Record the P16-01-DISMISS auxiliary acceptance and keep original P16-01 open

P16-01-DISMISS (dismissal of a general employee by the ordinary command and the Main staff panel, with the A14 severance, held unpaid wages, refusals R1-R9 and the cleanup at the command boundary) passed all four normal gates: validation, review, integration and final. A fresh separate Opus review passed F1-F10 with no high or medium finding and five lows. S f5fe219 -> Q 4ca3bbe with the same tree; the measurements are on S. Original credit is 0, so the count stays 24/88 and 4/30. Original P16-01 moves from planned to in_progress; recruitment, market and debt acquisition and the cost per employment category remain. P16-03 stays planned with a note. The P05 residual on the dismissal severance is restated (A14 answered, connected, not counted as P05 completion). The five review lows, the R9 boundary, the kept record gaps and the Windows device acceptance are disclosed. Earlier failures and changes_requested reviews are kept. IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN gains the current 24-unit, feature-first section above the kept history. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-10-25 18:52:22 +09:00
parent 4ca3bbef55
commit 8a2ea74f44
7 changed files with 1278 additions and 33 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,119 @@
+# P16-01-DISMISS 正式受入記録（補助の作業。原本への加算 0）
+
+- P16-01-DISMISS は、原 P16-01 の補助の作業である。対象は、一般従業員（ギルドで雇った `FREE_HIRE`）の通常の操作での解雇で、退職金を含む。
+- 次の3つをそろえて、正式に完了した。
+  - 受入 10 件（F1〜F10）についての、別の fresh な Desktop Opus 5.5 の独立レビューの PASS（高・中 0、low 5）
+  - 通常の validation・review・integration・final の全 PASS
+  - 実 DB と traceability の結合
+- S `f5fe219` → Q `4ca3bbe`。
+- 原本への加算は 0 で、正式の数は 24/88・4/30 のまま。部分点なし。
+- 原 P16-01・P16-03 は未達のまま。`AR.staff.dismissal_severance` の package P05 の原 work・原 AC も、この作業では閉じない。
+
+| 名前 | commit | 備考 |
+|---|---|---|
+| 提出 S | `f5fe2196740466a673879cb2950d96446fd99d6e` | 修正 2 |
+| 統合・最終検証 Q | `4ca3bbef553259e111b35856785ae83d34380287` | Q の tree は S の tree と同じ（`2cebcc3e…`） |
+| 基準 M | `0b59d7c23c301cf014343e217827cb2d837cc11c` | |
+
+- 正式証拠: `DISMISS_FORMAL_COMPLETION_4CA3BBE.json`
+- 独立レビューの結果（実結果の bytes の写し）: `DISMISS_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_F5FE219.json`（SHA256 `1f530e6c4e6158a469271d287763fc8a573295f44f04dd26bf9b5e6a93f8b737`）
+
+## 位置づけと原本の条件
+
+- 仕様は同じフォルダの `SPEC.md`（登録版 r04、ファイルの SHA256 `b4cc31c0…5f77`）。
+- 人の決定 A14（退職金の初期仕様、答え「この初期仕様で進める」）は、`PROVENANCE.json` のとおり。
+  - 退職金は、その職員の日給の3日分。
+  - 表金から払い、不足分を裏金で補う。合計でも足りなければ解雇しない。
+  - 未払いの給与は退職金と分けて保持し、次の 00:00 に精算する。
+  - 退職金は帳簿で区別し、日次決算では運営費に入れる。
+- R9（進行中の襲撃の防衛者は解雇しない、`DEFENSE_LOCKED`）は、Root が既存の範囲の権限で採った一時の境界で、人の承認ではない。
+- 原単位の文:
+  - P16-01 の acceptance: 求人から配置・精算・退職まで通常操作でき、ユニーク禁止操作を維持する。
+  - P16-03 の work: 勤務、休息、給与、気絶、救護、退職時参照除去を横断検証する。
+- 原子要件: `AR.staff.general_dismissal`（P16）、`AR.staff.dismissal_severance`（P05、D04）、`AR.unique.no_dismissal`（P17）。
+- 原の横断条件（P16、6 項目）:
+  - 原本条件とUI操作が一致
+  - Runtimeの実利用・会計・行動へ接続
+  - 途中保存・再起動で再現
+  - 異常/境界/中断を検証
+  - 関連回帰PASS
+  - 要件別ログとソースハッシュを保存
+- 受入 10 件（F1〜F10）は `SPEC.md` §7 と、登録の `acceptance_baseline.json` の本文のとおり。
+
+## 4つの通常のゲート（Runner の the-tree-p16-01-dismiss、task P16-01-DISMISS、completed、修正 2）
+
+| ゲート | commit | Runner の証跡 | 結果 |
+|---|---|---|---|
+| validation | S | evidence 6 | `p16-dismiss` exit 0、verified true、12 本（14 段）・1,888 checks・parse 354、engines_started 0 |
+| review | S | evidence 7 | 実結果 `1f530e6c…`、pass、F1〜F10、low 5 |
+| integration | Q | evidence 8 | `p16-dismiss` exit 0、verified true、engines_started 0 |
+| final | Q | evidence 9 | `32d1d379…-final.json` SHA `91b6d220…`、verified true、12 本・1,888 checks・parse 354、engines_started 0 |
+
+- owner の承認:
+  - Root が、正確な Q `4ca3bbe` の資格を確かめた（`ROOT_P16_Q4CA3BBE_QUALIFICATION_20261025_094225_R01.json`）。
+  - main の統合と push についての既存の人の許可を、正確な Q と main_base `0b59d7c` に当てはめた。新しい人の発言は作っていない。
+  - 記録は、Runner の approvals の行と `ROOT_OWNER_APPROVAL_4CA3BBE_R01.json`、統合の開始と終わりの記録、`ROOT_P16_DISMISS_COMPLETED_DB_JOIN_4CA3BBE_R01.json`。
+- 測定は全て S で行った。
+  - native: 12 本・1,888 checks（新しい suite 721、再開の書き手 120・読み手 273 を含む）
+  - S の全 roster: 201 本・24,073 checks・失敗 0。既存の代表負荷の性能の suite 10 本を含む。
+- Q での integration と final について:
+  - S で測った証拠を、中身が同じ Q の新しい checkout で、中身ベースの verifier が照合したものである。
+  - Q で測ったとは書かない。
+
+## 何ができるようになったか
+
+- 通常の命令 `dismiss_staff` と、Main の職員の管理の画面の「解雇する…」「解雇を確定」で、一般従業員を解雇できる。
+- 押す前に、退職金・裏金からの補填・未払いの給与・開き直す作業・命令の中で取り消す救護を出す。結果も出す。
+- 拒否の行（ユニーク・成人契約・物流の途中・予約を解けない・運営の終了・資金不足・襲撃の防衛中）では、ボタンが無効で理由が出る。
+- 解雇の命令の境目で、勤務・配置・経路・昇降機・救護・出来事・施設の人員の参照を片づける。乗ったままの救護の組でも解雇でき、残る人は本物の階まで乗る。
+- 開き直した予約つきの作業を、別の職員が取り直して終えられる（在庫の予約の操作 ID を直した）。
+- 締めの後に税・利息の未払いが残った保存が読めなかった P05-02 からの不具合を直した。
+
+## 独立レビュー（S f5fe219）
+
+- レビュー担当: 別の fresh な Claude Desktop Opus 5.5 の session（`local_4e746265`）。実装担当とも、前の S の2人のレビュー担当とも別である。
+- 凍結の入力の SHA を確かめ、読むだけで判定した。凍結の入力は packet・schema・材料 7,292 ファイル。
+- 判定の範囲:
+  - 受入 F1〜F10 の全部
+  - SPEC §4・§5・§6 の全ての行
+  - 原の横断条件と、U1（未達の開示）・U2（証拠の適用）
+  - 依頼文の項目 1〜11。F9 の通常の入力（viewport の入力の経路と、時計が動いている時の押し方を分けて判定）、§4.1 (d) の4つの巻き戻しの枝、画面の試験の実際の範囲、来歴の欠落を含む。
+- 配送の前に、会話の記録の全体を確かめた。
+  - tool の呼び出しは Bash 74・Read 5・Write 1・Edit 1 など。
+  - 書き込みは、その session の scratchpad と TMPDIR の補助と、結果のファイル（作成1回）だけ。
+  - engine・試験・Runner のコマンド・git の書き換えは無い。
+- low 5 件。原文は独立レビューの結果のファイルにある。どれも受入を止めないと判定された。
+  1. 命令の中で取り消す救護の、患者の側の結果の文を、画面で確かめていない。
+  2. 画面の中の守り（確認を開いた後に拒否に変わった時・古い確認の時に送らない）の分岐を、試験で通していない。
+  3. 出来事の欠けた actor の方針のうち REPLACE_WITH_ROLE と BRANCH_FAILURE を、解雇の境目で試験していない。
+  4. `_rollback_staff_dismissal` の戻り値を使っていない（既存の雇用の巻き戻しと同じ形）。
+  5. 来歴の欠落（下の「保持した記録の欠落」）は受入の判断に影響しないが、証拠の保持の欠落としては残る。
+
+## 修正の経過と保持した失敗
+
+1. S `b06fec1`
+   - native・validation・全 roster（201 本・23,659 checks）は合格した。
+   - 1回目のレビューは pass。同じレビュー担当の補足（改訂）の判定は changes_requested（high 1・medium 6・low 4）。
+   - 乗ったままの救護の組の解雇を、実装の判断で拒んでいた（SPEC §6.2 の「直し、拒否に変えない」に合わない）。開き直した予約つきの作業を別の職員が取れなかった。ほかに、説明の文と確かめ方の代用。
+   - 修正 1 で、組を解く後始末、予約の操作 ID、説明の分け方、条文どおりの試験を入れた。
+2. S `a073ccb`
+   - native・validation・全 roster（201 本・24,017 checks）は合格した。
+   - レビューは changes_requested（medium 1・low 3）。画面の試験がボタンの信号を直接出していて、F9 の通常の入力を確かめていなかった。
+   - 修正 2 で、画面の試験を viewport の入力で操作する形にし、巻き戻しの枝と画面の文の試験を足した（製品のファイルは変えていない）。
