Record P08 current candidate and Opus shared-preview support scope

2026-10-14 17:43:14 +09:00
parent 42c4a74923
commit d4747dd7e1
10 changed files with 145 additions and 8 deletions
@@ -73,6 +73,13 @@ def owner_model_argv(self, service, role, runtime, schema):
            position = argv.index('--model')
            del argv[position:position + 2]
        argv += ['--model', 'claude-opus-5-5' if service == 'claude' else getattr(self, '_owner_codex_model', 'gpt-6.1-sol')]
+    if service == 'claude' and role == 'reviewer' and self.config['project'] == 'the-tree-p08-03-code':
+        task_runtime = self.runtime('P08-03').resolve()
+        if Path(runtime).resolve().is_relative_to(task_runtime):
+            build = Path(self.allocation('P08-03')['build_dir']).resolve()
+            if not build.is_relative_to(task_runtime):
+                raise ValueError('existing task build scope required')
+            argv += ['--add-dir', str(build)]
    return argv

 Runner.provider_argv = owner_model_argv
@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
+{
+  "runner_initial_result": "authentication_expired",
+  "native_cli_logged_in": true,
+  "native_cli_response": "AUTH_REFRESH_OK",
+  "actual_model": "claude-opus-5-5",
+  "provider": "firstParty",
+  "api_fallback": false,
+  "permission_denials": [],
+  "manual_relogin_requested": false,
+  "runner_commander_retried_after_native_refresh": true
+}
@@ -1,22 +1,30 @@
 {
  "plan_id": "P08-03",
  "status": "in_progress",
-  "candidate": "7e2368f5c453a3900ba1bb038d7138d25f7eb4fb",
+  "candidate": "47750010b8694c72737f47078f925b2b2e22ce59",
  "executed_native_source": "31aa7706d28a92e313c432d5a62e35d19503dcc3",
  "formal_acceptance": false,
-  "independent_review": "INDEPENDENT_OPUS_REVIEW_7DDE98CC.json",
+  "independent_review": "INDEPENDENT_SEMANTIC_REVIEW_7E2368F5.json",
  "review_status": "changes_requested",
  "missing": [
-    "final175 full regression",
-    "independent semantic acceptance including stair preview/runtime difference",
-    "integration and final evidence checks"
+    "shared readonly Runtime precheck and placement preview/command agreement",
+    "Main must display real rejection reason consistently",
+    "Opus recorded scope reconciliation for necessary Runtime/test changes",
+    "changed-product native/OS recollection after batch freezes",
+    "final175 on exact final candidate",
+    "independent raw-proof read and all-five-condition review",
+    "integration, current final verification and ledger closure"
  ],
  "next_unit": "P08-03",
  "denominator_packages": 30,
  "denominator_units": 88,
  "completed_delta": 0,
-  "formal_validator": "passed:1c1e23a695664c0999a6924211108c00-validation.json",
-  "next_action": "Opus recommends independent all5-condition semantic review before costly final175 to decide green preview followed by domain refusal; final175 and final acceptance still mandatory",
+  "formal_validator": "7e2368f5 only historical after changed Main/checker; current 4775001 not accepted",
+  "next_action": "actual Opus commander running after native Claude subscription auth refresh; preserve submitted work; no duplicate implementer",
  "semantic_triage": "OPUS_PRE_FULL_SEMANTIC_TRIAGE_7E2368F5.json (read-only, no acceptance)",
-  "capacity": "two closed generated cache deletion approval pending; no deletion performed; used Codex log excluded from compression"
+  "capacity": "cleanup complete: 7.94GB free; 580 closed stages archived losslessly; current R09 retained; no cleanup permission pending",
+  "implemented_not_accepted": [
+    "readable demolition outcome/refund from real result",
+    "checker rejects preview/command disagreement; 128 local Python controls executed"
+  ]
 }
@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
+{
+  "task_id": "P08-03",
+  "commit": "7e2368f5c453a3900ba1bb038d7138d25f7eb4fb",
