Record strict P08 regression finding and Opus palette repair direction

2026-10-14 07:47:39 +09:00
parent 2c238e7b25
commit 3a7d20d16b
5 changed files with 75 additions and 7 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
+{
+  "action": "request-repair",
+  "task_id": "P08-03",
+  "reason": "Root cause is confirmed in the source. At scenes/main/main.gd:798-807, Main adds DemolitionButton as a child of the BuildPalette GridContainer and sets grid.columns = MVP_FACILITY_IDS.size()+1. That makes the grid hold 24 children, and tests/ui/test_main_dashboard.gd:132 requires get_child_count()==23. The iconized-23 facility check and the palette_scroll.is_ancestor_of(palette) check both still pass. This is a P08-03 product regression, not a test defect. Repair goes to the same worker and worktree, inside the immutable allowed_paths.\n\nRequired repair:\n(1) In main.gd, put back grid.columns = MVP_FACILITY_IDS.size() so BuildPalette holds only the 23 facility buttons from _populate_build_palette. ScrollContainer handles only one content child, so add a single container (for example an HBoxContainer named BuildPaletteRow) as the only child of BuildPaletteScroll. Put the BuildPalette grid and DemolitionButton side by side inside it. Keep the existing _button styling, toggle_mode, _toggle_demolition_mode wiring and the demolition_button member reference. The fixture at tests/fixtures/p08-03/placement.gd:144 uses main.demolition_button, so ordinary access is unchanged. Keep build/excavation/pan/selection/modal mode exclusivity, the palette open/close behavior and all 5 facets unchanged.\n(2) In tests/ui/test_p08_normal_placement_ops.gd, add a meaningful check. BuildPalette must be a GridContainer with exactly the 23 facility buttons and no DemolitionButton. DemolitionButton must exist, be visible when the palette is open, be a descendant of BuildPaletteScroll, sit outside BuildPalette, and still enter and cancel demolition mode. If the marker contract requires it, update the exact marker/policy source (completion_marker_contracts.json, suite-policy.json source SHA) and the p08-03 docs/implementation.json with the new source SHA and honest pending states.\n(3) Do not edit test_main_dashboard.gd or any other existing test, facility counts, the spec, assets or the denominator. Do not touch Runtime/service files and add no unrelated features. Do not overwrite or delete the R07 raw failure files (ROOT_FULL_REGRESSION_R07_PALETTE_MEMBERSHIP_FAILURE.json, ROOT_FULL_R07_STDERR.log, ROOT_FULL_R07_FAILED_PHASE.json). Keep them as honest history.\n(4) The worker runs only pure local Python syntax checks and checker tests. It runs no Godot, native or full regression.\n\nAfter a genuine submission, Root runs static/local affected UI first (test_main_dashboard, test_p08_normal_placement_ops, test_original_build_pointer, test_original_facility_controls). Then it runs one final exact native/OS proof and one full 175-suite regression on the frozen candidate, with no duplicate full regression, followed by separate independent Opus review. No acceptance is claimed and no human UI is run.",
+  "codex_model": "gpt-6.1-sol",
+  "codex_model_reason": "The fix is narrow and deterministic: one container restructure in a single function of main.gd (about 10 lines), one added check in an already-allowed test, and marker/doc SHA refreshes. The root cause and target design are already pinned down, and no fixture rewires are needed because the fixture uses the demolition_button member. Nothing here involves cross-module reasoning, Runtime semantics or ambiguous spec interpretation that would justify Astra's extra time and usage, so default Sol is the right quality/cost balance."