+- 全ての失敗の生の出力、診断の記録、前のレビューの結果は保持した。新しい S の証拠に流用していない。
+
+## 保持した記録の欠落（承認でも免除でもない）
+
+- S `a073ccb` の後続のスクリプトを作る1回目の実行の失敗。1回目の2つの出力、stdout、1回目の script の bytes は残っていない。失敗の全文は会話から書き写した（`DERIVE_A073CCB_SCRIPTS_FIRST_RUN_FAILURE.md`）。
+- 修正 2 の画面の場面の診断用の写し2つ（stage の上だけ）は、ファイルとして残っていない。log・生成の命令の写し・元にした source の hash は残っている（`P16_01_DISMISS_REPAIR2_DIAG_COPIES_PROVENANCE_R01.json`）。
+- Root はこれらを証拠の保持の欠落として保持している。新しい S の正式の試験の生の出力が失われたという意味ではない。
+
+## 未達として保つもの（主張しない）
+
+- 原 P16-01 は未達のまま。求人募集の通常の操作（`AR.staff.recruitment`）、奴隷市場・破産客からの獲得（D04）、雇用の区分ごとの費用の整理が残る。
+- 原 P16-03 は未達のまま。勤務・休息・気絶・救護の横断（D04）と、解雇の経路の外の退職時の参照の除去が残る。
+- 人身売買（`AR.staff.sale_*`、D04）は扱っていない。
+- `AR.staff.dismissal_severance` は A14 の決定とこの受入で接続したが、package P05 の原単位の完了には数えない。
+- 進行中の襲撃の防衛者の解雇（R9）は、原本の要件として未達のまま。退却や戦闘の規則は作っていない。
+- 試験の入力は viewport の入力で、OS の入力ではない。同じ Windows の実機・IME・OS の倍率・同じ候補での実機の受入（SPEC §10）は残る。UI は今の部品のままで、完成の見た目ではない。
+- 長い通常のプレイと、全ゲームの最終の受入は残っている。
@@ -0,0 +1,872 @@
+{
+  "at_jst": "2026-10-25T18:49:38.598450+09:00",
+  "auxiliary_unit": "P16-01-DISMISS",
+  "original_units": [
+    "P16-01",
+    "P16-03"
+  ],
+  "atomic_requirements": [
+    "AR.staff.general_dismissal (P16)",
+    "AR.staff.dismissal_severance (P05, D04; severance decided by A14)",
+    "AR.unique.no_dismissal (P17)"
+  ],
+  "project": "the-tree-p16-01-dismiss",
+  "task": "P16-01-DISMISS",
+  "state": "completed",
+  "S": "f5fe2196740466a673879cb2950d96446fd99d6e",
+  "Q": "4ca3bbef553259e111b35856785ae83d34380287",
+  "M": "0b59d7c23c301cf014343e217827cb2d837cc11c",
+  "repairs": 2,
+  "Q_tree_equals_S_tree": "2cebcc3e851387c26bb7066d37a60d7ae6e51703",
+  "all4_normal_gates_passed": true,
+  "scope": "Auxiliary unit of the original P16-01: dismissal of a general employee (FREE_HIRE) by the ordinary dismiss_staff command and the Main staff panel, with the A14 severance (three days of the effective daily wage, the front fund first and the hidden fund covering the rest), the held unpaid wages, the refusals R1-R9 (R9 DEFENSE_LOCKED is a Root temporary boundary, not a human approval) and the cleanup at the command boundary. Not a new human gameplay approval and not a deletion of the original P16-01 or P16-03 acceptance.",
+  "original_work": {
+    "P16-01": "求人、市場、原本の雇用区分ごとの費用と獲得・退職を非描写状態として整理する。",
+    "P16-03": "勤務、休息、給与、気絶、救護、退職時参照除去を横断検証する。"
+  },
+  "original_acceptance": {
+    "P16-01": "求人から配置・精算・退職まで通常操作でき、ユニーク禁止操作を維持する。",
+    "P16-03": "人員上限、未払い、交代中の予約・移動が整合し、消失や二重精算がない。"
+  },
+  "original_package_work": "雇用区分別費用、全職種業務、生成時特性、獲得/退職/処分の非描写状態処理を整理。乱数特性は生成時に固定しセーブへ保存。",
+  "original_package_acceptance": "求人から配置・業務・休息・精算・退職まで通常UIで通る。費用/忠誠/特性効果の変化が可視化され、ロードで特性が再抽選されない。",
+  "original_cross_cutting_acceptance": [
+    "原本条件とUI操作が一致",
+    "Runtimeの実利用・会計・行動へ接続",
+    "途中保存・再起動で再現",
+    "異常/境界/中断を検証",
+    "関連回帰PASS",
+    "要件別ログとソースハッシュを保存"
+  ],
+  "acceptance_ids": [
+    {
+      "id": "P16-01-DISMISS-F1",
+      "text": "通常の命令: §6.1 の許可の行の `FREE_HIRE` の職員を §4.1 の command で解雇でき、名簿から消え、`STAFF_REMOVED`（reason `DISMISSED`）が1つ記録される。"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "P16-01-DISMISS-F2",
+      "text": "区分の拒否: `UNIQUE` と `ADULT_CONTRACT` は命令でも画面でも解雇できず、§5 の比べ方で業務の状態が変わらない。"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "P16-01-DISMISS-F3",
+      "text": "退職金: §3.5 で決めた額と払う元で、解雇ごとに1回だけ払われ、日次決算と帳簿の照合が一致する。§3.5 で決めた支払ができない時は解雇されず、§5.c の比べ方で業務の状態が変わらない。"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "P16-01-DISMISS-F4",
+      "text": "未払いの給与: 解雇の前の未払いが退職金とは別に保持され、次の 00:00 の締めで1回だけ払われ（A09 の補填を含む）、解雇の後に日給が生じない。"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "P16-01-DISMISS-F5",
+      "text": "再送: 同じ key の再送が `DUPLICATE_IDEMPOTENCY_KEY` で、details に最初の結果がつき、§5.b の比べ方で snapshot の全体が同じ。退職金を二度払わない。"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "P16-01-DISMISS-F6",
+      "text": "拒否の境界: §6.3 の拒否の全ての行（R1〜R9）で拒み、§5 の該当の比べ方で業務の状態が変わらない。"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "P16-01-DISMISS-F7",
+      "text": "許可の境界と後始末: §6.1 の許可の全ての行（A1〜A10）で解雇でき、§6.2 の後始末が全て成り立つ。開き直した作業、サービスの待ちと失敗、救護のやり直し、出来事の欠けた職員の扱いは、それぞれ既存の規則どおりになる。A6・A7・A8 は §6.2.1 のとおり、命令の直後に保存して同じ process と別の process で読み込んでも参照が残らず、保存の照合が通る。"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "P16-01-DISMISS-F8",
+      "text": "保存と再開: 解雇の前後（命令の直後、次の進行の前を含む）・締めの前後の保存を同じ process と別の process で読み、同じ状態で、退職金と未払いの給与の支払が二重にならない。"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "P16-01-DISMISS-F9",
+      "text": "通常の画面: ゲームの本物の Runtime と Main の職員の管理の画面で、通常の入力で許可の行の一般従業員を解雇でき（退職金の額と開き直る作業を押す前に見られる）、拒否の行では操作が出ないか無効で理由が出る。fixture の直接の呼び出し（`staff_service.remove_staff`）だけで通常の入口の完了を主張しない。"
+    },
+    {
+      "id": "P16-01-DISMISS-F10",
+      "text": "回帰: 関連の回帰（狭い roster と再開の2段）と最終の S の全 roster が PASS。既存の試験の期待値の変更は `EXPECTATION_CHANGES.json` に変更前後と根拠を一覧にする。"
+    }
+  ],
+  "acceptance_baseline": {
+    "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/acceptance_baseline.json",
+    "bytes": 3915,
+    "sha256": "2c40932e96f6ca20e46aac8bd3b65cac51ae466fef6b0b62d7bb170e3a924258"
+  },
+  "spec": {
+    "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p16-01-dismiss/SPEC.md",
+    "bytes": 24414,
+    "sha256": "b4cc31c0b1cbfb99f0adcbb356cd919bf45c147a150bc7efa81bd982cab05f77",
+    "contract_spec_sha256": "14efffd90d7fc0ae466375030d0f1680a1319e1bbe1ec0f373c5a5d97ea59e6b"
+  },
+  "provenance_A14": {
+    "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p16-01-dismiss/PROVENANCE.json",
+    "bytes": 3061,
+    "sha256": "c023142d76241d3c5b78b6d53c98b0fe2e1c8c72ee03170c7406c98a144f6223"
+  },
+  "unit_disclosures": [
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p16-01-dismiss/IMPLEMENTATION_NOTES.md",
+      "bytes": 25864,
+      "sha256": "4b7971deb708a424eb4ba8c70af6a479c66c6b7674e9c8d45b7882271fa7b7f4"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p16-01-dismiss/EXPECTATION_CHANGES.json",
+      "bytes": 2062,
+      "sha256": "99a3a39eff6307e0edda9a12411af6e3ad116b4b26a61bcfcd25428af687d9fc"
+    }
+  ],
+  "runner_task": {
+    "id": "P16-01-DISMISS",
+    "state": "completed",
+    "submitted": "f5fe2196740466a673879cb2950d96446fd99d6e",
+    "candidate": "4ca3bbef553259e111b35856785ae83d34380287",