+  "status": "changes_requested",
+  "summary": "範囲: 最終受入ではなく semantic_pre_full_review。final175、最終独立受入、統合、Windows同一配布/実機は未了のまま。登録validatorの結果は integrity=pass, acceptance=pending（.review-material/validation-runs/0/0/stdout.log）。\n\n条件別の判定:\n(1) support_connection は不成立。正例 supported_connected（受付, CONNECTED）、lower_stair (4,1,0) OK、upper_stair (4,2,0) OK、unsupported の標準客室プレビュー拒否は妥当。lower_stair は DISCONNECTED のまま建設可で接続警告が表示されており、BASELINE:224 の「接続ライン警告表示」と整合する。一方 missing_connection (-8,2,0) は、ホバー時に緑の配置矩形と「配置可能…入口への経路未接続 — クリックで建設」を表示し（main.gd:1428-1432, world_preview.gd:1349-1359）、クリック後に Runtime が STAIR_LANDING_MISSING で拒否する（simulation_runtime.gd:7599-7600）。プレビューの根拠は construction_service.validate_placement（world_preview.gd:205-213）で、階段の下側着地点の判定を含まない。このため同一セルで表示上の判定と実判定が食い違い、「拒否理由と実判定が一致」を満たさない。クリック後の表示文言が Runtime の message と一致し、拒否時の差分がコマンド記録（command envelope）に限られることは確認した。\n(2) invalid_position_reason: ソース上は整合する（プレビュー拒否では送信せず、checker の preserve が型付き状態全体を比較）。範囲外・重複の生行は直接読めず未独立確認。reader の重複表示は coordinator 行と一致する。\n(3) demolish_rebuild: 次の 4 点は概ね妥当。\n  - STAIR_LANDING_IN_USE が実 demolish_facility で拒否され、表示コードが一致。\n  - 取消は before/after の SHA が同一。\n  - 受付の撤去は OK で refund materials:2。\n  - 同一セル (-8,0,0) への再建築は OK で、新ID facility_00000004 は既存 Runtime 上正当。\n  ただし表示品質に指摘あり（findings 参照）。\n(4) pan_zoom_world_identity: 移動モードの wheel で pan が変化し、zoom は 0.5/4.0 でクランプ、変換後ピクセルで (-8,0,0) を選択していることを coordinator 行と checker で確認。生 OS 証跡は未独立確認。\n(5) separate_pid_resume: writer PID 80337 と reader PID 92565 は別。reader は通常UIから (-8,0,0) で facility_00000004 の重複拒否を表示。生証跡は未独立確認。\n\n製品と checker に欠陥があるため changes_requested とする。",
+  "acceptance_ids": [
+    "P08-03"
+  ],
+  "findings": [
+    {
+      "severity": "high",
+      "message": "製品欠陥（support_connection / 拒否理由と実判定の一致）: 階段の下側着地点がない (-8,2,0) で、通常パレットのホバープレビューが can_build=true の緑矩形と「配置可能 … — クリックで建設」を表示する（main.gd:1428-1432, world_preview.gd:201-213, 1349-1359）。クリックすると Runtime が VALIDATION_FAILED/STAIR_LANDING_MISSING で拒否する（autoload/simulation_runtime.gd:7599-7600）。原因は、プレビューが construction_service.validate_placement だけを使い、Runtime 層の着地点判定を反映しないこと。同一セルで表示判定と実判定が食い違う。CONDITION_MATRIX.md:63 でも未解決 finding として自認されている。修正案: Main/WorldPreview（allowed_paths 内）で、既存の読み取り専用 API から着地点判定を参照してプレビューを拒否表示にする。既存 API がなければ、domain logic を UI に複製せず、Runtime 側の読み取り専用プレビュー API の最小提案と失敗証跡を返す。"
+    },
+    {
+      "severity": "high",
+      "message": "checker 欠陥: tools/check_p08_normal_placement_evidence.py:607-609 が missing_connection 行に row['report']['can_build'] == True を要求している（'connection refusal did not reach Runtime'）。これにより、プレビュー可・実判定拒否という不一致が合格条件として固定されている。さらに 'missing_connection' というラベルは、実際には階段着地点（支持）の拒否であり、接続の拒否ではない。プレビューの判定・表示理由と Runtime の結果が一致することを要求し、不一致を負例として検出する形に改めるべき。"
+    },
+    {
+      "severity": "medium",
+      "message": "撤去結果の表示が、利用者向けの結果表示になっていない: _show_demolition_result（main.gd:3175-3178）は成功時に 'OK |  | ' という生の enum 連結だけを表示し、撤去完了や返却資源を示さない。拒否時も 'VALIDATION_FAILED | STAIR_LANDING_IN_USE | …' の生ダンプになる。コード一致は保たれているが、production_scope が求める result/status handling としては不十分。"
+    },
+    {
+      "severity": "low",
+      "message": "撤去モードの軽微な点: 施設のないセルをクリックしても空の施設名で確認ダイアログが出て、instance_id '' を送信できる（main.gd:3136-3168）。また、建設が使う _submit_ui_command（音声フィードバック・idempotency 経路）を通らず、_runtime.submit_command を直接呼んでいる。"
+    },
+    {
+      "severity": "medium",
+      "message": "証跡アクセスの制約: R09 の生証跡（/Users/korizatou114/Projects/TheTree-managed-worktrees/p08-03-code/.runtime/P08-03/build/p08-normal-placement-evidence/os-pair/writer-actions.json など）の Read が、作業ディレクトリ外として拒否された（--restricted）。.review-material 内にミラーはない。このため invalid_position_reason、pan_zoom、separate_pid_resume、撤去／再建築の生行・画像・受領書は独立に照合できていない。本判定は対象ソース、checker、validator stdout、coordinator 提供の生行抜粋に基づく。final175 の前に、作業ディレクトリ内へのミラーか読み取り権限が必要。"
+    }
+  ]
+}
@@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
+{
+  "device": "TakeshinoMac-mini",
+  "observed_jst": "2026-10-14",