+}
@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
+{
+  "action": "run",
+  "task_id": "P08-03",
+  "reason": "Run repair10 in the same Codex worktree P08-03-implement. Base it on the R07 full-regression failure for candidate 1f0a2bc. In that run, tests/ui/test_main_dashboard.gd:132 failed `palette.get_child_count() == 23` because Main puts DemolitionButton inside the BuildPalette grid (columns = MVP_FACILITY_IDS.size()+1). 147 suites passed before the strict stop. Repair, limited to allowed_paths: (1) In scenes/main/main.gd, BuildPalette holds only the 23 facility buttons, with columns = MVP_FACILITY_IDS.size(). Wrap it in one HBox as the scroll content. DemolitionButton becomes a sibling of BuildPalette in that HBox. Keep the existing normal demolition entry, mode, selection, confirm, cancel, result and status handling working through SimulationRuntime.submit_command demolish_facility, with build, excavation, pan and modal flows unchanged. (2) Add a meaningful semantic check to tests/ui/test_p08_normal_placement_ops.gd. It must confirm palette membership is facility-only (23) and that DemolitionButton is a normal-access sibling. Do not change tests/ui/test_main_dashboard.gd or any other existing suite. (3) Update the strict marker entry, the completion_marker_contracts.json entry, the source-SHA-pinned cleanup policy hashes in tools/regression/suite-policy.json (existing policies and labels kept), CONDITION_MATRIX.md and implementation.json with the exact final local source and input SHAs and honest pending states. Forbidden: Runtime, service, spec, asset or denominator changes; edits to the raw failed-proof files (ROOT_FULL_R07_*, ROOT_FULL_REGRESSION_R07_*); test weakening; changing facility count. The worker runs only Python local syntax and checker tests (tools/test_p08_normal_placement_evidence.py). No Godot, native or full runs. Afterwards Root re-runs the affected native UI suites (test_main_dashboard and test_p08_normal_placement_ops) before a frozen final native, OS and full-175 regression and a separate Opus review. Return genuine submitted with all pending Root conditions stated. All caps stay null. No duplicate implementer and no AGY restart.",
+  "codex_model": "gpt-6.1-sol",
+  "codex_model_reason": "The repair is a narrow structural UI change with a known root cause: move one button out of the grid into a sibling HBox and fix the column count. The rest is one added local assertion and deterministic hash/doc bookkeeping in files the same worker has already edited. The diagnosis is done and there is no new domain logic or cross-system design, so gpt-6-astra's extra cost and time aren't justified. The default model fits on quality, time and usage."
+}
@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
+{
+  "unit": "P08-03",
+  "candidate": "1f0a2bcd53c3f9fdf057e7916871cf5b42145c55",
+  "output": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p08-03-full-regression-1f0a2bcd-r01",
+  "suites_passed": 147,
+  "failed_suite": "tests/ui/test_main_dashboard.gd",
+  "failed_labels": [
+    "ERROR: all23 facilities including the cleaning room appear in the build palette",
+    "ERROR: FAIL: 1 of 169 checks failed"
+  ],
+  "remaining_unexecuted": [
+    "tests/ui/test_opening_assignment.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_original_build_pointer.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_original_facility_controls.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_p08_normal_placement_ops.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_paired_bgm.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_pixel_tower.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_rank_pointer.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_room_presentation.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_selection_autosave.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_selection_departure.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_selection_lifecycle.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_staff_management.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_staff_rescue.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_staff_rest.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_stair_transport_details.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_supply_auto_purchase_ui.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_supply_management.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_ui_audio_feedback.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_ui_presentation_audio_contract.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_upkeep_closed_ui.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_upkeep_inspector.gd",
+    "tests/ui/test_world_tree_rank.gd",
+    "tests/world/test_elevator_topology.gd",
+    "tests/world/test_legacy_stairs.gd",
+    "tests/world/test_path_transit_density.gd",
+    "tests/world/test_path_vertical_policy.gd",
+    "tests/world/test_stair_infrastructure.gd"
+  ],
+  "error": "AssertionError: first strict failed phase stops without retry: 147",
+  "cleanup_errors": [],
+  "guard_errors": [],
+  "owned_ended": true,
+  "formal_acceptance": false,
+  "test_assertion": "palette.get_child_count() == 23 at tests/ui/test_main_dashboard.gd:132",
+  "observed_product_source": "Main adds DemolitionButton to BuildPalette with grid.columns = MVP_FACILITY_IDS.size()+1; catalog button/icon check23 separately passes",
+  "candidate_fix_for_Opus_assessment": "Keep 23 facility-only grid membership; normal demolition tool as sibling control within same scroll palette, preserve ordinary access and all modes. No test condition weakening or arbitrary facility count change."
