_all_thirteen_value_fields_present": true,
    "chapter10_visual_slots_360_present": true,
    "heroines_7_and_route_usages_21_present": true,
    "17_approved_refinement_merges": true,
    "no_final_content_denominator_claim": true,
    "all_unaccepted_evidence_retained": true,
    "supplement_applicability_open_expansion_retained": true,
    "external_validator_reports_no_errors": true
  },
  "all_scoped_checks_passed": true,
  "known_condition_denominator": 1291,
  "historical_schedule_atoms_excluded_from_game_percent": 18,
  "final_denominator_approved": false,
  "game_acceptance_added": false,
  "requirement_files_modified_by_review": false,
  "count_semantics": {
    "thirty_facility_value_fields": 390,
    "thirty_facility_visual_usage_slots": 360,
    "known_heroine_route_usages": 21,
    "route_usage_is_exact_cg_file_count": false,
    "visual_usage_slot_is_unique_image_file": false
  },
  "exact_condition_text_duplicates_reviewed": [
    {
      "condition": "対象施設は原本指定の観察機能に対応する。",
      "ids": [
        "AR.facility.adult_private_room.observation",
        "AR.facility.public_bath.observation",
        "AR.facility.vip_suite.observation"
      ],
      "review": "different facility identity; do not merge"
    }
  ],
  "missing_checks": {
    "facility_fields": [],
    "visual_slots": [],
    "routes": []
  },
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "ASR-01",
      "priority": "required_before_final_coverage",
      "topic": "chapter10 finite thirty versus all named facilities and infrastructure",
      "source_lines": [
        46,
        49,
        50,
        86,
        176,
        177,
        190,
        191,
        192,
        193,
        248
      ],
      "finding": "Chapter10 thirty-facility field and visual expansion is complete as a finite subset. The original additionally names reception/settlement, vault, purchasing, dark bank, corridors, stairs, staff doors, linen chute and hidden doors. Their normal features exist as atoms, but applicability of F01-F10 and Lv/front/back/exterior/interior visuals is unresolved.",
      "resolution": "Retain open applicability expansion; do not certify final all-facility field/art coverage, and do not automatically infer twelve slots or thirteen fields for every infrastructure item.",
      "current_state": "recorded in updated open_expansion_register; final denominator remains unresolved"
    },
    {
      "id": "ASR-02",
      "priority": "acceptance_operating_note",
      "topic": "set contracts and finite known usage identities versus unspecified artwork quantities",
      "source_lines": [
        9,
        30,
        125,
        235,
        242,
        243,
        245,
        252
      ],
      "finding": "The seven identities and twenty-one route usages are explicit. Main portrait and other-route tone asset atoms remain set contracts: every required known identity and both stated tone axes must pass. Individual scene, expression, outfit, voice and CG counts are not defined. A main portrait set or route flag alone cannot certify actual content.",
      "resolution": "Maintain per-usage asset/content mapping under D08/D09; require all members and all source tone axes. Split finite known usage assertions during future denominator revision if independently adjudicated; do not invent asset counts or equate twenty-one route usages to twenty-one CG files.",
      "current_state": "open D08/D09 and content-not-produced rejection are retained; no denominator revision requested in this review"
    },
    {
      "id": "ASR-03",
      "priority": "required_before_full_clear_acceptance",
      "topic": "all endings and encyclopedia complete",
      "source_lines": [
        9
      ],
      "finding": "AR.progression.all_endings and AR.progression.encyclopedia_complete preserve source set obligations with D08 pending. No endpoint/encyclopedia target catalog was supplied. They cannot be accepted solely from a generic flag, partial route list, or collection implementation.",
      "resolution": "Pin approved target catalogs, individual IDs, acquisition conditions, normal-route evidence and save/restart checks before accepting the set contract; retain missing targets as unresolved.",
      "current_state": "correctly unverified; final_denominator_established=false"
    },
    {
      "id": "ASR-04",
      "priority": "reviewed_no_duplicate_issue",
      "topic": "duplicates and refinements",
      "source_lines": [
        118,
        161,
        165,
        179,
        235,
        242
      ],
      "finding": "Seventeen A03/A04/A05 refinements retain the prior identity rather than add a second weight. Repeated source references for price unlocking, markings and SD walk/loops are merged. Three identical observation condition texts apply to distinct named facilities and are not redundant.",
      "resolution": "Preserve entity identity when comparing conditions; generic contracts and configured per-facility values remain separate duties.",
      "current_state": "no additional mandatory duplicate correction identified in this scoped review"
    }
  ],
  "completion_verdict": "known-condition register reviewed with unresolved applicability and content catalogs; no final all-original completion verdict"
}