+  "system_sleep": 0,
+  "display_sleep_minutes": 180,
+  "screensaver_idle": 0,
+  "hot_corner_raw": {
+    "bottom_right": 14,
+    "others": "unset"
+  },
+  "password_preferences": "not present in queried legacy preference keys; not assumed disabled",
+  "loginwindow_last2hours": "no lock-specific event found; clock change event only",
+  "guardian_last24hours": "audio clock events matched lock substring in clock; no actual lock reason identified",
+  "conclusion": "cause unresolved; current ordinary idle/saver settings do not explain frequent short-interval locks; no setting changed",
+  "limitations": "historical lock episodes not reproduced; absence of recent logs is not proof that no locking occurred"
+}
@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
+{
+  "action": "run",
+  "task_id": "P08-03",
+  "reason": "The Runner is at repair_ready for P08-03 (submitted 7e2368f5, repairs=17). The next step is to run the complete repair17 revision 2 direction exactly as recorded, with no change. That direction is the only one in force and follows review 3124b341. It has five parts:\n\n(A) Write the outside-scope Runtime preview proposal under docs/plans/original-completion-2026-10-02/execution/p08-03/runtime-preview-proposal/:\n- RUNTIME_PREVIEW_PROPOSAL.md, with the header \"OUTSIDE CURRENT TASK SCOPE — NOT APPLIED\" and a purity check that cites file:line.\n- runtime_preview.patch, a concrete unified diff for autoload/simulation_runtime.gd, scenes/main/world_preview.gd and a new targeted test with its .uid.\n- Check the patch only with `git apply --check`. Do not apply it.\n- Do not edit autoload/, scripts/construction/ or scripts/world/. Do not copy any domain rule into Main, WorldPreview or the checker. Do not disguise the green 「配置可能」 UI.\n\n(B) In tools/check_p08_normal_placement_evidence.py:\n- Evaluate the agreeing preview refusal for missing_connection first: can_build false, STAIR_LANDING_MISSING, no submission, preserved state, and status equal to the Runtime message.\n- On every build row, fail with 'preview/command disagreement' or 'preview reason differs from Runtime reason'. The current R09 evidence must therefore fail.\n- For demolition, require readable status text that matches the refund or the refusal message and contains no raw tokens, while the raw result still keeps code and reason.\n\n(C) In scenes/main/main.gd only, change the demolition status to Japanese text:\n- 撤去しました（返金: …／返金なし）, using one shared resource-title helper.\n- 撤去できません: <Runtime message verbatim>.\n- 撤去を受け付けました, with pending results sent through the same formatter.\n- Make no change to Runtime calls, domain values or the world_preview hunk.\n\n(D) Update only the wrong assertions in tools/test_p08_normal_placement_evidence.py and tests/fixtures/p08-03/checker_fixture.py. Add the listed negatives and positives, each checking its specific message. Make the minimal placement.gd expectation update and do not run it.\n\n(E) In CONDITION_MATRIX.md and implementation.json, add a repair17 entry and keep all history:\n- (1) is blocked until Root reconciles and applies the patch.\n- (2)–(5) are not claimed as verified; a future independent check with raw-proof access is required.\n- Old R09 evidence stays historical. Native/OS proof for the changed UI is invalidated.\n- Record the net diff. The new HEAD is bound by the Runner.\n\nBefore editing, the worker declares the findings it targets, the exact files and the exact commands. It runs only these four commands:\n- `python3 -B tools/test_p08_normal_placement_evidence.py`\n- py_compile on the three Python files\n- the implementation.json load check\n- `git apply --check` on the patch\n\nConstraints: no Godot, native or full runs, and no duplicate or intermediate recollection. No commit or branch change. No change to the spec, the denominator (1 unit of 30 packages/88 units), caps, budget, Runner, policy or credentials. No new domain or numeric values. Repair, inference and material limits stay null, with no 500k compression. Low findings stay deferred.