+    "main_base": "0b59d7c23c301cf014343e217827cb2d837cc11c",
+    "reason": null,
+    "repairs": 2
+  },
+  "runner_events": [
+    {
+      "id": 1,
+      "event": "registered",
+      "created": 1792807652.738952
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 2,
+      "event": "owner_delegated_implementer",
+      "created": 1792807668.3897338
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 3,
+      "event": "commander_proposal",
+      "created": 1792807823.042252
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 4,
+      "event": "submitted",
+      "created": 1792813771.980511
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 5,
+      "event": "validating",
+      "created": 1792814391.051862
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 6,
+      "event": "review_pending",
+      "created": 1792814399.380697
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 7,
+      "event": "owner_prepared_actual_desktop_independent_review_input",
+      "created": 1792818189.395961
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 8,
+      "event": "review_pending",
+      "created": 1792902931.012789
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 9,
+      "event": "owner_actual_independent_Desktop_review_output",
+      "created": 1792902941.714538
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 10,
+      "event": "reviewed",
+      "created": 1792902941.715863
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 11,
+      "event": "review_pending",
+      "created": 1792904036.379626
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 12,
+      "event": "owner_actual_independent_Desktop_review_supplement_output",
+      "created": 1792904045.946167
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 13,
+      "event": "repair_pending",
+      "created": 1792904045.9476
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 14,
+      "event": "commander_proposal",
+      "created": 1792904253.122462
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 15,
+      "event": "repair_ready",
+      "created": 1792904253.123292
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 16,
+      "event": "submitted",
+      "created": 1792907145.647569
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 17,
+      "event": "validating",
+      "created": 1792907933.879277
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 18,
+      "event": "review_pending",
+      "created": 1792907940.6854641
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 19,
+      "event": "owner_prepared_actual_desktop_independent_review_input",
+      "created": 1792911399.9793851
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 20,
+      "event": "review_pending",
+      "created": 1792913267.315629
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 21,
+      "event": "owner_actual_independent_Desktop_review_output",
+      "created": 1792913276.881197
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 22,
+      "event": "repair_pending",
+      "created": 1792913276.8830101
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 23,
+      "event": "commander_proposal",
+      "created": 1792913430.5026371
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 24,
+      "event": "repair_ready",
+      "created": 1792913430.504103
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 25,
+      "event": "submitted",
+      "created": 1792915285.8875031
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 26,
+      "event": "validating",
+      "created": 1792916082.429237
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 27,
+      "event": "review_pending",
+      "created": 1792916089.916318
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 28,
+      "event": "owner_prepared_actual_desktop_independent_review_input",
+      "created": 1792919753.202212
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 29,
+      "event": "review_pending",
+      "created": 1792921050.491998
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 30,
+      "event": "owner_actual_independent_Desktop_review_output",
+      "created": 1792921061.577804
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 31,
+      "event": "reviewed",
+      "created": 1792921061.580501
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 32,
+      "event": "approval_pending",
+      "created": 1792921121.711384
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 33,
+      "event": "approved",
+      "created": 1792921381.492307
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 34,
+      "event": "completed",
+      "created": 1792921438.661454
+    }
+  ],
+  "normal_evidence_join": [
+    {
+      "id": 6,
+      "task_id": "P16-01-DISMISS",
+      "kind": "validation",
+      "commit_sha": "f5fe2196740466a673879cb2950d96446fd99d6e",
+      "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/acb324fc062c44c9a075b19991fb8e9e-validation.json",
+      "passed": 1,
+      "artifact_sha256": "f29b4b738fc2092430898a8deadcef86acb1ab3ac114482849fc30935df6e2cc",
+      "checks": [
+        {
+          "id": "p16-dismiss",
+          "exit_code": 0,
+          "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/91313315f7fb46528b55818e300e26f7",
+          "cwd": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p16-01-dismiss/P16-01-DISMISS-validation-af80c5bc",
+          "stdout": {
+            "verified": true,
+            "actual_suites": 12,
+            "parse_checks": 354,
+            "actual_checks": 1888,
+            "engines_started": 0,
+            "formal_acceptance": false,
+            "original_unit_complete": false
+          },
+          "raw": {
+            "command.json": {
+              "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/91313315f7fb46528b55818e300e26f7/command.json",
+              "bytes": 739,
+              "sha256": "3f81eca34d40772edaf0bc39112a01f42343e5d30ea253e74183445e144249d1"
+            },
+            "stdout.log": {
+              "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/91313315f7fb46528b55818e300e26f7/stdout.log",
+              "bytes": 167,