+}
@@ -254,6 +254,6 @@
    "validate_facility_value_contracts.py": "91640e2a76cd6cc9186f7b85c0bf379b24b6cac0d48962815235ee628e7ae43e",
    "validate_plan.py": "23678227d9b3c556f1bd903f4b5b3147c4a82ce5085e10055481026803451b80",
    "validator_update_checks.json": "f997d0f3de2cea29550840b1d5cb23647d64f81329de46758551e2b6c8fecc27",
-    "work_packages.json": "d9754a2c4452dfcf01de91cd4d203327588515e25a7cd054ea114f9441d1ce1d"
+    "work_packages.json": "6345ce7653d284c29878ce3c5e79d7bd6d0a6574115e219f94f99563f3bc0ac8"
  }
 }
@@ -6909,16 +6909,22 @@
            "sha256": "71dc88e65d199dc591028ea5280be6eb01b58963c3af0be84d05f74c8729cb11",
            "scope": "exact submitted local83 source/log match and full175 start; not final regression or acceptance",
            "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false
+          },
+          {
+            "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/FULL_REGRESSION_R07_PALETTE_MEMBERSHIP_FAILURE.json",
+            "sha256": "86d76fa01fb62546a5ae9041c2a5bcc9bb69c486e8afa43bb39d9a455bbb7881",
+            "scope": "1f0a2bcd strict full regression failure after147 PASS; not acceptance",
+            "current_game_acceptance_inferred": false
          }
        ],
-        "progress_summary": "現対象P08-03、原5条件・部分点なし。提出0c5e0022は最終局所75件PASS、nativeR07のimport/parse/handler writer/reader全PASS。2400秒のOS writer35236は通常建設・階段・撤去再建・パン・50–400%ズーム・通常保存を含む実64操作を完遂。294確認中、操作後マウス位置によるセル観測と従属camera identityの2件が失敗しexit1、OS readerは未開始。実イベント座標から製品式で(-8,0,0)を再計算、画面の受付選択と一致したが後取得値は空。失敗原証拠を保持し、実Opusが入力時点座標と実選択IDの独立照合・負例試験を具体指示。同一Sol担当run06a039a93aed4317a544db58ceada6b1が9回目修正中、個別上限なし。原条件と終了判定を緩和せず、正式credit0。 修正提出1f0a2bcd、最終局所83件PASSとソース/ログSHAをRoot照合、提出クリーン。175スイート全回帰run71f3605072e64c3ca41422628f2f1fbfを開始。全回帰・新native/OS・独立レビュー・統合は完了未証明。",
+        "progress_summary": "現対象P08-03、原5条件・部分点なし。提出1f0a2bcdは実入力dispatchと施設選択を独立照合、最終局所83件PASS、Rootソース/ログSHA一致。必須全回帰run71f3605072e64c3ca41422628f2f1fbfは147スイートPASS後、test_main_dashboardで169確認中1失敗（施設専用BuildPaletteに撤去ボタンを含め24子要素となる製品回帰）。以降27スイート未実行、終了/全source/default profile/stage保全/cleanupは正常。全回帰失敗原証拠を保持。実Opusは施設Grid23件と同じscroll内の隣接撤去操作へ分離、既存dashboard試験を変更せず局所P08試験追加を具体指示。同一Sol/worktreeでrepair10 run675454ebb36e434885e006847ad01a9c実装中、個別上限なし。正式credit0。",
        "remaining_gaps": [
-          "修正提出1f0a2bcdの全回帰175スイートの最終結果・終了・保全を確認。局所83件はPASS、正式受入に代用しない。",
-          "修正後の正確な最終版でguarded nativeと実OS writer/別PIDreaderを最後まで採取。r07の64操作とexit1は失敗履歴として保持。",
-          "最終版の必須全回帰、別Opusセッションの独立レビュー、統合検証と台帳反映。",
-          "同一Windows配布版の実機受入は全体計画の未達として保持。延期P23ジェスチャーは別未達。"
+          "同一担当の施設パレットと撤去操作分離修正提出。既存施設/入力条件を緩和せず、局所83件と追加UI条件・exact marker/policyを確認。",
+          "最終候補の影響UI4スイートを先に検証し、その後同一版のguarded native/実OS writer/別PIDreaderと必須全回帰175を採取。",
+          "別Opusセッション独立レビュー、統合後検証・台帳反映。",
+          "同一Windows配布版実機受入と延期P23ジェスチャーは全体計画の別未達として保持。"
        ],
-        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-14T07:20:42.312279+09:00"
+        "updated_at_jst": "2026-10-14T07:47:26.700688+09:00"
      }
    ],
    "estimate_person_days_historical_2026_09_29": [