34 lines
7.2 KiB
JSON
34 lines
7.2 KiB
JSON
{
|
||
"candidate": "9641ed52def2ff8e5b0222449a4a83a1191e1d37",
|
||
"scope": "Limited normal click placement rejection and menu/modal-cancel evidence; not formal P24 whole review",
|
||
"result": {
|
||
"status": "passed",
|
||
"summary": "The supplied data supports the narrow observation on candidate 9641ed5, macOS, pid 49041. It covers one native valid reception placement, one overlap-invalid click, opening production SaveLoadMenu id 3 and cancelling the dialog. Exactly one command, job and cost charge occurred. The real overlap rejection text appeared and the reception selection stayed in place. The modal guard went false→true→true→false. Runtime snapshot bytes were identical from the valid placement through the cancel. The controller recorded exit 0, no ERROR lines and clean source, stage and default-player guards. My review covers only the supplied JSON, the supplied method excerpts and the collector/controller source. I did not recompute any hash, read events.jsonl or engine-native.log, or view any image. This is not whole-unit acceptance.",
|
||
"findings": [
|
||
"SUPPORTED – snapshot equality: ui-snapshot-000 and 001 share bin sha dfea68…/json ec054c…; 002 through 007 share bin sha 17399e…/json 07cebb…. The only state change is at 002, after the valid click. This is consistent with both valid_to_invalid_full_runtime_bytes_identical and all_full_runtime_bytes_identical_after_valid_through_modal_cancel. These are pin comparisons as supplied; I did not recompute them.",
|
||
"SUPPORTED – exactly one command, job and cost: after_valid_full_json has one accepted/processed command (command_id 1, key ui.build.00000001, code OK), one PLANNED job construction_00000001 (reception, origin [-5,0,0], 8 reserved cells), next_command_id 2, next_job_sequence 2, one new ledger entry ledger_00000004 (500 gold CONSTRUCTION) and resources 5000/50→4500/42, matching total_cost {gold 500, materials 8}. Because 003–007 are byte-identical to 002, no second command, job or charge was added later in the observed window.",
|
||
"SUPPORTED – actual status-text rejection: capture 003 status_text is exactly '配置不可: ほかの施設または工事と重なります', and the runtime bytes are unchanged. This matches the _on_map_cell_clicked path, which calls get_build_preview_report and then _set_status(_preview_failure_message(...), false) and returns before _submit_ui_command. The body of _preview_failure_message was not supplied, so I accept the mapping only from the observed text.",
|
||
"SUPPORTED – selection preserved: build_definition_id 'reception' and palette_open true appear in every capture from 002 to 007, including after the invalid click and after cancel. This agrees with _on_map_cell_clicked, whose failure path does not clear _selected_definition.",
|
||
"SUPPORTED – modal guard: modal_blocked is false at 004, true at 005 (menu_3) and 006 (dialog_visibility_true), and false at 007 (dialog_visibility_false). This matches modal_guard_states [false,true,true,false]. It is consistent with the source: _ensure_manual_save_slots connects visibility_changed to _update_modal_input_guard, and world_preview._gui_input calls accept_event() and returns when the guard is set. The actual_menu_item row (id 3, pid 49041, ticks 116393) comes from the production PopupMenu's id_pressed signal.",
|
||
"SUPPORTED (narrow) – no save on cancel: snapshot bytes are unchanged across open and cancel, save_path stays 'user://saves/manual_ui', and the supplied rows contain no save_operation_completed receipt. Limit: the supplied data does not include a directory listing of the private profile's saves folder or the full events.jsonl, so 'no file created' rests on the root claim plus the absent receipt.",
|
||
"SUPPORTED – observer/controller read-only (source level): PassiveRecorder only connects to signals, calls runtime.create_snapshot() and reads properties. Its _input logs events without calling accept_event and does not inject any input. Repeated create_snapshot calls across 002–007 produced identical bytes, which shows no observable mutation. The controller swaps project.godot to a private profile and restores it, then checks that the source refs, stage inventory and default player are unchanged; guard_errors and cleanup_errors are both empty.",
|
||
"SUPPORTED – no-error end: controller_guards.passed is true, there is one row with exit_code 0 and engine_ended true, and the log is pinned at 4f94d5…. The log was checked to contain neither 'ERROR:' nor 'SCRIPT ERROR:', but the log text itself was not supplied.",
|
||
"LIMIT – how reception got selected is not evidenced here. Capture 001 (a mouse press) shows palette_open false, and the next captured press, 002, already shows the placement succeeded with reception selected. No captured press covers palette opening or reception selection. Button release-mode activation and/or keyboard input would explain this, but the key rows in events.jsonl were not supplied. Treat the precondition path as unreviewed.",
|
||
"LIMIT – launch path: the collector runs `--script passive_os.gd` (a SceneTree subclass), instantiates main.tscn by hand and sets root.title. This is close to the production main scene but is not the project's ordinary main_scene boot.",
|
||
"LIMIT – the clock was paused (paused true, minute 360) for the whole session. Byte equality therefore shows no command or side effect, but says nothing about behaviour while time is running.",
|
||
"LIMIT – the background click behind the dialog (native CUA at 988,566) produced no root InputEvent receipt. Only open/cancel snapshot equality is supported. Do not claim acceptance of exhaustive behind-dialog input blocking or a native behind-click receipt.",
|
||
"LIMIT – the cancel click on the dialog's own Window viewport is not logged by the root observer; cancel is inferred from dialog_visibility_false plus snapshot equality.",
|
||
"LIMIT – visual: frame PNG pins are supplied, but I did not inspect any pixels. The checks of frame003 (invalid explanation, display 4500/42) and frame006 (dialog body and buttons) are the root reviewer's claims only. Dialog frames exclude native window chrome.",
|
||
"LIMIT – full-file review: whole_unchanged_file_review is false for main.gd and world_preview.gd. Only the listed methods were reviewed; _preview_failure_message, _submit_ui_command, the SaveLoadMenu id 3 handler, the cancel handler and ManualSaveSlotsDialog were not supplied.",
|
||
"RETAINED – the r04 run that failed (collector used definition_id instead of FacilityDefinition.id; ended.json sha 31346f…) stays recorded as failed. In r05 only the collector field was corrected, and the source-ref guards in the supplied controller show the product is unchanged.",
|
||
"SCOPE – this is one macOS session only. It does not complete all 8 P24 conditions, all modal, pointer or staff-assignment conditions, or Windows. independent_review in the proof data is false, and whole_unit_accepted stays false."
|
||
],
|
||
"whole_unit_accepted": false
|
||
},
|
||
"artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p24-02-operations/runs/1a197ec2abff40eca265f71baa4d621e",
|
||
"model": "claude-opus-5-5",
|
||
"whole_unit_accepted": false,
|
||
"formal_runner_review": false,
|
||
"proof_sha256": "56d5e47139841f40d7fed0d053fb9eb87956e07240a208355a77a94a7dd0a094"
|
||
}
|