+              "sha256": "0c677da2b25fa2e6601b2e6ac6fcfe2854c6790d84354f053ef332ff7ef16b2e"
+            },
+            "stderr.log": {
+              "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/91313315f7fb46528b55818e300e26f7/stderr.log",
+              "bytes": 0,
+              "sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855"
+            },
+            "sandbox.sb": {
+              "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/91313315f7fb46528b55818e300e26f7/sandbox.sb",
+              "bytes": 1984,
+              "sha256": "063e31b34a4160f36a2b17bbf0a003a6b92df70e8251071715511f02bcff2048"
+            }
+          }
+        }
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 7,
+      "task_id": "P16-01-DISMISS",
+      "kind": "review",
+      "commit_sha": "f5fe2196740466a673879cb2950d96446fd99d6e",
+      "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-f5fe219-r01/actual-independent-desktop-output/result.json",
+      "passed": 1,
+      "artifact_sha256": "1f530e6c4e6158a469271d287763fc8a573295f44f04dd26bf9b5e6a93f8b737",
+      "checks": []
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 8,
+      "task_id": "P16-01-DISMISS",
+      "kind": "integration",
+      "commit_sha": "4ca3bbef553259e111b35856785ae83d34380287",
+      "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/15ec10bebdd243c1a4e021de0304c7e5-integration.json",
+      "passed": 1,
+      "artifact_sha256": "d9f6fe28a1b040a39da6e3c12d0109a1924155e2aece46037c31aeb3a69a185a",
+      "checks": [
+        {
+          "id": "p16-dismiss",
+          "exit_code": 0,
+          "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/307bc8e26b0245aea3bc5b3a78826986",
+          "cwd": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p16-01-dismiss/P16-01-DISMISS-integration-18921040",
+          "stdout": {
+            "verified": true,
+            "actual_suites": 12,
+            "parse_checks": 354,
+            "actual_checks": 1888,
+            "engines_started": 0,
+            "formal_acceptance": false,
+            "original_unit_complete": false
+          },
+          "raw": {
+            "command.json": {
+              "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/307bc8e26b0245aea3bc5b3a78826986/command.json",
+              "bytes": 740,
+              "sha256": "2e73d96350daeabd34569cb9f6952d02fffeadd042523f0cc6b667e3a836fbcb"
+            },
+            "stdout.log": {
+              "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/307bc8e26b0245aea3bc5b3a78826986/stdout.log",
+              "bytes": 167,
+              "sha256": "0c677da2b25fa2e6601b2e6ac6fcfe2854c6790d84354f053ef332ff7ef16b2e"
+            },
+            "stderr.log": {
+              "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/307bc8e26b0245aea3bc5b3a78826986/stderr.log",
+              "bytes": 0,
+              "sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855"
+            },
+            "sandbox.sb": {
+              "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/307bc8e26b0245aea3bc5b3a78826986/sandbox.sb",
+              "bytes": 1985,
+              "sha256": "56cc0a16a025f5bf9be5c69d93de17994015146be92ebc07e83f03f242f33f68"
+            }
+          }
+        }
+      ]
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 9,
+      "task_id": "P16-01-DISMISS",
+      "kind": "final",
+      "commit_sha": "4ca3bbef553259e111b35856785ae83d34380287",
+      "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/32d1d3797e35400aa84ce8d55df03d22-final.json",
+      "passed": 1,
+      "artifact_sha256": "91b6d2202dd62fec3bb11683d344c653450447746f686e903e99bd583d587561",
+      "checks": [
+        {
+          "id": "p16-dismiss",
+          "exit_code": 0,
+          "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/92845d661406435eb46a31979a409095",
+          "cwd": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p16-01-dismiss/P16-01-DISMISS-final-d27fcc32",
+          "stdout": {
+            "verified": true,
+            "actual_suites": 12,
+            "parse_checks": 354,
+            "actual_checks": 1888,
+            "engines_started": 0,
+            "formal_acceptance": false,
+            "original_unit_complete": false
+          },
+          "raw": {
+            "command.json": {
+              "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/92845d661406435eb46a31979a409095/command.json",
+              "bytes": 772,
+              "sha256": "adc2dc85d22491c5714a23dcab56acc5eec8546c16ced5957d154310e8d2d5e5"
+            },
+            "stdout.log": {
+              "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/92845d661406435eb46a31979a409095/stdout.log",
+              "bytes": 167,
+              "sha256": "0c677da2b25fa2e6601b2e6ac6fcfe2854c6790d84354f053ef332ff7ef16b2e"
+            },
+            "stderr.log": {
+              "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/92845d661406435eb46a31979a409095/stderr.log",
+              "bytes": 0,
+              "sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855"
+            },
+            "sandbox.sb": {
+              "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/92845d661406435eb46a31979a409095/sandbox.sb",
+              "bytes": 1979,
+              "sha256": "dc417131d1b72066af7113145ae3aefa69951546a82d9614dab35fd8e77ee618"
+            }
+          }
+        }
+      ]
+    }
+  ],
+  "earlier_evidence_retained": [
+    {
+      "id": 1,
+      "kind": "validation",
+      "commit_sha": "b06fec17c7c1e2e4cc22116f209c51dec751215c",
+      "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/adab90a677f04ee0b0430517aa1bdb09-validation.json",
+      "passed": 1
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 2,
+      "kind": "review",
+      "commit_sha": "b06fec17c7c1e2e4cc22116f209c51dec751215c",
+      "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-b06fec1-r01/actual-independent-desktop-output/result.json",
+      "passed": 1
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 3,
+      "kind": "review",
+      "commit_sha": "b06fec17c7c1e2e4cc22116f209c51dec751215c",
