Files
TheTree_mock/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/checkpoints/mana-proposal-draft-r01/review-disposition.json
T

29 lines
1.8 KiB
JSON

{
"observed_at_jst": "2026-10-13T00:29:23.970192+09:00",
"status": "not_approval_ready",
"product_modified": false,
"original_delivery_completed": false,
"diagnostic_review": "diagnostic-independent-review.json",
"accepted_findings": [
"HIGH-1 furnace headroom moment ambiguous; same-boundary tree generation can create overflow after consuming actor; furnace F>0 boundary cases absent",
"HIGH-2 restore from zero only possible when generation exceeds retained demand; after==0 stop must preserve original depletion constraint; unconditional recovery claim needs qualification and owner decision",
"MED-1 generous excess demand reaches zero on ninth interval, not twelfth",
"MED-2 distinguish tree generation loss from local distribution loss; stock balance and local power result separate"
],
"review_suggestions_not_auto_adopted": [
"Replacing depletion stop with shortage-only would change original depletion constraint; do not apply automatically",
"MED-3 assertion that one furnace cannot offset demand63 is numerically incorrect: generation20+furnace100 exceeds63 each interval; actual actor cost and sustainable operation still unapproved",
"Furnace loyalty side effects and bankruptcy actor eligibility remain proposal decisions; do not fabricate original numeric effect"
],
"other_findings_deferred": [
"infirmary.tres duplicate properties and unknown queue_staff_min recorded outside proposal scope; no unsolicited fix"
],
"formal_workflow_gaps": [
"source_pins list differs from registered mapping schema",
"formal validator and Runner review absent",
"worker correction stopped due forbidden reuse-input reads, despite exact local copy; retry cap respected"
],
"next_original_candidate": "P24-03",
"proposal_numeric_choices_unapproved": true
}