\n\nThe worker returns a genuine submitted result that lists everything still pending:\n- Root reconciliation and application of the Runtime preview patch\n- Root native/OS recollection for the changed UI\n- Root final full175\n- independent Opus review of all 5 conditions, with raw-proof access\n- integration, current final verification and the ledger\n- Windows same-distribution/device (no Mac substitution)\n\nNo acceptance is claimed.",
+  "codex_model": "gpt-6.1-sol",
+  "codex_model_reason": "I'm keeping the default gpt-6.1-sol. The commander has already found the root cause, the exact order of the Runtime pre-checks (simulation_runtime.gd:7576-7615) and every checker and fixture line that has to change. The remaining work is bounded:\n- one main.gd formatter that reuses the existing resource titles\n- two checker branches with focused Python tests\n- docs\n- one patch that is not applied: it moves the existing checks into a helper unchanged and adds a read-only API, and it is checked only with git apply --check\n\nThere is no native run, no Runtime edit applied to the worktree and no debugging across components. gpt-6-astra would cost more time and usage without a clear gain in quality. The Python tests and the later independent review catch any mistakes in the patch."
+}
@@ -0,0 +1,18 @@
+{
+  "prior_refusal": "CLI restricted mode only knew cwd despite outer sandbox already permitting task runtime",
+  "correction": "--add-dir exact already-permitted P08 build for reviewer in same task runtime",
+  "preserved": [
+    "--restricted",
+    "Read,Grep,Glob only",
+    "outer sandbox",
+    "credential/shared Git write denies",
+    "all required raw proof and source"
+  ],
+  "actual_local_checks": [
+    "correct existing build argv",
+    "other runtime receives no add-dir",
+    "restricted and readonly tools unchanged"
+  ],
+  "actual_future_raw_read_check": "pending; no access success inferred from argv",
+  "unit_acceptance": false
+}
@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
+{
+  "id": "P08-03-RTPREVIEW",
+  "requirement_id": "P08-03",
+  "counting_scope": "Supporting implementation for existing P08-03 only. Zero added original units; 30 packages/88 units; no partial credit.",
+  "authority": "Original P08-03 preview/refusal agreement plus owner standing full implementation instruction; actual Opus scope direction OPUS_SHARED_RUNTIME_SCOPE_DIRECTION.json",
+  "scope": [
+    "autoload/simulation_runtime.gd",
+    "tests/transport/test_runtime_build_preview.gd",
+    "tests/transport/test_runtime_build_preview.gd.uid"
+  ],
+  "required_conditions": [
+    "One shared read-only precheck for preview and build preserves operations/NOT_FOUND/unsupported/origin/landing/elevator/rotation order and actual codes/messages",
+    "Unknown definition and prior operations failure preserve precedence without crashing",
+    "Typed snapshot bytes, command log and event count unchanged by preview",
+    "Preview and actual submission agree on required precheck cases, with meaningful negative/purity/precedence tests"
+  ],
+  "verification": "Worker static diff review only; Root owns guarded isolated targeted native and impact tests; independent Opus and integration required. A source-presence check alone is not acceptance.",
+  "forbidden": [
+    "No rule values, codes/messages/order changes",
+    "No construction service/data/original requirement edits",
+    "No main/UI/source edits beyond these three files",
+    "No worker native/full/Godot runs or new all-regression copies"
+  ],
+  "reuse": "Use submitted 4775001 concrete Runtime/test patch as seed; correct actual Opus findings; leave P08 UI hunks for existing task."
+}