+      "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-b06fec1-r01/actual-independent-desktop-output-r02/result.json",
+      "passed": 0
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 4,
+      "kind": "validation",
+      "commit_sha": "a073ccb59b9e20e91875008b5d34431ed5a1174f",
+      "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/runs/4fb740b267d84783bf2d035b389103cc-validation.json",
+      "passed": 1
+    },
+    {
+      "id": 5,
+      "kind": "review",
+      "commit_sha": "a073ccb59b9e20e91875008b5d34431ed5a1174f",
+      "artifact": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-a073ccb-r01/actual-independent-desktop-output/result.json",
+      "passed": 0
+    }
+  ],
+  "earlier_evidence_note": "evidence 2 is the first pass on S b06fec1 by local_e0348c69, superseded by the same reviewer's revised changes_requested (evidence 3); evidence 5 is the changes_requested on S a073ccb by local_cad69b68",
+  "approval": {
+    "task_id": "P16-01-DISMISS",
+    "candidate": "4ca3bbef553259e111b35856785ae83d34380287",
+    "main_base": "0b59d7c23c301cf014343e217827cb2d837cc11c",
+    "owner": "Root/Codex applying existing human authorization for exact-candidate main integration and push; no new human utterance",
+    "created": 1792921381.4913468
+  },
+  "owner_records": [
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/ROOT_P16_Q4CA3BBE_QUALIFICATION_20261025_094225_R01.json",
+      "bytes": 22154,
+      "sha256": "c6c5af0c64725279bfbba3959d0ee8e737eee923c6b7c2f936a41881d663370d"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/ROOT_OWNER_APPROVAL_4CA3BBE_R01.json",
+      "bytes": 3748,
+      "sha256": "ecd7303a9dc523d5ac04046ef78fe0f543c0030c641db9c3bc5333bf871e4f06"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/ROOT_INTEGRATE_4CA3BBE_R01.start.json",
+      "bytes": 830,
+      "sha256": "35aff6f3c5deaa85c265995d4d6963d336ddbc33c07c24993e350a76922e5120"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/ROOT_INTEGRATE_4CA3BBE_R01.ended.json",
+      "bytes": 424,
+      "sha256": "dab0fa02d8426c7c081209405153c160b5d28a5d6a8c64f40db06fb076bffbad"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/ROOT_P16_DISMISS_COMPLETED_DB_JOIN_4CA3BBE_R01.json",
+      "bytes": 18156,
+      "sha256": "c1eaa159e1c3dd7037044f6b9979a1daa6857a095ad3fcdf090a21894b194438"
+    }
+  ],
+  "traceability": {
+    "path": "/Users/korizatou114/Library/Application Support/agent-control/the-tree-p16-01-dismiss/traceability/P16-01-DISMISS.json",
+    "bytes": 5201,
+    "sha256": "836f2bb099ab0cea0ae0b75d4f0cee981988395c58a541b56e430ea84254206c"
+  },
+  "independent_reviewer": {
+    "task_id": "P16-01-DISMISS",
+    "commit": "f5fe2196740466a673879cb2950d96446fd99d6e",
+    "session_id": "local_4e746265-c2a6-4576-a894-84cbb0b7fc46",
+    "model": "claude-opus-5-5",
+    "context": "fresh",
+    "read_only": true,
+    "read_only_meaning": "The governor read every tool call of the actual reviewer transcript (762 rows, 149 assistant messages, all model claude-opus-5-5, 2026-10-25T09:18:31Z to 09:35:20Z): tools used were Bash 74, Read 5, Write 1, Edit 1, mcp__ccd_turn__update_plan 2 and mcp__ccd_turn__wrap_up 1; no Agent or Artifact call. Read: the frozen checkout's tests/helpers/p16_dismissal_fixture.gd and tests/staff/test_general_dismissal.gd only. Write and Edit: only the reviewer's own scratchpad helper write_result.py (/private/tmp/claude-501/-Users-korizatou114-Projects-------------/2edbe800-dc0f-4fbc-8e2f-54790a2406a5/scratchpad); the Edit changed one line reference in it. Every Bash command was read in full. Bash writes: only the reviewer's scratchpad (packet_data.json, spec_packet.md, diff.patch, gitdiff.patch) and its own TMPDIR (lsfiles.txt), and DESKTOP_RESULT.json created once by write_result.py (the listing just before shows no result file); rows without a timestamp are api-request-blob copies of the same tool calls, not further runs. git use: diff 12, log 1, status 1, rev-parse 1, ls-files 1 (no commit, checkout, reset, merge or worktree). No test, Godot, agent-control, tools/run_*.py or run_all_tests run. Two tool results were exit 1 of read-only cat/head commands. After the review the governor checked: frozen checkout HEAD f5fe219 with only ?? .review-material/, all 7,292 material files equal to the manifest SHA-256, packet/normal packet/schema/manifest equal to READY, no active run, task state review_pending. The empty folder .claude/.cc-writes in the review folder appeared at 18:18:44 JST, right after the reviewer's first cd into that folder (09:18:43Z); it is the harness's working-directory folder, not a file written by a tool. Schema checked by the reviewer by hand (transcript 2edbe800-dc0f-4fbc-8e2f-54790a2406a5.jsonl; tool calls {\"mcp__ccd_turn__update_plan\": 2, \"Bash\": 74, \"Read\": 5, \"Write\": 1, \"Edit\": 1, \"mcp__ccd_turn__wrap_up\": 1}; edit tools [\"Edit\", \"Write\"]; pattern matches read by the governor: 2)",
+    "tests_or_engines_started": false,
+    "packet_sha256": "1bd8457027d81ba2f856f9320e60b9f46f979ccf11f2edfd786d1204896614f8",
+    "normal_packet_sha256": "720a675afb1238eff11ef1fb51b60e00b69740568e22681275a138115ad780f5",
+    "schema_sha256": "49ca72d63dfe23d6a6ef50f4f261c7bf706b2fcb34cb4375ce733254693ebc39",
+    "material_manifest_sha256": "3a149af9a30f01ea4b041b02fb7179a6564204d1c9825a8c85910f5cb8e73de2",
+    "result_file": "/Users/korizatou114/Projects/とりにく工房ゲーム制作部/artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-f5fe219-r01/DESKTOP_RESULT.json",
+    "result_sha256": "1f530e6c4e6158a469271d287763fc8a573295f44f04dd26bf9b5e6a93f8b737",
+    "result_sha256_source": "computed by the governor from the actual DESKTOP_RESULT.json (not edited)",
+    "status_reported": "pass",
+    "delivered_by": "Desktop governor session local_a7f85421-3eed-4482-8030-c0dca669573a (implementer, commander and native executor of P16-01-DISMISS; did not review or edit the result)",
+    "session_started_by": "Root started the proposal card task_3d0cb301 once in the Claude Desktop UI (Root record ROOT_P16_F5FE219_FULL_ROSTER_REVIEW_READY_20261025_091748_R01.json, SHA-256 6f42a5fbadcb73140e6eda4fb4f7774dceb9bab5c171ae6cc2f762c58af66adf); the governor proposed the card and did not start it; a new fresh session, not local_a7f85421 (implementer), local_e0348c69 (the S b06fec1 reviewer) or local_cad69b68 (the S a073ccb reviewer); session metadata: model claude-opus-5-5, effort xhigh, permission mode auto, parent local_a7f85421",
+    "cli_authentication_recovered": false,
+    "cli_review_succeeded": false,
+    "recorded_at": 1792921039.984701
+  },
+  "independent_result": {
+    "path": "docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p16-01-dismiss/DISMISS_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_F5FE219.json",
+    "bytes": 19385,
+    "sha256": "1f530e6c4e6158a469271d287763fc8a573295f44f04dd26bf9b5e6a93f8b737",
+    "copy_of": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-f5fe219-r01/DESKTOP_RESULT.json"
+  },
+  "review_findings": [
+    {
+      "severity": "low",
+      "message": "項目 6・§4.3【受入を止めない。画面の試験の範囲】患者の側の結果の文は、画面で確かめていない。tests/staff/test_general_dismissal.gd 997〜1013 行では、患者は押す前の文（「この従業員への救護は取り消し、救護係を外します。」）だけを確かめて「やめる」で閉じる。運搬者を解雇した後に患者も解雇するが、その時はもう救護の作業が無く、確かめるのは名簿から消えることだけ。§4.3 が明示する結果は「成功、拒否の理由、払った退職金、保持した未払い」で、これらは画面で全て確かめている。結果の「関わっていた救護の作業は取り消しました。」は scripts/ui/staff_management_panel.gd 391〜408 行の同じ分岐で、運搬者の画面で確かめている。患者を解雇した時に interrupted_rescue_task_ids が空でないことは、source（simulation_runtime.gd 7177 行〜。患者を目標にした作業を取り消して並べる）と、命令の試験（_test_rescue_matrix の患者の場面で、作業の取り消しと救護係の解放）で読める。そのため、説明と実際の動作は合うと判断する。直すなら、運搬の途中で患者を先に解雇し、結果の文を画面で確かめる場面を足すとよい。"
+    },
+    {
+      "severity": "low",
+      "message": "§5.a・U1【受入を止めない。画面の中の守りの試験が無い】画面の中の判定で送らない守りの分岐は、この S の試験で一度も通らない。対象は、staff_management_panel.gd 329 行〜の request_dismissal の拒否の分岐と、349 行〜の confirm_dismissal の分岐（確認を開いた後に拒否に変わった時と、古い確認の時に送らない）。修正 2 で Button.pressed.emit をやめた結果、無効のボタンへの viewport の押しは Godot が受け付けず、これらの関数に届かない。5.a のうち、無効の行で押しても送らないこと、「解雇する…」と「やめる」で送らないことは、snapshot 全体の bytes で確かめている。§4.3・F2・F9 の明示の条件は満たすので、受入は止めない。ただし、IMPLEMENTATION_NOTES §4 の「確定の時に名簿を読み直す。読み込みや変化の後の古い確認では送らない。」は、source だけの主張になっている。直すなら、確認を開いた後に資金を減らして「解雇を確定」を viewport で押し、送らないことと理由の表示を bytes で確かめる場面を足すとよい。"
+    },
+    {
+      "severity": "low",
+      "message": "A8・F7【受入を止めない。出来事の方針の一部の試験が無い】命令の中の event_service.audit_actor_availability（simulation_runtime.gd 7117 行）は、既存の _handle_missing_actors（scripts/events/event_service.gd 1056 行〜）の4つの方針の全てを通す。一方、試験（_test_event_actors 654 行〜、再開の2段の A8・A8-continue-without）は CANCEL と CONTINUE_WITHOUT だけで、REPLACE_WITH_ROLE と BRANCH_FAILURE は解雇の命令の境目で試験していない。命令は既存の公開の関数を次の時刻より早く呼ぶだけで、どの分岐も、欠けた actor と拘束を外すか instance を取り消すので、参照を残さないと source から読める。そのため受入は止めない。"
+    },
+    {
+      "severity": "low",
+      "message": "§4.1 (d)【受入を止めない。巻き戻しの失敗を検出しない】_rollback_staff_dismissal（simulation_runtime.gd 7196 行〜）の戻り値は、呼ぶ側（7068・7078・7100・7108 行の4つの失敗の分岐）で使われていない。戻り値には、各 restore_snapshot と最後の _validate_runtime_path_crosslinks の結果が入る。そのため、巻き戻し自体が失敗しても latch せず、TRANSACTION_APPLY_FAILED を返す。この形は既存の雇用の巻き戻し（_rollback_staff_candidate_hire）と同じで、IMPLEMENTATION_NOTES §1 が開示している。二重の失敗はこの S の受入の条件の外で、4つの枝の巻き戻しの結果は試験で確かめているので、受入は止めない。"
+    },
+    {
+      "severity": "low",
+      "message": "来歴【受入の判断に影響しない。証拠の保持の欠落としては残る】(1) DERIVE_A073CCB_SCRIPTS_FIRST_RUN_FAILURE.md（ccae9e5e…）の欠落（1回目の2つの出力と stdout の元の bytes）は、前の S の後続のスクリプトの話。この S の分の derive_p16_f5fe219_scripts.py（ef47e675…）は1回目で exit 0（stdout 923a4d53…）。また、この S の native と全 roster の出力は、それを作ったスクリプトに依らず、凍結 checkout の bytes と直接照合して確かめた。(2) 局所の診断の記録 P16_01_DISMISS_REPAIR2_LOCAL_CHECKS_R01.json（4b5f2326…）は diagnostic_only・formal_acceptance false で、受入の根拠に使っていない。(3) 画面の場面の診断の写し2つ（stage の上の tests/staff/diag_r2_ui_flow.gd）は元の bytes が残っておらず、log と control の4つと、生成の命令の写し（05cc8b07…）だけがある。写しは IMPLEMENTATION_NOTES §4 の、修正 1 の診断の原因の説明（倍率 0.889、行の作り直し、締めの後の panel の切り替え）の根拠で、その説明は正式の証拠でないと明記されている。この S の F9 の判定は、正式の validation と全 roster が走らせた suite（f1f77bfd…。凍結 checkout と bytes で同じ）の結果と source だけに基づき、写しの bytes に依らない。(4) 全 roster の途中の R36 の clone の共有（A073CCB_CLOSED_ALIGN_R36.json 3fed617b…、script 1db5b7a5…）は、a073ccb の閉じた2つの checkout だけを対象にし、全 roster の stage には触れていない。全 roster の source-start の 1,438 ファイルが凍結 checkout と bytes で一致し、frozen_before と frozen_after が f5fe219・清潔なので、入力は変わっていない。driver の space の欄が R34 だけを挙げるのは記録の不足だが、別の記録で補われている。以上から、どの過程も入力の来歴と受入の判断を変えないと判断する。ただし、(1) と (3) の元の bytes は失われ、同じだったと誰も確かめられないので、Root が保持するとおり、証拠の保持の欠落として残る（承認でも免除でもない。受入を止める理由にはしない）。"
+    }
+  ],
+  "review_high_medium": 0,
+  "review_low": 5,
+  "review_provenance_records": [
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-f5fe219-r01/READY_FOR_DESKTOP_REVIEW.json",
+      "bytes": 2934,
+      "sha256": "aa8362e46aa06494aa49750679c965f81f5a35550c7c87b7e56a96338a5a4218"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-f5fe219-r01/REVIEW_BRIEF.md",
+      "bytes": 14868,
+      "sha256": "00d7e397eabbabb0024db6b7a4af8b6523f8fd8fcaac359af091c0dd23e8f612"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-f5fe219-r01/DESKTOP_DELIVERY.json",
+      "bytes": 3982,
+      "sha256": "0328910727b91155d315f111d0c56b95e5b3f71822fcb50189dc9eb76422be0b"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-f5fe219-r01/INTAKE_STARTED.json",
+      "bytes": 217,
+      "sha256": "cd5e3fbee5037d5320e249fa872f3b3dbd19b6fef5212ba8c011b2b844719ada"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-f5fe219-r01/INTAKE_FINISHED.json",
+      "bytes": 287,
+      "sha256": "f8ef1ebd47decfb90dfa48fab25f3073addfd004f8b79f0658137e9151ea841f"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/DESKTOP_DELIVERY_INSPECT_F5FE219.stdout",
+      "bytes": 32452,
+      "sha256": "03740c5fbe8b608c39121290faab2a16654a88aeb94b90b97fcedc31a6fb910f"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/DESKTOP_DELIVERY_WRITE_F5FE219.stdout",
+      "bytes": 192,
+      "sha256": "87e2e43eb8e2d9f9324b26194e4ecdbfcfc7e9ef1aae6e72a04438481e0795bd"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/RECEIVE_REVIEW_F5FE219.stdout",
+      "bytes": 179,
+      "sha256": "fe6019f16786d2944f34d5bac265c4c70253bc55a680a33a77af2106a1444ebe"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/PREPARE_INTEGRATION_F5FE219_SUMMARY.json",
+      "bytes": 3213,
+      "sha256": "ed07d7c6f62282b7584adf713a9e8e4d5a53b619e0035b49324137d3c12302ad"
+    }
+  ],
+  "earlier_reviews_retained": [
+    {
+      "S": "b06fec17c7c1e2e4cc22116f209c51dec751215c",
+      "reviewer": "local_e0348c69",
+      "first": {
+        "status": "pass",
+        "result": {
+          "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-b06fec1-r01/DESKTOP_RESULT.json",
+          "bytes": 12105,
+          "sha256": "12434d831139d3b5a0a149858cdd11e33dd71c035909c33ea36f5cf2677f241b"
+        }
+      },
+      "revised": {
+        "status": "changes_requested",
+        "high": 1,
+        "medium": 6,
+        "low": 4,
+        "result": {
+          "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-b06fec1-r01/DESKTOP_RESULT_SUPPLEMENT_R02.json",
+          "bytes": 19724,
+          "sha256": "8048931a47f5cc231fe043fd9febe678f5784da2f5cecdc8a66fdb9f9889cdbb"
+        }
+      },
+      "repair": {
+        "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/COMMANDER_REPAIR_PLAN_P16_01_DISMISS_R01.md",
+        "bytes": 5878,
+        "sha256": "6dbb5ce11e7c8f392ba71f7dd16ea34bab5146c312f7a33718205466c581d2b2"
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "S": "a073ccb59b9e20e91875008b5d34431ed5a1174f",
+      "reviewer": "local_cad69b68",
+      "status": "changes_requested",
+      "medium": 1,
+      "low": 3,
+      "result": {
+        "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-a073ccb-r01/DESKTOP_RESULT.json",
+        "bytes": 17281,
+        "sha256": "dacafb2225938df225cf30ef5412ab8ebded48b2307a230a76d7ad963ee87a22"
+      },
+      "brief": {
+        "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/p16-01-dismiss-independent-review-a073ccb-r01/REVIEW_BRIEF.md",
+        "bytes": 11497,
+        "sha256": "98e1a1e1df97d0177752cff562520298ca287ac5b3934568d90499a1a7b0eb94"
+      },
+      "repair": {
+        "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/COMMANDER_REPAIR_PLAN_P16_01_DISMISS_R02.md",
+        "bytes": 5953,
+        "sha256": "fec141abf13d4a4e3e9947d1c2b4888a04376317ce25f12be7f1f74d57dcaafd"
+      }
+    }
+  ],
+  "measurement": {
+    "measured_on": "f5fe2196740466a673879cb2950d96446fd99d6e",
+    "native": {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/NATIVE_F5FE219_START.json",
+      "bytes": 872,
+      "sha256": "984524b3ac62eded620d01e024b29ef5aa0462140eab3c45cf6f9c3a98a24bd5"
+    },
+    "native_bundle_transfer": {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/NATIVE_F5FE219_BUNDLE_TRANSFER.json",
+      "bytes": 1349,
+      "sha256": "fad160fd2ac3af620d922852b2b85735df7208cbc3a165b642b5bdd6693bf0d7"
+    },
+    "formal_validation_summary": {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/FORMAL_VALIDATE_F5FE219_SUMMARY.json",
+      "bytes": 2819,
+      "sha256": "d89ef221efec094612d719fe0b27f5839f02e970994389ca1af9d6130c75c0ce"
+    },
+    "full_roster_summary": {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/FULL_ROSTER_F5FE219_R01_SUMMARY.json",
+      "bytes": 3457,
+      "sha256": "53d615aecb12a9fb37b6d1a6f21ac7fc23f2c073d47687c62d1ec9f65f262cd6"
+    },
+    "full_roster_placement": {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/FULL_ROSTER_F5FE219_PLACEMENT.json",
+      "bytes": 981,
+      "sha256": "23d07fb54ba648680c43c05430324d7d265029244efc1624684a6c046ec74048"
+    },
+    "native_phases": 14,
+    "native_suites": 12,
+    "native_checks": 1888,
+    "full_roster_suites": 201,
+    "full_roster_checks": 24073,
+    "measurement_not_relabelled_as_gate_Q": true,
+    "Q_meaning": "the evidence measured on S was checked by the registered content-based verifier in fresh checkouts of Q (integration and final); nothing was measured on Q and no engine started"
+  },
+  "capacity_records_content_preserving": [
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/WX_CLOSED_ALIGN_R29.json",
+      "bytes": 5996450,
+      "sha256": "727ae9cbfd288064bd6899e12ba33c1f2a99d118b0a0ad7cc02fa91f9e8ed28a"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/B06FEC1_CLOSED_ALIGN_R30.json",
+      "bytes": 1544347,
+      "sha256": "25392b6da3c18f2c8adcb04fa8a6c1cd44e9a0bbdd0368ec8a69c6d636f840c2"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/P16_01_DISMISS_FULL_ROSTER_RAW_COMPRESSION_B06FEC1_R31.json",
+      "bytes": 3151119,
+      "sha256": "63611a45ba37a42b044ba22306643f41dbbba4accc87dc31c425a8e1f2dc951f"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/B06FEC1_BUILD_ITEMS_MOVE_R32.json",
+      "bytes": 1330,
+      "sha256": "e057a341803d95c4328f7758e69da74de1ccb2c2a237e5b725391bb1dac35fbc"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/P16_01_DISMISS_FULL_ROSTER_RAW_COMPRESSION_A073CCB_R33.json",
+      "bytes": 3187050,
+      "sha256": "d9f19a2ca8b2d51b11eed91b81f1d9d0c0a4aaa55332b7a136e552c0d0789256"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/A073CCB_BUILD_ITEMS_MOVE_R34.json",
+      "bytes": 1410,
+      "sha256": "6fbd0681edde6d80be21960c64ce8131c003be4eb8f8969a3d20080cc4ba681b"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/P16_01_DISMISS_FULL_ROSTER_RAW_COMPRESSION_F5FE219_R35.json",
+      "bytes": 3223348,
+      "sha256": "eaacdea029142ee164d6c3169f8c65a0977db87f1ba45b4329af0006ee5af66f"
+    },
+    {
+      "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/A073CCB_CLOSED_ALIGN_R36.json",
+      "bytes": 3115499,
+      "sha256": "3fed617b19d54eb6e91f55f493cb1c52a2149716194ded325b4006cc85dd5d3c"
+    }
+  ],
+  "capacity_note": "R36 ran during the S f5fe219 full roster (free about 0.52 GB with 23 suites left); it aligned only the closed S a073ccb checkouts and touched no roster input",
+  "historical_evidence_retained": [
+    {
+      "S": "b06fec17c7c1e2e4cc22116f209c51dec751215c",
+      "records": [
+        {
+          "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/FORMAL_VALIDATE_B06FEC1_SUMMARY.json",
+          "bytes": 2819,
+          "sha256": "b11f4f8416ae9c93e7886dcc05cb3efe5ccbfd695b784efda49538bab6c2b9a6"
+        },
+        {
+          "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/FULL_ROSTER_B06FEC1_R01_SUMMARY.json",
+          "bytes": 3227,
+          "sha256": "636a4d69b0e3afb697266d750148398a3145750c812e8cbbb9ba5ab16c40860e"
+        }
+      ],
+      "meaning": "S before repair 1: native, validation and full roster passed; the review was revised to changes_requested"
+    },
+    {
+      "S": "a073ccb59b9e20e91875008b5d34431ed5a1174f",
+      "records": [
+        {
+          "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/FORMAL_VALIDATE_A073CCB_SUMMARY.json",
+          "bytes": 2820,
+          "sha256": "c4541e73bfa024db00280203c0eb4aab4134c3c7318023bb95e50c15f575d64b"
+        },
+        {
+          "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/FULL_ROSTER_A073CCB_R01_SUMMARY.json",
+          "bytes": 3331,
+          "sha256": "c72f2fdfe9f916520e32952ba12ef2f408cb3d79fa581d39b053ca474b799489"
+        }
+      ],
+      "meaning": "S after repair 1: native, validation and full roster passed; the review was changes_requested (F9 normal input)"
+    },
+    {
+      "record": {
+        "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/P16_01_DISMISS_LOCAL_CHECKS_R01.json",
+        "bytes": 13545,
+        "sha256": "e26f9a6abec88809edeb1668dfa651c3b229db394a03a0f69ec330a04df4ea16"
+      },
+      "meaning": "first local checks with their failed runs (diagnostic)"
+    },
+    {
+      "record": {
+        "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/P16_01_DISMISS_REPAIR1_LOCAL_CHECKS_R01.json",
+        "bytes": 14381,
+        "sha256": "d3b8be1314ec522e55e4a835218c50df9eab7a6b08879cbcc572e77bc49bc91b"
+      },
+      "meaning": "repair 1 local checks (diagnostic)"
+    },
+    {
+      "record": {
+        "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/P16_01_DISMISS_REPAIR1_LOCAL_CHECKS_R01_CORRECTION_01.json",
+        "bytes": 6197,
+        "sha256": "391592eedbba654cdb0079521f6ba9f1480cbb03a0b60836e0ab7c24d7daa583"
+      },
+      "meaning": "correction of the repair-1 intermediate failure text (run-r1-1 7/640, run-r1-2 7/641, run-r1-3..5 2/663); the receipt kept unchanged"
+    },
+    {
+      "record": {
+        "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/P16_01_DISMISS_REPAIR2_LOCAL_CHECKS_R01.json",
+        "bytes": 10924,
+        "sha256": "4b5f2326d820b21fa524e159fc3aaca059cb3a1749a9623ca3450fe2681e6714"
+      },
+      "meaning": "repair 2 local checks with the failed first UI run (diagnostic)"
+    }
+  ],
+  "record_gaps_kept": [
+    {
+      "record": {
+        "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/DERIVE_A073CCB_SCRIPTS_FIRST_RUN_FAILURE.md",
+        "bytes": 1508,
+        "sha256": "ccae9e5e9c0922843f06e6240e92a1d35a2c7abf8766cfa8ece10f662e5a17ff"
+      },
+      "meaning": "the first run of the a073ccb follow-up script derivation failed; its two outputs, its stdout and the first script bytes are not kept; the failure text was transcribed from the conversation"
+    },
+    {
+      "record": {
+        "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/P16_01_DISMISS_REPAIR2_DIAG_COPIES_PROVENANCE_R01.json",
+        "bytes": 4072,
+        "sha256": "110bda16b0751e3876d266ba9ac3a25b5eeb1c2c82971e8fb93c3eda77dafc77"
+      },
+      "extracts": {
+        "path": "artifacts/original-completion-2026-10-02/p16-01-dismiss-control-r01/DIAG_R2_UI_FLOW_COPIES_TRANSCRIPT_EXTRACTS_R01.json",
+        "bytes": 21117,
+        "sha256": "05cc8b07b4ecdd745cd779a0735215768c188461afbbc908e5042b3fd2cc0efa"
+      },
+      "meaning": "the two stage-only UI diagnostic copies are not kept as files; their logs, generating commands (transcribed) and derived-from sources are kept"
+    },
+    {
+      "note": "Root keeps these as evidence-retention gaps; neither approved nor waived. The independent review judged they do not change the input provenance or the acceptance. They are not a loss of the new S formal test raw."
+    }
+  ],
+  "remaining_not_claimed": [
+    "Original P16-01 stays unmet: the ordinary recruitment operation (AR.staff.recruitment), market and debt acquisition (AR.staff.market_acquisition, debt_acquisition, D04) and the cost arrangement per employment category (SPEC section 8)",
+    "Original P16-03 stays unmet: the cross-check of shift, rest, collapse and rescue (D04) and the reference removal on departures outside the dismissal path (SPEC section 8)",
+    "Human trafficking (AR.staff.sale_*, D04) is not addressed",
+    "AR.staff.dismissal_severance is connected by the A14 decision and this acceptance but is not counted as the completion of the original P05 package work/AC",
+    "Dismissing the defender of an unfinished raid (R9 DEFENSE_LOCKED, Root temporary boundary) stays unmet as an original requirement; no retreat or combat rule was made",
+    "Review low: the patient-side result text of an interrupted rescue is not checked on screen",
+    "Review low: the panel guards that refuse a stale or changed confirmation are not exercised by a test",
+    "Review low: the Event missing-actor policies REPLACE_WITH_ROLE and BRANCH_FAILURE are not tested at the dismissal boundary",
+    "Review low: the return value of _rollback_staff_dismissal is not used (the existing hire rollback form)",
+    "The test input route is viewport input (root.push_input), not OS input; the same Windows device, IME, OS scaling and same-candidate device acceptance (SPEC section 10) remain; the UI uses the current parts and is not the finished look",
+    "Long normal play and whole-game final acceptance remain"
+  ],
+  "implementation_provenance": "Contract worker field codex is compatibility only; no Codex or Astra run or dispatch. Implementation, repairs 1 and 2, natives and full rosters by the registered Claude Opus 5.5 Desktop implementer and commander (local_a7f85421); commits made by Runner submit; independent reviews by separate fresh Opus 5.5 Desktop sessions (local_e0348c69, local_cad69b68, local_4e746265)",
+  "formal_original_credit": 0,
+  "original_completed_before": 24,
+  "original_completed_after_ledger": 24,
+  "original_delivery_total": 88,
+  "packages_completed": 4,
+  "packages_total": 30,
+  "partial_credit": false,
+  "new_engine_or_full_roster_runs_for_ledger": 0,
+  "all_prior_failures_retained": true,
+  "CLI_auth_recovered": false,
+  "no_new_human_utterance": true
+}